A Conversation on Sexual Harassment

I don't know if you can say she is trying to do the right thing. I guess her intent, generally speaking, is to spark a conversation between victims and alleged harasser. While that's not necessarily a bad idea, there's a difference between suggesting something offhand as a potential option versus saying whatever she said (the article doesn't say) but she comes across as ignorant, especially since she's herself a victim. I don't think it's a secret that a victim may not feel comfortable around the harasser so directly confronting him is not always a solution.

She's definitely wrong and apologized. Don't know if there's more to it but I think she's put her foot in her mouth.
 
Everyone should have the right to face their accuser, so I at least understand where her comments stem from.
 
When I first read this I was reminded of the phrase "an honest conversation on racism" which I think I heard for the first time back in the 80s. I've been waiting 30 years for that conversation which we can't quite seem to get to.

KK
 
Everyone should have the right to face their accuser, so I at least understand where her comments stem from.

That's a fair point but it's clearly difficult for a victim. If I accuse someone of theft, probably no issue if I'm brought in so the accuser can see me. However, if you are accusing someone of rape/harassment, clearly in many cases the victim will be traumatized. Watch Law and Order, SVU. Many times the victim doesn't want to press charges because they don't want the publicity or the stress of the trial where they will see the accuser, be badgered on the stand, etc.

One could argue to a certain degree that a victim facing the harasser may be therapeutic. One could argue that a victim facing the harasser shows strength of character and that they aren't afraid. But the victim has the choice to do so. Of course, there must be a way to question the victim - they can't just accuse and be done. But if they don't want to face their accuser, a 3rd party would be an intermediary.
 
That's a fair point but it's clearly difficult for a victim. If I accuse someone of theft, probably no issue if I'm brought in so the accuser can see me. However, if you are accusing someone of rape/harassment, clearly in many cases the victim will be traumatized. Watch Law and Order, SVU. Many times the victim doesn't want to press charges because they don't want the publicity or the stress of the trial where they will see the accuser, be badgered on the stand, etc.

I understand that it might be "clearly difficult" for the victim, but we're discussing a crime where the mere accusation is life destroying. If you're dismantling someone's existence I think facing them is the least you can do.

I also have to wonder how many fewer false accusations would occur if it was harder than sitting in a lawyers office telling a good story.

KK
 
I understand that it might be "clearly difficult" for the victim, but we're discussing a crime where the mere accusation is life destroying. If you're dismantling someone's existence I think facing them is the least you can do.

I also have to wonder how many fewer false accusations would occur if it was harder than sitting in a lawyers office telling a good story.

KK

Think of the reverse. How many people get away with it because the trauma was bad enough on the psyche of the victim so she doesn't press charges? There's always going to be a few innocent guys who get accused of something and they either did absolutely nothing or it's grey enough that they probably aren't guilty of anything other than bad judgement. But there are a ton of guilty guys who have the power/influence/money to get away with it. I think another consideration besides the victim being put on the stand is length of trial - if a guy his rich he just pays more to lawyers for extensions, appeals, etc. I'm sure there's a number of victims that look at the pros/cons of pursuing things and decide it's not worth all the trouble.

Again, I don't think the victim is off the hook as far as testimony. Do they need to be paraded out in front of the harasser - no.
 
Think of the reverse. How many people get away with it because the trauma was bad enough on the psyche of the victim so she doesn't press charges? There's always going to be a few innocent guys who get accused of something and they either did absolutely nothing or it's grey enough that they probably aren't guilty of anything other than bad judgement. But there are a ton of guilty guys who have the power/influence/money to get away with it. I think another consideration besides the victim being put on the stand is length of trial - if a guy his rich he just pays more to lawyers for extensions, appeals, etc. I'm sure there's a number of victims that look at the pros/cons of pursuing things and decide it's not worth all the trouble.

Again, I don't think the victim is off the hook as far as testimony. Do they need to be paraded out in front of the harasser - no.


"That it is better 100 guilty persons should escape than that one innocent person should suffer" said Benjamin Franklin, a principle that strongly informed the foundation of the US legal system.

I'm not sure what you mean by "paraded", but do I think my accuser should face me at a time before the damage is irreversible? Yes.

KK