Acquital for Zimmerman

It seems that this SYG law has effectively legalised duels and O.K. Corral style shootouts. Whoever wins just claims that they were standing their ground.

There will generally be a great deal of uncertainty about how it started and the winner will just say he feared the loser.

thats my take as well


Fuji, you can't read. Seriously. There as to be an attack by someone against another before you can invoke the right to stand your ground under Florida law. There's no evidence that TM was attacked. Other than the point blank GSW from GZ lying on the ground, did TM have injuries consistent with him being attacked? I'm not aware of any mentioned or discussed in this case.
 
I seriously doubt that fuji.

What I expect happened is after Martin questioned Zimmerman, George responded in an aggressive way feeling tough instead of calming the situation. How much of his tough attitude was because he knew he had a gun and how much was just his normal attitude I don't know. The next reasonable step is Martin thew a punch.
I will agree with you that this may well have been what occurred. The problem is with your last sentence above. Perhaps in T.M. mind it was reasonable to throw a punch when questioned aggressively or he felt "disrespected." Legally, however, the situation has just profoundly changed when you physically assault someone (throw the first punch).
 
Going back to #409,

"The whole reason that 60 percent of the states in the U.S. now have "stand-your-ground" laws are prosecutions that the public saw as being unfair (there have been discussions of such cases in the GTA here on TERB). Where (my opinion) overzealous prosecutors, looked at cases and said well the defendant didn't retreat long enough or far enough before they turned and confronted their attacker."

So how do you two propose to solve this problem? Particularly given that 30 state legislatures were so stupid that they were unable to figure out any other way than a SYG law.

Change your attitude about violence being a good solution and support the over zealous prosecutors who have it right.

The reason why you adopted those laws are the same reasons why you have so much gun violence.

You are a warlike country where everybody believes that a violent response is the best response and so voted for laws that promote violence.
 
SYG has nothing to do with being prevented from going somewhere GP. Read it. I posted it above.

The version I related is just as well supported by the facts as Z's version. The uncertainty about which is the truth is why both men are innocent. There is a reasonable doubt as to which of them is to blame.


You seem to think it does Fuji.

You think that it gives TM the right to confront GZ (and prevent GZ from being where he is entitled to be), then attack him when he's not satisfied as to an answer.

Your version doesn't fit what evidence there is in this case either, even if circumstantial.
 
Change your attitude about violence being a good solution and support the over zealous prosecutors who have it right.
Which sounds like you are saying that when in the middle of the night someone dressed in black breaks into your house through a ground floor window and refuses to obey your commands and you can't see whether or not they are armed - you should just ask them to join you in a chorus of Kumbaya or Dona nobis pacem.

In other words you haven't answered the question at all.
 
I will agree with you that this may well have been what occurred. The problem is with your last sentence above. Perhaps in T.M. mind it was reasonable to throw a punch when questioned aggressively or he felt "disrespected." Legally, however, the situation has just profoundly changed when you physically assault someone (throw the first punch).

In this scenario, TM is the attacker. He is the one who confronts the neighborhood watchman GZ and even prevents GZ from being where he would like to be. GZ has a SYG right in this scenario too, not TM, even if GZ pissed off TM, but that was a nuisance and not an imminent threat to his life, otherwise, TM would dart out of there or avoid GZ.
 
I am interested that in all the hypotheticals above no one seems to be paying much attention to what Rachel Jeantel has actually admitted in her recent television interviews.
 
I am interested that in all the hypotheticals above no one seems to be paying much attention to what Rachel Jeantel has actually admitted in her recent television interviews.

I did mention that she said she believes TM threw the 1st punch. Is that what you were talking about?
 
You seem to think it does Fuji.

You think that it gives TM the right to confront GZ (and prevent GZ from being where he is entitled to be), then attack him when he's not satisfied as to an answer.

Your version doesn't fit what evidence there is in this case either, even if circumstantial.

Confronting someone does not mean preventing them from being anywhere nor does it mean attacking them.

It means approaching them and verbally demanding an answer.

Let me know if you needed any other English words clarified I am always happy to educate new Canadians who are struggling with the language.
 
Change your attitude about violence being a good solution and support the over zealous prosecutors who have it right.

The reason why you adopted those laws are the same reasons why you have so much gun violence.

You are a warlike country where everybody believes that a violent response is the best response and so voted for laws that promote violence.


Well, those guest lawyers on CNN did say that the SYG law reinforces the 2nd Amendment if not give it a broader interpretation.
 
Which sounds like you are saying that when in the middle of the night someone dressed in black breaks into your house through a ground floor window and refuses to obey your commands and you can't see whether or not they are armed - you should just ask them to join you in a chorus of Kumbaya or Dona nobis pacem.

In other words you haven't answered the question at all.

Nope. It means I think you should flee from the danger and use force only as a last resort, and only the minimum amount of force reasonably required.

Americans, and Canadians who watch too much American TV, don't like that answer because it flies in the face of their pro-violent and warlike culture.
 
Confronting someone does not mean preventing them from being anywhere nor does it mean attacking them.

It means approaching them and verbally demanding an answer.

Let me know if you needed any other English words clarified I am always happy to educate new Canadians who are struggling with the language.


I should teach you that many English words have more than one meaning.

In any event, the evidence suggests that TM stopped or surprised GZ in his tracks and suckered punch him to enable TM to get on top of a heavier GZ. Even RJ says TM punched first.

How this equates to TM have a SYG right is beyond me.
 
In any event, the evidence suggests that TM stopped or surprised GZ in his tracks and suckered punch him to enable TM to get on top of a heavier GZ. Even RJ says TM punched first.

How this equates to TM have a SYG right is beyond me.

if trayvon felt threatened and trapped by the larger GZ on a dark street, then he would be justified in shooting or punching GZ
 
... suckered punch....

Very loaded term. We don't know if that's what happened. It is possible that Martin and Zimmerman both threw but Martin was faster, Zimmerman pushed him, or literally challenged him to a fight.

Maybe I missed it but nowhere does George say what happened between the Martin's question and being on his back nor is there other evidence.
 
I should teach you that many English words have more than one meaning.

In any event, the evidence suggests that TM stopped or surprised GZ in his tracks and suckered punch him to enable TM to get on top of a heavier GZ. Even RJ says TM punched first.

How this equates to TM have a SYG right is beyond me.

No doubt he did surprise him but how do you know that the punch wasn't because Z pulled out a gun or some other violent threat? You just take Z's word for it?
 
if trayvon felt threatened and trapped by the larger GZ on a dark street, then he would be justified in shooting or punching GZ

Speaking hypothetically, but remember what RJ said suggests that TM felt that GZ was following him. He didn't feel threatened or else he would've not confronted GZ. He acted as though his space was violated and it seems he confronted him, unless they accidentally and unexpectedly crossed paths.

Under SGY law, he must be attacked (I don't know if 'feeling threatened or trapped' is enough to justify deadly force).
 
I did mention that she said she believes TM threw the 1st punch. Is that what you were talking about?

in this case who threw the first punch didnt matter, because there was no proof either way. What mattered was Zimmerman legal team convinced the jury he acted in self defence .