all about the money

rgkv

old timer
Nov 14, 2005
4,389
2,052
113
I have reached that age in life where the goverment has said to me "" WHAT!! you have savings? You have RRSP's?? We cant have that!! You are now ordered to put those savings, that you have tried so hard to accumalate, into an account that we can force you to cash in at whatever rate we determine, starting NOW!! We dont want you to die before we grab as much as possible"
 
RRSPs are for deferring taxes, not escaping them, unfortunately.
They still want their pound (0.45 kg.) of flesh.
 
Last edited:
i quess the nice thing about it is, I get to pick an amount, deposited to my savings every month, like another pension check, figure it will last me around 15 years.. { let hope I live that long LOL} and to be honest, the amount will not change my income enough to cause me concern
 
  • Like
Reactions: angrymime666
i quess the nice thing about it is, I get to pick an amount, deposited to my savings every month, like another pension check, figure it will last me around 15 years.. { let hope I live that long LOL} and to be honest, the amount will not change my income enough to cause me concern
So you've gone from complaining to bragging.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: dvous11 and Indiana
I have reached that age in life where the goverment has said to me "" WHAT!! you have savings? You have RRSP's?? We cant have that!! You are now ordered to put those savings, that you have tried so hard to accumalate, into an account that we can force you to cash in at whatever rate we determine, starting NOW!! We dont want you to die before we grab as much as possible"
Good for you.
 
I have reached that age in life where the goverment has said to me "" WHAT!! you have savings? You have RRSP's?? We cant have that!! You are now ordered to put those savings, that you have tried so hard to accumalate, into an account that we can force you to cash in at whatever rate we determine, starting NOW!! We dont want you to die before we grab as much as possible"
Were you unaware that was how it worked when you were putting your money in an RRSP?

The point is, for most people, to pay no tax on it in your prime earning years and instead pay taxes on it when you're making far less. Most people are still coming out ahead on the tax front.
 
Were you unaware that was how it worked when you were putting your money in an RRSP?

The point is, for most people, to pay no tax on it in your prime earning years and instead pay taxes on it when you're making far less. Most people are still coming out ahead on the tax front.
I had no idea I could set it up like that, my finacial advisor only told a few months ago.. I am happy with the way I can withdraw it
 
Option 1 pay taxes
Option 2 and 3 maybe not

Your RRSP reaches maturity on the last day of the calendar year you turn 71.
At this point, you can access your RRSP assets through 3 maturity options. The tax implications of your decision depend on the option that you choose.
Maturity Option #1: Make a Lump Sum RRSP Withdrawal
You can choose to withdraw all the funds in your RRSP as a lump sum, but the withdrawn amount will be subject to withholding tax. The withholding tax gets taken out of your withdrawal immediately and paid to the government.
Additionally, this amount must be added to your income when filing your taxes.
Maturity Option #2: Convert RRSP to RRIF
You can choose to convert your RRSP to a RRIF (Registered Retirement Income Fund). A RRIF gives you a steady flow of retirement income, with a minimum amount that must be withdrawn each year.
When converting from your RRSP to a RRIF, it’s important to keep a couple things in mind:
Annual withdrawals: You must make annual minimum withdrawals from your RRIF. These minimum withdrawals must be included in your taxable income each year but are not subject to withholding tax at the time of the withdrawal. Any amount withdrawn over the minimum amount will be subject to withholding tax. See the schedule for RRIF withdrawals.
You could run out of money: Your return might not exceed your RRIF withdrawal rate, in which case you could eventually outlive your savings.
Maturity Option #3: Purchase an Annuity
You can convert your RRSP to an annuity which offers a guaranteed income for life or for a specified period. Withholding tax is not applied on amounts that are used to purchase an annuity. You may have to pay tax on the income when you start receiving payments.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rgkv and Massivo
Option 1 pay taxes
Option 2 and 3 maybe not

Your RRSP reaches maturity on the last day of the calendar year you turn 71.
At this point, you can access your RRSP assets through 3 maturity options. The tax implications of your decision depend on the option that you choose.
Maturity Option #1: Make a Lump Sum RRSP Withdrawal
You can choose to withdraw all the funds in your RRSP as a lump sum, but the withdrawn amount will be subject to withholding tax. The withholding tax gets taken out of your withdrawal immediately and paid to the government.
Additionally, this amount must be added to your income when filing your taxes.
Maturity Option #2: Convert RRSP to RRIF
You can choose to convert your RRSP to a RRIF (Registered Retirement Income Fund). A RRIF gives you a steady flow of retirement income, with a minimum amount that must be withdrawn each year.
When converting from your RRSP to a RRIF, it’s important to keep a couple things in mind:
Annual withdrawals: You must make annual minimum withdrawals from your RRIF. These minimum withdrawals must be included in your taxable income each year but are not subject to withholding tax at the time of the withdrawal. Any amount withdrawn over the minimum amount will be subject to withholding tax. See the schedule for RRIF withdrawals.
You could run out of money: Your return might not exceed your RRIF withdrawal rate, in which case you could eventually outlive your savings.
Maturity Option #3: Purchase an Annuity
You can convert your RRSP to an annuity which offers a guaranteed income for life or for a specified period. Withholding tax is not applied on amounts that are used to purchase an annuity. You may have to pay tax on the income when you start receiving payments.
I took option #2
 
Whether you take it monthly or all at once your tax burden would be the same though.
taking the mimimum i am required to take will not affect my taxes much, if at all.. i just like the idea of a monthly cheque👍
 
that i could set the amount and recieve a monthly withdrawal, i thought it was, you take this amount this year, period, all in one amount

IMO, this is why advisers are useless. Many have them have no idea how RSP's work. Worse off, they are nowhere near retirement age so have no idea how the process works. It's a travesty that we were never taught about these vital financial topics.
 
Why do we need to be taught? We're responsible for ourselves and should learn this stuff. Even if we were taught, how many would actually listen? Do I read about the Blue Jays which really doesn't benefit me or do I read about RRSP>RIF, LIRA> LIF etc... right?
The information is widely available either on various websites on on the government websites themselves. No one cares about our money but us.

I agree in principle that we're responsible for our ourselves and money. On the other hand, I'd argue that our current financial mess is due in large part to that lack of education. That lack of education makes it a lot tougher for the average person to seek out and understand the financial information that is out there.
 
Agreed, "lack of education" in math. It doesn't have to be financial advice or specific financials. It's basic math. Of course, many high school teachers can't pass the basic grade 9 math test setup by the government so hey...this won't change.

This is more than just a math problem. The OP didn't even know the fundamentals of the RSP, what happens when he turned 71 and blindly followed the financial adviser. I don't expect schools to teach specifics about RSP's, but we do need the foundations of how credit, debt, savings, and interest works and it should start sooner than high school. I know that the Ontario government has tried to change that in recent years, but I don't know how mcuh detail they go into and if they're only focusing on the math aspect of finance.

You are right though that many teachers are likely in debt to their eyeballs and aren't the greatest people to teach about financial topics. Then again, many parents are in the exact same boat. Not sure if schools do this, but the Monopoly board game is a great teaching tool. There's even a version where the paper money is replaced with credit cards and a card reader.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ez$$$
You are right though that many teachers are likely in debt to their eyeballs and aren't the greatest people to teach about financial topics. Then again, many parents are in the exact same boat. Not sure if schools do this, but the Monopoly board game is a great teaching tool. There's even a version where the paper money is replaced with credit cards and a card reader.

Teachers don't cover financial topics; the parents don't cover financial topics, because they expect the schools to take care of that. This leaves the Average Person financially illiterate.

So, the Average Person thinks to him or herself: "I'll just go to the Bank that I've been with since I was a kid; they'll help me with money!"

The "Advisor" at the Bank doesn't necessarily know anything either; the Average Person doesn't realize that the Personal Banker at the local Branch is there to simply sell the Bank's products. That's it.

I've worked Entry Level Roles at 2 Banks in the Retail Operation; all the Bank cares about is the Revenue Target. If you want to advance in your Career, you have to do more than 100% of your Revenue Target consistently; this can lead to some "questionable" sales practices....but that is a topic for another thread.