al Rahman vs Charles Martel

Insidious Von

My head is my home
Sep 12, 2007
45,756
11,205
113
The Battles of Tours is the most significant of the post-Roman First Millennium.

In 711 a Moorish Army crossed the Strait of Gibraltar, with lightning speed they conquered Gothic Spain.

Then they ran into The Roman Problem.

 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
For awhile it seemed like the Spanish Moors would lose on two fronts. The Frankish Duke of Aquitaine (Odo) successfully lifted the Siege of Toulouse. A lull occurred while the participants mended their wounds. In the north the Frankish Leader Charles who would become known as The Hammer (Martel) was fighting the Saxons in the Rhineland.

The new Viceroy of Cordoba, Abdul al Rahman assembled a gigantic army and swept into what is today France. This time the Duke of Aquitaine Odo, barely escaped with his life. He fled north and pledged his allegiance to the Duke of Nustria Charles Martel. Charles had developed a new strategy for dealing with cavalry, the heavy pikemen. The two adversaries met at Tours.

 
 
The Battle of Tours had two significant side effects.

It ended the Moorish expansion into France. It eventually freed the Western Christian Church of Rome from under the thumb of the Patriarch of Constantinople...more on that later.

I will always love Chuck Heston, it's a shame that the National Rifle Association took advantage of him while he was dealing with creeping dementia.

 
If the Muslims had captured a port city like Marseilles, already a major port at that time, they would have been able to bring in more troops rapidly from North Africa. Eventually, they could have marched on Rome and eliminated the Papacy. Charles Martel prevented that and saved Europe.

Interestingly there are numerous prophecies dating back to the middle ages of a Great Monarch who will save Europe near the end of the world. A future Charles Martel perhaps. Only time will tell.
 
If the Muslims had captured a port city like Marseilles, already a major port at that time, they would have been able to bring in more troops rapidly from North Africa. Eventually, they could have marched on Rome and eliminated the Papacy. Charles Martel prevented that and saved Europe.

Charles Martel's invasion of Narbonne (Montpelier) failed and the Spanish Moors took Marseilles. Charles son Pepin eventually put Marseilles to siege but appeared to be failing, the Arabs were able to supply the city by sea. So Pepin did something underhanded, he did a deal with the pirates of Genoa - your enemy is my enemy. The Genovese ships were faster than they Arabs and they used Roman grappling tactics. They turned the tide of the siege at sea and eventually Pepin took Marseilles.
 
In the film El Cid, the role of Admiral Yussuf was played by Herbert Lom.

He is best known as Inspector Dreyfus in the Pink Panther series. But I chose to remember him for this.

 
I think the Battle of Tours repelled the first (far from the last) major Islamic invasion of Europe. I think the next major Islamic invasion of Europe ended in a major Christian victory at the Gates of Vienna.
 
Considering the battle took place 1300 years ago, I'd guess both Martel and al Ramhan are dead.

BTW. Martel played Odo brilliantly
You missed the point. The muslim hordes Martel drove back at the gate are now inside the gate and turning France into a caliphate. Took a bit of time, but mission accomplished. A big fuck you to Martel I would say. Game.Set and Match.
 
I took al Rahman and the points. Lost a few shekels that day.
 
You missed the point. The muslim hordes Martel drove back at the gate are now inside the gate and turning France into a caliphate. Took a bit of time, but mission accomplished. A big fuck you to Martel I would say. Game.Set and Match.
I was trying to be nice and distract from your comment so you wouldn't turn a discussion of history into opportunity to push anti-muslim conspiracy theories.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
The Battles of Tours is the most significant of the post-Roman First Millennium.

In 711 a Moorish Army crossed the Strait of Gibraltar, with lightning speed they conquered Gothic Spain.

Then they ran into The Roman Problem.
Are you saying the Visigoths and Franks were really Roman?
 
For awhile it seemed like the Spanish Moors would lose on two fronts. The Frankish Duke of Aquitaine (Odo) successfully lifted the Siege of Toulouse. A lull occurred while the participants mended their wounds. In the north the Frankish Leader Charles who would become known as The Hammer (Martel) was fighting the Saxons in the Rhineland.

The new Viceroy of Cordoba, Abdul al Rahman assembled a gigantic army and swept into what is today France. This time the Duke of Aquitaine Odo, barely escaped with his life. He fled north and pledged his allegiance to the Duke of Nustria Charles Martel. Charles had developed a new strategy for dealing with cavalry, the heavy pikemen. The two adversaries met at Tours.


New strategy for dealing with cavalry was little different than the Macedonians, only with shorter pikes...
 
Are you saying the Visigoths and Franks were really Roman?
The Visigoths were Germanic horsemen from the Black Sea steppe who were driven into the Roman Empire by the Huns in 374 AD. They defeated the Romans at the Battle of Adrianople and were allowed to settle inside the empire. Much else happened, including the Teutonic fuckers sacking Rome itself in 406, but they became Romanized and spoke Latin - or the form of Latin used in Spain in the 7th Century. They established a kingdom in Spain successfully for about 300 years, but it was undermined by internal politics and feuding. Hence the easy Moorish success in 711. Basically the Visigoths were a successor fragment of the Western Roman Empire, under new management.

The Franks remained a little more Germanic and much of their kingdom was on the East of the Rhine and still German speaking and un-latinized. But otherwise, they developed like the Visigoths.