All black school???

LancsLad said:
For your childs sake, I hope you are joking.

In the real world an education counts , not some feel good posturing by a bunch of do gooders who will no doubt search out some crap to teach, while kids in other schools learn math and science.


No University worthy of the name will ever give credit for these "classes" unless forced to under some as yet to be developed affirmative action program.

No matter how much coddling theses kids will get thru the school system and how "high" an education they can get through it with some "second class" degree, it all ends with a crash when they finally have to join the real world and find that employers want people with skills not soft fuzzy feel good awareness of their oh-so-hard done by heritage.

It will all come crashing down but the damnable thing is the amount of money that will be wasted before they finally admit defeat.

Some may want to call me a word that ends with "ist" and they are welcome to, as the word is realist.
I agree with you, totally.

Equality comes with living, working and learning together. If we really want to solve any 'racial' problems, we need to ge in there and work from the home front and to replace self defeatism with 'positivism'. It is the only way to do justice to all races and ethnic backgounds. And, there is room to appreciate and to celebrate our ethnic and racial differences. THIS is how I was raised and educated in Toronto, from SK, right up to advanced university degrees. In other words, I think that those who want these types of schools are very badly mistaken, and they are whistling 'Dixie' through the wrong body orifices.
 
basketcase said:
How about schools focus on teaching the poor students in Toronto. We have more than enough of them and they have much more in common than just skin colour. I'd like to see some schools in poor neighbourhoods be able to provide the same kind of educational experience as some of the private schools.

Of course to deal with issues around poverty, the school board/province would have to spend a hell of a lot more money than the few bucks spent on this afrocentric experiment.

You are so right. But, what do you expect from a government that was not voted by the majority of the eligible electorate?
 
Back Burner said:
You know what's really funny about this whole thing. I'm black and I've been talking to a lot of my black friends and we all think it's a stupid idea.

I was watching TV the other day and I saw a few blacks say the same. So who actually came up with this idea?

A bunch of pushy moms from what I see on the news. Mind you the media might make it seem worse than it is.... I remember a mother causing a scene at a school board meeting shouting and demanding the floor.

Okay they got it started.... but it took 11 scared board members to vote yes.
 
basketcase said:
How about schools focus on teaching the poor students in Toronto. We have more than enough of them and they have much more in common than just skin colour. I'd like to see some schools in poor neighbourhoods be able to provide the same kind of educational experience as some of the private schools.

Of course to deal with issues around poverty, the school board/province would have to spend a hell of a lot more money than the few bucks spent on this afrocentric experiment.

Poor neighbourhoods get the same cut of the pie as other schools so long as they are all part of the same school board. Mind you amounts vary but it's based on enrolement/population of the school.

But I agree with you that maybe these neighbourhoods deserve more resources but I think it should be to run after school programs like I had suggested in a previous post.

The 8:30 to 3 is not so much the problem. Mind you I think principals should be given more leeway to run the school in a safe and strict manner free of parent's opinions. But we need to start thinking about the times before and after school. Heck even a breakfast program is not a horrible idea..... a lot of kids do go to school hungry and that has to have an effect on their ability to learn and their outlook on life.

This whole thing is an awful example of a gross simplification of a complex social problem. To think that blacks are the only ones that are struggling with school and that the answer is an afrocentric view is well...... near sighted. It's flawed because it's based on the assumption that black kids simply need to see themselves reflected in the lessons to be engaged...... no! What they need is to be shown that
1) the schools care about them
2) the lessons are valuable
3) the education is worth something
4) crime is not the solution

Maybe I'm wrong but the kid that drops out either does it because they feel hopeless or that they have a better option. They need to be proven wrong.
 
Actually, I think this is a very interesting idea. Apparently 40% of black kids drop out of high school once they hit 16 years of age. If such a black school can help these kids, then it cannot be a bad idea.

I have only read the first page of this thread. But I am stuck with something.

How many of you guys actually have kids in the Toronto school system?

How many of you guys actually have kids that need extra support from the TDSB?
 
I support the idea of a school for gay teens so they feel comfortable enough to learn but blacks don't face the same problems.
 
well

dont worry most white people have it all so let other races fight for something.


dj1470 said:
Opps sorry PC please - "Afrocentric" school favoured in Toronto.

Are you kidding me?

Segregation? Didn't several generations of people fight against this idea? Calling Dr. King. Dr. Martin Luther King.

I guess this has being going on for a while but they had a vote in the school board trustees last night and it was passed 11-9 to build this school?

http://www.torontosun.com/News/TorontoAndGTA/2008/01/30/4801254-sun.html

OK then. . . . I guess we can build and publically fund all white schools now? All oriental schools? All east Indian schools? All martian schools?

Yep great idea - let's start dividing kids up by race now. That's really inclusive.

So much for Toronto being multi-cultural.

Incredible.
 
This will also result in segregation amoung blacks themselves, maybe even more so than segregation between blacks and whites.
 
I'm tired of hearing things about blacks and the racism they feel, and that somehow they are not provided with the right "cultural" environment to learn. Blacks have NO more racism then east asians, south asians, arabics etc, or anyone else of colour. This is an excuse NOT to have to blame the family setting. I think IMHO that the reason that asians, and south asian kids exceed at such a high level is because education is valued tremendously in that culture. I am south asian and my parents taught me that the greatest equalizer that goes beyond my colour will be my education. And this country has provided me with the most amazing opportunities to succeed as long as I wanted to succeed and I tried hard....I didn't need any special school to realize that. I think the biggest problem here is the parents making this an issue, and in my opinion, an excuse for their lack of parenting.

HOW PATHETIC of these parents/people thinking that this is a solution.
 
So now the school board appears to be making a commitment to a percieved problem that is causing black students to drop out. So essentially the board is trying to show it's commitment to solving the problem. Now it is up to the students who attend these programs to make their commitment.
However if the drop out rate continues then what? Will the students and parents finally take ownership of the fact they also have a responsibility in the learning process?
As someone noted before alot of kids don't like the subjects they have to take and they think school is stupid, not much changes over the years and generations. But they get through it because of a variety of factors such as personal drive and parental influence. Many have a variety of cultural backgrounds.
When I was failing a subject I thought it was because I skipped class and didn't do my assignments I didn't realize it was all the school's fault.....
If this concept had been presented as an idea to expand the course outlines to give a world view of subjects I am sure most parents would accept more in depth courses be given to their kids. Ask a parent if their kids should be restricted from learning about other cultures and other parts of the world and you might find they don't want their kids limited. But the way it was handled didn't give this idea.
 
Shades said:
The statistics suggest that for some reason or reasons black students have a very high drop out rate. There is clearly a problem and something should be done.

Yep. One of my best friends is a High school English teacher. She's a card carrying member of the NDP and quite a bleeding heart, but she'll tell you that a lot of black kids don't want to be in school, nor do they work at it. Followed closely by Portuguese males she says who are completely disinterested in school. I guess they just want in at Local 183.
 
I think that it is a great idea. In general, I would support the idea that any group of parents could organize themselves and get a school aimed at their particular need. Whether it was a Catholic school, gay school, aboriginal, disabled, smart, or whatever. Our current public education is such crap (yes, I have kids in it), that allowing any group of parents some say is good. Even if the premise of that particular school is stupid (left-handed school anyone), just the fact that the parents could choose to send you there, and it is in some way designed for your needs, is an improvement.

As far as a black school in particular, I also think that is a great idea. I am no expert on African-Canadian issues, but there seems to be a widespread belief among many black parents that their children are discriminated against and persecuted, making it impossible to succeed. I think that if your parents felt that way, it would be a huge impediment to success, why would you work hard and put up with the crap in school if there was no point, and you were going to be sabotaged anyway. But if you are at a special black school, with presumably black teachers, then that excuse is removed, now, if you are failing, it is your fault, so you might as well knuckle down and get to work. Which in turn leads to success. Even if the school is no more oriented towards African learning styles and culture, whatever that would consist of, just the fact that the discrimination excuse for failure is removed is a huge step forward. It starts to make people responsible for their own success, once the excuses are removed.
 
I've changed my mind a bit. I think it's a GREAT idea. I think once it fails miserably it will be one more nail in the coffin of the "black community's" pathetic victim mentality.

In fact I think we should do Everything they ask & with any luck, it will only take a few more collossal fuckups in judgement with respect to diagnosing the problem that even they will finally see that it is not the color of thier skin but the content or lack therof of their character & their so called culture that is to blame. Maybe the "black community" might even cease to exist as a separate entity & they might actually follow the lead of the real leders of the "blck community" & get an education, a job, a life & stop popping out bastard kids no one can take care of. Every race & culture & group & family in history eventully had to learn these things to survive & theyre no better, no worse & therefore no different so like it or not, the same goddamn rules apply.
 
Its not a Black problem...Its a Jamaican problem ..as in all the "men" that father as many as possible.Like an alley cat that gets what he can before he gets run over crossing one street too many....
 
I dont see why some of you are making a big deal of this, we're not headed for total segregation form all this, gimme a break!

We already now have Asian schools over by Agincourt and in chinatown.
We have mostly Italians in catholic schools, we have gay schools for homo's (heard that on the news today). No homo

So whats the big deal??????

Even if it doesnt work they can always revert back to mixed schools
 
C Dick said:
As far as a black school in particular, I also think that is a great idea. I am no expert on African-Canadian issues, but there seems to be a widespread belief among many black parents that their children are discriminated against and persecuted, making it impossible to succeed.

The parents are just making excuses for their lack of proper and responsible parenting.

C Dick said:
I think that if your parents felt that way, it would be a huge impediment to success, why would you work hard and put up with the crap in school if there was no point, and you were going to be sabotaged anyway.

Except thats not the problem; Quite frankly... their priorities are out to lunch. They cant hide behind the "no hope" angle; these days there are opportunities everywhere you look. There are black people doing just as much as "the white man"; they are CEOs, Lawyers, Doctors, Entrprenuers, Engineers, Politicians...The problem is as soon as a black person finds success doing anything other than athletics, singing, dancing (or any other form of side show), other black people turn on them...they cast them out calling them "white washed" and "sell outs"; The kids would rather look up to some rapper or ball player. How fucked up is that?

This all goes back to a severely faulted "culture" or lack there of combined with shitty half-assed parenting.

C Dick said:
But if you are at a special black school, with presumably black teachers, then that excuse is removed, now, if you are failing, it is your fault


If they are failing now its their fault as well... this is the problem... always looking for excuses; never wanting to own up and take responsibility.
 
is goes to show how stupid the school trusties are... tax dollars at work... next thing they will tell you only nappy headded kids are allowed in... oh sorry wait that is what they are saying...F@cking a$$holes!!!!!!!!!!! more b#llsh!t...
 
This Afrocentric black school will become a "white elephant". It will fail for a few reasons, such as those who will be operating the school will not have the ability to make it succeed, and those who want it to fail will make sure it fails, a heavy double negative burden. Interesting enough, I suspect that very few parents who are actually, really from Africa, for example, Nigerians, Somalis, Ehiopians etc. will want to send their children to such a school. Although well intentioned, the school will definitely open up several cans of worms. Several other self interest groups would have a legal argument for the same treatement, perhaps some constitutional challenges will arise? Didn't one guy, just blow a recent provincial election for proposing separate school funding? Public funding, taxpayers money in itself virtually guarantees a failure. Until the negative, familial and socially destructive environments contributing to the decadence that many kids are faced with on a daily basis are removed, the six hours per day that a school attempts to use to shape a child's mind will continue to be for the most part in vain, no matter what the skin colour of the educators happens to be.