Abolish the Senate......

That's part of my point, the Senate has evolved into a cesspool of patronage appointments and is a redundant entity. Why should taxpayers pay any amount, personally I don't think $100 million is nothing to sneeze at regardless of your rounding out argument. The original intent of the Senate is no longer applicable as government has made a mockery of this institution over the years by thanking party loyalists with a well paid position at our expense.

Its worth a couple of bucks a person to have a possible break on radical changes to our society.
Harper has been able to push through a lot of big changes but without even a senate full of conservative fundraisers it would turn into a one person government.
A majority government could push through any changes their leader wanted, and that's a bit dangerous.
 
but that's exactly what we have today, a one person government. Harper gets anything he wants with his majority government and he pulls the strings on all his loyal conservative puppets on the Senate, they control it. They go through the motions to debate a proposed bill but he knows full well he's going to get what he wants due to his majority and total control of the Senate. It's actually comical. Just bugs me that the taxpayers are paying for this stupidity.
 
but that's exactly what we have today, a one person government. Harper gets anything he wants with his majority government and he pulls the strings on all his loyal conservative puppets on the Senate, they control it. They go through the motions to debate a proposed bill but he knows full well he's going to get what he wants due to his majority and total control of the Senate. It's actually comical. Just bugs me that the taxpayers are paying for this stupidity.

That's because 'we' gave him the opportunity by voting him in 'again' with a majority. It's not all a system problem. We also hold some of the responsibility.
 
That's because 'we' gave him the opportunity by voting him in 'again' with a majority. It's not all a system problem. We also hold some of the responsibility.

Exactly, if we didn't give him a majority this time the senate would still be a useful brake on extremist legislature.
 
Here's an example of a thoughtful Senator acting on personal principles, good constitutional advice and knowledge and in the best interests of the country and his party as he understands them. All the things we want in a legislator, whether appointed or elected. The really good news is that he rallied enough support from within his party to carry the day and kill a badly conceived Bill that regrettably got government support to pass in the House. It's why sober second thought can be a very good thing.

You can read about it here, in the Vancouver Sun, or Google Hugh Segal, or Bill C-377
 
Here's an example of a thoughtful Senator acting on personal principles, good constitutional advice and knowledge and in the best interests of the country and his party as he understands them. All the things we want in a legislator, whether appointed or elected. The really good news is that he rallied enough support from within his party to carry the day and kill a badly conceived Bill that regrettably got government support to pass in the House. It's why sober second thought can be a very good thing.

You can read about it here, in the Vancouver Sun, or Google Hugh Segal, or Bill C-377

.... and Hugh Segal is a long time Conservative appointed by Trudeau.
 
RCMP find that Duffy change his banking accounts from an Ottawa address to a PEI address 2 days after the investigation/audit was announced; lovin' it. The horseman are really doing a job on this. Duffy's pork belly is so cooked.

Asked the other day if he would accept a senate seat, Rex Murphy said nope, no way, no how. The same response he gave last year. He says that reporters should not accept seats in the Senate.
 
i agree. i would go further and ban reporters from public office
 
Harper is now side stepping and laying the ground for an abolition. He and his cronies will fail to amend any satisfactory segment of the Senate and in the 8 years in power then he'll take the easy way our and say dump it, but he need to meet the conditions set out in theConstitution.

Wallins' audit may or may not make it to the light of day.
 
According to reports the audit showed Senator Wallins has questionable claims in the amount of ~$140,000. This after Harper gave her the all clear earlier this year. Boy, did he just get pied in the puss. Of course she's not guilty, but will pay it back and she will use her own money. Wow, what a concept.
 
RCMP question Duffy payment to consultant for computer work. The consultant says he did nothing for the money. He is a form concrete contractor, presently on disability. Nigel Wright handed over documentation between he and Duffy. The noose is tightening big time. The throne speech should be fun to watch next week.

Still no peep from Frank and Ridgeman about all the shite on the Hill.

I remember this prediction form RM

Here's what's going to happen if there's another Conservative Minority:


Iggy will be fired as Liberal Leader- Bob Rae will step in.
Harpo will continue to govern as always (thinking he can run the country as if he has a majority)
There will be a ANOTHER non-confidence vote in the near future as a result
Wacko Jacko and Bobby Rae will form the next governing parliament via coalition.


Taxes soar, business's leave or just fail outright, major recession, Canada goes bankrupt in the next 4 years!


Its Onta-RAE-o all over again. What's that saying about history repeating itself?

2 out of 5, sort of, nothing to crow bout.
 
i agree. i would go further and ban reporters from public office
Ban the lawyers first, please. Then ban anyone who's ever said business does everything better than government (listening to them is a dumb as hiring Karl Marx as your CEO). Then maybe we can get down to banning reporters. Personally, I think we should do all we can to encourage those who investigate and question those in power; perhaps we should ban them from being on the government side.
 
Ban the lawyers first, please. Then ban anyone who's ever said business does everything better than government (listening to them is a dumb as hiring Karl Marx as your CEO). Then maybe we can get down to banning reporters. Personally, I think we should do all we can to encourage those who investigate and question those in power; perhaps we should ban them from being on the government side.

Considering the number of them who are lawyer, way worse in the US, you'd might be hard pressed to fill the House, short of a bunch of wannabes.
 
Last edited:
Here is what I would do assuming that abolition, my first choice was not possible.

I would call a national referendum on an elected Senate 100 seats same as now. The elections would be by proportional representation by province. Ontario for example would get around 40 Senators. Each party would put up a list of 40 candidates. The seats would be awarded to the parties based on their % of the vote. Similar in each province. Parties themselves would need to be sensitive to region, race, gender etc.

Now we have 2 elected houses like the USA BUT if their was an impass caused by the 2 houses being in conflict, the TOTAL vote of both houses would pass or defeat a bill. Legislation could be initiated in either house.
 
What a pointless and mindless proposition it is to simply abolish the Senate! We need a reworking of our democracy to engage and represent the will of the people. Perhaps give the Senate some power and have them elected by proportional representation with all regions being given a voice. We now have a dictatorship with Harper proroguing parliament and issuing omnibus megabills with no debate. No wonder the youth have given up on voting. It is a fucking joke that needs lots of retooling unless you belong to the small cabal of power brokers who enjoy the status quo.....
 
Rumour has that according to senior tories Harper was going to have a referundum on abolishing or reforming the Senate, but because he sent the question to the Supreme Court he's fucked until they rule.
Now they've ruled and Harper is completely fucked in his attempt at senate reform.

What a pointless and mindless proposition it is to simply abolish the Senate! We need a reworking of our democracy to engage and represent the will of the people. Perhaps give the Senate some power and have them elected by proportional representation with all regions being given a voice. We now have a dictatorship with Harper proroguing parliament and issuing omnibus megabills with no debate. No wonder the youth have given up on voting. It is a fucking joke that needs lots of retooling unless you belong to the small cabal of power brokers who enjoy the status quo.....
We already elect people in order to (at least theoretically) represent us.
There's no reason to elect a different set of people to a completely different house of government to also represent our interests.
 
Now they've ruled and Harper is completely fucked in his attempt at senate reform.


We already elect people in order to (at least theoretically) represent us.
There's no reason to elect a different set of people to a completely different house of government to also represent our interests.

That was the ruling of the Quebec court, it has yet to go before the Supreme Court, which won't start the trail until mid November.

Still this will hurt Harper's case.

Requiring 7 provinces and 50% of the voting population for reform, when there are a million competeing propesals for reform, will be impossible, simple abolishing it be far simpler, there is only one form of abolishment.
 
http://www.ndp.ca/news/jim-flaherty-joins-ndp

Jim Flaherty Joins the NDP.

Okay that title is misleading, he's only joined the NDP in calling for the Senate to be abolished, he's not taking out a membership ;p

Still if the finance minster is saying this, you know its likely a trail balloon from Harper. I have a feeling that the fact that the Senate revolted against his plan to suspend the three Senators has been the straw that broke the camels back.
 
http://www.ndp.ca/news/jim-flaherty-joins-ndp

Jim Flaherty Joins the NDP.

Okay that title is misleading, he's only joined the NDP in calling for the Senate to be abolished, he's not taking out a membership ;p

Still if the finance minster is saying this, you know its likely a trail balloon from Harper. I have a feeling that the fact that the Senate revolted against his plan to suspend the three Senators has been the straw that broke the camels back.

Exactly.