Abolish the Senate......

Apparently c311 goes by many names apparently. Why, I don't know.


From; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_Change_Accountability_Act_(Bill_C-224)

The Climate Change Accountability Act is a Private Member's Bill that has been submitted in the39th, 40th and 41st Canadian Parliament. It was originally tabled in October 2006 in the Canadian House of Commons as Bill C-377[SUP][1][/SUP] of the 39th Parliament by Jack Layton, then the leader of the New Democratic Party of Canada (NDP). It passed third reading by a vote of 148 to 116 with the support of caucuses of the Liberal Party of Canada, the Bloc Québécois and the NDP (the Conservative Party of Canada, led by Prime Minister Stephen Harper, voted against it).[SUP][2][/SUP] However, Bill C-377 died as it was still before the Senate when Parliament was dissolved for the 2008 Canadian federal election.[SUP][3][/SUP]
On February 10, 2009 Bruce Hyer, then the New Democrat Deputy Environment Critic and MP forThunder Bay-Superior North, seconded by Layton, reintroduced it in the 40th Parliament as Bill C-311.[SUP][4][/SUP] It passed 2nd Reading on April 1, 2009 by a vote of 141 to 128, and was sent to the Standing Committee on the Environment and Sustainable Development.[SUP][5][/SUP] On October 21, 2009, the House voted 169 to 93 to allow the Committee more time to study the Bill,[SUP][6][/SUP] as the sixty sitting days permitted for its consideration under Standing Order 97.1(1) of the House of Commons had expired.[SUP][7][/SUP] Passage of the Climate Change Accountability Act was therefore effectively delayed until 2010, meaning it would not influence the government in negotiations at the UN COP15 global climate change treaty negotiations held in December 2009 in Copenhagen. On December 10, 2009, the committee report on Bill C-311 was presented to the House, without amendment to the Bill.[SUP][8][/SUP]
The December 30, 2009 prorogation of the House did not affect the Bill, as Private Member's Bills are reinstated at the stage last completed, and Bill C-311 had not been considered at Report Stage at prorogation. When Parliament resumed, C-311 was concurred in at Report Stage on April 14, 2010 by vote 155 to 137.[SUP][9][/SUP]
The bill was passed by the House of Commons at 3rd Reading on May 5, 2010 with 149 votes for and 136 votes against.[SUP][10][/SUP] It received 1st Reading in the Senate on May 6, 2010[SUP][11][/SUP] before being defeated at 2nd Reading on November 16, 2010 by a vote of 43 to 32.[SUP][12][/SUP]
The bill was re-introduced as Bill C-224 on June 15, 2011 by current NDP Environment Critic and MP for Halifax, Megan Leslie. The bill was seconded by Deputy Environment Critic Laurin Liu.[SUP][13][/SUP]


I just read up on this bill to better understand why the Senate vetoed this bill. I discovered that Harper ordered the Conservative senators to veto the bill, lol. In effect, they are puppets of the government in power at the time, what a waste.
 
Which is why the Canadian Senate should be reformed.

The Upper House does serve a purpose in giving greater thought to legislation and it can be a check on the Lower House, but that is not really happening in Canada, should it - I believe so, hence the need for reform rather than abolition.

Do you have any suggestions on how to reform? Many people think senators should be elected and be accountable to Canadians, not be appointed by the GG on the recommendation of the Prime Minister and most of these are loyal to the Prime Minister and will vote the way the Prime Minister wants, what a waste of money.

It costs Canadians well over $100,000,000 each year to have the Senate, not to mention their pensions, and under its current form it's such a waste of fuckin' money. This money should be put into improving the CPP, which is long overdue.

This link provides a good summary on the senate.

http://abolishthesenate.ca/facts/
 
I just read up on this bill to better understand why the Senate vetoed this bill. I discovered that Harper ordered the Conservative senators to veto the bill, lol. In effect, they are puppets of the government in power at the time, what a waste.

That is true and clearly shows the problem in the 'present' Senate, That is only the latest action. There have been other times where the Senators have done their jobs and halted or delayed various bills, not many but they certainly aren't rubber stamping anything that comes to them. If you were able to read up on this one, then also read up on them as well.
 
What if the Canadian Senate has as much power over as the US Senate? The senators would be elected officials and be given certain powers like to veto bills on certain topics without the influence of the Prime Minister? I think that would be a better use of the Senate, however it will probably slow down governing and stagnate just like in the US, what a mess down there. I don't know what the answer is but the current Senate has to go, we need to either abolish it or reform it so it is impartial and has an effective role in governing.
 
FFS there will never be real reform as long as the conventional political system is in force. Elites don't "reform" or "abolish" against their own personal self-interest. They only expand it. Wake the PHUCK up. They want us to discuss small ball changes, while they grab more and more.
 
Man the Barricades!!!!!

NOW.jpg

Well Captain Cut and Paste they are manning the barricades for mainly fiscal/ economic/ entitlement issues in Greece, Italy, Spain, you know, developed , historically important countries.

And in passive Sweden, they are manning the barricades over cultural changes. In progressive London, same thing. Paris, same thing.

Add to that the myriad of countries from Egypt to /?/ name it , its a good time to be in the barricade manufacturing business.

So please, sit back on your sofa, drink your mind numbing cool-aid, eat your mushy pablum and continue to auto-believe that we here are insulated from these forces.
In my view, we aren't. Unrest is bubbling both fiscally/ economically and culturally. Where will this manifest? we saw a glimpse w Occupy. Some of the G8 stuff too. Anonymous hacking. Targets are being selected and tested, the elites, whether corporate or political won't reform themselves, unfortunately.

I am not for armed revolts or that sort of thing. But there is plenty of evidence that a large and growing percentage of the population is ... and future demographics , if things dont change, would only suggest that this dissent will increase in frequency and violence.
 

CTV poll: 13% believe Harper didn’t know about $90K bailout for Mike Duffy


Meanwhile, when asked about the fate of the Senate:
43 per cent said it should “be done away with completely,” up seven points from February.
45 per cent said it should “be reformed to make it, for example, an elected body,” up three points.
13 per cent said the senate should be “kept as is,” down nine points.


The best argument against the Senate's status quo is the Senate itself.
 
Fuck the goddamned senators for not protecting citizens at all.

OTTAWA – A new change to the Criminal Code that makes it illegal to wear a mask at a protest or riot is likely to be challenged in the courts as limiting freedom of expression, experts say.

The clause makes it a crime for a person to attend an unlawful protest “while wearing a mask or other disguise to conceal their identity without lawful excuse.” Supporters say it is one more tool to help the police maintain order, while civil liberties advocates say it tramples constitutional freedoms.

“It’s outrageous, there’s all kinds of legitimate reasons to mask your face in terms of a protest,” said Micheal Vonn, policy director with the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association.

The bill, which just passed the Senate
and awaits royal assent
10 year jail term?!
If we can't rely on the Constitution to protect our freedom, the Senators better not rely on the Constitution to stop reform or abolishment.

Fuck 'em all.
 
Fuck the goddamned senators for not protecting citizens at all.


10 year jail term?!
If we can't rely on the Constitution to protect our freedom, the Senators better not rely on the Constitution to stop reform or abolishment.

Fuck 'em all.

Explain how stopping people from wearing masks at demonstrations goes against the freedoms invoked in the Constitution?

History has shown us that those who wear planning to have a peaceful demonstration. It is not saying all wearing mask will automatically will be arrested, just that it is grounds for arrest. The 10 year jail term is the maximum sentence, not the default.
 
Explain how stopping people from wearing masks at demonstrations goes against the freedoms invoked in the Constitution?

History has shown us that those who wear planning to have a peaceful demonstration. It is not saying all wearing mask will automatically will be arrested, just that it is grounds for arrest. The 10 year jail term is the maximum sentence, not the default.

That is explained in the article which you apparently didn't bother read. And since you want to speak about history, someone much smarter than me once said,
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
A new change to the Criminal Code that makes it illegal to wear a mask at a protest or riot is likely to be challenged in the courts as limiting freedom of expression, experts say.

The clause makes it a crime for a person to attend an unlawful protest “while wearing a mask or other disguise to conceal their identity without lawful excuse.” Supporters say it is one more tool to help the police maintain order, while civil liberties advocates say it tramples constitutional freedoms.

“It’s outrageous, there’s all kinds of legitimate reasons to mask your face in terms of a protest,”
said Micheal Vonn, policy director with the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association.

The bill, which just passed the Senate and awaits royal assent, is similar to a bylaw in Montreal that restricts mask-wearing during protests. A challenge to the constitutionality of that bylaw is before Quebec’s Superior Court.

...

However, critics say C-309 is likely going to end up in court.

Sen. Serge Joyal, a former lawyer who argued against the bill in the Senate, said the law restricts the constitutional right to freedom of expression.

“The courts in the past have recognized that wearing a mask is a form of expression that is protected,”
he said. “Of course, if you wear a mask to commit a criminal offence, it’s already well prohibited.”

Julien Villeneuve, a philosophy professor who became “Anarchopanda” in a giant panda costume during the Quebec student protests, and is now challenging the Montreal mask law in court, said it is “terrifying” that police will have these expanded powers.

...

...protesters could get caught without knowing that the police have declared the protest illegal.

“There’s an incident that occurs at the tail end, you’re at the very front, the police now decide that this is going to be an unlawful protest, how are you to know?” Vonn asked.

She pointed out that the intent of the law – to make it easier to arrest people – ignores the fact that the police already have significant powers to arrest protesters who are causing problems because it’s already against the law to riot or break windows, for example.

“It doesn’t add to police powers, except to capture people who shouldn’t be arrested in the first place,” Vonn said.

And if the Senate is not going to stick up for citizens we shouldn't be forced to pay for them.
 
For crying out loud, it takes nearly 5 years to learn what needed to be a good Senator. Like any good job. Experienced Senator would almost be an oxymoron.

I like this idea, and for those first 5 years they should be unpaid interns and not allowed to vote on legislation LOL.
 
That is explained in the article which you apparently didn't bother read. And since you want to speak about history, someone much smarter than me once said,
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."


And if the Senate is not going to stick up for citizens we shouldn't be forced to pay for them.

I did read it and it doesn't say anything that contradicts any of my points. As i said anyone who wears masks aren't there for a picnic. Call it profiling, but it's true.
 
I like this idea, and for those first 5 years they should be unpaid interns and not allowed to vote on legislation LOL.

Like that's going to happen. i can't think of any profession that is expected to go through a five year unpaid internship, but you expect them to.
 
I did read it and it doesn't say anything that contradicts any of my points. As i said anyone who wears masks aren't there for a picnic. Call it profiling, but it's true.
That's weird. I wore a mask at a protest, and it was done
1. because the organization that was being protested was known for taking photos, finding and harassing the protesters.
2. it bugged them
3. it was fun to be with a bunch of people all wearing similar masks.

There were some police around, there was no violence and I certainly had no intention of doing anything more than being there as a show of support for the cause.

So anyway, this email came out today:

9asqad.jpg


The senators think it's a partisan place and their job is to raise money for their political party. There is no way you can convince me that this sort of fund-raising should be supported by taxpayers.
 
That's weird. I wore a mask at a protest, and it was done
1. because the organization that was being protested was known for taking photos, finding and harassing the protesters.
2. it bugged them
3. it was fun to be with a bunch of people all wearing similar masks.

There were some police around, there was no violence and I certainly had no intention of doing anything more than being there as a show of support for the cause.

So anyway, this email came out today:

9asqad.jpg


The senators think it's a partisan place and their job is to raise money for their political party. There is no way you can convince me that this sort of fund-raising should be supported by taxpayers.

Whether Senators do it or your MP does it, it really doesn't matter as the fun raising will happen anyways. It may not be their job, but nothing prohibits them from doing so , they are Citizens of Canada. If the party leader comes to a local function held by your local MP does it cost twice as much to do so because two MPs are at your function? No, they get paid anyway, the Senator should/can get only paid by one of the bodies and that's one reason Duffus is in trouble, double dipping, billing both for his time.
 
That is true and clearly shows the problem in the 'present' Senate, That is only the latest action. There have been other times where the Senators have done their jobs and halted or delayed various bills, not many but they certainly aren't rubber stamping anything that comes to them. If you were able to read up on this one, then also read up on them as well.

This is what you want to believe, but you are not a senator. Here is what a senator says:

The upper chamber’s current crisis is the result of too many senators mindlessly following orders from their political masters rather than representing the interests of their region, says a former Conservative senator who champions Senate reform.

Bert Brown, a retired farmer who gained national prominence after plowing the words “Triple-E or Else” in his neighbour’s barley field, was twice elected by Albertans to represent them in the Senate. He was appointed to the red chamber by Prime Minister Stephen Harper in 2007 but retired this March after reaching the Senate’s mandatory retirement age of 75.
...
The real problem, Brown told HuffPost, is that the overwhelming majority of senators don’t do the job they were appointed to do.

Senators are supposed to represent their province’s interest “but they don’t,” he said; they just follow what their party’s leadership tells them to do.

“They just vote either for Liberals or for Conservatives,” he said.

“I was there for five years and eight months and we voted everything that was voted to the Conservative government, every one. There was one guy who said who wanted to abstain once,” Brown recounted.
 
The same Senator with all of 5 years in the Senate after hanging up his farmer overalls for the new job, said a lot of things.Some didn't make any sense. It also appears he has his own problems with expenses as well.


Without pointing the finger directly at Duffy and Wallin — both of whom don’t actually reside in the provinces they were appointed to represent — Brown said everybody that sits in the upper house “should represent their home province; that is in the Constitution.”
If they were doing their job, they would not be “out running around doing rallies for one or another of the parties,” he said. “That is what gets them into trouble.”
“In my opinion, they should be 'rah rah-ing' for their own election in their own provinces not for anything else,” Brown said.
Brown said it’s fine for senators to promote their leader in their own province but senators shouldn’t travel the country for partisan activities. “These people get so worked up and think that a person who works as hard to become leader, they become some kind of a god you know. It becomes a little bit of a religion.”
MPs should, and do, run around the country fundraising and making announcements on behalf of their political parties, Brown said. But “there is no reason for the senators to be pitching the party.”
He told HuffPost he still dreams of an equal, effective and elected red chamber and he believes more Canadians are increasingly coming on side.
The Senate can still do “great things for this country” and abolition would just “automatically create a dictatorship,” he said.
The scandal has probably done as much good for Senate reform as it has done bad, he added, because “people who used to say, ‘Oh the Senate doesn’t seem so bad to me’ are now saying ‘Oh boy we need to be able to get rid of them.’”
“We want them required to live in the province that they come from and we want them to be re-elected or not re-elected depending on how they perform,” he said.
“Senators should be elected and if they get in very much trouble, they won’t get voted in again.”
Brown declined to comment on the allegations of wrongdoing against his former colleagues saying he didn’t want to disparage anyone’s character and that “there was nothing under the sun that hadn’t been done before.”
The retired Alberta senator had his own share of unflattering media attention after posting $43,543.94 in travel expenses during a three-month period in 2011 that covered the last election.
Brown was one of the top travellers, according to the NDP during that period. He told HuffPost his travel expenses ballooned because his wife fell ill and he expensed her travel to Ottawa and flew back to see her in Alberta every weekend to care for her.
He said he didn’t want the details published but that everyone in the Senate knew about it.