Abolish the Senate......

Although a referendum has no force and affect, a national referrendum where the NDP, the Tories and the Greens and others call for abolition as a national "direction" would put Trudeau in an awkward spot saying the only thing wrong with the Senate is not enough Liberals.

After a vote, a point person could travel the nation lining up premiers. It would need to be log rolled. Needs to pass the 7/10 rule.
 
Although a referendum has no force and affect, a national referrendum where the NDP, the Tories and the Greens and others call for abolition as a national "direction" would put Trudeau in an awkward spot saying the only thing wrong with the Senate is not enough Liberals.

After a vote, a point person could travel the nation lining up premiers. It would need to be log rolled. Needs to pass the 7/10 rule.

You make that sound so easy, which is isn't. Provincial governments change regularly. Trudeau objection is not just 'not enough Liberals'. For starters;

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...leaders-sensible-plan-for-red-chamber-reform/

His comments were given in response to the NDP’s new campaign to abolish the Senate – ‘‘roll up the red carpet’’ – launched by leader Tom Mulcair last week.


“To want to abolish it, that’s demagoguery. It has to be improved,” Mr. Trudeau told La Presse.


In an attempt to defuse his initial comments, he also criticized the Conservative position of pushing for elected senators, which would impact the West adversely because it remains under-represented.


The Tories have been quick to leap on the Liberal leader’s “divisive” comments, claiming he champions the status quo, “which again underscores his lack of judgment and experience to lead all Canadians.”


In fact, the Trudeau position is to improve the Senate, rather than getting rid of it or making it a rival to the House of Commons by electing senators.


We will know later this year whether the preferred options of the NDP and the Conservatives would require the re-opening of the Constitution, when the Supreme Court hands down a decision on the reference made by the government. It would be a surprise if the court decides the government of the day can simply legislate away an historic pillar of Canadian democracy.

Yet the idea of improving the appointments process to ensure worthy, non-partisan Canadians sit in the Upper Chamber is barely discussed. In a Forum poll in the Post Monday, 39% opted to abolish the Senate, 37% wanted to elect it, 9% were in favour of the status quo and 15% said they didn’t know.


There is another option. In the U.K., the House of Lords has an independent appointment commission that provides the Prime Minister with the names of non-partisan candidates. In Canada, there is a similar advisory committee on vice-regal appointments, which makes non-binding recommendations on the selection of governors-general, lieutenant-governors and territorial commissioners.


There’s no doubt reform is required. Stephen Harper said he wouldn’t name appointed people to the Senate before becoming prime minister. But he has since appointed 59 senators, including two failed Conservative Party candidates. The current expenses scandal is proof that a number of those politically inspired appointments were ill-judged, to say the least.


That controversy has seriously dented the Tories’ reputation for good governance and they will be delighted that both Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Mulcair have shifted the focus on to the wider debate about the future of the Senate. Neither opposition leader, apparently, buys into the advice Napoleon gave his marshals at the battle of Austerlitz: “The enemy is making a false move, why should we interrupt him?”


If there are no more explosive revelations, the circus will move on, leaving the debate over the Senate’s legitimacy. Mr. Harper and Mr. Mulcair are offering solutions that are likely to be unpalatable, if not untenable.


That leaves the unlikely conservative Mr. Trudeau, who is hinting at a more practical way forward that should be embraced by Canadians. It’s not a quick fix – it will be more than 36 years before Senator Patrick Brazeau retires (unless his court case goes badly), but such is the current rate of retirals, a majority of senators could be non-partisan appointments within nine years.


That should be Mr. Trudeau’s line on the Senate, rather than urging Quebecers to stick with the status quo because they’ll get more jam.


National Post
 
Although a referendum has no force and affect, a national referrendum where the NDP, the Tories and the Greens and others call for abolition as a national "direction" would put Trudeau in an awkward spot saying the only thing wrong with the Senate is not enough Liberals.

After a vote, a point person could travel the nation lining up premiers. It would need to be log rolled. Needs to pass the 7/10 rule.
I believe the Quebec Court of Appeal said complete abolition would require all the provinces. They're not the Supremes, but they are judges working with the same laws and wordings.

Harper's original plan: 'Since we're stuck with it, let's make it work the best we can', may prove to be all that is doable in practical terms. It was worth a better effort than the half-hearted one he gave it.

Too bad he gave in to 'Same-old, same-old'. One needs high principles and values for that to work. Look at the guys he appointed as Senators, because they gave great after dinner speeches at Conservative fundraisers.

If we're stuck with it, we should give real truth and meaning to appointing the best folks we have.
 
You make that sound so easy, which is isn't. Provincial governments change regularly. Trudeau objection is not just 'not enough Liberals'. For starters;

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...leaders-sensible-plan-for-red-chamber-reform/

His comments were given in response to the NDP’s new campaign to abolish the Senate – ‘‘roll up the red carpet’’ – launched by leader Tom Mulcair last week.


“To want to abolish it, that’s demagoguery. It has to be improved,” Mr. Trudeau told La Presse.


In an attempt to defuse his initial comments, he also criticized the Conservative position of pushing for elected senators, which would impact the West adversely because it remains under-represented.


The Tories have been quick to leap on the Liberal leader’s “divisive” comments, claiming he champions the status quo, “which again underscores his lack of judgment and experience to lead all Canadians.”


In fact, the Trudeau position is to improve the Senate, rather than getting rid of it or making it a rival to the House of Commons by electing senators.


We will know later this year whether the preferred options of the NDP and the Conservatives would require the re-opening of the Constitution, when the Supreme Court hands down a decision on the reference made by the government. It would be a surprise if the court decides the government of the day can simply legislate away an historic pillar of Canadian democracy.

Yet the idea of improving the appointments process to ensure worthy, non-partisan Canadians sit in the Upper Chamber is barely discussed. In a Forum poll in the Post Monday, 39% opted to abolish the Senate, 37% wanted to elect it, 9% were in favour of the status quo and 15% said they didn’t know.


There is another option. In the U.K., the House of Lords has an independent appointment commission that provides the Prime Minister with the names of non-partisan candidates. In Canada, there is a similar advisory committee on vice-regal appointments, which makes non-binding recommendations on the selection of governors-general, lieutenant-governors and territorial commissioners.


There’s no doubt reform is required. Stephen Harper said he wouldn’t name appointed people to the Senate before becoming prime minister. But he has since appointed 59 senators, including two failed Conservative Party candidates. The current expenses scandal is proof that a number of those politically inspired appointments were ill-judged, to say the least.


That controversy has seriously dented the Tories’ reputation for good governance and they will be delighted that both Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Mulcair have shifted the focus on to the wider debate about the future of the Senate. Neither opposition leader, apparently, buys into the advice Napoleon gave his marshals at the battle of Austerlitz: “The enemy is making a false move, why should we interrupt him?”


If there are no more explosive revelations, the circus will move on, leaving the debate over the Senate’s legitimacy. Mr. Harper and Mr. Mulcair are offering solutions that are likely to be unpalatable, if not untenable.


That leaves the unlikely conservative Mr. Trudeau, who is hinting at a more practical way forward that should be embraced by Canadians. It’s not a quick fix – it will be more than 36 years before Senator Patrick Brazeau retires (unless his court case goes badly), but such is the current rate of retirals, a majority of senators could be non-partisan appointments within nine years.


That should be Mr. Trudeau’s line on the Senate, rather than urging Quebecers to stick with the status quo because they’ll get more jam.


National Post

How can anyone defend the Trudeau position of "improve" the Senate. The point of abolition is that there is no place for appointed people with political power period, no matter what the appointments process gives. There are 2 legitimate democratic positions. Abolish or elect. I favour the former but the latter is better than appointment.

I propose using proportional representation to elect the Senate on a provincial basis. If the Hofc and senate reached an impass, the 100 Senators would move to the House of commons and total vote would decide.
 
You make that sound so easy, which is isn't. Provincial governments change regularly. Trudeau objection is not just 'not enough Liberals'. For starters;

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...leaders-sensible-plan-for-red-chamber-reform/

His comments were given in response to the NDP’s new campaign to abolish the Senate – ‘‘roll up the red carpet’’ – launched by leader Tom Mulcair last week.


“To want to abolish it, that’s demagoguery. It has to be improved,” Mr. Trudeau told La Presse.


In an attempt to defuse his initial comments, he also criticized the Conservative position of pushing for elected senators, which would impact the West adversely because it remains under-represented.


The Tories have been quick to leap on the Liberal leader’s “divisive” comments, claiming he champions the status quo, “which again underscores his lack of judgment and experience to lead all Canadians.”


In fact, the Trudeau position is to improve the Senate, rather than getting rid of it or making it a rival to the House of Commons by electing senators.


We will know later this year whether the preferred options of the NDP and the Conservatives would require the re-opening of the Constitution, when the Supreme Court hands down a decision on the reference made by the government. It would be a surprise if the court decides the government of the day can simply legislate away an historic pillar of Canadian democracy.

Yet the idea of improving the appointments process to ensure worthy, non-partisan Canadians sit in the Upper Chamber is barely discussed. In a Forum poll in the Post Monday, 39% opted to abolish the Senate, 37% wanted to elect it, 9% were in favour of the status quo and 15% said they didn’t know.


There is another option. In the U.K., the House of Lords has an independent appointment commission that provides the Prime Minister with the names of non-partisan candidates. In Canada, there is a similar advisory committee on vice-regal appointments, which makes non-binding recommendations on the selection of governors-general, lieutenant-governors and territorial commissioners.


There’s no doubt reform is required. Stephen Harper said he wouldn’t name appointed people to the Senate before becoming prime minister. But he has since appointed 59 senators, including two failed Conservative Party candidates. The current expenses scandal is proof that a number of those politically inspired appointments were ill-judged, to say the least.


That controversy has seriously dented the Tories’ reputation for good governance and they will be delighted that both Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Mulcair have shifted the focus on to the wider debate about the future of the Senate. Neither opposition leader, apparently, buys into the advice Napoleon gave his marshals at the battle of Austerlitz: “The enemy is making a false move, why should we interrupt him?”


If there are no more explosive revelations, the circus will move on, leaving the debate over the Senate’s legitimacy. Mr. Harper and Mr. Mulcair are offering solutions that are likely to be unpalatable, if not untenable.


That leaves the unlikely conservative Mr. Trudeau, who is hinting at a more practical way forward that should be embraced by Canadians. It’s not a quick fix – it will be more than 36 years before Senator Patrick Brazeau retires (unless his court case goes badly), but such is the current rate of retirals, a majority of senators could be non-partisan appointments within nine years.


That should be Mr. Trudeau’s line on the Senate, rather than urging Quebecers to stick with the status quo because they’ll get more jam.


National Post

How can anyone defend the Trudeau position of "improve" the Senate. The point of abolition is that there is no place for appointed people with political power period, no matter what the appointments process gives. There are 2 legitimate democratic positions. Abolish or elect. I favour the former but the latter is better than appointment.

I propose using proportional representation to elect the Senate on a provincial basis. If the Hofc and senate reached an impass, the 100 Senators would move to the House of commons and total vote would decide.
 
I believe the Quebec Court of Appeal said complete abolition would require all the provinces. They're not the Supremes, but they are judges working with the same laws and wordings.

Harper's original plan: 'Since we're stuck with it, let's make it work the best we can', may prove to be all that is doable in practical terms. It was worth a better effort than the half-hearted one he gave it.

Too bad he gave in to 'Same-old, same-old'. One needs high principles and values for that to work. Look at the guys he appointed as Senators, because they gave great after dinner speeches at Conservative fundraisers.

If we're stuck with it, we should give real truth and meaning to appointing the best folks we have.

I don't believe the QCA said unanimous consent just "provincial consent" which means 7/10 50%.

A national vote would expose those self interested small provinces and individuals who are out of step with the population at large. This allows the holdouts to be "persuaded" to come into the fold. There is no legitimate argument for appointment.
 
How can anyone defend the Trudeau position of "improve" the Senate. The point of abolition is that there is no place for appointed people with political power period, no matter what the appointments process gives. There are 2 legitimate democratic positions. Abolish or elect. I favour the former but the latter is better than appointment.

I propose using proportional representation to elect the Senate on a provincial basis. If the Hofc and senate reached an impass, the 100 Senators would move to the House of commons and total vote would decide.

well recent polls mentioned earlier showed that most Canadians didn't want abolition, but did see the need for change.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/incoming/article12260108.ece/BINARY/w620/grenier.jpg

This is a running pullover several years. It would seem that Canadians want what Trudeau wants, not hard to understand or defend.

http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/2013/02/19/majority-of-canadians-want-senate-reformed-poll

A recent Ipsos Reid poll found 36% of Canadians believe the Senate should be done away with, a 10-percentage point increase from 2007. On the whole, 78% would like to see it either reformed or abolished, but Darrell Bricker, CEO of Ipsos Reid Public Affairs, says it is the idea of abolishing it that is gaining the most traction.

Apparently more, 42%, want to the Senate reformed/not abolished, 78%-36%= 42%.
 
well recent polls mentioned earlier showed that most Canadians didn't want abolition, but did see the need for change.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/incoming/article12260108.ece/BINARY/w620/grenier.jpg

This is a running pullover several years. It would seem that Canadians want what Trudeau wants, not hard to understand or defend.

http://vancouver.24hrs.ca/2013/02/19/majority-of-canadians-want-senate-reformed-poll



Apparently more, 42%, want to the Senate reformed/not abolished, 78%-36%= 42%.

They believe it can be reformed in a meaningful way. It can't. Offer Canadians A) status quo or B) Abolition B looks good.
 
They believe it can be reformed in a meaningful way. It can't. Offer Canadians A) status quo or B) Abolition B looks good.

Why not? So when the Canadian public answers the question a way you don't like, you put forwards a question that ignores the majority of Canadian's wishes. Another for it or against it, a la PM Harper and POTUS Shrub.
 
Why not? So when the Canadian public answers the question a way you don't like, you put forwards a question that ignores the majority of Canadian's wishes. Another for it or against it, a la PM Harper and POTUS Shrub.

Canadians are moderate people so they "hope" there is a middle way. it is there nature but nobody can describe a middle way that does not give political power to people that are not elected. Canadians will feel, if they USE their unelected power it is anti-democratic. If they don't use it they are a useless waste of money.
 
Canadians are moderate people so they "hope" there is a middle way. it is there nature but nobody can describe a middle way that does not give political power to people that are not elected. Canadians will feel, if they USE their unelected power it is anti-democratic. If they don't use it they are a useless waste of money.

Probably more Canadians are worried about giving some leaders too much power. That's what the senate is for, co-incidentally, if the senate votes not to kick out Duffy et al, they will be standing against the will of the PM and justifying the usefulness of the senate.
 
Canadians are moderate people so they "hope" there is a middle way. it is there nature but nobody can describe a middle way that does not give political power to people that are not elected. Canadians will feel, if they USE their unelected power it is anti-democratic. If they don't use it they are a useless waste of money.

Because Canadians are a moderate country doesn't mean they don't do exceptionally good jobs? There are a lot of countries and people who think we do many things well. The most recently on a world scale was setting down the guidelines that kept our economy on a better footing than most of the other major nations during the melt down. Governments were knocking down our doors to find out what we did Sometimes a modest approach is a damn good approach.
 
I don't believe the QCA said unanimous consent just "provincial consent" which means 7/10 50%.
In [29] of the judgement, they say:

…Nevertheless, unanimity would be required (Section 41) to abolish the Senate, since, subject to section 47, it is an institution whose agreement is required for all amendments to the Constitution… .

I feel you might have researched just a little, before attributing your assumption on such an exacting difference to the Court.
A national vote would expose those self interested small provinces and individuals who are out of step with the population at large. This allows the holdouts to be "persuaded" to come into the fold. There is no legitimate argument for appointment.
But if the vote revealed it was the government proposing the measure that was out of step it would be A Bad Thing. Losing the Charlottetown referendum (and a few other things) reduced the Cons to just two seats. Losing the MegaCity referendum set Toronto back decades.

Unless your content with a fatuous and silly popularity contest deciding how the next century and a half of our legislation is accomplished, I think a good deal of serious and thoughtful discussion about what the existing Senate could and should do is wanted first. At $30+ millions a national vote that could be undone by one heroic holdout in a with an eagle feather is a very expensive persuader, and the record isn't good. Improving it is easier, and who doesn't think government needs to be improved?

Certainly it would be no improvement to concentrate even more power in the office of someone like the unscrupulous party hack who thoughtlessly appointed Duffy, Wallin and Brazeau to entertain at Conservative fundraisers on Senate pay, and charge their expenses to … ? Well, anyone, as long as it isn't CPoC.
 
Some people don't trust democracy so they call it a "popularity" contest. If you want to limit the power of the PMO; the Senate must be 100% elected or it has no legitimacy. The Senate must end up 100% elected or be abolished. There is no place in a modern democracy for people with political power but no democratic mandate.

I have proposed election by province, using proportional representation. In tiny provinces PR and FPTP would not appear much different but in large provinces, competing slates with 25 candidates on each would be fabulous.

A PR Senate totally squares the circle on the PR vs FPTP debate. Impass solved by total vote clearly favouring the 308 + new seats vs the 100 seat Senate.
 
Some people don't trust democracy so they call it a "popularity" contest. If you want to limit the power of the PMO; the Senate must be 100% elected or it has no legitimacy. The Senate must end up 100% elected or be abolished. There is no place in a modern democracy for people with political power but no democratic mandate.

I have proposed election by province, using proportional representation. In tiny provinces PR and FPTP would not appear much different but in large provinces, competing slates with 25 candidates on each would be fabulous.

A PR Senate totally squares the circle on the PR vs FPTP debate. Impass solved by total vote clearly favouring the 308 + new seats vs the 100 seat Senate.

So you propose reform, not abolition, just like Trudeau? Make up your mind, will ya?
 
So you propose reform, not abolition, just like Trudeau? Make up your mind, will ya?

Sure lets hear JT say "I am for a totally elected Senate with no appointments" It is the second best solution to abolition but it is far better than any other. Abolished or elected. No other possibilities.
 
The stumbling blocks to reform are many, but the term of appointment is the biggie. It gets in the way of any electoral scheme. Of course there's also the downside of party politics—so spectacularly on display these days as the Hack-in-Chief discovers that bus is a moving target and Duffy in particular doesn't throw easy—attaching to those sober second-thinkers one you elect them.

I've a lot of hope for a PR Senate as a bandaid fix for a FPTP House that we won't be changing soon. But you'd have to change the present 'appointment until 75' to some fixed term, and how would you cope with confidence votes that forced snap elections? To say nothing of the skew that using party totals from MP elections that are affected by local popularity contests would introduce. But it could be done.

I've even more hope though for a Senate of the Wise chosen by some sober thinkers other than party hacks. It might give Order of Canada holders a useful bit of work. You could even make it a two-stage process with the OofC's nominees being sorted into party lists and getting their seats by PR. Heck that might even get the occasional Independent.

What I'm not attracted by is the same electoral terms in both house, especially if it produces a deadlock between them as current standings could. The American experience isn't encouraging, although the guys who weren't campaigning seemed far more sensible than the ones hustling votes in elections coming soon.

But the problem isn't with getting good people in, that's always been possible. Previous PMs like Mulroney and Chretien who didn't put party before all else actually appointed meritorious members of opposition parties. One doubts Hugh Segal would ever have been a Harper appointee, because he has principles. Chretien may not have, but he could reward Segal for his. The real constitutional problem is getting the sitting Senators out so we can put fresh bums in their seats to get up to new mischief. The electoral version of democracy has no other remedy.
 
The stumbling blocks to reform are many, but the term of appointment is the biggie. It gets in the way of any electoral scheme. Of course there's also the downside of party politics—so spectacularly on display these days as the Hack-in-Chief discovers that bus is a moving target and Duffy in particular doesn't throw easy—attaching to those sober second-thinkers one you elect them.

I've a lot of hope for a PR Senate as a bandaid fix for a FPTP House that we won't be changing soon. But you'd have to change the present 'appointment until 75' to some fixed term, and how would you cope with confidence votes that forced snap elections? To say nothing of the skew that using party totals from MP elections that are affected by local popularity contests would introduce. But it could be done.

I've even more hope though for a Senate of the Wise chosen by some sober thinkers other than party hacks. It might give Order of Canada holders a useful bit of work. You could even make it a two-stage process with the OofC's nominees being sorted into party lists and getting their seats by PR. Heck that might even get the occasional Independent.

What I'm not attracted by is the same electoral terms in both house, especially if it produces a deadlock between them as current standings could. The American experience isn't encouraging, although the guys who weren't campaigning seemed far more sensible than the ones hustling votes in elections coming soon.

But the problem isn't with getting good people in, that's always been possible. Previous PMs like Mulroney and Chretien who didn't put party before all else actually appointed meritorious members of opposition parties. One doubts Hugh Segal would ever have been a Harper appointee, because he has principles. Chretien may not have, but he could reward Segal for his. The real constitutional problem is getting the sitting Senators out so we can put fresh bums in their seats to get up to new mischief. The electoral version of democracy has no other remedy.

The Senate elections would parallel the Federal not provincial elections. Voters would be given two ballots (or one long one) one ballot would be to elect local MP. The other ballot for Senate would simply list the parties. Lists of candidates would be printed on newspapers, party brochures, websites etc. No a la charte voting. Party gets 35% of provincial Senate vote elects top 35% of list and so on. Parties use internal mechanisms to set ballot order. Could be convention or every member vote like a primary. They can make own rule like every second position female etc.

Most people will vote the same party at both levels but not all people.

Cabinets can be formed using MPs or Senators. Probably 3/4 MPs 1/4 Senators.
 
Sure lets hear JT say "I am for a totally elected Senate with no appointments" It is the second best solution to abolition but it is far better than any other. Abolished or elected. No other possibilities.

Nothing like making shit up to support your point. Call me up when he says that, will you? Maybe they can use the Irish model, look it up.
 
The Senate elections would parallel the Federal not provincial elections. Voters would be given two ballots (or one long one) one ballot would be to elect local MP. The other ballot for Senate would simply list the parties. Lists of candidates would be printed on newspapers, party brochures, websites etc. No a la charte voting. Party gets 35% of provincial Senate vote elects top 35% of list and so on. Parties use internal mechanisms to set ballot order. Could be convention or every member vote like a primary. They can make own rule like every second position female etc.

Most people will vote the same party at both levels but not all people.

Cabinets can be formed using MPs or Senators. Probably 3/4 MPs 1/4 Senators.
Easy stuff, though it would need a tidy bit of footwork from all to get the right number from each region while still reflecting popular vote. Getting all the changes enacted would not be. But I'd go for it.

I'm still wondering how you'd propose to deal with confidence motions. Two elected houses have equal claim to legitimately representing the people's interests, and either one could muster an opposition majority, vote down a significant government bill, and threaten to block further measures (which is what non-confidence is). Your scenario would have had Harper's minority governments (and this one) facing non-Con majorities in your Senate from Day tlll now. What's your proposal?