A serious traffic ticket question

Would you feel the same way if it were a bus with YOUR children on it? :confused:

Do you have school age children? Do you drop them off daily? If you did you would know what people are talking about. The school bus drivers are the most aggressive drivers out there . Ask any parent who has to work arond these guys in school zones.
 
School bus drivers are amog the biggest scum bags outthere. Have you ever applied? The checks and balances are a joke,

I find a lot of these idiots put ontheir flashing lights but keep speeding downthe street. So you stop immediately and then end up passing you , wih flashing lights, like they are cops or something,

I know for a fact the protocol for bus drivers is to come to a full stop and then put their lights on.They need to check both sides and then open the doors. The are always behind so drive like mad men rushing from one pick up to another,


Are there assholes that ignore a stopped school bus? Yep.They deserve everything coming to them. But , if you stop and teh school bus is still moving towards you- what can you really do? They will violate the law and you get screwe.

That right, the law gives cops and bus drivers lot of power but that also means use it responsibly. If the bus was stop, I know I am wrong for sure. But flash while changing lanes??? That's grey area if you ask me. Even cops, some of them abuse their powers quite a bit (I know cuz I have cop friends!).
 
Would you feel the same way if it were a bus with YOUR children on it? :confused:

How would you feel if the bus driver is not following the rules while your kids on it??? In this case the bus driver is not wrong but maybe extra cautious. There's always two sides to the story...
 
Relax guys...

Do you have school age children? Do you drop them off daily? If you did you would know what people are talking about. The school bus drivers are the most aggressive drivers out there . Ask any parent who has to work around these guys in school zones.

How would you feel if the bus driver is not following the rules while your kids on it??? In this case the bus driver is not wrong but maybe extra cautious. There's always two sides to the story...
I was merely responding to cobster...

Those school buses are SO fuckin' annoying, good luck Ad.
Yes, I have 3 school aged children but their schools are close enough that they walk or ride their bikes (weather permitting) every morning. We also live on the edge of town, so we have a lot of country kids that are bused into the school so I am very familiar with sharing the road with them. Yes they are a pain in the ass, but if this is the biggest annoyance you have in a day, you will live a charmed life. Don't sweat the little things guys, you'll live longer.

Having said this, if there is a bus driver that is taking advantage... fight the ticket... you have that right. :)
 
tboy,

I must admit I was about to write a post that was almost verbatim what you said, but then I read the HTA. I would appreciate your help, as I had to read it fairly quickly and may have missed another section, but this is what I found:

Duty of drivers when school bus stopped

(11) Every driver or street car operator, when meeting on a highway, other than a highway with a median strip, a stopped school bus that has its overhead red signal-lights flashing, shall stop before reaching the bus and shall not proceed until the bus moves or the overhead red signal-lights have stopped flashing. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 175 (11).

While the HTA requires a bus driver to start the flashing lights before he stops, in my cursory read I found nothing in the Act that requires someone to stop until the bus itself is stopped. The OP indicated that when he passed the bus was still in motion, in the process of pulling over.

I will defer to others who have time for a closer read of the Act, or may try and give it a closer read over lunch, but as I say, from a cursory, the OP may in fact have a case.
thompso, you have the wrong forum. This is the forum where people speak out of their ass. No rational discussion allowed. No facts please. ;)
 
What is it with people who break the HTA and then want advice on how to get off?

The rules state that YOU MUST STOP WHEN THE SCHOOL BUS LIGHTS ARE FLASHING!!! End of story, no excuses, no reasons, no nothing.

You should have stopped PERIOD. I mean christ, those are kids on that bus......I mean really, you (the op) probably think it's ok to blast through a crosswalk as long as the pedestrian isn't directly in your path? You probably think it's ok to run a red if there isn't any cross traffic, you probably also think it's ok to speed through a school zone after 3 pm?

You're lucky I'm not a JOP. If you showed up in MY court I'd double the fine for wasting my and the court's time.....

Hey...cool it a bit. I've had a situation where I met a school bus when I was going 80K (the speed limit) and the bus was moving (toward me) and stuck the flashers on when I was just about to meet it. Absolutely impossible to stop in that situation. And no warning that the bus was about to put the flashers on. Now I didn't get a ticket in that situation...but I can see how it could happen. The buses are not supposed to cause these situations...but I'm not sure how the rules they have (which are probably not law) are enforced.

I think buses can put the flashers on while still moving to warn traffic that is some distance away to stop...but I don't think they are supposed to ambush people.

I'm not sure from the OP comments what the situation was...he will probably have to go to court to sort that out.

Believe me...I do everything in my power to stop for school buses including locking my wheels into a 4 wheel skid...but I've had times when I"ve been ambushed and could have been ticketed.
 
No, the bus was still in the middle lane in a three lane stree so it was changing lane when I passed it. Although the red light were flashing...and I was right next to the bus at the time.



If you fight it you will need to have the bus driver in court as a witness for you.


Other wise you will be guilty.
 
If you fight it you will need to have the bus driver in court as a witness for you.


Other wise you will be guilty.

But he probably does not remember that..where that was or if he indeed flash early...how do I know which school bus driver even? If I guarrantee to lose in court, I just pay up and forget about it. My insurance policy has a feature called "one forgiveness" basically my rate does not change if I only get one traffic violation...and I thought I never need it!
 
If you fight it you will need to have the bus driver in court as a witness for you.


Other wise you will be guilty.

Nah it's beatable. Techinally, by word of law, the bus must have flashing lights and fully stopped. Here's the loop hole;

Drivers may not proceed until the lights cease flashing or the bus resumes moving.

So if the bus is moving with flashing lights, you technically don't have to stop.
 
No, I'm not the pope but when it comes to kids, schools and the like, I ERR on the side of CAUTION. Before these rules were in place quite a few kids lost their lives due to unattentive drivers.

The section of the HTA where it describes how long a vehicle has to stop, that is AFTER it has stopped and discharged the kids, not before. As someone indicated, the lights go on to warn drivers that they are stopping as opposed to stopping then putting the lights on. Doesn't matter. You're supposed to stop when the lights are flashing PERIOD. Now if the OP was directly beside the vehicle? (but according to his story the road he was on would have had to be 3 lanes wide) It would be impossible to stop.

However, using the good old Tboy logic: he wouldn't be able to SEE the lights if he was directly beside the vehicle unless he was driving a large semi truck. So, one can extrapolate that in order to see the flashing lights, he would have had to be behind the vehicle (partially at least) therefore giving him time to stop (even if the school bus hadn't come to a complete stop).

Put it another way: At crosswalks in the GTA, the lights are flashing. Drivers MUST stop if it is safe to do so when the lights are flashing. There is no criteria that states that a driver only has to stop when there's a pedestrian directly in front of him, or if he can't see a pedestrian. Driver's are supposed to stop when the lights are flashing and not proceed until they stop flashing. (least that's what I recall from reading the new law).

As for school buses controlling speed. Good on 'em! I have been working in a subdivision with 2 schools within a block. I can't tell you how many assholes go racing down the street at 1.5 to 2.0 times the speed limit. One school is senior public and the other is grade school.

mencken: good on ya. See, when it comes to kids it is better to err on the side of caution. When I approach or am running with a school bus, the NUMBER 1 thing on my mind is to watch for him slowing in preparation for him stopping. See, in response to your approaching a school bus at 80 kph, it is just about impossible to stop if you are paralell with the school bus. But if you are a conscientious driver, and see a bus slowing, you HAVE to know he's not doing it just for the heck of it. Therefore you must be prepared to stop especially if one is in a position to see the lights.

Sorry if I came off a little heavy handed but I cannot tell you how many asshats I've seen passing a stopped schoolbus WITH the lights flashing and kids disembarking. I've had half a mind to chase em down and get their plate numbers.
 
Nah it's beatable. Techinally, by word of law, the bus must have flashing lights and fully stopped. Here's the loop hole;



So if the bus is moving with flashing lights, you technically don't have to stop.

Not a loophole: that "clause" is after the vehicle has stopped and has already discharged the passengers....after, get it????
 
Not a loophole: that "clause" is after the vehicle has stopped and has already discharged the passengers....after, get it????



yeah I get it Einstein. I doubt any bus driver would start MOVINg while the kids are discharging. You just like to post or you really this dumb?
 
What is it with people who break the HTA and then want advice on how to get off?

The rules state that YOU MUST STOP WHEN THE SCHOOL BUS LIGHTS ARE FLASHING!!! End of story, no excuses, no reasons, no nothing.

You should have stopped PERIOD. I mean christ, those are kids on that bus......I mean really, you (the op) probably think it's ok to blast through a crosswalk as long as the pedestrian isn't directly in your path? You probably think it's ok to run a red if there isn't any cross traffic, you probably also think it's ok to speed through a school zone after 3 pm?

You're lucky I'm not a JOP. If you showed up in MY court I'd double the fine for wasting my and the court's time.....

T-Boy your such a tard....everyone who is charged with an offense gets an opportunity to be tried in front of a judge or jury. It's every Canadians right..our taxes, and fines pay for the court costs. A judge can't double your fine, just for showing up to court to fight what you are being charged with...the court time has already been payed for by your very own tax money...
 
thompso, you have the wrong forum. This is the forum where people speak out of their ass. No rational discussion allowed. No facts please. ;)

Lol, then tboy is the resident expert.
 
The bus started flashing while changing lane and i was behind the bus (on the left) at that point. Yes, I did see the flashes but I moved w/ the bus anyways. And Yes, I had time to stop since the bus was moving slowly. And no need to jump on Tboy, he's just passionate on this topic. I have 3 boys too going to school so I totally see his point. If I am wrong, I am wrong. There are lot worst things in life anyways. I just want to get expert opinions as I found terbies are very resourceful.
 
T-Boy your such a tard....everyone who is charged with an offense gets an opportunity to be tried in front of a judge or jury. It's every Canadians right..our taxes, and fines pay for the court costs. A judge can't double your fine, just for showing up to court to fight what you are being charged with...the court time has already been payed for by your very own tax money...

Well, good luck with that! By wasted time I meant with an "open and shit case" and as per the OP, it was. As for increasing fines, don't kid yourself. I have seen it done. Now mind you, it's been in civil court, and FYI: it is up to the prosecutor and if they feel it is advisable to increase the fine, so be it. The JOP can and would unless the charge carries a stipulation that the fine be "no more than (the amount specified on the ticket)". Many charges in the criminal code say "not less than and not more than" clauses.

For eg: during a recent civil matter, during a settlement meeting the defendant stated "I could take this to court and the judge could award nothing" and both my lawyer and their lawyer reminded him: "but he could award double the amount as well....". I know this was a civil matter but still.....

mmmouse? How can you breathe with your head so far up questor's ass? What's the view like from up there anyways? lol......
 
yeah I get it Einstein. I doubt any bus driver would start MOVINg while the kids are discharging. You just like to post or you really this dumb?

so why didn't you post it nutbar? And notice I didn't say "while" the kids are discharging? I said AFTER dipshit........
 
I agree with the comment above: By my reading you are not in violation of the HTA if you pass a school bus that has its lights on and is still moving. The HTA 175(11) clearly does use the phrase "a stopped school bus", not a school bus that is currently changing lanes.

Definitely fight this one, you SHOULD win, and $500 is a lot, and 6 merit points is a lot, so it is well worth fighting.

Now whether you will or not.. traffic court can be a bitch, but I do believe the law is on your side.

Tboy: I agree with you WRT people who violate the law and then look for an out, but I do not believe the OP violated the law.
 
I agree with the comment above: By my reading you are not in violation of the HTA if you pass a school bus that has its lights on and is still moving. The HTA 175(11) clearly does use the phrase "a stopped school bus", not a school bus that is currently changing lanes.

Definitely fight this one, you SHOULD win, and $500 is a lot, and 6 merit points is a lot, so it is well worth fighting.

Now whether you will or not.. traffic court can be a bitch, but I do believe the law is on your side.

Tboy: I agree with you WRT people who violate the law and then look for an out, but I do not believe the OP violated the law.

I agree with you too Fuji, technically he might not have broken the literal interpretation of the law but the spirit of the law? (which is: school bus/flashing lights/stop). I think that is what has driven our legal system into the state it is in: too much play on words.

For eg: in the condominium act it states that an elected board cannot spend more than 10% of the annual budget without getting approval of the owners.

Then in another area it states they can spend more than 10% if it is an emergency situation.

Basically that means that all they have to do is wait until the expenditure is an emergency, then they can have carte blanche.

In this case, the spirit of the law is: don't pass a school bus with the lights flashing.
 
o.k here is what really happened.

The bus driver awoke with a woody. It happened to be his first case of morning wood in months so he snuggled up to his wife who said, " why is your pinky finger sticking in my back?" He explained and asked her if she would do something about it and was told, "fuck off and leave me sleep." He went downstairs only to find that his kids had eaten all of his favorite cereal and that the dog had pissed on the kitchen floor again.

After cleaning up the floor and finding something else to eat he discovered his daughter had used all the hot water and he had to have a cold shower. It was then his throat started to hurt and he thought that he was coming down with swine flu.

Realizing he was late again he was rushing through his morning stops, put the lights on early, swooped in like the fighter pilot he always wanted to be and picked up the kids.

It was then that that asshole Adickson drove up and put everyone's life at risk.

I think he should not be punished with a mere fine and some lousy points. Castration or the electric chair seems to be the only recourse.