Abolish the Senate......

I don't see how your quote helps the case for keeping the senate, it simply shows once again that the entire establishment is terrible from appointment process to expense accounts, and is not really helping Canadians at all.

But okay let's look at a senator with more years at the patronage trough. "House of sober second thought" is more like "department of expensing like a drunken sailor on never-ending shore leave" :

Sen. Pamela Wallin could be paying back taxpayers an additional $20,000 for improperly claimed travel expenses, CTV News has learned.
The Saskatchewan senator has already repaid $38,000 in travel expenses she claimed over the last 19 months, as CTV’s Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife reported in May.
Just last month alone, the embattled senator reimbursed taxpayers almost $8,000 for a personal trip that she had improperly billed the Senate.
According to sources, a Senate committee was told Thursday that Wallin may have to pay up to $20,000 more.
“They obviously found something in that first year’s audit that said we need to go further,” said Liberal Senate Leader James Cowan. “Now they are going back to the date of her appointment.”
Some $321,000 in questionable travel expenses claimed by Wallin is currently the subject of an audit by forensic accounting firm Deliotte. The details of the audit will be discussed before the Senate Committee on Internal Economy next week.
In the real world, she's be fired and then taken to court to get the money back with the threat of jail time. In the senate fantasyland that we're all paying for, there's no such penalty.

She is a criminal, and the other senators are going along with her fraud by giving Wallin the opportunity to pay her way out with no penalties and no real consequences. This whole criminal undertaking needs to be abolished, the sooner the better.
 
I don't see how your quote helps the case for keeping the senate, it simply shows once again that the entire establishment is terrible from appointment process to expense accounts, and is not really helping Canadians at all.

But okay let's look at a senator with more years at the patronage trough. "House of sober second thought" is more like "department of expensing like a drunken sailor on never-ending shore leave" :

In the real world, she's be fired and then taken to court to get the money back with the threat of jail time. In the senate fantasyland that we're all paying for, there's no such penalty.

She is a criminal, and the other senators are going along with her fraud by giving Wallin the opportunity to pay her way out with no penalties and no real consequences. This whole criminal undertaking needs to be abolished, the sooner the better.

I don't, for a second, claim the Senate is perfect, but I also don't think for a moment there isn't some problems, We had a primary audit and 98% of the Senators were in compliance, but you want the whole thing shut down based on three or four idiots. Taking the same logic why are you calling for the elimination of the House as two Conservatives are following the Election Canada's guideline and an NDP critic has not in compliance with the CRS? Your post clearly show you are not aware of how the Senate works and what part it plays in the governing of the country. You continue to show this with almost every post. You are the one who is asking for change and asking for such a change that will just not happen because of the Constitutional guidelines. I don't need to defend keeping it. I would like reform, but not abolition.

So far you have no knowledge with the certainty you try to show, of what will happen to Wallin. As an example, the Senators are talking about kicking them out of the Senate and even taking away their pension if found criminally guilty. They still be the victim of 'real world' sanctions yet.
 
More Wallin lies and avarice came out today.
I don't see how anyone can believe she had any interest in representing anyone but her own stock portfolio.
Wallin Filing Lists Toronto Residence

Senator Pamela Wallin is listed as a resident of Toronto — and not Saskatchewan, the province she represents in the Senate — according to the corporate filings of a Bay Street investment firm.

Wallin, a former Conservative now sitting as an Independent, was named to the board of directors of Gluskin Sheff and Associates in 2006, when it first sold shares to the public. She sat on the board for seven years, earning more than $450,000 in directors' fees and stock payments.

Gluskin Sheff describes itself on its website as a wealth management firm handling portfolios of $3 million or more for high net worth private clients, as well as some institutions and pension plans. It was founded in 1984 by Ira Gluskin and Gerald Sheff.

It’s difficult to determine with certainty how much Wallin was paid to sit on this board, but documents show directors were paid between $500 and $1,500 per meeting, plus an annual retainer of between $40,000 and $50,000. There were also other payments and stock options offered.
...
Wallin never attended more than 10 board or committee meetings per year, the filings show.

CBC News has learned Wallin resigned from the board last month.

Wallin was named to represent Saskatchewan in the Senate by Prime Minister Stephen Harper in 2008.
....

The Gluskin Sheff corporate filings appear to support that allegation. In each one of seven separate annual filings required by securities regulators, Wallin was officially listed as a resident of Toronto.

Each filing was certified as accurate by the board of directors on which Wallin sat. That means that for the last five years, Wallin asked the Senate to believe she resided in the Prairie province, while down on Bay Street, they thought she lived in Toronto.
There's no confusion. This isn't due to misreading any rules

Senator, con artist...same thing.
 
Whether the Senate was theoretically a good idea or not, it has reached a point where -- in reality -- it is useless and a waste of money.

Kill the beast.
 
Whether the Senate was theoretically a good idea or not, it has reached a point where -- in reality -- it is useless and a waste of money.

Kill the beast.

Apparently most of the Canadian electorate thinks differently than you and Matt. In most polls, about only 1/3 want it abolished. Feel free to pull a nottyboi math trick on the results, but the result seldom change from near the 1/3 mark. Considering the logic you try to apply to the CBC, it's not surprising to see you post this.
 
Yes, I know. My proposal that governments focus their spending in areas that are of value to Canadians is quite radical.

No it's your attempt at saying the CBC is not worth the money spent and that the only thing to do with the Senate is to dump it, nice try. As i said most Canadians don't want the Senate abolished, not even close.
 
Hey BR, where you getting your info from? Most of the polls I've read want the Senate either abolished or at the very least reformed. Few want it to stay as is.

An online poll says to abolish by almost 80%, lol, not scientific.

http://www.bulletnewsniagara.ca/2013/05/23/reader-poll-should-the-canadian-senate-be-abolished/

Just off the press:

http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/story/2013/06/19/pol-nanos-number-june19-senate.html

Please don't confuse him with facts, it makes him questions his assumptions.
 
Please don't confuse him with facts, it makes him questions his assumptions.

A reader poll of the Niagara Bullit, a regional weekly(?) paper, totaling 150 votes, please, talk about a small local sample. The questions were yes, no, don't know, don't care. Really. Not a national poll of 1000 people.

The Nanos Reed poll showed that a minority of those polled, 41% wanted the Senate abolished. Those are the facts, no questioning needed.
 
Last edited:
lmao, BR I told you that online poll was a joke, so don't give it any credence, just wanted to show you more and more Canadians are getting fed up with the Senate.

You conveniently left out all the results of that Nanos poll"

http://www.cbc.ca/gfx/images/news/topstories/2013/06/19/mi-nanos-460-jun19.jpg

Abolish 41%
Reform 49%
Leave as is 6%
Not sure 4%

41% abolish is a very significant number and 90% want it abolished or reformed, that's quite a statement.

Where did you get your stats from? You're just using the link I provided after you made your claim.
 
lmao, BR I told you that online poll was a joke, so don't give it any credence, just wanted to show you more and more Canadians are getting fed up with the Senate.

You conveniently left out all the results of that Nanos poll"

http://www.cbc.ca/gfx/images/news/topstories/2013/06/19/mi-nanos-460-jun19.jpg

Abolish 41%
Reform 49%
Leave as is 6%
Not sure 4%

41% abolish is a very significant number and 90% want it abolished or reformed, that's quite a statement.

Where did you get your stats from? You're just using the link I provided after you made your claim.

I didn't conveniently leave anything out and yes 41% is significant, but considering that almost 1 1/2x more, 59-41 are not in favour of abolition, then it becomes much less significant. I look at the poll the same way I look at gun control polls right after the major gun tragedy, slightly skewed against the status quo. The Senate is in every headline newspaper these days. 'If' it ever gets back to normal, the numbers will change as well. People have short memories unfortunately. If some changes are made to transparency and responsibility in the Senate and the House, then people will loose interest and the numbers will shift.
 
I didn't conveniently leave anything out and yes 41% is significant, but considering that almost 1 1/2x more, 59-41 are not in favour of abolition, then it becomes much less significant. I look at the poll the same way I look at gun control polls right after the major gun tragedy, slightly skewed against the status quo. The Senate is in every headline newspaper these days. 'If' it ever gets back to normal, the numbers will change as well. People have short memories unfortunately. If some changes are made to transparency and responsibility in the Senate and the House, then people will loose interest and the numbers will shift.

Where did you get your figure of 80%?
 
anyway.......there is always a margin of error in these pools and I don't know for this poll. I'm pretty confident if there ever was a serious poll on this issue and Canadians were educated enough they'll vote to scrap it, especially when they find out it costs over $100 million a year to run the Senate.

Besides that, why don't we focus on why the Senate is required for Canadian politics in today's era. As I've mentioned before it's outlived it's purpose, we don't need this entity to rubber stamp bills. In the last 10 years I think you pointed out they stopped one bill and that's because Harper told his conservative senators to vote against it. Senators are a bunch of party appointees who vote how they're directed to, they've lost their independence and power today. Seems a waste of money.
 
anyway.......there is always a margin of error in these pools and I don't know for this poll. I'm pretty confident if there ever was a serious poll on this issue and Canadians were educated enough they'll vote to scrap it, especially when they find out it costs over $100 million a year to run the Senate.

Besides that, why don't we focus on why the Senate is required for Canadian politics in today's era. As I've mentioned before it's outlived it's purpose, we don't need this entity to rubber stamp bills. In the last 10 years I think you pointed out they stopped one bill and that's because Harper told his conservative senators to vote against it. Senators are a bunch of party appointees who vote how they're directed to, they've lost their independence and power today. Seems a waste of money.

A $billion is a rounding off error when you look at what you get for $500 billion it takes to run Parliament. The House runs around $8.50 per canadian and the Senate costs around ~$1.50.

Cost to run Parliament totalled $561-million, up 14% in five years ...
Training manuals for Parliament guides boost Senate ... - Global News

As for the party appointees, it has been that in recent years, yet it wasn't always the but you might want to look into who appointed Hugh Segel.
 
That's part of my point, the Senate has evolved into a cesspool of patronage appointments and is a redundant entity. Why should taxpayers pay any amount, personally I don't think $100 million is nothing to sneeze at regardless of your rounding out argument. The original intent of the Senate is no longer applicable as government has made a mockery of this institution over the years by thanking party loyalists with a well paid position at our expense.