There has been absolutely no indication that there is a Palestinian movement that has any any chance of bringing about change while showing any consideration for democratic values .
.... But if you believe Israel has the right to acquire nuclear weapons while Iran, or any other country in the region for that matter, does not, you must have a twisted sense of logic indeed....
Considering how silent the voices of Palestinians are in western media, I understand how you can say this.
However, when you read of days like this, you understand there is a large movement underfoot that is trying to bring about change without violence only to be shot at.
http://rabble.ca/news/2012/04/israel-opens-fire-global-march-jerusalem
Unfortunately the movement is still way underground and those in power are a wonderful mix of corruption and disposition to violence as a solution.
Dealmaker said:This is a country that brutalizes Palestinians and subjects them to daily indignities. This is a country that sticks its fingers in the eys of the world by continuing to build illegal settlements. To call Israel a democracy is to damn the word.
But if you believe Israel has the right to acquire nuclear weapons while Iran, or any other country in the region for that matter, does not, you must have a twisted sense of logic indeed.
Are they going to be stupid enough to use them against Israel knowing very well that they in turn would be wiped out?
groggy said:I'd say its the opposite.
You seem to be arguing that Israel should continue its violent and spiteful destruction of Palestine at the hands of a theocratic Jewish state, while most others hope that a one state solution with equal rights for all can be accomplished through the new non-violent movement coming out of Gaza and the West Bank.
You are the equivalent of Col Shalom Eisner randomly hitting non-violent protesters in the face with their gun.
groggy said:Actually that's not true. Hamas has gone over almost totally to non-violent protests now. Its only a few fringe groups in Gaza that are responding to Israel's aggression with aggression.
Dealmaker said:Basically you are an asshole with IQ of a rat. I have put you on my ignore list. Please do the same.
More posts than voters indicates very narrow interest in the subject.
Basically you are an asshole with IQ of a rat. I have put you on my ignore list. Please do the same.
On what basis? That Israel can have nuclear weapons to the silence of the west but Iran cannot? If not good for the gander, it shouldnt be good for the goose either.
Because they have had nukes for the last 45 years without issue and are not a part of the NPT. In fact most sources believe that Israel has had nukes since before the NPT and would therefore be titled an existing nuclear power (same as the US, Russia, China, UK, etc.) even if they had signed it.On what basis? That Israel can have nuclear weapons to the silence of the west but Iran cannot? If not good for the gander, it shouldnt be good for the goose either. Period. I mean Israel's nuclear weapons are not even acknowledged let alone anyone doing anything to get rid of them. To me this is mind boggling.
And I believe issues should be debated on their merits. Using terms like "horse shit" and "hate" and reciprocating with "asshole" label is wrong.
Poorly worded poll.....
I agree with Krugman here (and I almost never do, he's the smartest guy who's always wrong).
Israel is digging it's own grave, it's isolated itself to support from the US government and US Jewish funding, it's fighting peasants with tanks, it's building walls (no image issue there), it's going to lose the demographics battle at some point 20-30 years from now... and yet it plays for time when time is the last thing Israel has.
It will be interesting to see if the Jewish lobby hit's him hard on this....
OTB
Does the sun rise in the East?
Anyone who dares criticize Israel or any aspect of the Jewish religion is instantly labeled an anti-semite. It's a given.
Does the sun rise in the East?
Anyone who dares criticize Israel or any aspect of the Jewish religion is instantly labeled an anti-semite. It's a given.
Your post right here is in the same league. So let's look at facts. Israel is a democracy. Iran is not.
.
Tel Aviv mayor: Jewish law would turn Israel into Iran
A state based on Jewish law is a religious state; it's Iran," he said.