Abolish the Senate......

You need to build in "joint sessions" whenever their is an impass. A confidence vote can be considered an impass. 100 Senators would be allowed into the h of c and their votes would be totalled.
 
Nothing like making it more complicated.

Abolition is much less complicated but you dont like that either. Bi cameral legislatures are a hold over from an era when upper classes wanted a break on an overenthusiastic popular democratic legislature.

John A said in best. The Senate exists to protect minorities and there will always be fewer rich people than any other class. :)
 
Abolition is much less complicated but you dont like that either. Bi cameral legislatures are a hold over from an era when upper classes wanted a break on an overenthusiastic popular democratic legislature.

John A said in best. The Senate exists to protect minorities and there will always be fewer rich people than any other class. :)

Much less complicated and not what the majority of Canadians want. Did you look up the Irish model?
 
Abolition is much less complicated but you dont like that either. Bi cameral legislatures are a hold over from an era when upper classes wanted a break on an overenthusiastic popular democratic legislature.

John A said in best. The Senate exists to protect minorities and there will always be fewer rich people than any other class. :)


John A was a loud mouth drunk, a model politician of the time.
 
Abolition is much less complicated but you dont like that either. Bi cameral legislatures are a hold over from an era when upper classes wanted a break on an overenthusiastic popular democratic legislature.

John A said in best. The Senate exists to protect minorities and there will always be fewer rich people than any other class. :)
Abolition is more complicated than anything any Canadian government has ever tried. Don't be deceived because it has a one-word name.

The only solid reason for improving the Senate is that abolition—unanimous consent of the provinces (not to mention the territories who would have every right to demand a voice. Another complication)—is too complicated to be a realistic possibility.
 
You need to build in "joint sessions" whenever their is an impass. A confidence vote can be considered an impass. 100 Senators would be allowed into the h of c and their votes would be totalled.

Or it's that impasse which should be considered a government lacking the confidence of the legislature. With two elected houses to settle an issue by asking the electorate, it could work. That would be better than saying one elected house can defeat a government but the other could not. Especially if the 'powerless' chamber is the one that mirrors the national vote.

I can't see anyone thinking joint sessions a good idea. Not the elected 300 plus FPtP MPs, nor the elected 105 PR Senators, nor the voters who prefer one or the other, although you might be able to sell the idea if the numbers were less unbalanced. As is, such sessions would pretty much make any minority government impossible.

But the essential issue you still ignore is that nothing can be done if you cannot figure out how to get rid of Senators to have the next election. Harper couldn't, why don't you give it a try.
----------
PS. Although I have argued for a PR Senate myself, and these details are amusing, there are two more serious issues blackrock and others raise. Why have a Senate at all? Party hacks appointed to make a show of PR isn't very persuasive. Even the Irish model has more appeal. How to get the amendments needed for change? That flows somewhat from the first. Abolitionists aren't likely to vote for improving amendments.
 
We need a series of PMs to refuse to appoint anyone new to the Senate.
 
We need a series of PMs to refuse to appoint anyone new to the Senate.
And when they can't get their legislation through because there is no Senate to vote approval as the Constitution requires?

Never mind that even high-principled PMs like Harper can't resist the temptation to stack the place with hacks and speechmakers they don't have to pay for out of party funds like Duffy and Wallin.

Harper used to make noises like that about only appointing elected Senators, but he sold out for $90K worth of 'free' campaign help from media stars.

Can you name any two successive PMs who have kept to a single principled stand?
 
Surprise surprise, The PMO office has found the emails they reported to the RCMP were deleted, hmmmm. Love it. The house of cards is shaken'.
 
Surprise surprise, The PMO office has found the emails they reported to the RCMP were deleted, hmmmm. Love it. The house of cards is shaken'.

They suddenly found them again. Sounds like McGuinty's office.
 
Harper among least trusted leaders, poll shows

DANIEL LEBLANC
OTTAWA — The Globe and Mail
Published Monday, Nov. 12 2012, 6:00 AM EST
Last updated Monday, Nov. 12 2012, 2:00 PM EST

Canadians are slowly losing trust in Parliament and political parties, and share some of the toughest views in the American hemisphere about their national leader, according to a new 26-country survey.

At the same time, Canadians are holding on to their positive views of the Canadian Forces and the RCMP, an above-average appreciation of their law-and-order institutions. All in all, Canadians are expressing dissatisfaction with their political system, but also no appetite for major changes to the federal apparatus.

The survey by The Environics Institute, part of an investigation into political attitudes in 26 countries in the Americas, found that Canadians have been shedding some of their optimistic and positive views on politics and government.

While attitudes toward politics are slowly improving in the southern half of the Americas, the findings in Canada show “clear evidence of decline” in the approval of political institutions since the first survey was conducted in 2006.

“Canada hasn’t made any progress [on a number of key rankings] in recent years, and it has lost a bit of ground on others in the last few years,” said pollster Keith Neuman of The Environics Institute. “The gap with other countries is smaller than it was before.”

The survey found only 16 per cent of Canadians place “a lot of trust” in their Prime Minister, putting Stephen Harper near the bottom among all leaders in the Americas.

“In an international context, Harper has a lower level of trust than almost every other national leader in the hemisphere,” Mr. Neuman said.

The levels of trust are also low for the Canadian Parliament (17 per cent), political parties (10 per cent) and mass media (6 per cent). The findings come after Canada lived under a series of minority governments from 2004 to 2011, fuelling a sense of growing partisan bickering in Ottawa.

Still, the survey found little appetite for major changes to Canadian institutions or the governance regime, with large numbers of respondents feeling that they can make their views heard in the political process.

“There is no groundswell for an overhaul of the system,” Mr. Neuman said of the results.

A large number of Canadians have trust in institutions such as the Canadian Forces (53 per cent) and the RCMP (36 per cent), and the level of confidence in the country’s justice system remains above average among respondents to the pan-American survey. Mr. Neuman said that the Canadian Forces and the RCMP have long commanded much respect in Canada, despite controversies that have affected the national police force in recent years.

The full results of the Canadian survey will be made public on Thursday at a meeting of the Marketing Research and Intelligence Association in Ottawa.

The 2012 AmericasBarometer survey was conducted in 26 countries. Overall, 40,971 people were polled, with samples ranging from 1,412 in Haiti to 3,009 in Bolivia. Each questionnaire was administered by a domestic pollster, with the polls conducted in people’s homes everywhere but in the United States and Canada, where an online survey of 1,500 respondents was conducted.
 
The 13th senator resign to take a teaching job. Hugh Segal, one of the last true red tories in the Senate has decided enough is enough. He will be missed, as he was not afraid to go against the grain, read PMO. I did not agree wit everything he said he at lest had good reasons for saying why he did.

Harper is in a tight spot in that strict scrutiny will be put on his appointments, should he decide to appoint new Senators.
 
The 13th senator resign to take a teaching job. Hugh Segal, one of the last true red tories in the Senate has decided enough is enough. He will be missed, as he was not afraid to go against the grain, read PMO. I did not agree wit everything he said he at lest had good reasons for saying why he did.

Harper is in a tight spot in that strict scrutiny will be put on his appointments, should he decide to appoint new Senators.

My favourite Tory. Says unions necessary for democratic Canada.
 
Apparently the Canadian electorate like what this apposed lightweight is and has done.

CTVNews.ca Staff
Published Sunday, February 9, 2014 11:44AM EST
Last Updated Sunday, February 9, 2014 4:17PM EST



Although Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau's decision to remove Liberal-appointed senators from his caucus was met with approval from many sides, his surprise move did not result in more votes, according to a new CTV News/Ipsos Reid poll.
Among those surveyed, 68 per cent agreed that "Prime Minister (Stephen) Harper now needs to follow Justin Trudeau's lead and expel all Conservative-appointed Senators from the Conservative caucus."
Even among Tory supporters, 48 per cent believe that Harper should remove all Conservative-appointed Senators from caucus in an effort to give the Upper Chamber more independence, while 52 per cent disagreed.


Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau stands in the House of Commons during Question Period in Ottawa, Tuesday, February 4, 2014. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
But although Trudeau's controversial move appears to be popular, the Liberal lead over the Conservatives has slipped to four points from six points in late November, according to the poll.
The poll is accurate to within 3.5 percentage points.



If an election were held tomorrow, this would be the vote breakdown:
Liberals: 33 per cent (-2 points since November),
Conservatives: 29 per cent (unchanged),
NDP: 27 per cent (+ 1)
Bloc Quebecois: seven per cent (+1)
Other (including Green Party): 4 per cent (+1)
Fifteen per cent of those surveyed remain undecided.



An equal proportion of those surveyed -- 68 per cent -- said that Trudeau's decision to expel Liberal senators from the caucus shows that he's more serious about Senate reform than Harper and that he's willing to make tough decisions.
However, 55 per cent of voters agreed that Trudeau's decision is "just a publicity stunt."
IPSOS CEO of public affairs Darrell Bricker said support is beginning to "solidify" for the Liberal Leader.
"We've seen a pretty good level of support for Justin Trudeau, but what we're seeing now is a solidifying of that lead, a real feeling that maybe people should be seriously considering him for prime minister," he told CTV News Channel on Sunday.
The poll also found that of the 53 per cent of Canadians who said nothing short of an "unforeseen emergency" would prevent them from casting a ballot in the next federal election, 38 per cent would vote Liberal, compared to 28 per cent for the Conservatives.
When asked which leader would make the best prime minister, 42 per cent of respondents chose Trudeau, followed by 34 per cent for Harper and 24 per cent for Mulcair.
Bricker said a "huge" part of Trudeau's popularity likely stems from his image.
"Justin Trudeau's got a certain amount of celebrity. He seems like a likeable individual, looks visibly younger and more charismatic than the prime minister. I think people have gotten interested in that," he said. "The prime minister is seen as a 'steady Eddy’ and right now, I think people are contemplating more change than more of the same.”
The poll surveyed 1,001 Canadians online between Jan. 31 and Feb. 4.




Read more: http://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/trud...s-to-boost-votes-poll-1.1677821#ixzz2srb1EAFd
 
And your point is..... ?