A question for the religious crowd.

Imposing Christianity on the declining Roman Empire was a smart move by Constantine. Jesus tells his followers that the poor, and the weak, and the sick and the afflicted will be rewarded in the next life, while the rich and powerful will not. When a small oligarchy owns almost all of the wealth, they want the unwashed majority to be content with a low standard of living, so there won't be rebellion against the status quo.
 
Many scholars propose that Biblical God = Allah = Yahweh. The irony is in that Christians, Muslims and Jews all follow the same deity and have lots of similarities in their dogma and yet religion is the root cause of their historic hatred for each other.
I was being facetious. If there is a God, it makes sense that there is only one, no matter what he is called, however, the followers of this God disagree and cannot accept each other's faith and hence Gods. So, we are back to: my God is the real God and yours is not, which makes less sense, but this is how world religion works in practice.
 
I was being facetious. If there is a God, it makes sense that there is only one, no matter what he is called, however, the followers of this God disagree and cannot accept each other's faith and hence Gods. So, we are back to: my God is the real God and yours is not, which makes less sense, but this is how world religion works in practice.

It is truly bizarre. Catholics are told to believe that protestants are going to burn in Hell forever and ever, even if they supposedly believe in the same God. And I find it really unfair that I have to burn not once, but forever in all eternity, just because my parents took me to the "wrong" church.
 
I cannot disprove God any more than I can disprove the Flying Spaghetti Monster, but imo, the world makes much more sense if God does not exist. It is exactly what we would expect if there was no god. It is stochastic. Bad things happen to good people. Good things happen to bad people. Bad things happen to bad people. Good things happen to good people.

The multiplicity of religions are easily explained as a byproduct of human and cultural evolution, but not so easily explained if there was indeed a divine source.

In the words of Stephen Hawking, "One can't prove that God doesn't exist, but science makes God unnecessary."

And to quote Sean Carroll:


"Over the past five hundred years, the progress of science has worked to strip away God's roles in the world. He isn't needed to keep things moving, or to develop the complexity of living creatures, or to account for the existence of the universe. Perhaps the greatest triumph of the scientific revolution has been in the realm of methodology. Control groups, double-blind experiments, an insistence on precise and testable predictions – a suite of techniques constructed to guard against the very human tendency to see things that aren't there. There is no control group for the universe, but in our attempts to explain it we should aim for a similar level of rigor. If and when cosmologists develop a successful scientific understanding of the origin of the universe, we will be left with a picture in which there is no place for God to act – if he does (e.g., through subtle influences on quantum-mechanical transitions or the progress of evolution), it is only in ways that are unnecessary and imperceptible. We can't be sure that a fully naturalist understanding of cosmology is forthcoming, but at the same time there is no reason to doubt it. Two thousand years ago, it was perfectly reasonable to invoke God as an explanation for natural phenomena; now, we can do much better.

None of this amounts to a "proof" that God doesn't exist, of course. Such a proof is not forthcoming; science isn't in the business of proving things. Rather, science judges the merits of competing models in terms of their simplicity, clarity, comprehensiveness, and fit to the data. Unsuccessful theories are never disproven, as we can always concoct elaborate schemes to save the phenomena; they just fade away as better theories gain acceptance. Attempting to explain the natural world by appealing to God is, by scientific standards, not a very successful theory. The fact that we humans have been able to understand so much about how the natural world works, in our incredibly limited region of space over a remarkably short period of time, is a triumph of the human spirit, one in which we can all be justifiably proud."
 
Last edited:
It is truly bizarre. Catholics are told to believe that protestants are going to burn in Hell forever and ever, even if they supposedly believe in the same God. And I find it really unfair that I have to burn not once, but forever in all eternity, just because my parents took me to the "wrong" church.
Having had a nice lunch with a Roman Catholic Priest a couple of weeks ago, I have been assured that I am not going to "burn in Hell forever and ever" merely because I am not a Roman Catholic. I certainly hope he hasn't changed his mind so soon.

Indeed he has "problems" that I am not a Roman Catholic and indeed that I am far from enthusastic about a great many points of Roman Catholic doctrine, but automatically going to Hell. . . . . is an other matter.
 
Well past the "best before" date.

I cannot disprove God any more than I can disprove the Flying Spaghetti Monster, but imo, the world makes much more sense if God does not exist. It is exactly what we would expect if there was no god. It is stochastic. Bad things happen to good people. Good things happen to bad people. Bad things happen to bad people. Good things happen to good people.

The multiplicity of religions are easily explained as a byproduct of human and cultural evolution, but not so easily explained if there was indeed a divine source.

In the words of Steven Hawking, "One can't prove that God doesn't exist, but science makes God unnecessary."

And to quote Sean Carroll:


"Over the past five hundred years, the progress of science has worked to strip away God's roles in the world. He isn't needed to keep things moving, or to develop the complexity of living creatures, or to account for the existence of the universe. Perhaps the greatest triumph of the scientific revolution has been in the realm of methodology. Control groups, double-blind experiments, an insistence on precise and testable predictions – a suite of techniques constructed to guard against the very human tendency to see things that aren't there. There is no control group for the universe, but in our attempts to explain it we should aim for a similar level of rigor. If and when cosmologists develop a successful scientific understanding of the origin of the universe, we will be left with a picture in which there is no place for God to act – if he does (e.g., through subtle influences on quantum-mechanical transitions or the progress of evolution), it is only in ways that are unnecessary and imperceptible. We can't be sure that a fully naturalist understanding of cosmology is forthcoming, but at the same time there is no reason to doubt it. Two thousand years ago, it was perfectly reasonable to invoke God as an explanation for natural phenomena; now, we can do much better.

None of this amounts to a "proof" that God doesn't exist, of course. Such a proof is not forthcoming; science isn't in the business of proving things. Rather, science judges the merits of competing models in terms of their simplicity, clarity, comprehensiveness, and fit to the data. Unsuccessful theories are never disproven, as we can always concoct elaborate schemes to save the phenomena; they just fade away as better theories gain acceptance. Attempting to explain the natural world by appealing to God is, by scientific standards, not a very successful theory. The fact that we humans have been able to understand so much about how the natural world works, in our incredibly limited region of space over a remarkably short period of time, is a triumph of the human spirit, one in which we can all be justifiably proud."

Well put,...and the only way to look at this subject,...though again,...only if you have not been indoctrinated,...but then this type of thinking would make a believer's head spin.

FAST
 
Mental Things are alone Real; what is Calld Corporeal Nobody Knows of its dwelling Place; it is in Fallacy & its Existence an Imposture. Where is the Existence Out of Mind or Thought? Where is it but in the Mind of a Fool? Some People flatter themselves that there will be No Last Judgment, & that Bad Art will be adopted & mixed with Good Art, That Error or Experiment will make a Part of Truth, & they Boast that it is its Foundation. These People flatter themselves; I will not Flatter them. Error is Created; Truth is Eternal. Error or Creation will be Burned Up, & then & not till then Truth or Eternity will appear. It is Burnt up the Moment Men cease to behold it. I assert for My self that I do not behold the Outward Creation & that to me it is hindrance & not Action; it is as the Dirt upon my feet, No part of Me. "What," it will be Questioned, "When the Sun rises, do you not see a round Disk of fire somewhat like a Guinea?" O no no, I see an Innumerable company of the Heavenly host crying "Holy Holy Holy is the Lord God Almighty." I question not my Corporeal or Vegetative Eye any more than I would Question a Window concerning a Sight: I look thro it & not with it.

William Blake, 1810
 
Well put,...and the only way to look at this subject,...though again,...only if you have not been indoctrinated,...but then this type of thinking would make a believer's head spin.

FAST

.... and who decides if someone is 'indoctrinated'? Apparently you seem to think you can. I know you are not an atheist or one of them indoctrinated ignorant, but if it quacks like a duck and walks like a duck ............ you sure are talking like one.
 
While debating theology - especially "hot button topics" with those who have no background, no education in such matters, is usually a fruitless exercise, I will weigh in nonetheless.

God created man (mankind) in His image; however, man was created with Free Will(*). A fallen angel led Adam and Eve to make choices which led mankind away from God and towards a failed human condition.

Asking whether God created cancer is akin to asking whether God created sin. In response, I would ask whether you are responsible for the actions of your children. Your grandchildren. Your great-grandchildren. Did you not "create" them? Raise them? Teach them how they should behave? Teach them right from wrong? Are your parents not responsible for all of your actions?

Yet people recognize their own free will and would still blame God for the evil which man commits under their own free will.
 
.........Asking whether God created cancer is akin to asking
whether God created sin.

I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD
do all these things.
(Isaiah 45:7)

In response, I would ask whether you are responsible for the actions of your children. Your grandchildren. Your great-grandchildren................

......for I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on
the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, ...
(Exodus 20:5)
 
I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD
do all these things.
(Isaiah 45:7)

......for I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on
the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, ...
(Exodus 20:5)
Accepting this as a studied response and not a glib one, I will ask: what is the Prophet Isaiah referring to as "evil"? Is he saying the LORD created *all* evil? That some of what the LORD created is regarded by Man as Evil? That some of what the LORD created is regarded by God as evil? What is the Prophet referring to by "peace"?

Isaiah generally wrote in "couplets", with the two halves mirroring each other. In this verse, "peace" would refer to the same thing as "light", and "evil" would refer to the same thing as "darkness". And we understand from Isaiah's writings that "light" refers to "Salvation", atonement, being "at-one" with God, forgiveness of one's sins. Darkness refers to separation from God and all that that entails. Without studying this verse further, we can understand that it refers to God's Judgement, bringing heavenly peace to those who believe on Him and trust in Him for their Salvation, and separating Himself from those who do not.
 
......for I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on
the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, ...
(Exodus 20:5)
Which I suppose from a Jewish perspective is from whence one argues, Christian Theology takes a different view.
 
. . I also don't believe in religion, bible etc. I make an effort and try to respect other peoples beliefs and feelings.

Well, to a degree. A person is entitled to our respect for his religious beliefs to the same extent that he is entitled to our respect for his belief that his kids are smart and his wife is beautiful. No more, no less.
 
It is truly bizarre. Catholics are told to believe that protestants are going to burn in Hell forever and ever, even if they supposedly believe in the same God. And I find it really unfair that I have to burn not once, but forever in all eternity, just because my parents took me to the "wrong" church.

Why do you feel the need to lie about this Dan?

Catholic doctrine in fact states that muslims, protestants, atheists, and all sorts can get into heaven based on their conduct.

They just teach that Catholics have the best chance of salvation.

But why the lies?
 
I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil: I the LORD
do all these things.
(Isaiah 45:7)



......for I the Lord your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on
the children to the third and the fourth generation of those who hate me, ...
(Exodus 20:5)

As long as you put the right parts of the OT into the context that they refer to the people of the covenant, and not people in general, then your understanding of this will be greatly enhanced.
 
Why do you feel the need to lie about this Dan?

Catholic doctrine in fact states that muslims, protestants, atheists, and all sorts can get into heaven based on their conduct.

They just teach that Catholics have the best chance of salvation.

But why the lies?

You really don't expect Mr Peabody to give you a legitimate answer, do you?
 
Just wait until you get to the afterlife, find out that the Chinese have it right, the Qin emperor rules the place and his huge terracotta army is marching around telling everybody what to do.
 
Why do you feel the need to lie about this Dan?

Catholic doctrine in fact states that muslims, protestants, atheists, and all sorts can get into heaven based on their conduct.

They just teach that Catholics have the best chance of salvation.

But why the lies?

I have it from Richerd Dawkins that a catholic priest said that to a child. My neighbour went to a catholic school and say he was told similar.



It is never the dogma that is a problem, because the dogma's are formulated by learned, civilized people. But you have to look at the religion and its cleric in a totality. All religions I know of are against killing, but we have all seen christian priests bless instruments of war, and we have seen wars (untill recently in northern Ireland between different versions of christianity. And I hardly need to mention the muslim religion, where clerics call for killing of authors and cartunists, and where clerics encourage young people to blow themselves up, and wage vicious wars between different versions of the religion. Even buddist priest are not beyound r3eproach in the regard.
 
I have it from Richerd Dawkins that a catholic priest said that to a child.
You have it from Richard Dawkins
sick0021.gif
 
Other view points

While debating theology - especially "hot button topics" with those who have no background, no education in such matters, is usually a fruitless exercise, I will weigh in nonetheless.

God created man (mankind) in His image; however, man was created with Free Will(*). A fallen angel led Adam and Eve to make choices which led mankind away from God and towards a failed human condition.

Asking whether God created cancer is akin to asking whether God created sin. In response, I would ask whether you are responsible for the actions of your children. Your grandchildren. Your great-grandchildren. Did you not "create" them? Raise them? Teach them how they should behave? Teach them right from wrong? Are your parents not responsible for all of your actions?

Yet people recognize their own free will and would still blame God for the evil which man commits under their own free will.

I agree that people such as myself, should not be part of this theology discussion/debate, as I have not been EDUCATED in this philosophy.
But I have to disagree with anybody who makes a statement such as, "God created man (mankind) in His image.....",... without preceding like statements with something to the effect,..."Christian theology teaches/states.....

Or are we to assume that when anybody makes statements based on theology,...it is assumed that it is to be taken in that context.

FAST