A "Relationship" Question for the Ladies

happygrump

Once more into the breach
May 21, 2004
820
0
0
Waterloo Region
This seems to be a common issue in relationships, even on this board as of late, and I think we all might do better if we can get a woman's perspective.

Here's the situation (purely hypothetical, of course):

A couple in a relationship has a disagreement about something. The topic doesn't matter. Could be paint colours, could be money, could be the raising of children, could be burned potatoes.

Being a SNAG (sensitive new-age guy) the male tries to get the female to discuss the issue. She clams up, crosses her arms and stomps off into another room.

He tries to draw her out further. "Honey," he says through the closed door, "it's really not that big a deal. Will you just come out and talk with me please?" Either she doesn't answer him or says something like, "JUST LEAVE ME ALONE!!!"

Exasperated, he retreats to read the paper.

She stews for a few days. Then, without warning, she erupts.

"WHAT THE HELL WERE YOU THINKING ABOUT?" she yells at him. "DON'T YOU KNOW HOW MUCH THAT MEANS TO ME?"

"Sweetheart, I was trying..."

"DON'T PATRONIZE ME!"

"I wasn't patronizing..."

"You were so. This meant a lot to me. If you loved me you'd know that."

"How am I supposed to know if you don't tell me?"

"Don't you remember when I told you that six months ago? You said you'd remember?"

"uh... ummmm... well..."

"Oh, that figures. Something that was so important to me that you forgot about it."

"Well, now that I think about it, I do recall..."

"Oh, NOW you remember. NOW it's important. Well, it wasn't important when it happened, was it??"

etc etc...

It could also go,

"Oh. woman, knock it off. It's not that big a deal."

"Well, it is to me."

"I don't care. It's not important. Lighten up."

"But it matters to me."

"It may matter to you, but I don't care one way or the other. Get over it already."

She stomps off and cries, calls her mother or sister or friend, while he goes downstairs to his woodshop to break something.

------------------------

OK, so here's the question.

Neither party is completely blameless in the situation. However, how can men deal with a woman who has gone from rational to irrational in a heartbeat? How can a husband/mate/SO encourage the woman to actually share the problem so they can work on it together, rather than stomp off in a huff and create poisonous feelings all the way around?

Any ideas?
 
Simple rule: she's ALWAYS right.
 
anon1 said:
Simple rule: she's ALWAYS right.

It's so DAMN TRUE.

Wait until she becomes a soccer mom if things go that far. It's only to get worse when the kids are now the receiving end, especially the boys.

The bottom line is no matter how "sensitive", "enlightened", "reasonable" you put up or really are, she will never buy this kind of BS.

In her mindset, this is too fishy for metrosexual or SNAG.

Unless you are gay.

BTW being a bi is NOT an asset, she will probably have fears of getting HIV/STD if she finds out you are one.
 
Well

There is no simple answer. Communications difficulties are always the root of problem.

If you want to stay in the relationship and she is willing, then seeking outside assistance will likely help. Couples cousnselling should address these interaction styles and aid in the development of more effectuve communication.

I'm sure there are workshops that deal with these issues as well. Perhaps take a look to community or religious organizations

It is best dealt with as a couple, but you can improve your skills on your own if you want - it may not eliminated the problems, but it may help you recognize just what parts of any negative encounter you are responsible for and try to improv your own level of input.

Good Luck
 
LeatherDoll;

I swear this is a real question, not any sort of shot:

Have you ever, in your experience, had a woman admit to you that she was wrong in a relationship? That she made a mistake? That she was incommunicative or impossible?

From my experience, it has always, without exception, been the fellow who blames himself even if his actions had nothing whatsoever to do with the breakup (including infidelity on the woman's part). Now, just so you understand, I have more women friends than male friends. (They smell nicer, and look better too!) Not once have I ever heard a woman take responsibility for a relationship breakdown, but every single man I know, who's had that experience, takes the blame upon himself.
 
First of all no offense to anyone with this!! But why would she discuss anything with you after you start by saying "it's no big deal"? If she's upset over whatever happened obviously it is a big deal to her and by stating "it's no big deal" you obviously don't care what her feelings are or not. I know women can be overly sensitive at "certain" times but why would you start off a "discussion" or an argument by saying that?

I can also say the same thing regarding men as well. Every time you hear of why a guy has "extra marital relationships" it's always the wife's fault, why don't guys take responsibility for their own doings? It works both ways ;)
 
happygrump said:
LeatherDoll;

I swear this is a real question, not any sort of shot:

Have you ever, in your experience, had a woman admit to you that she was wrong in a relationship? That she made a mistake? That she was incommunicative or impossible?

From my experience, it has always, without exception, been the fellow who blames himself even if his actions had nothing whatsoever to do with the breakup (including infidelity on the woman's part). Now, just so you understand, I have more women friends than male friends. (They smell nicer, and look better too!) Not once have I ever heard a woman take responsibility for a relationship breakdown, but every single man I know, who's had that experience, takes the blame upon himself.

I love my ex more now that she is persuing her dream. She will tell you that her self centered focus was 50 percent to blame for our relationship breakdown.

Chivas
 
diva631 said:
First of all no offense to anyone with this!! But why would she discuss anything with you after you start by saying "it's no big deal"? If she's upset over whatever happened obviously it is a big deal to her and by stating "it's no big deal" you obviously don't care what her feelings are or not. I know women can be overly sensitive at "certain" times but why would you start off a "discussion" or an argument by saying that?

I can also say the same thing regarding men as well. Every time you hear of why a guy has "extra marital relationships" it's always the wife's fault, why don't guys take responsibility for their own doings? It works both ways ;)

Yes, diva, it sure does. I personally don't buy the argument that a man is "driven" into the arms of another by an uncooperative partner. There is such a thing as self-control.

The thing about the "no big deal" episodes is this: Men are somehow expected to understand that women think differently about things. So far, so good. However, like you said, "it works both ways." So what reason do women have for refusing to try to see things from a man's point of view?
 
happygrump said:
The thing about the "no big deal" episodes is this: Men are somehow expected to understand that women think differently about things. So far, so good. However, like you said, "it works both ways." So what reason do women have for refusing to try to see things from a man's point of view?

The reason is many women believe man's point of view is nothing but a joke. At best they believe men point of views are all about face, ego and worse childish. Nothing seems right in the women "realistic", "attentive", and "mature" point of views.

Men are somehow expected to understand that women think differently about things because we were taught by the education system to think this way.

Guess what's the gender of the majority teachers?

Women

Exactly when will the male teacher teach the girls men thinks differently from women? Many male teachers teach sports, Math, Sciences subjects instead of humanities.

Oh yeah the majority of the elementary teachers are women too.

Would that be a surprise to know girls were grown up with more allowance than boys, something further reinforced into the adulthood?
 
happygrump said:
Neither party is completely blameless in the situation. However, how can men deal with a woman who has gone from rational to irrational in a heartbeat? How can a husband/mate/SO encourage the woman to actually share the problem so they can work on it together, rather than stomp off in a huff and create poisonous feelings all the way around?

Any ideas?

You cannot gain any ground by arguing the issue, no matter what it is. Your only hope is to attack the attack on it's own ground.

When the S.O. goes into "communication shutdown", they are doing so to protect their perceived high-ground advantage. You can't lose an argument that you refuse to participate in.

So attack the tactic. Inform the S.O. that when they refuse to discuss the issue, they are hurting you deeply. Tell them that when they do this, you begin to wonder if they even love you anymore.

Important - this cannot be done in anger - sincerity is required. A "blanket" apology thrown in doesn't hurt. If communications don't start opening up, walk away from the arguement, but not in disgust or frustration. Make it clear in the things that you say and do from that point forward that you are the injured party - deeply hurt by her refusal to communicate.

This is not necessarily a devious tactic. After all, your S.O.'s refusal to communicate actually IS hurting you and your relationship. Telling the S.O. your feelings serves to get the real issue on the table. Getting angry and ignoring it, however, does nothing to resolve the problem.
 
happygrump said:
The thing about the "no big deal" episodes is this: Men are somehow expected to understand that women think differently about things. So far, so good. However, like you said, "it works both ways." So what reason do women have for refusing to try to see things from a man's point of view?

Both sides seem to accept that the other side is different and rationalize accordingly.

Guys:
"That is how women are. They can get overly emotional and thus irrational!"

Girls:
"Typical guy! Always thinking with his macho-driven ego and his penis!"
 
It takes two ......

I'm the type of person who will get mad, seethe for a moment or two and then either look over at the person that is upsetting me and evaluate what is really important in life or vent it out to a friend so I can "think out loud". I'm not a yeller or a door slammer and tend talk too much, so giving anyone the silent treatment wouldn't work as punishment for anyone other than myself. :)

In fact, when there is a problem or disagreement, I always look to myself first to see if I'm to blame and then seek how to "mend" or fix it. Affixing blame is never the answer but looking for solutions is and also to evaluate just how important is the issue at hand? We all need to share our feelings without anger, especially with loved ones.

I do make mistakes. I'm wrong at times and have no problem admitting my mistakes or errors. Constructive criticism should be taken as a positive and not a negative. I'd rather know my mistakes and not repeat them, this applies to relationships, business and friendships.

Many men and women are closed minded or can't take criticism, constructive or otherwise, some are defensive and take things wrong (I can at times but have learned to temper my responses and to use reason to think things out before I react or overreact.) I think that this is a problem for both men and women alike.

I know that if I'm upset with someone, I would not go to bed angry and never use sex or lack of sex as a weapon. Hell, I would only be hurting myself and not solving anything.

Everyone is different but if I do get upset, just bring me a bowl of ice cream and we can talk.
 
Such problems are often linked to passive-aggressiveness. Someone will avoid a problem because they have difficulty facing it, and then blame the other person for the whole situation because they cannot take responsibility for it. Either the passive-aggressive person has got to do a lot of hard work on themselves, and the mate has to as well to understand the behavior and relate to it in a way that supports their mate, but does not encourage the passive-aggressiveness. It takes a certain elusive personality to relate well to a passive-aggressive personality and teach them to take responsibility for their behavior.
 
The fact of the matter is that none of it matters...what you really need is mutual goodwill, and you hafta understand the the paint colour-potato-kid raising thing doesn't have to be a consensus thing....why argue at all? You want the other to be happy, you want the other to succeed and feel secure, you want the family to thrive...as does the other...so who cares about the details.
The need to be right, to feel good at the expense of others, to feel "important" or "contribute" are all at the root of the problem.
If you think about the big picture...the colour of the walls, or choosing kid's school isn't so important.
 
wop said:
The fact of the matter is that none of it matters...what you really need is mutual goodwill, and you hafta understand the the paint colour-potato-kid raising thing doesn't have to be a consensus thing....why argue at all? You want the other to be happy, you want the other to succeed and feel secure, you want the family to thrive...as does the other...so who cares about the details.
The need to be right, to feel good at the expense of others, to feel "important" or "contribute" are all at the root of the problem.
If you think about the big picture...the colour of the walls, or choosing kid's school isn't so important.


What he said .... :)
 
You have to learn the two most important words in a married mans vocabulary.....YES DEAR!!!!!

This is so true!..........
>Marty wakes up at home with a huge hangover. He forces himself to open his eyes, and the first thing he sees is a couple of aspirins and a glass of water on the side table.

He sits down and sees his clothing in front of him,all clean and pressed. Marty looks around the room as sees that it is in perfect order, spotless, clean. So is the rest of the house. He takes the aspirins and notices a note on the table "Honey, breakfast is on the stove, I left early to go shopping. Love You!" So he goes to the kitchen and sure enough there is a hot breakfast and the morning newspaper. His son is also at the table, eating.

Marty asks,"Son, what happened last night?" His son says, "Well, you came home after 3 AM, drunk and delirious. Broke some furniture, puked in the hallway, and gave yourself a black eye when you stumbled into the door."

Confused, Marty asks, "So, why is everything in order and so clean, and breakfast is on the table waiting for me?" His son replies, "Oh, that! Mom dragged you to the bedroom, and when she tried to take your pants off, you said, "Lady, leave me alone, I'm married!"
 
Put her over your knee and give her a good spankin'...It's worked in the past for me. :)