A shill is a shill...

Armagettin

Member
Dec 9, 2008
338
1
18
Define shill


Here is my unsolicited take on this...

-ANY promotion that is more than reviewing is a shill.
-Too many reviews
-Reviews that are unrealistic - 10/10 on all counts etc.
-Reviews that are fake
-Comments injected into many threads promoting someone
-Reviews and/or comments from one poster harping on a select girl or girls.


Define review
A fair and balanced description of looks, chemistry and services with a judgment of value given the price. A second review if the session was significantly different or a significant length of time has passed. Comments made in someone else's review to enhance the review with another/same perspective.
 
So, if I like an SP, and enjoyed my time with her, and tell people that because I want her to be successful so that she keeps SP'ing so I can keep fucking her, is that a shill?

If I recommend a girl to a newbie askingfor advice, is that a shill?

If we're discussing the relative merits of different SP's in a thread, and I have ones I prefer and post that, is it a shill?

I think your definition is a bit wide. I get what you're saying, but shilling to me is done by the lady herself or someone who derives benefit from her posting false reviews or promotions outside the advertisers sections. But reviewers and Terb members should remain free to discuss our preferences without being shills. I mean Mirage and Dreammakers don't need my help, but I have definitely recommended Noir and Mercedes to people. Am I a shill?
 
But reviewers and Terb members should remain free to discuss our preferences without being shills.
Hate to bring up this guy but it will serve as a good example...

Mr.Big1949 aka James Bond likes Crystal. He posted in roughly FORTY different threads with around ONE HUNDRED posts about Crystal.

By your definition, it is o.k. for him to do this. I disagree.

The purpose of this board (besides making money) is to act as a forum to allow hobbyists to trade information on service providers. When a person has a motive to generated business for a girl and starts influencing the board, it undermines the credibility of the board. You can't take the reviews, comments at face value.
 
This is a reason why a lot of people won't post reviews -- they'll be accused of being shills. We need to encourage people to posts so information can be gathered. However, it doesn't just stop there. Once you have information, then you can review it and decide whether you can believe it. But discouraging people from posting is not going to help this forum. I say let people post and then you can come with your own conclusion as whether you want to believe them or not.
 
Armagettin, I do agree with you in principle. I'm just saying that your definition efectively muzzles most posters.

You were able to see that James Bone or Mr Big or whoever the hell he is was a giant shill without imposing extra rules on the rest of us.

Like I said, I've recommended ladies to other members, but I wouldn't call that shilling. Is that too much, do you think?
 
Like I said, I've recommended ladies to other members, but I wouldn't call that shilling. Is that too much, do you think?
Not at all. Sharing information is what it is all about. I am talking about repeated posts about the same girl. We don't need someone to post a half dozen times about the same girl. It simply gets annoying and does not add any value. If someone asks for info and you have already posted about a girl a few times, just send a pm.

I am also not suggesting a muzzle or limit but rather an understood etiquette.

Just my thoughts. Many might disagree.
 
Now, that I can agree with, and I think most guys do. I understand wantign to sing a girl's praises, but you're right - endless bumps and posts don;t do her any good and are super-irritating.

I wanted to spread the word about a visiting SP so she would continue to visit. But she doesn't advertise here, and just bumping reviews would be out of line. So, not much I can do but hope she does well here rather than shill her.

Yeah, I'm down with what you're saying. Most dudes are. Some will always come along and see a free, easy way (they think) to promote their faves though.
 
Sharing information is the name of the game, that is for sure. But a review that is all 10s, never anything wrong, and a review that is repeated over and over again sort of crosses the line from information to disinformation pretty quickly.

In the end, it isn't information anyone anymore, in fact this sort of over suggesting actually can mislead many. The girls I like are not always the girls you like, and so on. Review the girl, say your piece, discuss her services / looks / whatever as she comes up in discussion, but don't try to monopolize every other thread with her information.

100 posts about the same girl isn't just being a shill, it borders on an obsession that might need medical attention. It's creepy, and certainly doesn't add any information for the community as a whole.
 
This is a reason why a lot of people won't post reviews -- they'll be accused of being shills.
I think you are talking about something different. Someone writing a review or two and contributing a few comments about a girl will not be called a shill unless it looks fake. If they write multiple reviews and/or posts then they are shilling.

But discouraging people from posting is not going to help this forum.
I disagree. Discouraging people from writing multiple posts about the same girl will help the forum. I don't want to read 10 posts from someone writing the same thing about the same girl. I'm not blind. I get it the first few times.
 
I think you are talking about something different. Someone writing a review or two and contributing a few comments about a girl will not be called a shill unless it looks fake. If they write multiple reviews and/or posts then they are shilling.

I disagree. Discouraging people from writing multiple posts about the same girl will help the forum. I don`t want to read 10 posts from someone writing the same thing about the same girl. I`m not blind. I get it the first few times.

Maybe someone heard you. It looks like James Bond has been banned:

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=252632&page=2
 
Posters shouldn't engage in self-censorship or feel hesitant to post their opinion as the greater the pool of information available, the better it is for all readers. I think most experienced readers should find it fairly easy to identify the posters whose reviews should be taken with a grain (or perhaps tablespoon) of salt, of whom the now banned Mr.Big1949 being the most egregious example.

I get skeptical when I read positive reviews which sound too much like advertisements and negative reviews which resemble angry rants. Anything in between those extremes I would assign more credibility to.