Acquital for Zimmerman

As has been mentioned several times the defence never raised the issue of stand your ground the defence was entirely based upon self-defence.

Okay I recall that, but the jury decided based on the law. Did they implicitly take that into account? Doesn't it reinforce a self-defence justification?
 
For defending himself from an aggressor who hunted him down and attacked him?
What law do you perceive having been violated by "hunting him down?" Stalking which generally requires putting a reasonable person in fear of serious inconvenience or emotional distress; fear of bodily injury; or fear of death is in my opinion way, way to far a reach.

As to the attack what evidence is there that G.Z. was the attacker any more than T.M.?
 
Okay I recall that, but the jury decided based on the law. Did they implicitly take that into account? Doesn't it reinforce a self-defence justification?
Stand-your-ground involves not having a duty to retreat if you can in a public place. In this case there was plenty of evidence that G.Z. was unable to retreat so stand-your-ground wasn't even raised.
 
Why not get the the facts of this case instead of trolling for arguments with an ill- informed perspective? Sincerely, Jon .

Buddy there are very few facts - mostly testimony. Trayvon is dead so no one could hear his side of the story. Also "witnesses" gave conflicting accounts of what happened...

Let's not forget that based on the so-called "facts" the initial vote was not unanimous - there wasn't enough evidence to prove beyond reasonable doubt that George was guilty of 2nd degree murder. This says nothing about self-defence, manslaughter, who was the aggressor, etc
 
Stand-your-ground involves not having a duty to retreat if you can in a public place. In this case there was plenty of evidence that G.Z. was unable to retreat so stand-your-ground wasn't even raised.

Thank you Sir. (When I was a juror in a criminal trial, I brought my annotated Pocket Criminal Code of Canada to understand the law in question, and we even asked the judge a couple of questions, to aid in our deliberation).
 
Buddy there are very few facts - mostly testimony. Trayvon is dead so no one could hear his side of the story.

Let's not forget that based on the so-called "facts" the initial vote was not unanimous - there wasn't enough evidence to prove beyond reasonable doubt that George was guilty of 2nd degree murder. This says nothing about self-defence, manslaughter, who was the aggressor, etc

Yes, but I think it's a stretch to say that GZ was hunting down TM. If he had his gun drawn while following him, okay but that's not the case here. TM would not have even come anywhere close to GZ in that scenario.
 
Again, read the testimony. He said the only reason he got out of his car was to check the street sign. Even if you don't believe that, once he got out of his car, he would have had a 10 ft walk to the nearest house to check the sign but instead he walked down a dark alley to another street.

Why would I withdraw my conclusion? He clearly was following Martin instead of doing what he was trained.

Look if you have a better source of factual information on this trial than legalinsurrection.com, please share it w me. If you dont, then do me the courtesy of reviewing the comprehensive evidence on this sight. They debunk many of the nonfacts and untruths floating around in conventional wisdom. I don't have the time or interest to educate you further. The knowledge you should have before forming a false opinion on this trial is all there.
 
Buddy there are very few facts - mostly testimony. Trayvon is dead so no one could hear his side of the story.

Let's not forget that based on the so-called "facts" the initial vote was not unanimous - there wasn't enough evidence to prove beyond reasonable doubt that George was guilty of 2nd degree murder. This says nothing about self-defence, manslaughter, who was the aggressor, etc

Facts are facts. "so called facts" and "few facts" are rationalizations you are bringing into the situation to try and justify your opinion. The system cant work that way. Decisions have to be made on the facts admitted to a case. The jury uses the testimony to help weigh the importance , relatively and absolutely , of the available facts.

The jurys vote changed, towards not guilty- it could have gone the other way , as they systematically went through evidence, compared / applied it to the law and the thresholds required to convict.

We should all be grateful that there is a process that we are entitled to, first assuming our innocence, before being proven guilty.
 
Yes, but I think it's a stretch to say that GZ was hunting down TM. If he had his gun drawn while following him, okay but that's not the case here. TM would not have even come anywhere close to GZ in that scenario.

Yea I never implied Zimmerman was hunting anyone down.

Anyway I've seen countless videos from both sides essentially doing the same thing (downplaying the "facts" that smear their side and emphasizing the "facts" that smear the other) - both Trayvon and Zimmerman have a laundry list of sh*t that can be used to paint each one of them as a "trouble maker".

Did Zimmerman HAVE to confront the kid? Why would he? Did he steal something? Was he on his way to commit a crime? If he was, what should Zimmerman have done - pull out his gun and say stop?

Why did Trayvon have to start a fight just because someone approached him? Did he have to prove how tough he was? On that night, he basically picked a fight with the wrong guy - too bad.

This is all speculation on my part but that's what this whole thread has been - speculation and pure idiocy on both sides.
 
As to the attack what evidence is there that G.Z. was the attacker any more than T.M.?

There is none. That is the point. If Z were dead and M on trial the evidence that Z had assaulted M, and that M was standing his ground and lawfully defending himself would be overwhelming. The same doubts that acquitted Z would acquit M.

It is only racists here who want to conclude anything different.
 
Facts are facts. "so called facts" and "few facts" are rationalizations you are bringing into the situation to try and justify your opinion. The system cant work that way. Decisions have to be made on the facts admitted to a case. The jury uses the testimony to help weigh the importance , relatively and absolutely , of the available facts.

The jurys vote changed, towards not guilty- it could have gone the other way , as they systematically went through evidence, compared / applied it to the law and the thresholds required to convict.

We should all be grateful that there is a process that we are entitled to, first assuming our innocence, before being proven guilty.

What facts are these - the recording of the dispatch call where it was inconclusive as to who was shouting for help? Or the account given by Zimmerman (and not Trayvon since he's dead)? Or the accounts of witnesses that were conflicting as to who was on top of who and who started the fight?

Unless there was a camera there that recorded the event, the "facts" are murky - and this is why in the end, he was found not guilty of 2nd degree murder.
 
Yea I never implied Zimmerman was hunting anyone down.

Anyway I've seen countless videos from both sides essentially doing the same thing (downplaying the "facts" that smear their side and emphasizing the "facts" that smear the other) - both Trayvon and Zimmerman have a laundry list of sh*t that can be used to paint each one of them as a "trouble maker".

Did Zimmerman HAVE to confront the kid? Why would he? Did he steal something? Was he on his way to commit a crime? If he was, what should Zimmerman have done - pull out his gun and say stop?

Why did Trayvon have to start a fight just because someone approached him? Did he have to prove how tough he was? On that night, he basically picked a fight with the wrong guy - too bad.

This is all speculation on my part but that's what this whole thread has been - speculation and pure idiocy on both sides.

You're right. You didn't imply that.

I don't think you've been foolish here either.

If I had a gun, I would not alarm someone just because they are suspicious. In an unexpected encounter, I would've notified that I was a neighbourhood watch volunteer and that I was packing but mean no harm and just checking. This would be enough to hopefully ward off a negative response from TM. Best that I would've done would be to wait for the cops and let them frickin' walk the paths. If I think someone is suspicious, they might even be armed so why would I venture needlessly?
 
What facts are these - the recording of the dispatch call where it was inconclusive as to who was shouting for help? Or the account given by Zimmerman (and not Trayvon since he's dead)? Or the accounts of witnesses that were conflicting as to who was on top of who and who started the fight?

Unless there was a camera there that recorded the event, the "facts" are murky - and this is why in the end, he was found not guilty of 2nd degree murder. Your "facts" don't prove anything - it's the other way around, the "facts" COULD NOT prove that Zimmerman had committed 2nd degree murder.

Isn't it a fact as to who was on top? TM's shirt was not close to his body when shot as confirmed by the forensic evidence (so the shirt was dangling from gravity since he was on top). It may also be academic as to who started the fight. There were more credible witnesses to support that it was GZ shouting.
 
Isn't it a fact as to who was on top? TM's shirt was not close to his body when shot as confirmed by the forensic evidence (so the shirt was dangling from gravity since he was on top). It may also be academic as to who started the fight. There were more credible witnesses to support that it was GZ shouting.

If someone pulled a gun on me at close range I would not wait for them to shoot. I would be on top of them pushing the muzzle away from me and smashing their head into the pavement.

Anyone would, unless you like getting shot.
 
There is none. That is the point. If Z were dead and M on trial the evidence that Z had assaulted M, and that M was standing his ground and lawfully defending himself would be overwhelming. The same doubts that acquitted Z would acquit M.

It is only racists here who want to conclude anything different.
IF the facts were 180 degrees different so as to show what you are positing to have been the facts. With the same facts as were actually presented at trial, no T.M. would have been convicted probably of Aggravated Assault.
 
If someone pulled a gun on me at close range I would not wait for them to shoot. I would be on top of them pushing the muzzle away from me and smashing their head into the pavement.

Anyone would, unless you like getting shot.

95% of people would be begging not to shoot. Especially people from 1st world.