A serious traffic ticket question

LMAO - Spirit of the law. Most of us here break the law every day in one way or another.
In Canada, we have many "activist" judges (and even worse Justices of the Peace) who will read a very broad intent into a law.

We have even more judges who will interpret a law according to certain sets of facts.

I have no idea whether this section of the HTA has been interpreted as to legitimize the charges against the OP. Or, whether the officer has the same version of events as the driver. The advice to consult a legal opinion is good advice. And with your own lawyer present, asking for a meeting with the Prosecutor to determine whether the officer will claim that the bus was already stopped might also be useful: the Prosecutor could conceivably decline prosecution if that cannot be proven in court (i.e. by the officer's testimony). Or, the OP may decide to not fight the charge if it is going to come down to a case of his word against the officer's testimony.

But those are not things to pursue without proper legal advice.
 
I agree with you too Fuji, technically he might not have broken the literal interpretation of the law but the spirit of the law? (which is: school bus/flashing lights/stop). I think that is what has driven our legal system into the state it is in: too much play on words.

For eg: in the condominium act it states that an elected board cannot spend more than 10% of the annual budget without getting approval of the owners.

Then in another area it states they can spend more than 10% if it is an emergency situation.

Basically that means that all they have to do is wait until the expenditure is an emergency, then they can have carte blanche.

In this case, the spirit of the law is: don't pass a school bus with the lights flashing.

That is a very poor analogy. The condo act says you can't do something unless certain circumstances are met. And whether or not those circumstances have been met is justiciable. In the case of the HTA it seems pretty clear that the bus in question needs to be stopped, as no one seems to have found another section that I may have missed.
 
tboy,

I must admit I was about to write a post that was almost verbatim what you said, but then I read the HTA. I would appreciate your help, as I had to read it fairly quickly and may have missed another section, but this is what I found:

Duty of drivers when school bus stopped

(11) Every driver or street car operator, when meeting on a highway, other than a highway with a median strip, a stopped school bus that has its overhead red signal-lights flashing, shall stop before reaching the bus and shall not proceed until the bus moves or the overhead red signal-lights have stopped flashing. R.S.O. 1990, c. H.8, s. 175 (11).

While the HTA requires a bus driver to start the flashing lights before he stops, in my cursory read I found nothing in the Act that requires someone to stop until the bus itself is stopped. The OP indicated that when he passed the bus was still in motion, in the process of pulling over.

I will defer to others who have time for a closer read of the Act, or may try and give it a closer read over lunch, but as I say, from a cursory, the OP may in fact have a case.

Hoping that he gets an honest JP, then that is, hopefully, a good defense. I have seen speeders get off because the cop was not exact in his testimony. Maybe, a good lawyer can fight the case in favour of the OP. After all, how can you expect a driver to stop on a dime if the bus isn't stopped in the first place. Not safe or reasonable at all if the police insist on a car stopping on a dime, IMHO.
 
HAfter all, how can you expect a driver to stop on a dime if the bus isn't stopped in the first place. Not safe or reasonable at all if the police insist on a car stopping on a dime, IMHO.

I could be wrong, but I read the OP's original post as that he was going in the same direction as the bus. Should be a lot easier to stop in time that way.... not always 100% possible, depending on where you were and where the bus was and all that.


But as has been said many times.... get some legal advice from a real lawyer, not free advice from a bunch of anonymous posters.
 
I am going to focus on the OP's request, which is what to do with the ticket.

The answer is quite simple, hire one of those ticket fighter guys, they are all ex-cops, you pay them, they go drinking with their ex-colleagues, buy a few tickets to some stags hosted by the prosecutor that may or may not exist (but who cares) and your charge will be dropped or reduced to something relatively minor. This is Canada, everything can be purchased, the very fact that TERB exists is living proof. If you can buy an hour with a blonde with hazel eyes that enjoys doing BBBJ, CIM and doggie, how hard is it for you to get off on a failure to stop for school bus when nobody got hurt?

In all likelihood and at a minimum, your charged will be reduced to something else much more minor, such as failure to obey a traffic sign (or some other stupid shit), no points, take that and call it a day and go see that blonde, will likely cost you at least $500 for the ticket fighter plus another $100 or so for the actual ticket, but much less damage to your insurance. So the blonde enjoys BBBJ, CIM and doggie but green eyes instead of hazel. Life's not perfect.

Whatever you decide to do, do not try to fight the ticket yourself. On school bus charge, which is very serious from insurance standpoint, you cannot afford to lose, you must get it reduced, this is where the pro's would come in.

I have been to traffic court, the typical citizen will try to explain to the JP what happened blah blah blah and the end result, guilty. Now the guys represented by ticket fighters, they always get reduced to something else, "your worship, not guilty to failure to stop for school bus, but guilty to failure to obey traffic signal", JP goes "prosecutor?", "agreed your worship", less than one minute and you don't even need to show up at all. And when deciding who to hire, always hire the one that charges the most, why? The more you pay, the more money he has to spend on drinks and stag tickets and the more likely your charge will be dropped. Do not be cheap or you will regret the outcome.

Good luck.