Aluminum vs Asphalt Roofs?

bsi

New member
May 19, 2006
959
0
0
I am looking at a new roof. Asphalt look like around $7K and aluminum quoted as $23K, more than triple.

The last asphalt roof lasted only 9 years and the supplier is out of business.

So, I guess I am looking for anyone with experience with aluminum (or steel) roofs.

The guy had a lot of bad things to say about steel but of course he has to since he sells aluminum. Basically he said stick with asphalt rather than go to steel and he has a bunch of photos of 10 year old steel buildings to show the flaws.
 
If you are referring to asphalt shingles lasting only 9 years there is something wrong. If you have a bill listing the shingle manufacturer you could make a claim. I have seen warranty claims honoured many times by the two largest manufacturers which are IKO and Emco who markets their product as BP. As for steel or aluminum roof, I would suggest that you consider the newer fiberglass shingles. They are a much better product than the previous shingles which probably you have that were made from a base of recycled paper and cardboard. These type of shingles are still manufactured but are still not recommended. Why buy a steel roof which may last 50 years when you may not be in the house for another 50 years? Not a great investment.
 
metal roofs

Just ask the fire departments opinion on metal roofs. If you have fire in the attic with the old roofs it can be chopped open and put out. The metal it gets very hot so the firemen can't get on it plus you never get it open in time anything below will be gone!:confused:
 
Steel should last 50 years.
It can be recycled, so there's no tipping/environmental fees to get rid of it.
Its noisier in the rain, and creaks sometimes when it changes temperature.
It comes in colours that are generally more rural/industrial than urban/residential.
Snow slides off and can damage eaves troughs.
It comes in three different gauges (thicknesses) so be careful comparing quotes.
 
Think of it this way: Nothing lasts forever, so how much per year are you willing to spend on the roof? Nobody rents roofs, so how much of that can you put together upfront? If you paid the $7K nine years ago, then you paid around $750 for each of those years ($60 or so a month to put a roof over your head) as a starting point. Just keep getting quotes till you have a ballpark average.

Of course you'll have to also answer the questions, how long will you be in the house, and how much of the unrealized value still sitting on the roofcan you get the buyer to pay you.
 
The newer steel roofs appear to be better than the older generation . More colours better designs etc.

Aluminum is not a roofing material that I am familiar with.

Ashphalt shingles are the industry standard in our environment at the moment. Properly installed they should last for 15 years at a minimum.

You should be asking questions about why yours failed after such a short period. The ussual reason is bad installation and most of those are from poor atic ventilation.

How old is the house?

Are the soffits clear? The soffit is the portion of the roof that overhangs the walls ther must be vents in the soffit to allow air to travel under the roof deck to the vents at the top of the roof. If the house has had siding installed freqyuentky the sideing installers block the vents. The other reason is when the attic was insulated the the insulation blocked the soffit vents.

Did they remove the old shingles when putting the new ones down. In theory they can install over existing shingles to a limit of 3 layers. That is providing the layer that is on there is no damaged or curled etc. ( I recently worked on a garage that had 5 layers the roof was buckling from the wait)

For 7 grand they should be stripping and removing the old shingles
 
I live in the country and have a steel roof 8 years old and love it!! When i had it installed was told price was very comparible to asphalt as labour on steel is much cheaper....

b d
 
If your existing roof only lasted 9 years, odds are it was a pound over.

IMHO, always remove the old shingles. Not to is a waste of money.

As to the steel / aluminum debate, if the steel is properly protected, it should be fine. Steel is much less expensive than aluminum, however, aluminum is lighter and does not corrode in the same manner as steel (though it does oxidize.)
 
I replaced a roof last year with asphalt for about 25K. The metal was triple the cost. I put 25 yr shingles on which should last about 20 yrs. If I stay in the house for 60 yrs it would make sense to put the metal roof on. Given that I will be in the house for probably another 10-15 yrs, the metal roof didn't make sense.
 
I just did my roof in shingles 40 year shingles just thicker felt, I paid $4000 but I live in the country that included 4 new vents and stripping the old layer off. Steel was like double the amount and should last about 40-50 years. If your roof only lasted 9 years there is a serious problem like lack of venting in the roof (attic)
 
WhOiSyOuRdAdDy? said:
Is this a flat roof??

Never seen a shingled flat roof before. Don't think that it would be possible to get a waterproof seal that way.
 
using a steel roof is a good way to put a ceiling on your roofing costs
 
Interesting how comfortably so many folks blithely compare prices w/o ever stating the size of the roof. Size does matter, as does complexity, and perhaps elmo just has a bigger house than some are used to, or a roof with more hips and valleys.