Abolish the Senate......

The elites never have any living expenses and are expert in disguising all of the perqs and freebies they book to their economic benefit, at our cost.

Lets look at bankers, lawyers, big firm accountants, financial services people like insurance, mutual funds etc... .... Their living expenses, like meals, clubs, entertainment, first class travel (and they keep the points) are almost all covered by corporate expense accounts, so they bank their salaries and bonuses and spend that sum on stupid ego-boosting shit or to drive up the price of houses - dont forget their special, employee discounted mortgages - for the non elites.

Or look at those who toil away in the "public service", especially the politicians, who also don't reach into their pocket for a lot of the stuff mentioned above.

And the kicker is that these salary multipliers / lifestyle enhancers pale in comparison to the riches in their defined benefit pensions and for-life health plans and other benefits.

I'm guessing you don't know many executives do you?
 
I'm guessing you don't know many executives do you?

I Know Plenty who live exactly this way - enjoying all kinds of quiet 50 bucks worth of value here / 200 bucks of value there, "freebies" and subsidies that lead to a real leg up financially.
Do you think an Ibanker at TD, a lawyer at Gowling, an accountant at PWC or for that matter a lobbyist taking a Senator out for a chat ever pays for his own lunch? or his dinner at OPUS ? or his Leaf tickets?

I also know that you type way too much without saying anything useful or accurate.
 
And in the news today:
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/05/26/lebreton-senate-reform-abolish_n_3340769.html
The (Conservative) government's leader in the Senate says the Senate should be abolished if it can't be reformed, comments that come as Prime Minister Stephen Harper returns this week to Ottawa, where he is expected to face questions about the expenses scandal.

Marjory LeBreton made the rounds of the Sunday talk shows to highlight a package of proposed changes to Senate rules on expense claims. However, in an interview with CBC News, she conceded, "The public do not see the Senate as a legitimate institution.

"We have got to fix this, once and for all," said LeBreton. "Otherwise ... the Senate as an institution cannot survive."

LeBreton, who has served the Conservatives in various roles for more than three decades, emphasized that abolition of the Senate was one of the possibilities that the government has asked the Supreme Court of Canada to rule on.

"One of the options that the Supreme Court should have to consider is whether the Senate should be abolished."

Harper, fresh of a tour of South America, is expected to face questions in the House of Commons this week for the first time since the Senate spending scandal heated up, and led to his chief of staff’s resignation.

LeBreton said on the weekend that Canadians have every reason to be angry about the latest expense scandal in the Red Chamber.

Also I don't believe that any constitutional change needs to be made to get rid of, or shrink the senate down to the relevancy it deserves. We've seen over and over this Harper government cut funding for scientific research, in effect ending that field of study. All the House of Commons needs to do is slash the Senate budget down to something reasonable like $20 million per year (still a hell of a lot), pay senators as part-timers to better reflect the actual hours they spend on work-related matters, and set the pensions in line with those of other civil servants, and suddenly a whole lot of leeches like Wallin and Duffy and Brazeau will leave to seek other employment opportunities.
 
I Know Plenty who live exactly this way - enjoying all kinds of quiet 50 bucks worth of value here / 200 bucks of value there, "freebies" and subsidies that lead to a real leg up financially.
Do you think an Ibanker at TD, a lawyer at Gowling, an accountant at PWC ever pays for his own lunch? or his dinner at OPUS ? or his Leaf tickets?

I also know that you type way too much without saying anything useful or accurate.

They do, if it's a private lunch. If it's a business lunch, then it's an expense. $50 worth, $200 worth? What the hell is that? Business and sports club membership are easily defended as business expenses as a lot of business is conducted on the links or the court. It's not much different then a lowly salesman getting a special price on his suits or his car when he works for such companies. Even assembly line people get perks on their products. This is just good business sense. Even first class travel is legit as it allows for more comfort and privacy should you decide to do work, billable of course, while flying.
 
And in the news today:
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/05/26/lebreton-senate-reform-abolish_n_3340769.html


Also I don't believe that any constitutional change needs to be made to get rid of, or shrink the senate down to the relevancy it deserves. We've seen over and over this Harper government cut funding for scientific research, in effect ending that field of study. All the House of Commons needs to do is slash the Senate budget down to something reasonable like $20 million per year (still a hell of a lot), pay senators as part-timers to better reflect the actual hours they spend on work-related matters, and set the pensions in line with those of other civil servants, and suddenly a whole lot of leeches like Wallin and Duffy and Brazeau will leave to seek other employment opportunities.

Good luck with that.

You need a constitutional amendment backed by at least seven provinces representing 50 per cent of the population, or one with unanimous provincial consent. Experts are split on which amending formula applies.
Yes. the federal government referred several questions related to Senate reform—including how to abolish the chamber—to the Supreme Court of Canada. It’s rare for the government to look to the courts for clarity on constitutional matters, but it happens. In 1996, Jean Chretien’s government asked the court about the legality and mechanics of secession, a reference that led to the Clarity Act. In 1980, Pierre Trudeau’s government asked the court about how it could repatriate the Canadian constitution.
The current government asked the court for an opinion on four matters related to Senate reform: term limits; the appointment process; qualifications; and abolition.
Can an amendment to the Constitution of Canada to abolish the Senate be accomplished by the general amending procedure set out in section 38 of the Constitution Act, 1982, by one of the following methods:

  • by inserting a separate provision stating that the Senate is to be abolished as of a certain date, as an amendment to the Constitution Act, 1867 or as a separate provision that is outside of the Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982 but that is still part of the Constitution of Canada;
  • by amending or repealing some or all of the references to the Senate in the Constitution of Canada; or
  • by abolishing the powers of the Senate and eliminating the representation of provinces pursuant to paragraphs 42(1)(b) and (c) of the Constitution Act, 1982?
If the general amending procedure in section 38 of the Constitution Act, 1982 is not sufficient to abolish the Senate, does the unanimous consent provision set out in section 41 of the Constitution Act, 1982 apply?
The constitution can be amended in a few ways, and each procedure is laid out contained in the Constitution Act, 1982. Two procedures are relevant here:

  • The 7/50 rule: Section 38 of the Act sets out what’s known as the general amending procedure for the Constitution. That procedure comprises two conditions: a) that the House of Commons and the Senate both pass resolutions supporting the amendment; and b) that legislatures in seven provinces that cumulatively represent at least 50 per cent of the population pass resolutions supporting the amendment.
  • Unanimous consent: Section 41 of the Act sets out several matters that require unanimous consent, including one that involves the Senate; namely, the right of every province to at least as many Members of Parliament in the House of Commons as Senators.
The government knows abolition would require a constitutional amendment, and it knows there are a few options. But it’s leaving it up to the court to decide
The court is currently accepting arguments. Every province and two territories, Yukon being the sole exception, are listed as interveners. Liberal Senator Serge Joyal and Independent Senator Anne Cools are also interveners, as are the Fédération des communautés francophones et acadienne du Canada and the Société de l’Acadie du Nouveau-Brunswick. The court will hold hearings over three days in November, from the 12th to the 14th.

A few provincial governments have expressed support for abolition, including Ontario, where former premier Dalton McGuinty was quite vocal toward the end of his tenure; Saskatchewan, where Premier Brad Wall, an ally of the federal Conservatives, says provinces already play a more effective role than the Senate; and Nova Scotia, where an NDP government holds the same position as its federal cousin.

Other provinces have expressed a desire for reform, instead of abolition. Prince Edward Island wants to push for equal representation, while New Brunswick hopes for Senate elections. The Maritime provinces have arguably the most to lose from abolition. Currently, P.E.I.’s four MPs vastly over-represent the province’s population, but it’s constitutionally required to maintain the same number of MPs—four—as senators.
According to Ron Watts, professor emeritus of political studies at Queen’s University, a leading expert on federal systems around the world and an adviser to past Canadian governments on constitutional issues. “While it’s possible,” Watts says, “I would say highly unlikely.”
The court will send down its ruling at some point after the November hearings. When? That’s up to the court.
What about a referendum on the future of the Senate?

One prominent supporter of that approach comes from the unlikeliest of sources: The Senate. Conservative Hugh Segal, appointed by former prime minister Paul Martin in 2005, has from the very beginning of his tenure supported a referendum on the abolition of the Senate. John Geddes wrote about Segal’s idea in 2007. In 2011, the CBC talked to the senator about his idea.

Conservative Senator Hugh Segal has twice introduced a motion in the Senate to hold a referendum on its future and he’s going to try again. His referendum would ask voters to choose between three options: abolish, reform, or keep the status quo.
And why a referendum? According to Segal, the Senate is “democratically completely illegitimate.” A referendum would embrace “the rather democratic notion that governments work for the people… as opposed to the other way round.”
Intriguingly, Segal says that if he does finesse a referendum on the Senate’s future, he’ll immediately campaign against abolition. He believes senators should be elected, so he’ll pitch that the “reform” box be checked off on the ballot.
Segal reaffirmed that position during the ongoing Senate expense controversy. For the record, a Harris/Decima poll in February found that 32 per cent of Canadians would scrap the Senate. A majority of those polled supported various types of reform, including Senate elections and term limits.
http://www2.macleans.ca/2013/05/23/how-to-abolish-the-senate-of-canada/

If you think the budget of the Senate can be cut to $20 million from $90 million and still be effective, it's time to wake up and for a reality check.
 
They do, if it's a private lunch. If it's a business lunch, then it's an expense. $50 worth, $200 worth? What the hell is that? Business and sports club membership are easily defended as business expenses as a lot of business is conducted on the links or the court. It's not much different then a lowly salesman getting a special price on his suits or his car when he works for such companies. Even assembly line people get perks on their products. This is just good business sense. Even first class travel is legit as it allows for more comfort and privacy should you decide to do work, billable of course, while flying.

What? the individual does not pay for this lifestyle, the corporation pays for all of these nice things as a corporate expense. Therefore his or her personal lifestyle is enhanced significantly beyond their visible salary without them reaching into their after tax income to pay for it . Got it?
You are a wealth of regurgitated conventional thinking, with zero insight or practicality. We'd call you dumb money/ or distribution, but you are likely such an odd-lot that its not worth our effort.

Spew on wizard ...
 
It was an NDP sponsored bill killed by the Conservative dominated senate, so of course it wasn't rubber stamped.

How does that make a difference as the initial bill had support from all sides with 149/136 vote in the House, but was quashed by the Conservatives Senators who had the majority, without allowing debate.
 
What? the individual does not pay for this lifestyle, the corporation pays for all of these nice things as a corporate expense. Therefore his or her personal lifestyle is enhanced significantly beyond their visible salary without them reaching into their after tax income to pay for it . Got it?
You are a wealth of regurgitated conventional thinking, with zero insight or practicality. We'd call you dumb money/ or distribution, but you are likely such an odd-lot that its not worth our effort.

Spew on wizard ...


A post so full of FUJISMs, he would be proud, carry on.
 
We've taken this thread in another direction. The question is if the Senate is relevant in today's political landscape. Has it outlived its raison d'etre?. . . . .Although a two house system can be valuable, ie. the US, lol, although many claim this just stifles progress, Canada really is not using the two house system the way it should be. I can understand why many want the Senate disbanded.
Which is why the Canadian Senate should be reformed.

The Upper House does serve a purpose in giving greater thought to legislation and it can be a check on the Lower House, but that is not really happening in Canada, should it - I believe so, hence the need for reform rather than abolition.
 
A post so full of FUJISMs, he would be proud, carry on.

I dont seek Fuji's approval, could care less. I am just curious as to whether or not you can actually produce any practical or insightful thoughts . The reason is you preen and pontificate like a know-it-all , but in reality the emperor has no clothes
 
I dont seek Fuji's approval, could care less. I am just curious as to whether or not you can actually produce any practical or insightful thoughts . The reason is you preen and pontificate like a know-it-all , but in reality the emperor has no clothes

Actually if you bothered to read, post #46 is full of info on how to abolish the Senate, the threads topic, whether it probable and much more, but alas you don't bother, so it was wasted on you.

Seeking FUJI's approval is irrelevant.
 
i would appoint some one like dr suzuki

although you may disagree with this specific appointment the idea is to appoint someone who has sound character , intelligence, a proven hard worker , and is an expert in an area that concerns the average canadian

WTF can a hockey player bring to the table???

So I would ask WTF can Dr Suzuki bring to the table that applies to ordinary Canadians that go out to work each day and struggle to earn a living, not having the ability to suck off the public purse?
 
All we need is for the Senate to be dismissed, as the Commons is, when an election is called. Mass resignation by prior agreement when appointed would accomplish the same thing. The parties recognized by Elections Canada would publish their ranked list of Senate nominees at election time. The PM would appoint the new crop of Senators from those lists according to the popular vote each party got. We voters might even change our choice of MP if we hated their party's Senate list badly enough, or if we we bowled over by their merits.

The current PM has already gone on record with his belief that all of the above lies within the area of ordinary legislation and asked the Supreme Court to say he's right. But all he's offered as a vision is the same sort of Senate as before but made even more troublesome by Senators now having the mandate of personal election and thinking they're just as good as MPs.

An appointed upper chamber of party choices, gives us the proportional representation our current set-up lacks, but leave the power balance we're used to. If we're stuck with the Senate—like the aging relative we can't toss out in the cold—at least this would admit what the Senate does, and get the foolish doing it in a more direct and even useful way.

I agree with your idea but I would tie it to the individual provincial elections. Tied to the federal election will just get us a Senate that represents the party that won the last election, no house of sober second thought. If you tie the appointment to list of nominees by the provincial parties and award seats based on the percentage of the popular vote in each provincial election you have a far better chance at having a Senate that is not beholden to the party in power Federally. Senators would also be resigning and changing at different times as the provinces hold their elections so the Senate would have degrees of experience. Would also need term limits to keep party hacks from always being at the top o the nominees list.
 
Actually if you bothered to read, post #46 is full of info on how to abolish the Senate, the threads topic, whether it probable and much more, but alas you don't bother, so it was wasted on you.

Seeking FUJI's approval is irrelevant.

Post 46 is a COPY and PASTE job, which i guess you try and pass off as your own thoughts.
Of course it is not probable that the Senate will be abolished , elites never give up power .
You regurgitate useless "analysis", i offer common sense and the insight that only something very radical would force the elites, whether they are political, bureaucratic, corporate to give up the "stuff" that the rules they set grant themselves
 
Post 46 is a COPY and PASTE job, which i guess you try and pass off as your own thoughts.
Of course it is not probable that the Senate will be abolished , elites never give up power .
You regurgitate useless "analysis", i offer common sense and the insight that only something very radical would force the elites, whether they are political, bureaucratic, corporate to give up the "stuff" that the rules they set grant themselves

Yup, I sure tried to pass it off as my thoughts. That's why I put the link at the bottom of it and left all the hot links in the body of the post, duffus. If your analytical skills are that sharp, I suggest others pull their chin straps tight.

As for your common sense suggestions, they won't happen, but feel free to offer them up.
 
We've taken this thread in another direction. The question is if the Senate is relevant in today's political landscape. Has it outlived its raison d'etre? I really don't care who is qualified or not, although that is controversial as well, but I really think it serves no purpose today. It's really a waste of tax payers money. 102 senators getting almost $150k a year plus generous travel allowances and expense accounts. Our hard earned income is paying for them and they've really not accomplished much in the last several years. What have they done to justify this large cost? Does anyone know what they've contributed over the last several decades? I don't recall the last time they rejected a bill. Although a two house system can be valuable, ie. the US, lol, although many claim this just stifles progress, Canada really is not using the two house system the way it should be. I can understand why many want the Senate disbanded.

The last bill was Jack Layton's climate change bill, which the senate rejected in a confusing farce that left the Liberals blaming the Tories and the Tories blamed the Liberals. Total fucking tools.

Also the chair of one Senate Committees gets 11,200 dollars annually for a committee the mets once a year or in some years not at all.

That more then a single person gets on welfare. Hell its more then many minuim wage people get a year.
 
Exactly, Blackrock13, The Undisputed KING of Cut and Paste!!!! Bravo. 31,000 nuggets and counting ......

You accuse me of trying to pass of a C&P as my word and when shown your foolishness of your error, you then label me the King of C&P. Are you the new MSOG?
 
You accuse me of trying to pass of a C&P as my word and when shown your foolishness of your error, you then label me the King of C&P. Are you the new MSOG?

You truly try to argue over the most petty, irrelevant stuff , and whine/ deflect with tiny little technicalities . How about , instead of cutting and pasting, links included or not, , you type an original thought or interpretation. Show some insight and intelligence , Bud Fox.