Acura or Lexus

Compared to a Q50 with AWD ?

As I said, IF the Subaru full time AWD system is slightly better than my Q50, but will NOT allow the car handle like a rear drive sports sedan, for most of the year, sorry, I enjoy the handling of a sports sedan more than a possible better AWD system.

Don't get me wrong, I'm NOT saying that the Subaru is a bad car, or not worth the cost, just have to consider other aspects than AWD.

The Scion FRS uses the Subie boxer motor, which enables it to have the lowest center of gravity of ANY car on the road.

FAST

The difference is your q50 lacks the ground clearance to get through real snow, forester/outback/crosstrek all have nearly four inches better clearance.

Subaru AWD will in fact be better, especially in more recent versions which have a traction mode, your AWD is designed to avoid slips in wet weather and won't often do the right thing when a tire gets stuck (may send no power to the only wheel with grip), but that is much a smaller factor. The much bigger factors in getting through deep snow are snow tires and ground clearance.

Getting through snow isn't rocket science, it is about traction tires, bottom of the vehicle clearing the snow so you don't high center, and somehow getting power to a wheel that has grip. Any AWD will be better then FWD so that difference will be small and is the smallest factor already.

You can and should get snow tires and your AWD will be almist as good, but unless you go jack up your suspension there is a simple physical reason why you just aren't going where a Subaru can go: your car will push a snow drift in front of it until it builds up 5 inches of pack and then your four wheels will be spinning in the air.

Same thing on crappy logging roads, a Subaru can clear a rock 3.5 inches taller than the one that will take out your oil pan. Again, it is about tires and ground clearance, with the AWD being only the third factor in getting through.
 
Engine won't turn over wouldn't be a CVT issue. Most likely a dead battery. Hesitant while accelerating is likely CVT but the question is whether it was actually hesitant or just didn't sound the same to somebody coming from a different platform.

Last week I test drove an Outback 3.6R with CVT. It did drone a bit with maintaining a steady speed and although hesitate isn't the right word, it was slow to accelerate --- I think this is because the CVT in the standard mode is optimized for fuel economy (it's gets great mileage!). I then played with the two sport modes (sport, sport#), the drone disappeared and the transmission/car was very responsive. I was quite pleased with the performance.

It was only a 30 minute test drive, so it's a limited sample, but based on the drive I would hesitate to buy an Outback with a CVT.