Affirmative action for men

Would you support affirmative action for male students in university admissions?

  • Yes

    Votes: 19 35.8%
  • No

    Votes: 34 64.2%

  • Total voters
    53

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
Male students are being squeezed out of professional programs and universities by smarter, harder working female students. A majority of spots in universities and professional programs now go to women, due to their superior academic performance and their superior test scores.

Would you support an affirmative action program to give university spots to males, denying entry to a female student with higher grades in the name of gender parity?

Poll attached.
 
Wow, you're really obessesed with this topic aren't you?

I would not support your proposal. For the simple reason that, as far as I know, affirmative action was based on the fact that the groups that it was supposed to assist (women, African-Americans etc) were not achieving their potential because of discriminatory action by academic institutions and policies. They were denied placement in high schools that would have academically benefited them, denied placement in classes necessary as pre-requisites for subjects that they wished to study in university, and denied placement in universities themselves despite equal or better test scores than males, or Caucasians. In your case, males are given equal opportunities, they are just wasting them. Women are earning their placements in universities because of their hard work and skill, not because of discrimination. You can argue that there is a bias forming that pushes females onto the university track, I don't particularly agree with that, I guess it's an argument, but I don't believe there is active discrimination that would be basis for an affirmative action-type program.
I just think high school curriculum needs to do a better job of positioning men to succeed in high school and beyond.
 
explain why men on average still earn more than women? if they are disadvantaged in university admissions?
 
Preferential treatment ("affirmative action") in university admissions, job hiring, etc. of any group of people for any reason is discrimination, and should be abolished.
The most qualified person should get the job. Full stop.
 
explain why men on average still earn more than women? if they are disadvantaged in university admissions?

The answer to your question is so painfully obvious and magnificently irrelevant as to boggle the mind.
 
The answer to your question is so painfully obvious and magnificently irrelevant as to boggle the mind.

i was asking Fuji
 
explain why men on average still earn more than women? if they are disadvantaged in university admissions?

Because it is an un-weighted statistic, looking only at average annual incomes. That statistic takes no account for training, seniority, experience, negotiating skills, or how much work is actually done.

Everytime someone trots that statistic out, they want people to think that a woman will get paid 30%(the typical number thrown around) less than a male counterpart just because she is female, but that isn't the case.
 
It's commonly known that both men and women are easier on women than on men. Women doing better in school and University than men is probably due to teachers being more lenient on women than men and grading them easier. On top of that many female teachers, professors and TA's have a political agenda to "make things equal in the workplace" so they silently up the grades of their female counterparts and hire more female staff. Combine this with teachers and TA's more likey to sleep with female students than males, and teachers giving a break to any sob story female whose grandma died over the weekend (when in fact she was probably partying and fucking her boyfriend), and there you go, more women in schools and universities and workforce. No brainer. On top of all of that, teachers and employers don't want to look like they are encouraging an "all boys club" so they routinely hire more women and promote just to look like they are being fair. None of this has anything to do with actual performance or talent, just the politics surrounding it.

All you need to do is observe a girl outside of work or school (i.e. at a club, at the mall, at the food court) and you know how dumb they really are. Ever been in a relationship? Ever seen a girl when she's with other girls? Ever seen whom a women chooses to have sex with and have as a boyfriend? Ever seen what women do after they break up with you or you go through a divorce?

It's all bullshit. No real world examples of how women behave on the day to day can convince me that they are smart. None. Maybe one or two. But whom women choose to date is a direct reflection on whether they would be good to run a company or not. If they make the stupidest choices from those available, no way would I let them run a company or elect into office. Sarah Palin? come on. Girls can't even get their act together between girls. We're going to take them seriously anywhere else? We tolerate it, and are way too slow to do anything about it that's all. Also men leaving school or the workforce, does not imply that women are smarter than men. It's like a professional athlete retiring, and then the competition saying that they are better (yeah, by default).
 
explain why men on average still earn more than women? if they are disadvantaged in university admissions?

I believe that under 30 women out-earn men. The stat is skewed by people over 40 who graduated from university at a time when things were skewed in favour of men.
 
It's commonly known that both men and women are easier on women than on men. Women doing better in school and University than men is probably due to teachers being more lenient on women than men and grading them easier. On top of that many female teachers, professors and TA's have a political agenda to "make things equal in the workplace" so they silently up the grades of their female counterparts and hire more female staff. Combine this with teachers and TA's more likey to sleep with female students than males, and teachers giving a break to any sob story female whose grandma died over the weekend (when in fact she was probably partying and fucking her boyfriend), and there you go, more women in schools and universities and workforce. No brainer. On top of all of that, teachers and employers don't want to look like they are encouraging an "all boys club" so they routinely hire more women and promote just to look like they are being fair. None of this has anything to do with actual performance or talent, just the politics surrounding it.

All you need to do is observe a girl outside of work or school (i.e. at a club, at the mall, at the food court) and you know how dumb they really are. Ever been in a relationship? Ever seen a girl when she's with other girls? Ever seen whom a women chooses to have sex with and have as a boyfriend? Ever seen what women do after they break up with you or you go through a divorce?

It's all bullshit. No real world examples of how women behave on the day to day can convince me that they are smart. None. Maybe one or two. But whom women choose to date is a direct reflection on whether they would be good to run a company or not. If they make the stupidest choices from those available, no way would I let them run a company or elect into office. Sarah Palin? come on. Girls can't even get their act together between girls. We're going to take them seriously anywhere else? We tolerate it, and are way too slow to do anything about it that's all. Also men leaving school or the workforce, does not imply that women are smarter than men. It's like a professional athlete retiring, and then the competition saying that they are better (yeah, by default).

You're quite the sweetheart aren't you?
 
i answered based ont he title of the thread before i read the question lol.
 
Male students are being squeezed out of professional programs and universities by smarter, harder working female students. A majority of spots in universities and professional programs now go to women, due to their superior academic performance and their superior test scores.

Would you support an affirmative action program to give university spots to males, denying entry to a female student with higher grades in the name of gender parity?

Poll attached.

If they are smarter, work harder, have superior academic performance and test scores then they should get the job.
 
I read somewhere that girls are outperforming boys in school because guys are wasting their time on videogames, but girls aren't. On the other hand, I can totally see that evening out in the long run as I think girls will start to spend too much time on social media.

Regardless, in the real world, I have always found that men outperform women. In part, because we're more aggressive in the workplace where success isn't built around writing tests, and in part, because once the going gets tough mid-career, most women don't tough it out and instead, run off to have children. They never recover their full earning potential afterwards.
 
I read somewhere that girls are outperforming boys in school because guys are wasting their time on videogames, but girls aren't. On the other hand, I can totally see that evening out in the long run as I think girls will start to spend too much time on social media.

Regardless, in the real world, I have always found that men outperform women. In part, because we're more aggressive in the workplace where success isn't built around writing tests, and in part, because once the going gets tough mid-career, most women don't tough it out and instead, run off to have children. They never recover their full earning potential afterwards.

I don't know if it is matter of the going getting touch or some such, but you make an important point. Many women make life choices that cause them to make less money than the average man.

The field of law is particularly hit by this. It has nothing to do with innate intellect or work ethic or discrimination/reverse discrimination, it is a matter of individual choice.
 
It's commonly known that both men and women are easier on women than on men. Women doing better in school and University than men is probably due to teachers being more lenient on women than men and grading them easier. On top of that many female teachers, professors and TA's have a political agenda to "make things equal in the workplace" so they silently up the grades of their female counterparts and hire more female staff. Combine this with teachers and TA's more likey to sleep with female students than males, and teachers giving a break to any sob story female whose grandma died over the weekend (when in fact she was probably partying and fucking her boyfriend), and there you go, more women in schools and universities and workforce. No brainer. On top of all of that, teachers and employers don't want to look like they are encouraging an "all boys club" so they routinely hire more women and promote just to look like they are being fair. None of this has anything to do with actual performance or talent, just the politics surrounding it.

All you need to do is observe a girl outside of work or school (i.e. at a club, at the mall, at the food court) and you know how dumb they really are. Ever been in a relationship? Ever seen a girl when she's with other girls? Ever seen whom a women chooses to have sex with and have as a boyfriend? Ever seen what women do after they break up with you or you go through a divorce?

It's all bullshit. No real world examples of how women behave on the day to day can convince me that they are smart. None. Maybe one or two. But whom women choose to date is a direct reflection on whether they would be good to run a company or not. If they make the stupidest choices from those available, no way would I let them run a company or elect into office. Sarah Palin? come on. Girls can't even get their act together between girls. We're going to take them seriously anywhere else? We tolerate it, and are way too slow to do anything about it that's all. Also men leaving school or the workforce, does not imply that women are smarter than men. It's like a professional athlete retiring, and then the competition saying that they are better (yeah, by default).


This is exactly why affirmative action was created. Because in this posters mind, no women could be smarter then him. No minority male. Anyone who is proven to be smarter has somehow been given a free ride or a free pass on something. It is never on their own merit.

A choice in dating reflects on how a person would run a company??? You are calling out Sarah Paulin????? LMAO!!! Seems for stupid political figures Clinton comes to mind. How many CEO were STUPID and got busted cheating?????? But it only counts when looking at the stupidity of women. Never men.

When people have their head up their ass, they can not see the light of day. I don't blame them. Just thankful it is not them making the rules.
 
Considering there's still affirmative action in place for females by way of scholarships, it's not likely to happen. And I wouldn't support it anyway. Let everyone get in on their own merits, not their sex or skin colour. I'm against all forms of affirmative action.
 
Even though I hate Affirmative Action and everything it stands for, you have to be foolish to say that we have it tough, while women have it easy.

There are boy clubs at workplaces everywhere. We love to discuss, women, sex, work,politics while maintaining the relationships with our SO.

And there is no way a female can get into our inner circle. As long as you're a male with wits enough to get your ass through the school, you are deemed to be successful. Women? You will have to work your ass off.
 
Nope.

Young males today are a sorry fucking lot. Not all of them, but a definite majority. I don't blame the school system. I blame the parents who baby these kids. I see it all the time. (Either that, or there is something in the water making young males lazy sad sacks.)

PS

I hire both University grads and students. (Always Engineering Students - from Waterloo, U of T, McMaster.)

The best student I ever hired was a young woman. She was ON THE BALL. Tough kid, smart, organized.

That said, I've hired some young males who were equally on the ball and smart.

And I've fucked up twice over the years and hired 2 completely useless boobs and both of them happened to be male.