A Surprising Request from a former S.O.

Kudos to her for being honest about what women want. It is what most women in general want but many are able to hide and disguise it till after the marriage.

You know there are worst things. Like you meeting the woman of your dreams who does not smoke and you marry her only to find out that what your smoker GF said is exactly true with regards what most women want, they just have to play cat and mouse until they get it.

I admit I don't like the smoking either. Especially distasteful when I see hotties doing it especially just because they wanted to belong to the cool crowd in high school etc.
 
Don't do it! For the rest of your life you'll have a child that you may never really get to know or have them get to know you. It can be heart-breaking, and we are talking the REST OF YOU LIFE.
 
So only pre-nupt agreements override family law except child support?

Sections of the family law act override a prenup. Yes. In a situation where a prenup exists and a child is born into the marriage, then stuff like alimony and child support based on incomes kick in.
 
with all due respect to you, i'm not sure what your issue was here. she asked you to be a donor, not a father or husband. as a previous poster mentioned, you should take this as a compliment and an honour that she would ask you in the first place. you have your own outlook on childrearing which you are completely entitled to, but was there really a reason for you to come down on her because her ideas about childrearing and the concept of family differ from yours? lots of people come from mixed families, single parent families.... sure i also think that its ideal for both a mother and father to be present in a childs life, but just because that isnt possible for this woman, does that mean she should be denied a child of her own?

furthermore, i dont really think that you can consider the desire to have a child as a "checklist" item. its not like you can just go have a kid and then say, ok great! got that one done! most women feel the biological urge to have children, its not like she wants to keep up with the jones'es by having one.

love definitely is the higher law, but maybe she wants a child so she can experience that kind of love (the love between a mother and child)?

i didnt really see the "cold calculating and clinical" that you saw. wouldnt it be more calculating and clinical to go get a sperm donor? she obviously thought highly enough of your good qualities that she wanted you to be the father, that seems quite warm and thoughtful.

i feel that you may owe this lady an apology...

Sabiha, she told him that she has no use for him other than his sperm, and he told her that he can't have a child outside of wedlock. She was blunt, and he was honest with her. He doesn't owe her any apology as far as I'm concerned. She may have no need for a father, but his opinion, is equally as valid if not more.

To me, a child is the by-product of the love between a couple. (Sorry, I'm a traditionalist).
 
Marriage or not, pre-nup or not... the biological father of a child in Ontario is financially responsible to support that child according to HIS means if ever called upon.

If an SP drained your condom and impregnated herself with your baby juice, YOU are responsible to support the child if called upon. At any time and retroactively.

Thank you.
 
i think its a little shallow to dump a wonderful caring person just because she smokes but each to their own... instead of helping her quit its easier just to throw up your hands and break up

It's her other traits that I would consider instead of her smoking habit.
 
I don't think she was being manipulative, or cold, or calculating. I would have listened to her intently, thanked her for the honour of asking me, told her I would really think about it. I would then do her the honour in return and really think about it, but then probably told her a day or two later that after a lot of thought it wasn't something I was prepared do, and express again how proud I am that she considered me worthy of asking.

I think the only thing DD did wrong is blew her off a little rudely. When someone asks you a Big Thing like that, whether it's "marry me", or "father my child", or whatever, you should show a little respect in the way you answer the question, especially when the answer is "no". She asked a big enough thing that it deserved a real think, unless you really just wanted to insult her--in which case, that really must have put her down.

Showing some respect doesn't mean you have to compromise on your beliefs or values.

He didn't say manipulative. He said, cold, calculating and clinical. After he RESPECTFULLY declined, she bluntly explained in a nutshell "Hey, I don't care about what a man wants, I just need your sperm cuz I like your pedigree (& she still has a crush on him)".

That's being cold & calculating (maybe even manipulative with the crush part).

He honestly replied in kind. Why should he hold his punches when she doesn't?
 
Marriage or not, pre-nup or not... the biological father of a child in Ontario is financially responsible to support that child according to HIS means if ever called upon.

If an SP drained your condom and impregnated herself with your baby juice, YOU are responsible to support the child if called upon. At any time and retroactively.

Ok that picture is really!! i'll have to make sure used condoms are completely disposed of whenever i am hobbying now!!
 
She told him that she has no use for him other than his sperm, and he told her that he can't have a child outside of wedlock. She was blunt, and he was honest with her. He doesn't owe her any apology as far as I'm concerned. She may have no need for a father, but his opinion, is equally as valid if not more. To me, a child is the by-product of the love between a couple. (Sorry, I'm a traditionalist).

Now, to be fair I never said that I would not have a child outside of Wedlock. However, I am of the personal opinion that if a couple are going to have a child, I believe that the child should be raised in a Loving Home. Whether the couple is legally married or not is of no consequence. Mutual affection and shared efforts are essential. Societal distinctions mean little to me but I believe a child is deserving of two loving, caring parents because that child did not ask to come to this world. That child was brought here by two other people that made that decision and now they need to be responsible for the care, love and education of their offspring. Would you invite people over to your home and then have nothing to offer them?

As I mentioned, I could never disassociate myself emotionally from any child of mine. I would feel compelled and driven to contribute all I could to the health and welfare of any children I sired. This was not the request I was presented with. Furthermore, my former S.O. is fully aware that I am presently in a happy relationship that does not involve her. I thought it somewhat selfish that she should bring this up now when I had already offered it to her when we lived together. She declined that option when it was presented by me to her initially.

I have very much enjoyed and appreciated all the thoughts, opinions and feedback. I am very much buoyed by the collective majority proclaiming that a child should be brought to the world by Love and not a desperate need for life affirmation.

Lovely thoughts and quite fitting for the festive season we are presently experiencing.
 
Very true.

Did you know that under Ontario law that even an anonymous sperm donor is considered the legal father of a child. And as such, is obligated to support that child under any circumstances. The mother cannot sign away the rights of the child.

Rubmeister, things may have changed, but I have been following the legal rights of sperm donors in Canada for years, with the expectation that the situation you describe would someday be accepted.

25 years ago, as a student, a buddy and I were contemplating an offer to sell sperm to a donor clinics. It was a twice-weekly gig at 100 bucks a squirt. We were assured of not only anonymity, but of protection against future claims.

I argued, that in Canada, they could change the rules at any time. And what is true today may change tomorrow, if enough women made a fuss about it.

We passed on the option. My friend agreed that my argument outweighed the evolutionary-biology, and short-term economic advantages of the scheme, but we have a standing bet on this, that in our lifetimes this will change.

As far as I know, kids born to donors (from clinics), have no access to these records, and sperm-donors (from clinics) are still protected from support claims.

Otherwise, the “market” for sperm-doners would be permanently flaccid. So to speak.


While cash-for-sperm transactions are no longer legal in Ontario, voluntary donations are still accepted by clinics, and guys are obviously being told they are protected.

Donors are both necessary and desirable, and a benefit to society. Because donor-assisted-birth remains an expensive procedure, the kids are invariably brought up in stable, middle or upper class, two-partner, loving homes, with good prospects to be productive members of our society.

I would not be surprised if there IS in fact a way to do this and still protect a future donor, if the sample was collected by a clinic, and administered by a doctor. I’ve certainly heard about it among same sex partners, who want their guy pal to step up.

I don’t want to hijack this thread, so you might put your answer in a new post.

By the way, a few points you guys are overlooking is the fact that this chick won’t remain single forever. Her baby alarm just went off, but it won’t be long before she gets the nesting impulse. A woman like her won’t be single for a minute longer than she wants to be, single mom or not, and her offspring will be well taken care off, with or without DD’s dough.

Secondly, a typed transcript of a conversation does little to convey the actual messages that were communicated. So cut the guy a break. And her too, maybe, for that matter.
 
I'd say good call if that's what you (don't) want. Wear a rubber that you bought if you go there again.

If you were to say 'yes' I'd make sure I got a contract drawn up. I'm not even sure if a contract like that would be binding, but I would very much see a lawyer and get her to pay. Yeah, all lawyers are scum, but this sort of thing is well beyond the land of 'verbal contract' and more like 'bomb in a bonnet'.
 
I'd say good call if that's what you (don't) want. Wear a rubber that you bought if you go there again.

If you were to say 'yes' I'd make sure I got a contract drawn up. I'm not even sure if a contract like that would be binding, but I would very much see a lawyer and get her to pay. Yeah, all lawyers are scum, but this sort of thing is well beyond the land of 'verbal contract' and more like 'bomb in a bonnet'.

You can't have a legal contract with an illegal component. As long as parents cannot sign away the rights of their children you cannot draw up a contract that does so (and have it enforced or course).
 
You can't have a legal contract with an illegal component. As long as parents cannot sign away the rights of their children you cannot draw up a contract that does so (and have it enforced or course).

That's what I figured-- In my case, and in the case of people I know, we've used that to get out of bad work related contracts. The more stereotypical case is 'contracted to do a hit'.
 
Notwithstanding this countries instability in holding to contracts that it makes with its citizenry, if DD or anyone else did agree to donate, and the donation/insemination was done under the regulatory contract of a certified clinic like Repromed, then how would any illegal component exist? All he or anyone else might need to fear is the government possibly changing its mind on anonymity sometime in the future.
 
Notwithstanding this countries instability in holding to contracts that it makes with its citizenry, if DD or anyone else did agree to donate, and the donation/insemination was done under the regulatory contract of a certified clinic like Repromed, then how would any illegal component exist? All he or anyone else might need to fear is the government possibly changing its mind on anonymity sometime in the future.

If you look at some of the cases in the courts, there is an argument that you can't give up your parental rights. (Just like you can't waive your Charter rights.) Any contract between a donor and an individual, or a donor and an organization, would therefore be stuck down if it went to court depending on how current events in the courts go. IMHO, this isn't the sort of thing you'd want a cloud of uncertainty over.

IMHO, the sane legal fix would be to allow for contacts of this nature if they are signed prior to conception-- But god only knows how this will play out long term.
 
I contacted Repromed, Toronto's own, and Canada's only reproductive ID clinic, and they said they do it all the time under their designated donor program. They have a basic contract for the parents and the donor to sign, and suggest additional legal council as the parties may deem fitting. The promise to pay the legal costs of the donor would probably have to be negotiated outside of the basic contract.

So, if DD changes his mind, or anyone else decides to step up, at least he/they have some hope of protection from the mother, and time will tell if the courts will ever bend to the will of over-curious ID children, whenever thwy finally hit their age of majority.

My bet was, all those years ago, that the court would eventually rule in favour of nosy children.

But maybe not.

Adult feminists, who normally steamroll regulations like this "Rights of ID Children" lawsuit currently before the courts, (see my post on Ontario donor anonymity) may be smart enough to see their own perceived "Right" to have kids could be affected or threatened.

The needs of the many, in this case that of the whole country, need be considered as well. Our birth rate is currently hovering just above sustainability, and along with it, our way of life. The more children born to assimilated Canadians, as opposed to relying on immigrant births, or imports who may or may not share our constitutional values, the better it is for everybody.