A question.

DavidSam

Banned
May 28, 2010
67
0
0
Can a cop tell you to show your ID or be tazered? I know a person that went through this. He just handed over his ID without hesitation but I feel he had a right to challenge that order.
 
No. They cannot force you to show ID. What if you have none?

I think they can demand a name and address from you, ie: they can insist you identify yourself. Also, if you are a person of interest (ie: a suspect), they can ask you questions. You have to decide if you want to answer them.

If you ever get stopped on a bicycle, I would never admit to possessing a driver's license. I would always produce a different form of identification.

Finally, remember that there is nothing to stop the police from tasering you. A police officer can use whatever force they decide appropriate and that judgment is made in the heat of the moment. The consequences for the police officer, if any, for using excessive force always happen later. Additionally, you never know if the cop in front of you is pursuing a murder suspect, so it is a bad idea to antagonize them and assume the situation is all about "you."
 
He was alone in the room when the cop said this to him. So the 'heat of the moment' argument does not stand.
 
He said,she said.....................the black hearted beast said!

You know if a cop puts his fist into your face or tazers you, he will find a way to justify it. Guess who the judge believe.
 
He was alone in the room when the cop said this to him. So the 'heat of the moment' argument does not stand.
why was he alone in the room with a cop?
 
If you ever get stopped on a bicycle, I would never admit to possessing a driver's license. I would always produce a different form of identification.
As I recall Ontario is an automated Province - probably good since otherwise you might be standing there by the side of the road waiting for someone to physically look it up and then teletype back the information.
 
Ever notice that in these "Can a cop do this thread" any information giving out about exactly what happened is always vague and incomplete ?
 
I know they can ask you to identify yourself, and if they aren't satisfied with your answer (ie refusal/inability to produce physical id like a driver's lic.) I believe they can detain you until they are satisfied in regards to who you are.

If the threat of tasering is there I'd probably not be debating with the cop as to whether I was going to show id or not.... file a complaint later.
 
A bicycle of a size appropriate for an adult is defined as a vehicle under the Highway Traffic Act of Ontario (HTA). You can be charged with HTA offences such as operating a bicycle under the influence. The good news is that a bicycle is not defined as a vehicle under the criminal code of Canada. So there is no CCoC offence. Also bicyclise need to obey all of the rules of the road and stop at stop signs, lights etc. You cannot ride a bicycle on the sidewalk because you can not drive a car, bus, or truck on the side walk.
 
Ever notice that in these "Can a cop do this thread" any information giving out about exactly what happened is always vague and incomplete ?

One of the first things I notice in almost every, as you put it, "Can a cop do this thread".





A bicycle of a size appropriate for an adult is defined as a vehicle under the Highway Traffic Act of Ontario (HTA). You can be charged with HTA offences such as operating a bicycle under the influence. The good news is that a bicycle is not defined as a vehicle under the criminal code of Canada. So there is no CCoC offence. Also bicyclise need to obey all of the rules of the road and stop at stop signs, lights etc. You cannot ride a bicycle on the sidewalk because you can not drive a car, bus, or truck on the side walk.

Unfortunately these rules are rarely enforced by anyone in authority.
 
You know if a cop puts his fist into your face or tazers you, he will find a way to justify it. Guess who the judge believe.

To get to the judge, you have already been punched or tazered.

Invariably the best option is to not let the situation escalate. As such:
- you don't have to be punched,
- you don't need to be tazered,
- you don't need to be arrested,
- you don't need to hire a lawyer,
- you don't need to post bail,
- you don't need to go to court, and
- you don't need to sit in anticipation of the judge's ruling.

Who wants to deal with this stuff for no reason?
 
why was he alone in the room with a cop?
Because the other cops took the other person he was with out of the room to separate them and to also remove any potential witness to whatever they want to do. They always do this. If they can they'll always find a way to block the view of anyone not involved with the situation via closing a door on them or removing them away from the person/suspect they're directly dealing with.

He was alone with the one cop after they took the other person outside of the room, he was told to put his hands up and then to give his ID or be tazered. After he told me this I told him what the cop did was bullshit.
 
Okay, so there was something going on otherwise the cops wouldn't have separated your friend from the other person. This is usual so that they can compare the stories the two of you tell.

Was the cop being a power-mad douche and told your friend he had a choice between giving his id and getting zapped. Possibly.
Was the cop reacting to an escalation in the situation by either your friend or the other guy. More likely I think.
 
There was nothing going on when they came in.

The cop gave him no choice. He simply said give me your ID or be tazered. No situation was going on at that point. He was just standing there with his empty hands at his sides.
 
Sometimes our LE's take undue advantage of people who are black, brown, or olive skin, their attitude is entirely different with local white Canadians, LE's should be trained in their job to be impartial with who so ever they are dealing, and act thoroughly professionals, and those officers who violate their code of conduct should be dealt with severe punishments. We must have have more police offfers inducted from various ethnic communities, to balance the the attitude of White Racist Officers, in their Oath to Office they should solemnly affairm to the Crown that they would treat everyone on equal footing.
 
Your best options for dealing with LE are polite minimal compliance, while never incriminating yourself and doing your best to assert your rights. (WRT, reasonable search and provide ID type situations.) Respect their authority, be polite, but be firm. Never let them in, never let them start rummaging your car, don't talk incessantly (especially if you were up to something). Provide them with no reasonable cause for anything, and hope for the best.

The first part of provide them with no reasonable cause-- Is to be polite and to respect their authority. The second part is to try to be 'reasonably collected and calm'. The third part is to never have anything in lain sight and to provide have any 'easy excuses' (taillight was out and he was acting twitchy). The fourth part of that is to politely assert your rights. "No thank you, I'll check my own glove box." "Pardon me." when a cop goes to open your pack of smokes. (I've had both happen.)

This works less well the further 'off white' you are, and the judge will indeed 'take their word for it' and will hold any of your claims of misconduct against you.