A Hunting Story

Despo

New member
Jun 22, 2010
263
0
0
http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2012/02/hunters-are-people-too/252870/

TOVAR CERULLI - Tovar Cerulli is the author of The Mindful Carnivore: A Vegetarian's Hunt for Sustenance. He is also a doctoral student at the University of Massachusetts, where his research focuses on food, hunting, and human relationships with nature.

Watching hunters headed to the woods each autumn, I used to shake my head. As a vegan who abhorred violence and suffering, I wondered what possessed such people. That they ate flesh was bad enough. That they spent time and money in pursuit of the chance to deal death to fellow creatures was incomprehensible.

From where I stood in our organic vegetable garden, I saw hunting as a barbaric relic of humanity's pre-agricultural past, the antithesis of our gentle efforts to coax sustenance from the soil. I couldn't possibly have pictured myself a decade later, mapping deer trails all summer in hopes of dragging home venison come November.

Like many vegans and vegetarians, I abstained from animal-derived foods because I cared about the consequences of my eating, for the planet and for the beings who inhabit it. I sought a kind of responsible dietary citizenship, a respectful, holistic way of living as a member of the larger-than-human world. My turn toward hunting was an unexpected extension of that same search.

Even local, organic greens and strawberries came to us courtesy of missing forests, smoke-bombed woodchucks, and rifle-shot deer.
By the time my fiancée and I returned to eating eggs and dairy due to health concerns, I had realized that everything I ate took a toll on animals. I knew that clearing crop land wipes out wildlife habitat, that grain harvesters mince birds and mammals (PDF), and that farmers kill to protect virtually every crop grown in North America. Even local, organic greens and strawberries came to us courtesy of missing forests, smoke-bombed woodchucks, and rifle-shot deer. If farmers had had their way in the late 19th century, deer populations here in the Northeast would have remained at the near-extinction levels to which they had been driven by overhunting and the clearing of forests for agriculture.

Our return to eating local chicken and wild fish was even more unsettling. These creatures had not died as a side effect of agriculture. They had been killed specifically so I could eat them.

So I took up hunting. I needed to take responsibility for at least a few of the deaths that sustained me, to confront that emotional and moral difficulty. I needed to look directly at living, breathing creatures. I couldn't have all the killing done by proxy.

As in my vegan years, I sought a respectful, holistic way of living as a member of the larger-than-human world. Ecologically, venison from local woods made more sense than anything shipped cross-country. Ethically, a truly wild animal made more sense than any creature raised in confinement.

Hunting, of course, is hard for many Americans to swallow.

In part, that's a matter of history. From the Puritans, who saw hunting as a sign of degeneracy in both European nobles and American Indians, to lionized hunters like Daniel Boone and Theodore Roosevelt to our modern stereotype of hunters as reckless rednecks, we have inherited a wildly conflicted legacy.

In part, it's a matter of current events. Some hunters take dangerous shots at unidentified flashes of movement, occasionally resulting in tragedy. Some take marginal shots at animals, with little care for the suffering inflicted or the risk of a slow, painful death.

We are -- and should be -- troubled by such behavior. But we should also see it for what it is: the dark side not just of hunting but of our culture as a whole.

As writer and hunter Ted Kerasote pointed out years ago, recklessness and disrespect are hardly unique to thoughtless hunters. As a society, we engage in all kinds of gratuitously harmful behavior, from drunk driving and factory farming to rapacious development and agricultural practices that cause soil erosion and poison birds by the tens of millions (PDF). Poor hunter conduct -- attributable to the willful actions of individual members of a minority -- serves as a lightning rod for disapproval, but it is not particularly unusual.

In great part, our difficulty with hunting stems from the simple fact that we are disturbed by the killing of animals. Most burger-wolfing Americans don't want to know what happens in slaughterhouses. Most yogurt-scooping vegetarians don't want to know that dairy farming depends on the constant butchering of male calves for veal. As a salad-munching vegan, I didn't want to know about the impacts of agriculture.

Unlike going to the grocery store, the idea of hunting brings us face to face with animal death. Though hunters may go days, weeks, and even years without shooting an animal or bird, we all know that they intend to kill eventually.

Fifteen years ago, I found such voluntary participation unfathomable. In my imagination, I painted hunters with a dark brush. At best, I thought, they must be callous and ignorant. Now, after nearly a decade as a hunter, I think hunting deserves a fair hearing.

Other Americans are concluding the same. As the local food movement grows, vegetarians and omnivores alike are seeking paths to responsible dietary citizenship. Disturbed by the industrialized food system's impacts on humans, other animals, and the wider natural world, many of us are supporting local farmers. Many are planting gardens or raising backyard chickens. And some are taking up rifles, shotguns, and bows.

Though hunting will never provide a substantial portion of our national food supply -- deer hunting, for instance, yields roughly 300 million pounds of venison per year, less than one pound per American (PDF) -- it can be significant for individual families. Four of the past five autumns, I have hiked into the woods with a rifle, waited patiently, killed swiftly, and dragged home 70-100 pounds of healthy, local, sustainable, free-range meat.

Over the past two years, articles on hunting for food have appeared in newspapers and magazines across the country. From New York and Virginia to Arizona and Wisconsin, people are enrolling in classes designed for what I call "adult-onset hunters." Others are learning on their own or getting guidance from lifelong hunters they know personally.

Even if this surge of interest in hunting proves to be a passing trend, it has already begun the important work of busting stereotypes. As more Americans find that hunters exist within their circles of family and friends, hunters are getting harder to pigeonhole. Shattered stereotypes offer us a chance to think and see with greater clarity.

As we continue to reassess our relationships with food and nature, hunting -- like agriculture -- should be examined with a discerning eye. Approached with hubris, it can perpetuate the worst of who we are: humans at our greediest and most careless. Approached with humility, it can encourage the best of who we are: humans at our wisest and most mindful.

Read more: http://ontariohunter.proboards.com/index.cgi?board=Porch&action=display&thread=31523#ixzz1mppwD82V
 
As a teenager, my first hunting trip was with my dad and older brother. My father had the dog bring my first bagged bird to me and made me hold it, feel the heat leave the body and realize that this bird was living only minutes before. It made a big impression on me. My dad was an avid hunter throughout his life until his mid 50's, when he was standing in the woods on Anticosti Island, where the deer were just standing there 50 feet in front of him and his buddies in groups, not running away. He thought, this is not fun any more and never hunted again.

In my mid twenties when my work first took me regularly into the woods, I was shot at twice by hunters mistaking me for was something else. I'm sure some on this BB might think too bad they missed, but maybe there is a God who has a plan for me after all. you will always remember what that sounds is like. I try to do as little as possible in the bush during hunting season in the provinces.

I'm not against hunting, but I leave the hunting to the experts.
 
I've been saying that for years. Meat eaters who don't hunt, are eating animals that have been cruelly treated their entire lives. Hunters, and most hunters are ethical and professional in their killing, take meat in the manner that provides the animal the best overall quality of life up to the time of its death and including the manner of its death (free, un-stressed, in its natural environment).

FWIW I eat both hunted meat and slaughterhouse meat so I don't profess to be any better than anyone else. The comments are directed at meat eaters who disparage hunting.
 
Hunters are such Macho men......
hunter.gif
 
^^^Ohhhh officer Applejack you're such a smart fellow.....
moon.gif
 
killing animals is cruel, you should just get your meat at the grocery store like the rest of us. leave the animals alone.
 
killing animals is cruel, you should just get your meat at the grocery store like the rest of us. leave the animals alone.

People should go to an abattoir or chicken farm. A pneumatic bolt to the head or slicing the skinny throat isn't much different.
 
Despo, thanks for the story. Hunting and fishing are near to my - and my kids - heart. It was an interesting read from someone the made the move to the "dark side".
 
Its legal to hunt trolls 12 months of the year, you know.
i was trying to quote a "fail" pic i saw once but currently can't find from memory. i hunt and use everything i can from the animal and when i still lived near some folk that would use the rest.
 
I have been hunting for almost 20 years.... 85% of the meat in my freezer is wild game, my family eats this game as part of our regular food source.... I hunt for multiple reasons some of which non-hunters will neither accept nor understand... suffice it to say I am a proud and accomplished hunter, both my family and I benefit from this fact... and I make no apologies for it.

carnivorously yours