Acquital for Zimmerman

that is interesting ..... is the commentary suggesting that in RJs and TMs culture, whoop ass only means that he is going to adminster a beating? not a lethal beating?


Only if proper notice is given (what a silly notion - can't believe they put her on national TV).
 
Really. Did you look at the website? every minute of the actual trial is packaged into nice bite sized videos.

Precisely my point. Video snippets put together by a website describing itself as fighting against governmental authority seems a bit to biased for my tastes.

Of course that is besides the point since Zimmerman's statement to police was entered into evidence and in it he stated that he only got out of his car to check for a street sign (despite there only being 3 streets in the neighbourhood) then instead of checking the street sign or street numbers proceeded to follow Martin down a path to another street.
 
However, that is not what the evidence showed. The evidence showed that T.M. approached G.Z. and said words to the effect of why was he following him. In other words that the first contact between the two of them was instigated by T.M. How on earth does that get into "stand your ground"

Stand your ground seems to include defending yourself instead of fleeing which I'm sure even a half-assed lawyer could use to defend Martin from assault charges.

If I was neighbourhood watch, was stupidly following a suspicious person, and that person approached me asking what my problem was, I'd calmly say, 'Hi, I'm George with the neighbourhood watch. I didn't recognize you and wanted to see if you needed help finding an address.' Unfortunately that doesn't seem to be how Zimmerman responded (and yes, I can guarantee you that between Martin's reported comment and the start of violence there was enough time for George to verbally respond which he quite possibly did is a more aggressive way than my example).
 
p.s. Just a reminder that 'Not Guilty' does not mean 'Innocent'. In a legal sense they might be synonymous but there is a big difference.
 
Stand your ground seems to include defending yourself instead of fleeing.
In a traditional jurisdiction: you have a duty to retreat in a public place, if you can before you engage in self-defence.

The whole reason that 60 percent of the states in the U.S. now have "stand-your-ground" laws are prosecutions that the public saw as being unfair (there have been discussions of such cases in the GTA here on TERB). Where (my opinion) overzealous prosecutors, looked at cases and said well the defendant didn't retreat long enough or far enough before they turned and confronted their attacker.
 
ZimmermAn has always, and will continue to be INNOCENT.

DO YOU FOLKS NOT UNDERSTAND THE BASIC FOUNDATION OF WESTERN LAW, THAT BEING.....'You are innocent until proven guilty'

He is INNOCENT, AND ALWAYS WILL BE UNTIL A COURT PROCESS FINDS HIM GUILTY.

PERIOD
 
However, that is not what the evidence showed. The evidence showed that T.M. approached G.Z. and said words to the effect of why was he following him. In other words that the first contact between the two of them was instigated by T.M. How on earth does that get into "stand your ground"

Martin had every right to confront Z and demand to know why he was following him.

When Z then became violent M had every right to stand his ground and defend himself.
 
Martin had every right to confront Z and demand to know why he was following him.

When Z then became violent M had every right to stands his ground.

As stated earlier, ZIMMERMAN is innocent. ( read above)

No matter who 'stood their ground' , that too has limits.

I can consent to a fight with you Fuji, And there would be no assault charge implications.

But, if, inevitably, I start beating you to pulp, which likely would happen, it would no longer be consensual on your part, and I may face assault charges.

Or conversely, if you by some remote chance took that consent fight too far, and inexplicably somehow started bashing my head on the sidewalk, I would then be able to blow you away without consequence. This is true in both Canada and the USA
 
More food for thought in this article by John Sexton.


"John Sexton
17 July 2013

Rachel Jeantel Says Martin Threw the First Punch

In an interview with Marc Lamont Hill, Rachel Jeantel says she believes Trayvon Martin threw the first punch in the altercation that ultimately led to his death. She also believes Trayvon was in fact beating Zimmerman but suggests he would have stopped short of killing him.

Hill's 25-minute interview with Jeantel offered a more detailed account of what she believes happened than has been revealed previously. "Trayvon was not doing nothing" Jeantel tells Hill.

At this point, Hill attempts to draw her out more fully "So, just so I understand you right, you're saying--you're depiction of what happened is that George Zimmerman is pursuing Trayvon?" Jeantel replies "Yes." Hill continues his line of questioning, "At some point a fight breaks out, who swings--who hits who first in your mind?" Jeantel replies "In my mind, I believe Trayvon. It was Trayvon..."

At this point Jeantel begins talking about Martin's headset. She asks the rhetorical question "Why would Trayvon leave me on the phone if he was going to start something?" She implies that because Trayvon did not say anything to her about an impending fight he must not have known it was coming.

Hill refocuses with another question "If Trayvon swung first, what do you think Zimmerman did to make him swing first?" Jeantel replies "I believe Zimmerman was a wannabe cop trying to say 'Oh, I got you.'" Hill then brings up a theory which has been discussed by some in the media since the verdict "Do you think he pulled his gun out?" Jeantel replies "No, I believe he tryin' to grab him. 'Okay, I got you, you coming with me.'"

So it appears Jeantel's view is that Zimmerman put his hands on Martin and then Martin responded by throwing a punch. However in testimony at trial Jeantel never claimed to have heard anyone saying "Okay, I got you." She testified that Martin initiated the confrontation by asking Zimmerman "What you following me for?" Zimmerman responded "What are you doing around here?" At this point she says she heard a bump and faintly heard Martin say "get off."

It is telling that Jeantel can only describe her version of events by inventing a new bit of dialogue for George Zimmerman, i.e. "Okay, I got you." Clearly it would have fit better if Zimmerman had said "Okay, I got you" and then assaulted Martin, but he didn't say that. So you have to assume Zimmerman asked "What you doing around here?" and then put his hands on Martin without waiting for an answer. The words and actions don't seem to escalate in a normal manner. Jeantel's mind fills in that gap with something that would fit, "Okay, I got you."

Zimmerman's account was that Martin approached him and asked "You got a problem, motherf--ker?" Zimmerman says he backed up, reached for his phone and replied "I don't have a problem." At this point he claims Martin said "You got a problem now" and punched him in the nose. Is it true? Obviously only Zimmerman knows for certain, but his account does escalate with a certain logic. The words and actions of his account don't have any obvious gaps that need to be filled in to explain how one thing led to another.

The other interesting part of Jeantel's interview is her claim, also made on Piers Morgan Tuesday night, that Zimmerman should have taken his beating. Hill pointed out "George Zimmerman's defenders would say well, if he didn't pull out a gun, if Trayvon was whoopin' his ass he could have killed George Zimmerman." Jeantel replies "No. Trust me. That's not killing. You have a big bruise, you don't see inside your skin. You might have a little stitches." Jeantel adds "He [Trayvon] would have fight him and run."

Even if Jeantel is right about Martin's intentions, there is no way George Zimmerman, who was the one taking a beating and therefore very probably the one calling for help, to have known that."
 
As stated earlier, ZIMMERMAN is innocent. ( read above)

No matter who 'stood their ground' , that too has limits.

I can consent to a fight with you Fuji, And there would be no assault charge implications.

But, if, inevitably, I start beating you to pulp, which likely would happen, it would no longer be consensual on your part, and I may face assault charges.

Yes he is. So is Martin.

Zimmerman had a gun and it would seem they were struggling for control if the gun. That is what I would do too if someone hunted me and then pointed a gun at me.
 
As stated earlier, ZIMMERMAN is innocent. ( read above)

My understanding is you are innocent until proven guilty. Therefore not guilty is a statement that the prosecution has not proven you guilty of any thing therefore your status of innocent has hot changed.
 
My understanding is you are innocent until proven guilty. Therefore not guilty is a statement that the prosecution has not proven you guilty of any thing therefore your status of innocent has hot changed.

Yes, quite correct.
 
I was watching an angry :mad:Larry Elder on Piers Morgan last night and he blasted the politically correct Piers and the rest of the media for focusing so much attention on this one case when X (I forgot the actual number) number of young Black males have been killed (mostly at the hands of other young Black males) since Trayvon died. Larry cited Chicago as one example and asked why there is so little or no media coverage of those murders?
 
Its all about ratings my man....RATINGS!!

Nothing more.

They find hot city..Miami.....some racial tension, man vs boy deal...And blow it up for ratings!?

Larry Elder was quite right to be angry...and was correct.

As he said...3% of the black population are committing 50% of the murders in America.....further suggesting 75% of these are from single parent homes.

Quite rightly, that is the issue to address...... NOT GZ

GZ was an innocent man that Larry Elder believes we need more of!

Amen!
 
Martin had every right to confront Z and demand to know why he was following him.

When Z then became violent M had every right to stand his ground and defend himself.


I can't see 'stand your ground' being an issue here with respect to either party. Martin was going somewhere. GZ did not stop him from going anywhere. Also, the CNN lawyers spoke of that law in terms of broadening the 2nd Amendment for gun owners in that they can stand their ground in defending their homes and not have to mitigate or retreat before using their weapon to defend themselves. I can't see that applying to TM here.
 
Its all about ratings my man....RATINGS!!

Nothing more.

They find hot city..Miami.....some racial tension, man vs boy deal...And blow it up for ratings!?

Larry Elder was quite right to be angry...and was correct.

As he said...3% of the black population are committing 50% of the murders in America.....further suggesting 75% of these are from single parent homes.

Quite rightly, that is the issue to address...... NOT GZ

GZ was an innocent man that Larry Elder believes we need more of!

Amen!


He pissed me off in that he didn't answer PM's questions directly, but Larry Elder spoke right about many things.