Affirmative action for men

Would you support affirmative action for male students in university admissions?

  • Yes

    Votes: 19 35.8%
  • No

    Votes: 34 64.2%

  • Total voters
    53
Society's dirty secret about men is that we do nothing to address the significantly shorter life expectancy of men An average of 4-6 years in most countries including Canada.

Yet while there are women's only hospitals, and doctors who specialize in w.omen's health, there are no such initiatives for men's health issues.

Similarly, we do nothing to address the significantly higher incarceration rates of men, the significantly higher suicide rates of men, etc.

Life is not about how much money you make, nor about whether or not you are a CEO. It's about whether or not you are happy.

Maybe these discussions about men and women should be looking at ALL the variables, instead of just the the headline numbers that special interest groups advance in pursuit of their cause.

It is so absurd to suggest that 50% of the world (men), have been "keeping down" the other 50%. (women). There are pro's and con's on both sides, advantages and disadvantages for each gender.

When the "I am a Girl" charity folks stop me on Queen Street, I always ask "Where is the 'I am a Boy'" charity. They seem dumbfounded by the suggestion. Such is the double standard.
 
When the "I am a Girl" charity folks stop me on Queen Street, I always ask "Where is the 'I am a Boy'" charity. They seem dumbfounded by the suggestion. Such is the double standard.

This is a moronic false equivalency.

Watch "Half The Sky", Nick Kristof and his wife's amazing book and PBS series about women in the developing world, and you will never make such an absurdly smug comment again. A boy born in the world is born with a golden spoon, metaphorically speaking. To be born a girl is to be declared in vitro, already a second class citizen in about fifty thousands ways that matter.

This entire thread is filled with idiocy and idiots, just like much of TERB. Nuckle dragging men trapped in yesteryear and tedious machismo, hoping that they can take their half-baked bullshit theories and storm the world that's busy growing up outside of their computer windows. Jesus.
 
The problem is that when you have decades and centuries of an uneven playing field, suddenly making it level is NOT going to make it fair. Giving the ones who were stuck with the short end of the stick a bit of a boost is one (albeit flawed) way to try to bring things into real balance.

I agree that it's definitely an imperfect solution, but not so sure that it creates more problems than it solves. If you treat an entire population of people poorly for generations and give perks and advantages to the group on top, addressing the problem by giving some minor benefits to the ones you have been fucking over isn't the worst thing you can do. Especially considering the momentum and continuing perks/advantages the buggers on top keep getting.

Except that you aren't giving benefits to the ones who were fucked over, are you? The men of yesteryear still had an unfair advantage, and the women of yesteryear still got screwed over. Now we're providing benefits to women who didn't have to suffer that bias and screwing over men who had nothing to do with it.

It's akin to making reparations to African Americans for the enslaving of their ancestors.

EDIT: I can't believe two posters used the word "yesteryear" in subsequent posts lol.
 
But I fail to see how forcing sexism/racism (aka. affirmative action) was the right way to go about it, rather than just ensuring a level playing field.

First, while affirmative action is plainly discrimination based on sex or race, it is NOT sexism or racism, and that is just an incorrect and ignorant thing to say. Sexism and racism imply some level of hate or at least xenophobia that is plainly not present in an affirmative action initiative.

As to your point:

If we could just wave magic wands and create "level playing fields" that would be great, but we can't. Racism and sexism are part of the human element of the system, generally speaking there isn't overt discrimination in any policy manual anywhere saying "let's discriminate against girls" that you could just cross out. When you have a systemic problem that runs through the whole system, from end to end, then really creating a level playing field is a fantasy--you aren't going to be able to.

Systemic discrimination like that extends from girls growing up believing they aren't as capable, and that internalized belief impacting their performance, through their teachers in elementary, middle, and highschool giving them different encouragement, through bias at university in which students the professors select for extra encouragement of the, "have you considered graduate school" sort, to which graduate students get the most attention from the supervisor all the way on through implicit and unconscious discrimination in hiring and promotion in the workforce.

You can't just wave a magic wand and create a level playing field when you face that sort of thing. The ONLY way you'll ever get rid of it is to force the group suffering discrimination into the process, into every nook and cranny, until the notion that they don't belong there evaporates and the discriminatory ideas fade away.

I believe that affirmative action was necessary, and I believe it was effective. So effective that now something else has come to light--which is poorer performance by male students for perhaps inherent reasons. Men mature later, are more easily distracted, and less willing to adapt to change than women are, for a bunch of reasons that we don't totally understand.

I for one don't think it was healthy that we had a society where women were excluded from mainline participation, and it won't be healthy if we wind up with a society where men are.

Perhaps what we should do is simply assert that the quotas run both ways, that if one program hasn't got enough girls, it will have to implement a program to correct that; and if another program hasn't got enough boys, same thing. I don't think we need it to be exact, so that it's always 50-50, all the time, but when there's widespread and evident systematic bias then perhaps some action should be taken to correct that.
 
Society's dirty secret about men is that we do nothing to address the significantly shorter life expectancy of men An average of 4-6 years in most countries including Canada.

Yet while there are women's only hospitals, and doctors who specialize in w.omen's health, there are no such initiatives for men's health issues.

Similarly, we do nothing to address the significantly higher incarceration rates of men, the significantly higher suicide rates of men, etc.

Life is not about how much money you make, nor about whether or not you are a CEO. It's about whether or not you are happy.

Maybe these discussions about men and women should be looking at ALL the variables, instead of just the the headline numbers that special interest groups advance in pursuit of their cause.

It is so absurd to suggest that 50% of the world (men), have been "keeping down" the other 50%. (women). There are pro's and con's on both sides, advantages and disadvantages for each gender.

When the "I am a Girl" charity folks stop me on Queen Street, I always ask "Where is the 'I am a Boy'" charity. They seem dumbfounded by the suggestion. Such is the double standard.

With the exception of birds, males have higher mortality in almost every species in the world. What program is this that you are planning to reverse deeply ingrained biological issues.

But, there is no biological reason that a few years ago a major study determined that women do 70% of the world's labour, earn about 10% of the world's pay and own about 1% of the world's property.
 
With the exception of birds, males have higher mortality in almost every species in the world. What program is this that you are planning to reverse deeply ingrained biological issues.

But, there is no biological reason that a few years ago a major study determined that women do 70% of the world's labour, earn about 10% of the world's pay and own about 1% of the world's property.

I missed you! ;)
 
first world problems on display here
 
First, while affirmative action is plainly discrimination based on sex or race, it is NOT sexism or racism, and that is just an incorrect and ignorant thing to say. Sexism and racism imply some level of hate or at least xenophobia that is plainly not present in an affirmative action initiative.

An action doesn't have to be deemed hate-motivated to be coined sexism or racism, nor do I imply that is the case here. In fact, I think affirmative action was instituted under moral motivations, which is quite the opposite. It's all in the semantics, and I don't think we should really spend time on that.

I'm sure you and I have already argued this in another thread, because I seem to recall most of your points. You're right, we can not guarantee a level playing field...so we encourage an uneven one? That's the solution? I imagine (correct me if I'm wrong) that you support affirmative action for males in the university application process? Lets say we implement that. So 15 - 20 years down the road it again flips, with males being more prevalent. Do we change it around again? How far past that balance point do we wait before we take action? Male/Female presence on university campuses will start to resemble a sine curve, with one gender being screwed over at one point of time, and the other at other times, with a short period of time where things are equitable. I say equitable as in both genders will be equally represented. Yet at no time will the application process be fair and balanced. Under this method one gender will always be preferred. This method screws over the deserving, and uplifts the undeserving. I can't support that.

Maybe it's a generational belief. I'd like to see ages put to each vote in this poll. I remember taking a sociology class damn near a decade ago. At one point we were talking about sexism and it's role in our world. The teacher (he was male) would constantly argue that females were undervalued and underprivileged and that the problem was ingrained in our society. He would provide the usual statistics, mostly related to unequal pay in the business world. He received a lot of pushback to his arguments, exclusively from female students (after all, a male student daring to speak up against it would face social reprisal and few would value his arguments, but rather depict them as self-serving). These young women didn't see that discrimination, nor had they all their lives. Yet they saw the reverse. They saw support groups and programs set up exclusively to help women in their studies, with no equivalent for male students.

Like I said, academia is one thing, and I think unfortunately that it is now biased against males (if not heavily). The business world is another thing entirely, but I have yet to see a real world example of women being undervalued in my trade. Women are underrepresented in my trade, but their roles and compensation are equitable to their male counterparts. Women being underrepresented in my trade is not a systemic problem. I receive more than twenty resumes from men seeking positions for every one resume from a woman. Should I hire 1 woman for every man? Should I even hire 1 woman for every twenty men? I don't believe in either. I will always hire based on merit alone, and if government legislation dictates that I do otherwise, I will try my best to lessen its impact and continue as I was. Sorry, I believe that even if we can't achieve a level playing field, we should always strive for it.
 
well said. My son is struggling with his chosen career path and sees exactly this... women and minorities have an advantage, and the women don't even understand why. There are women who aren't working as hard as him but they have more opportunities. I keep saying to him 'there must be some program or course for this or that...there was when I was that age.... " and he is telling me there isn't ... he's a white male born in Canada. He's absolutely at a disadvantage. It sucks.

Just explain to him that white males had it good in the past and he is being punished for it. I'm sure he'll understand.... Unfortunately, this is the way it works. Even worse, it's being done in the name of equality.
 
With the exception of birds, males have higher mortality in almost every species in the world. What program is this that you are planning to reverse deeply ingrained biological issues.

But, there is no biological reason that a few years ago a major study determined that women do 70% of the world's labour, earn about 10% of the world's pay and own about 1% of the world's property.

Ah, I see....

...so the problems which face women, are caused by men.
...and the problems which face men are "that's just the way men are"?
 
This is a moronic false equivalency.

Watch "Half The Sky", Nick Kristof and his wife's amazing book and PBS series about women in the developing world, and you will never make such an absurdly smug comment again. A boy born in the world is born with a golden spoon, metaphorically speaking. To be born a girl is to be declared in vitro, already a second class citizen in about fifty thousands ways that matter.

This entire thread is filled with idiocy and idiots, just like much of TERB. Nuckle dragging men trapped in yesteryear and tedious machismo, hoping that they can take their half-baked bullshit theories and storm the world that's busy growing up outside of their computer windows. Jesus.

Actually, I do yoga, pilates, ballet and cry when watching chick flicks. A macho knuckle dragger I am not.

Take a read of your post and mine, and tell me who sounds like the "idiotic knuckle dragger".

The sign of a weak argument is when you need to resort to attacking the other person with insults. Think about it.
 
Except that you aren't giving benefits to the ones who were fucked over, are you? The men of yesteryear still had an unfair advantage, and the women of yesteryear still got screwed over. Now we're providing benefits to women who didn't have to suffer that bias and screwing over men who had nothing to do with it.
Except that's not entirely true. There's a hella strong momentum to power and privilege sticking with those folks that it has traditionally been invested in - even after we've all held hands and sung kumbaya by the campfire. Just because it's no longer the 50s and career women are no longer an anomaly, doesn't mean the playing field really is level.

On top of which, hella lot of the gnashing of teef going on about women or minorities getting the plumb positions is a crock. Almost without exception it turns out to be a situation where a candidate is chosen over an EQUALLY QUALIFIED white male candidate. And Imma OK with that.

It's akin to making reparations to African Americans for the enslaving of their ancestors.
And I see it as more akin to recognizing that generations of segregation and keeping African Americans ghettoized is NOT going to be fixed by saying "Oh, hey there! We're all equal now. (sorry about the squalor. And the shitty underfunded schooling. And the rotten environment you're stuck in with a statistically minuscule chance of ever escaping. But hey, at least we're equal now. It's all good, right?)"
 
And I see it as more akin to recognizing that generations of segregation and keeping African Americans ghettoized is NOT going to be fixed by saying "Oh, hey there! We're all equal now. (sorry about the squalor. And the shitty underfunded schooling. And the rotten environment you're stuck in with a statistically minuscule chance of ever escaping. But hey, at least we're equal now. It's all good, right?)"

Providing proper funding for underfunded schools does not have a negative impact on other students, so that would be perfectly fine and expected actually. Providing affordable housing for low income families in underprivileged areas of the country is also a fair and equitable deal, as it doesn't put undue, negative stresses on other individuals.

Accepting students to university, where there is a limited number of placements available, based on their skin colour or sex, rather than their academic performance is a completely different scenario. Hiring an individual to meet a quota is disgusting in my eyes when it turns out you are passing over a more qualified individual. I've hired a lot of people, and rarely do I come across equally qualified individuals. I may interview several candidates, but when I'm done, I leave with a clear choice of first pick, second pick, third pick. I'd go so far as to say there is no such thing as an equally qualified candidate, considering that even if their resumes matched perfectly, performance in an interview or similar environment is a subjective measure.

That is beside the point anyway, because picking an individual based on race or sex is discriminatory, and doing so is unfair to the individuals who would otherwise have a fair shot at the position. Actions designed to help one group reach the same ground other groups are standing on are great. Actions designed to benefit one group, while hindering another are not.
 
Society's dirty secret about men is that we do nothing to address the significantly shorter life expectancy of men An average of 4-6 years in most countries including Canada.

Yet while there are women's only hospitals, and doctors who specialize in w.omen's health, there are no such initiatives for men's health issues.

Similarly, we do nothing to address the significantly higher incarceration rates of men, the significantly higher suicide rates of men, etc.

Life is not about how much money you make, nor about whether or not you are a CEO. It's about whether or not you are happy.

Maybe these discussions about men and women should be looking at ALL the variables, instead of just the the headline numbers that special interest groups advance in pursuit of their cause.

It is so absurd to suggest that 50% of the world (men), have been "keeping down" the other 50%. (women). There are pro's and con's on both sides, advantages and disadvantages for each gender.

When the "I am a Girl" charity folks stop me on Queen Street, I always ask "Where is the 'I am a Boy'" charity. They seem dumbfounded by the suggestion. Such is the double standard.

Quite corrrect.

"Male bashing" is completely socially acceptable.

Men in the media are portrayed often as fools, oaffs, idiots and just general dumb-asses whilst their female partners are portrayed as wise and inteligent.

Think about how many times you've seen a movie where a guy gets punched, kicked, shot in the balls and people laugh. Now imagine if if it was a woman shown having the same done to her genitals. Don't think that would fly.
 
explain why men on average still earn more than women? if they are disadvantaged in university admissions?

Men make more generally, because they do jobs that many women won't. They often commuter farther, work longer hours, etc. There has been several studies done on this topic.