alberta cops seizing john's cars

  • Thread starter Thread starter feminista
  • Start date Start date
F

feminista

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Law/2006/02/12/1438973-cp.html

EDMONTON (CP) - Two years after passing a law allowing police to seize cars from men trying to buy sex on the street, Alberta is now ready to enforce it.

Transportation Minister Lyle Oberg says the government will proclaim the long-awaited law this spring, bringing some relief for business owners and neighbourhoods infected with prostitution
 
I guess that mean that you park the car a block or 2 away, and approach the ladies on foot
 
New service Package

That will lead to a lot of new material for stand-up comics. If the street SP's take the fast food operating style, you must DRiVE up to the window to place your order; Over a shitty speaker system shaped like a 60's pimp you speak into the hat to place your order.
" I'll have a double breasted cowgirl , an order of tossed salad, with greek on the side".
 
Expect more of the same now that the conservatives are in power. Art Hanger's only mission is to attack prostitution.

http://www.arthanger.ca/ go to news archives
http://www.arthanger.ca/newsarchive/index.htm


A self-styled lone wolf on a House of Commons committee considering relaxing Canada's prostitution laws is cheering what he says will be the death of the group's report when the Liberal government falls.

A five-member justice subcommittee has been fine-tuning a draft report that will recommend legal reform to Justice Minister Irwin Cotler. Sections of a draft leaked to the media show the committee is recommending the federal government scrap all Criminal Code sections that deal with adult prostitution.

"I stalled it as long as I could. It looks like I will be successful because it will not see the light of day," said Conservative MP Art Hanger, who opposes decriminalization of prostitution.
 
LancsLad said:
That will lead to a lot of new material for stand-up comics. If the street SP's take the fast food operating style, you must DRiVE up to the window to place your order; Over a shitty speaker system shaped like a 60's pimp you speak into the hat to place your order.
" I'll have a double breasted cowgirl , an order of tossed salad, with greek on the side".

speaker noise shhhhhsssquwk "would you like that double sized?"
 
Transportation Minister Lyle Oberg says...

[Those who lose their cars under the law will have a chance to get them back by going to "john school"...The cars will be impounded for weeks or months, rather than just a few days.

They're going to have to pay for the storage, they're going to have to take the course and then they will receive their car back.]


That law is so unfair. A john school requirement is fine, but they could compel attendance simply by laying a criminal charge and having the Crown suspend proceedings conditional on completion of John School.

I think this is ripe for a Charter challenge.

s.7 violation of life, liberty, security of the person
s. 12 cruel and unusual treatment or punishment

Weeks or months of storage @100 bucks a day = a few thousand $.
 
from article:
"If you cruise, you lose," said Quinn, head of the Prostitution Awareness and Action Foundation. "So we think it will have a really strong deterrent value which will have a really deep impact on street prostitution

What is the charge?

I assume it must be communicating for the purposes of, but it doesn't say.
 
The Sociology of Prostitution

Our prostitution laws/enforcement varies according to the socio-economic class of the participants.​

Poor - high-moderate risk of Prosecution

Prostitutes and Johns in the lowest income stratum tend to engage in street solicitation. Police harrass/charge them the most. (in alta. take their cars away)

Cheaper, more run-down MP's and cheaper incalls - moderate risk of getting raided. Why? Providers and clients tend to be minority-race and/or low socio-economic standing

Middle-Class - Low risk of Prosecution

Upscale massage parlours tend to operate hassle-free. SRM - 15yrs, Allure - 10 yrs. Why? Clients tend to be white, middle professionals.

Sames goes for upscale incall locations. Roomates, TopIndEscts will never get busted, notwithstanding operating in broad daylight dwtn. Why? A middle and upper middle clientele.

Upper middle/Upper - Zero chance of Prosecution

The most exclusive escorts, serving affluent Johns are usually Independent, outcall only = Legal
 
so it is basically the same prosecution pattern that applies to most "crimes".
It's as much or more about who the participants are then what they are doing.
 
Americans again

feminista said:
so it is basically the same prosecution pattern that applies to most "crimes".
It's as much or more about who the participants are then what they are doing.

I blame George Bush. :confused:
 
It's also what the community wants, they back the actions of the police who tend to go for the easiest and obvious targets mostly due to laziness.
 
Moral of the story, unless you are driving a 1984 Chevy Citation and don't care if they seize your car, don't pick up a street walker.....
 
Sos

Frankly I am a bit concerned myself. IF Harper and his cronies decide to stall or not go forward at all with decrim that will be a big disappointment (to put it lightly) for all those who have been working hard to promote decrim. Over all though just that alone I think will not be too much of a setback. Biz will go on as it currently is. However if they decide to bring in more even stronger laws against the adult industry… well I don’t even want to go there. I dare say… a lot of us will be looking for new jobs if the latter happens.
 
yeet said:
Our prostitution laws/enforcement varies according to the socio-economic class of the participants.​

Poor - high-moderate risk of Prosecution

Prostitutes and Johns in the lowest income stratum tend to engage in street solicitation. Police harrass/charge them the most. (in alta. take their cars away)

Cheaper, more run-down MP's and cheaper incalls - moderate risk of getting raided. Why? Providers and clients tend to be minority-race and/or low socio-economic standing

I am not so sure about this....

Some of the girls on the Churc / Carleton / Jarvis / Gerrard track charge big bucks, much higher than many incalls, and many times you see some very high end cars pulling over.

Drive by these girls in a Citation, and they don't even notice you, drive by them in a BMW and they are doing the streetwalker come on.

Of course, there is always parkdale, and you still see some high end cars pulling over there too.

1. Many guys have no intention of looking for a street walker, they just happen to be out, or drive past, and bing, off goes the "why not" prompt.

2. Lots of well off dudes are just driving along and think, "yeah, I could use a blow job" and go for it. Hugh Grant has to be the most famous example.

Personally, i think the street walkers downtown add quite a bit of colour to the street scape. Like good architecture, the sight of beautiful (and there are quite a few) women standing on the edge of the sidewalk in July wearing a thong, with an ass you could bounce a quarter off is a good thing.

Now some burned out crack whore working the corner of Queen and Sarauran is a completely different thing....
 
TheNiteHwk said:
Frankly I am a bit concerned myself. IF Harper and his cronies decide to stall or not go forward at all with decrim that will be a big disappointment (to put it lightly) for all those who have been working hard to promote decrim. Over all though just that alone I think will not be too much of a setback. Biz will go on as it currently is. However if they decide to bring in more even stronger laws against the adult industry… well I don’t even want to go there. I dare say… a lot of us will be looking for new jobs if the latter happens.

Are you kidding.

There is ZERO chance of any decriminalization of the hobby EVER happening under Harper.

The best we can hope for is the status quo doesn't get interrupted.

I would in fact wager the opposite, that the laws get tightened and ENFORCED.

Time will tell, but if it does happen, I can't help but laugh at the number of posters on this board who were so PRO conservative during the election. Talk about ironic.
 
james t kirk said:
Are you kidding.

There is ZERO chance of any decriminalization of the hobby EVER happening under Harper.

The best we can hope for is the status quo doesn't get interrupted.

I would in fact wager the opposite, that the laws get tightened and ENFORCED.

Time will tell, but if it does happen, I can't help but laugh at the number of posters on this board who were so PRO conservative during the election. Talk about ironic.
Vote consevative and thats what you get the morality police. :(
 
james t kirk said:
Are you kidding.

There is ZERO chance of any decriminalization of the hobby EVER happening under Harper.

The best we can hope for is the status quo doesn't get interrupted.

I would in fact wager the opposite, that the laws get tightened and ENFORCED.

Time will tell, but if it does happen, I can't help but laugh at the number of posters on this board who were so PRO conservative during the election. Talk about ironic.


Exactly my point. Thanks.

And yah... I think you may be right. Hobbyists who supported Harper may live to regret it.
 
art hanger stalled the the decrim report. It is dead. It was no secret that Hanger in particular and the conservatives in general would work harder to criminalize than to decriminlaize prostitution and related activities.

Anyone who voted for them is getting what they deserve. Too bad for the rest of us.
 
LOL

The federal Parliament is responsible for the Criminal Code. The provinces are responsible for enforcing the laws. Alberta's PROVINCIAL government is merely looking for methods to enforce the federal laws ALREADY in existance. Art Hanger, Stephen Harper and the Conservative FEDERAL administration do not have jurisdiction to dictate to the Alberta PROVINCIAL government what to do. And unless the Criminal Code is changed, Alberta could seek to go ahead with its plans irrespective of who is in power in Ottawa.

If there is a Constitutional challenge to Alberta's proposed actions, it likely will not be under the Charter, but rather under sections 91 and 92. A defendant could claim that the Alberta law is in pith and substance a criminal matter and therefore within the sole legislative jurisidiction of the federal Parliament, and beyond the power of a province.

I know it's hard work, but it would be useful if one would keep track of which level of government is doing what, that way you will know which politicians to blame.

If you are in Alberta, don't pick up street walkers (actually if you are anywhere in Canada, don't pick up street walkers). If you oppose the actions of the Alberta government, take it up with your Alberta MLA. If you are not an Alberta resident, butt out of their business, and let them run their province how they like. Come down to Montreal instead.
 
The subcommittee's report would have been issued and quickly forgotten, much like previous ones. Martin had already made it clear that he intended to ignore it.

Hanger is a former cop and is from Calgary, where the city not only licenses escort agencies, but actually requires that every new escort be interviewed by someone from the vice squad.

If you look at the Edmonton Sun article feminista linked to in her post, Hanger and all the people against decriminalization base everything they say on the false assumption that the sex trade in Canada equals nothing but drug-addicted street walkers forced into the business by pimps. There is absolutely no acknowledgement of the thousands of escorts and MPAs across the country, who must greatly outnumber the streetwalkers. Hanger & co simply rely on the media and general public's ignorance of the situation.

I believe if more people understood that LE and municipal governments already tacitly allow and often license most of the nominally criminal sex trade businesses such as MPs, agencies, and incalls, then more people would realize the present laws have become practically meaningless, have led to a dishonestly two-faced system, and must be reformed (presumably by a future non-Conservative federal government).

The efforts for decriminalization should be refocused on reforming sections 210, 211, and 212 of the criminal code regarding bawdy-houses and living on the avails. The constant attention on the public communicating law (213) feeds right into the hands of Hanger and his ilk, and this law is definitely the least likely to ever be changed since very few Canadians want legal street prostitution.

Hanger's silly statement claiming that decriminalization in New Zealand has caused the number of sex workers to increase by four times makes no sense, and I haven't read this anywhere else. For the most part, the MPs were allowed to legally call themselves brothels, which really wasn't much of a change in practice. All I can assume is that this is a dishonest manipulation of the facts, once again based on the false assumption that the MPs/brothels did not exist before decriminalization.