Bunch of things you can do:
1. Store the phone in pieces... phone in one spot and battery and cover in another spot, see point 2 for the sim card. If anyone finds one of the pieces you can just say that must be from an old phone. Even better if the screen is cracked in some way but phone is still usable. Also your burner phone should be old. Old enough that you could explain it was a work phone or old phone etc... from 5 or more years ago that has never been updated between then and now. You want it old enough that memory of it or lack of memory of it will be 'hazy' to the SO.
2. You need two sim cards - one should be expired and the other a real burner sim.
2a. Burner sim card should be pin locked obviously. Old sim card - no pin.
2b. The burner sim card preferably should be stored in a sealed addressed envelope to an address that doesn't exist (no return address either), put in a birthday and an old expired gift card you can feel through the envelope. This for your buddies birthday, the buddy that doesn't exist and who moves around a lot, with the oh-so generic, commonly used name. If the envelope is found well you've been meaning to get that mailed haven't you. The great thing here is Canada Post will have no fucking clue what to do with it, if by chance the SO finds and mails it, eventually it will be destroyed. Make it look like the envelope has been opened because you forgot to add something to it, this way if the SO puts the return on it and it does come back, well some asshole at Canada Post tampered with your mail and filled the envelope with crap after stealing the contents.
3. Assuming your using android... create two Google accounts and set the 2nd account as the recovery account to the 1st. Don't access either account from outside the burner phone ie. never interact with these two accounts from anything close to your real identity. Take the time to lock both the Google accounts down - no location tracking, no contacts stored etc... Why two accounts? The second account is where you store anything you need to store regarding the 1st account - contacts etc... 2nd account has no recovery beyond the idiot verification questions which you will not use obvious answers for. If you lose access to 2nd account too bad - see point 6. You also only access the 2nd account through the web browser on the phone. Don't hook the 2nd account up to the phone directly.
5. Back to points 1 and 2. Your burner phone leaves the home with the old sim in pieces and returns to the home in pieces.
6. If you have to dump your burner, you dump everything - phone, sims, Google accounts etc...