A-Rod becomes A-Roid

Diz, much like Koufax, had an injury shortened career, but was pretty much dominant when healthy.
 
stever said:
Diz, much like Koufax, had an injury shortened career, but was pretty much dominant when healthy.

Dizzy only had 4 20 win years, including a 30 win season. Is that enough to get one into the hallow hall? Also, there is one player in the HOF who only played 9 years in the majors. Shouldn't a player play at least 10 years to be eligible?
 
It's a good question. I think baseball writers of today would not elect Diz, because most writers just look at numbers. When Diz was elected, I think the writers looked at his dominance in those few years, plus he was a bit of a character. Also, medical science did not allow Diz to have a longer career, much like Koufax. How many players benefit from the advancement of medicine in the last 30 years? It allows players to come back and continue a good career, maybe not as dominant, but allows them to "achieve the numbers". Paul Molitor comes to mind- one of my favorite players of all time, but injuries could have shortened his hall of fame career. I think Diz belongs, but I can see the arguement that he doesnt as well.

A better question might be: Does Mike Mussina deserve to be in the Hall of Fame?
 
stever said:
A better question might be: Does Mike Mussina deserve to be in the Hall of Fame?

Other than being an active major leaguer for a 1,000 years, what has Mike actually accomplished? Led the league in wins, strikouts, ERA, etc.? Won Cy Young, World Series, etc.?

Question: Why is Jack Morris not in the HOF?
 
I agree on both counts. If they let Mussina in, then they should let Tommy John in as well. I'd take Jack Morris in a heartbeat. The guy was a pure winner. ERA, strikeouts didnt matter... just wins and the guy was probably the best clutch pitcher in the 80's and early 90's. His 10 innings in the World Series against Atlanta might be one of the greatest world series accomplishments.
Over the last 15 years, the only pitcher I was amazed by was Greg Maddux. The man could pitch.
 
stever said:
Over the last 15 years, the only pitcher I was amazed by was Greg Maddux. The man could pitch.

Greg was a true craftsman. A "pitcher" in the true sense of the word. I don't think his fasball ever exceeded 91 MPH. (He never pitched a no hitter but so what.)
 
Maddux had that killer change up, a terrific moving fastball (how many batters struck out with that moving fastball that starts at you then tails to hit the inside corner), plus a curve, slider, cut fastball. That is the art of pitching, just changed speeds and locations. He didnt need to overpower.
 
Let me see if I understand this right. A-Rod hits a home run, gets a couple of walks and leaves the park with his cousin after his first game of spring training. The same cousin who he said obtained the steroids for him years ago. Would not an intelligent individual be trying to distance himself from the whole issue as much as possible? Maybe I answered my own question.
 
The Oracle said:
Let me see if I understand this right. A-Rod hits a home run, gets a couple of walks and leaves the park with his cousin after his first game of spring training. The same cousin who he said obtained the steroids for him years ago. Would not an intelligent individual be trying to distance himself from the whole issue as much as possible? Maybe I answered my own question.

He doesn't get it. However, at 33 going on 34, he is 'very young and naive' ;)
 
Steroids have been running rampant everywhere for years. I was an upper echelon athlete back in the day (early teens) and I beat the competition quite handily. My coach told me that if I want to go further in my athletic career that I would have to take a supplement (he called it "Rocket Fuel") of some kind to keep up with world class competition. I finished the year winning awards at track meets and starting for the basketball team (I was the only rookie on the team). I then decided to give up sports as a profession. The guys in my high school bulked up considerably and in no time at all and they let it be known they were taking steroids. I'm not sure how much it affects one person's strength but these guys were a decent size and then they became musclebound meatheads.

I have no regrets and I am very happy I did not take anything to enhance my performance.

Some people just don't care and will do anything to gain fame and money. It's pretty sad when you have to cheat to do it.

I have no problem with someone making all kinds of money but do it legitimately.

A-Rod's numbers were absolutely huge during the time he claimed he took steroids and who knows how long he has really been taking them. He's probably doing them right now but then with all the masking agents (reminds me of computer hackers) around, these guys are one step ahead of the guys trying to help the game. It's time to grow up A-Rod.
 
lawyerman said:
Steroids have been running rampant everywhere for years. I was an upper echelon athlete back in the day (early teens) and I beat the competition quite handily. My coach told me that if I want to go further in my athletic career that I would have to take a supplement (he called it "Rocket Fuel") of some kind to keep up with world class competition. I finished the year winning awards at track meets and starting for the basketball team (I was the only rookie on the team). I then decided to give up sports as a profession. The guys in my high school bulked up considerably and in no time at all and they let it be known they were taking steroids. I'm not sure how much it affects one person's strength but these guys were a decent size and then they became musclebound meatheads.

I have no regrets and I am very happy I did not take anything to enhance my performance.

Typical response LM. You sound like Bonds, Palmeiro, Clemens, etc. Deny, deny, deny. :p

(just kidding of course)
 
blueline said:
Typical response LM. You sound like Bonds, Palmeiro, Clemens, etc. Deny, deny, deny. :p

(just kidding of course)

I know you're kidding blueline. It's all good.

I just wanted to tell people my story. I'm sure there are many more people in the world like myself that wanted to stay clean.
 
lawyerman said:
I'm sure there are many more people in the world like myself that wanted to stay clean.

Of course there are. Thankfully, in MLB they all wear Red Sox uniforms. :p

(retreats to a safe hiding place)
 
lawyerman said:
The guys in my high school bulked up considerably and in no time at all and they let it be known they were taking steroids. I'm not sure how much it affects one person's strength but these guys were a decent size and then they became musclebound meatheads.
Some guys also do the stuff so they can be babe magnets. I never did the stuff and never made the starting hockey team roster and never become a babe magnet. No regrets, there is more to life than playing hockey and chasing women (isn't there?).
 
Rockslinger said:
Some guys also do the stuff so they can be babe magnets. I never did the stuff and never made the starting hockey team roster and never become a babe magnet. No regrets, there is more to life than playing hockey and chasing women (isn't there?).

No regrets. I love that.

I never took the stuff and still earned the respect of the guys that were the obvious users. They took it for obvious reasons and that's there choice I guess.

Back in high school, there was nothing more important than women and sports.
 
lawyerman said:
Back in high school, there was nothing more important than women and sports.

Sadly, that is so true and I would also add "wheels". However, there were some of us who considered the SAT tests and life after high school important as well.
 
Rockslinger said:
Sadly, that is so true and I would also add "wheels". However, there were some of us who considered the SAT tests and life after high school important as well.

I absolutely hated high school. I was into my studies and always in the library whenever I could. I did not have a vehicle. The social aspect of it sucked big time. It's funny that I never went out with a girl from my high school but I went out with a bunch of girls from other schools all across the city as I usually met them when I was participating at a sporting event.