A pilot earns his pay

rubmeister100 said:
Maybe the Chief Pilto will when they fire the Airbus pilot's ass.

No pilot should ever try to land in those winds. Irresponsible.

If you dont allow landings in strong winds, you might as well close the
airport in Hamburg.
 
Cool video. I would not want to be on that plane. :eek:
 
I was once on a propeller plane landing in Sonderborg (not that far from Hamburg) in similar stormy condition,
and with the wind coming at 90 degree angle to the runway, as in the video.

When we were approaching the runway, I looked out of the window, and could see straight down the runway,
the plane must have been flying in at least a 45 degree angle to the runway untill just before touchdown.

In the video, you can see the pilot doing the same maneuvre.
 
Why does nothing like that ever happen when I fly???

Looks like it would have been more fun than a roller coaster
 
That pilot is a fool and should be grounded. If that landing gear had touched the ground the spoilers would have deployed and he would have been splattered all over that runway.
 
In addition to that video on the right side there are others.

The BA jumbo landing sideways is pretty good. the pilot timed it perfectly. Bet he's glad he paid attention in school.


.
 
toughb said:
That pilot is a fool and should be grounded. If that landing gear had touched the ground the spoilers would have deployed and he would have been splattered all over that runway.


Provided that the protocal is same here (Canada and USA) as it is Europe the pilots reley mostly on other pilots that have landed and reports from ATC. If previous pilots had reported little to no problems then there's not much you can do.

The Air France crash at YYZ a few summers back - no problems reported and I think it was attributed to a wind sheer. Something that is almost impossible to predict. The other one that comes to mind is Southwest sliding off the runway at Midway in Chicago. The previous pilots had reported slippery runways but not un-landable. The problem is that it was about 10 minutes between the last report and when the plane in question came in to land. That 10 minutes made the difference.

IMO it looks's like the only thing this pilot is responsible for is saving the live's aboard the plane.
 
toughb said:
That pilot is a fool and should be grounded. If that landing gear had touched the ground the spoilers would have deployed and he would have been splattered all over that runway.

Pilot was actually praised by the airline as implementing an "absolutely professional maneuver". The winds that knocked the plane around could have come out of anywhere. See link below.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080303/ap_on_re_eu/germany_rough_landing_1
 
I was on a plane that had similar problems when taking off from Cuba with a hurricane in the area. Once the plane's nose lifted up the plane when a bit sideways and then one of the wings was caught by a gust from the side and lifted up, assuming this, and it felt like the plane was going to flip over. It all happened very fast. Once in the air the plane had to circle and maneuver around the clouds to gain altitude and be above the storm.
 
I am aware of the thunderstom - my bad for not mentioning it.

The point I'm making is that something like wind sheer is unpredictable.
 
toughb said:
That pilot is a fool and should be grounded. If that landing gear had touched the ground the spoilers would have deployed and he would have been splattered all over that runway.


Look again the gear did touch down.
 
Negative...

Hammerstein said:
Look again the gear did touch down.
***************
He scraped the ground but with what one cannot tell. Any pressure on the landing gear automatically deploys the spoilers and prevents lift. He would have crashed.
 
yesguy said:
As a good friend who's a commercial pilot told me flying is essentially a very boring occupation. Every one in a while though....... it gets more exciting than you ever bargained for
The general expression is 'flying is (thousands of) hours of boredom, punctuated by a few seconds of sheer terror.' - And it is for the seconds that they pay.
 
Try again

toughb said:
***************
He scraped the ground but with what one cannot tell. Any pressure on the landing gear automatically deploys the spoilers and prevents lift. He would have crashed.

wheels are the closest thing to the ground and I seriously doubt that the any other part of the plane woiuld have created that whisps of smoke other than the tires.
 
Hammerstein said:
wheels are the closest thing to the ground and I seriously doubt that the any other part of the plane woiuld have created that whisps of smoke other than the tires.

German jet wing scrapes runway; all safe


Airline spokesman Wolfgang Weber said the plane was rocked by wind clocked at 155 mph as it tried to land.

The left wing grazed the runway for a moment, but Weber said the pilot was able to stabilize the aircraft and take off again in what he called an "absolutely professional maneuver."