Afghanistan

You are now claiming that the canadian soldiers were in Afghanistan to protect the people helping the Afghan people. Is that the best you can come up with.

My problem is that "helping" the people of Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan inevitably involves killing a whole lot of them.

The typical dan problem of reading.

I said quite clearly in the post you ignored that the Canadian soldiers were there because they as individuals chose to be there.

The post you quoted is asking your opinion on our soldiers protecting aid missions and you chose to ignore the question.
 
The typical dan problem of reading.

I said quite clearly in the post you ignored that the Canadian soldiers were there because they as individuals chose to be there.

The post you quoted is asking your opinion on our soldiers protecting aid missions and you chose to ignore the question.

That is a bizarre post on so many levels.
 
Might be different in other situations but I understand that every single Canadian soldier deployed in Afghanistan volunteered to go knowing the risks. They weren't drafted. They weren't forced to go. They felt for reasons of their own which I am sure are varied that they CHOSE to serve.

Yes, may wars are to serve the agendas of others but that doesn't take away from the free will of soldiers to act as they felt was right.

Which is absolutely irrelevant to my point, just because people volunteered doesn't mean their lives are worth nothing. The number of casualties we expect to take MUST be weighed against the benefits of going to war, it is just ludicrous to suggest the cost in lives should not be considered.

Somehow you seem to think that anyone who volunteers is therefore worthless and their life of no value, that is the absurd implication of your claim.
 
...
Somehow you seem to think that anyone who volunteers is therefore worthless and their life of no value, that is the absurd implication of your claim.

Actually it seems you devalue the choice of those soldiers by telling them they were wrong. The Canadians who volunteered chose to put themselves at risk for what they felt is a good cause. You may disagree with their choice but they are the ones entitled to make it.
 
3 more Americans, including one doctor, murdered (by their "guard") in Afghanistan. Why are we there again?

"Ours is not to question why, but to do and die."
 
3 more Americans, including one doctor, murdered (by their "guard") in Afghanistan. Why are we there again?

"Ours is not to question why, but to do and die."

We aren't there.

BTW, the quote is "Theirs not to reason why, theirs but to do and die." Lord Tennyson's Charge of the Light Brigade. Fantastic piece of work.