A British Lesson on Auto Bailouts

RTRD

Registered User
Sep 26, 2003
6,003
3
0
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/18/business/economy/18car.html

A British Lesson on Auto Bailouts
By NELSON D. SCHWARTZ
Published: November 17, 2008

PARIS — A faltering auto giant whose brands are synonymous with the open road. Hundreds of thousands of unionized workers with powerful political backers. An urgent plea for the government to write a virtual blank check.

This is not the story of Ford and General Motors, but British Leyland, a car company that went through £11 billion of inflation-adjusted British taxpayer money, or $16.5 billion, in the ’70s and ’80s before going out of business. All that is left of the company now are memories of cars like the Triumph, and a painful lesson in the limited effectiveness of bailouts.

“It’s all too evocative,” said Leon Brittan, a top official in the government of Margaret Thatcher, the free-market-minded prime minister who nevertheless backed the rescue. “I’m not telling the U.S. what to do, but the lessons of the British experience is don’t throw good money after bad. British Leyland carried on for a few more years, but they’re not there now, are they?”

Other experts are sounding the same alarm. “The British Leyland experience is a relevant and cautionary one,” said John Casesa, a principal in the automotive consulting firm Casesa Shapiro Group in New York. “The government got in the business of trying to make a winner out of a structurally flawed company. That’s the risk in the U.S. as well.”

Though Continental automakers have fared better than British ones, Mr. Casesa argues that the long history of government support in Europe made companies like Renault and Fiat strong players in their home markets, but not worldwide.

“With the exception of BMW and Mercedes, European automakers haven’t been globally successful,” he said. “Nor have they been hugely profitable.”

That comparative history is receiving new attention as Congress turns its attention this week to the fate of Detroit.

The British Leyland bailout remains the classic example of a futile government intervention. The tight cooperation between governments and automakers on the Continent has produced happier results.

For half a century after World War II, the French government was the majority stakeholder in Renault, and Paris still holds a 15 percent stake in the company. In the 1980s, the company received a bailout equal to nearly 4 billion euros, or $5.1 billion in today’s money. Now it is highly profitable — at least compared with its American counterparts.

Today, G.M.’s German subsidiary, Opel, is appealing to Berlin for help, seeking more than 1 billion euros in credit guarantees, according to Carl-Peter Forster, G.M.’s European chief.

Monday, Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany said her government would make a decision before Christmas.

“It’s not decided yet whether these loan guarantees will become necessary,” Mrs. Merkel told reporters in Berlin after meeting with Mr. Forster and other management and labor officials.

“If these guarantees become necessary, those funds should remain within Opel” in Germany, she added, echoing a concern some Americans have expressed that any United States bailout money go only to American automakers.

So far, Asian companies have not complained that such a bailout would amount to an anticompetitive subsidy. But José Manuel Barroso, president of the European Commission, said last week that he thought an aid package for Detroit could be “illegal” under World Trade Organization rules.

That has not stopped European automakers from seeking 40 billion euros in loans from the European Investment Bank, ostensibly to help develop cleaner cars.

For Garel Rhys, head of the Center for Automotive Industry Research at Cardiff University in Wales, the trajectory of General Motors is reminiscent of British Leyland not only because of the former’s decision to seek aid to avert bankruptcy, but also for its slow, seemingly inexorable loss of market share. “Both had a history of being the biggest in their market but couldn’t adapt as they lost sales,” he said. “They couldn’t get customers back.”

Historically, British Leyland’s roots stretched back further than Henry Ford’s Model T. The company controlled 36 percent of the British market well into the 1970s, with mass-market brands like Austin and Morris and premium lines like MG and Jaguar. But rising competition from Japanese and German automakers, shoddy workmanship and a breakdown in labor relations brought the company to near bankruptcy by 1975, Mr. Rhys said.

Michael Edwardes, who took over as British Leyland’s chief executive in November 1977, recalled that when he joined, no one even knew whether individual brands were profitable. “It was a farce — no one knew what the costs were,” he said.

As it turned out, every MG the company sold in the United States resulted in a loss of $2,000 for British Leyland.

Wildcat strikes consumed more than 32 million worker-hours in 1977, and the company became a symbol of labor strife, with some employees walking out the door with spark plugs in their coat pockets and engines in the trunks of their cars, Mr. Edwardes said.

Mr. Edwardes immediately began reducing the company’s work force of roughly 200,000 — to 104,000 within five years — and closing 19 factories. He appealed to the Thatcher government for aid, arguing the money was needed if British Leyland was going to be able to afford to lay off workers while investing in new models.

Eventually, the government put up £3.6 billion, equal to £11 billion in today’s money. But the rescue did not do much to preserve British Leyland’s labor force or market share in the long term.

By the time it received its last government infusion of cash in 1988, Mr. Rhys said, British Leyland’s market share had slumped to 15 percent. British Leyland evolved into MG Rover, which was eventually acquired by BMW, then spun off, finally going bankrupt in 2005.

According to Mr. Rhys, just 22,000 workers remain at British Leyland’s successor companies, about 10 percent of its work force in the mid-1970s.

“It was a very poor return,” he said. “We felt collectively and nationally that we got our fingers burnt, and this was always used as a reason to avoid bailouts, both by Labor and Conservative governments in Britain.”

Mr. Edwardes still defends the government aid, arguing it preserved parts of the company that remain in business now — like Jaguar and Land Rover, which were bought by Ford.

Jaguar never made a profit for Ford, however, and was sold with Land Rover to Tata Motors of India earlier this year. Ford recouped only about half of what it paid to acquire the two brands, and is estimated to have poured $10 billion into Jaguar.

Despite the British experience, the case of Renault, which combined fresh money and new management in the 1980s, showed that government bailouts can be beneficial.

The French government help for Renault also came amid increasing losses for the company. But Mr. Rhys said that unlike British Leyland, Renault was able to use the financing to create new car models that were ultimately successful. That, along with tough cost-cutting by a newly installed chairman, cleared the road to profitability by the time the government began privatizing Renault in the 1990s.

If Washington does go ahead and help Detroit, Mr. Edwardes said, it is crucial that the government overhaul the management of the Big Three. “Throwing money at them isn’t enough,” he said. “They need money and they need new management. They need both, not one or the other.”
 
So the lesson is what? We better sell the big 3 to Tata? How about Magna, we might as well sell that off too.
 
If we do this, what do we have bankruptcy laws for?

Bankruptcy laws exist to take overvalued assets away from bad managers, de-value them to their proper worth, and put them in the hands of good managers.

Why are so many people opposed to this?

There is still a market for cars, and someone will have to build and sell them.
 
If British car makers go under so will the oil companys.

The lost revenue of replacing oil leaking on driveways will cripple big Oil.
 
A down turn in the market like this will shake the well managed companies from the poor run companies, this is darwnism at its best, the times of having one profession or working for one employer for your entire working carreer are over.

Let the automakers come to Washington every 3 months for their nest check and everytime make them present thier plan and everytime vote one off like survivor, Make it a reality show, ibeat it will have the highest ratings.

jmho
 
lookingforitallthetime said:
If British car makers go under so will the oil companys.

The lost revenue of replacing oil leaking on driveways will cripple big Oil.


I hope you are being sarcastic
If car makers go under there is always someone else to replace their sales
GM, Ford & Chrysler could all go down & Exxon would not lose a beat
There would be temporary economic fall out from the big three collapse that would probably lower oil prices, however in the long term the price would stabilize
 
Sukdeep said:
The lesseon is no bailout. Let capitalism run its course.

As for selling losers, why not?
Interesting why those wonderful principals of capitalism are not applied to the financial industry.
 
Meister said:
Interesting why those wonderful principals of capitalism are not applied to the financial industry.

Depends on whether you're talking about Canada or the US.

So far, in Canada, all that has happened is that the government has assumed a number of low risk loans (mortgages, etc), thereby freeing up capital in the banks so that there isn't a shortage of money to lend. In effect, the government has become engaged in a low risk investment. It isn't (not yet, anyway) "throwing good money after bad", like it would be to provide funding to the auto industry.

It's yet to be seen what the design of the US financial package will be.
 
Bud Plug said:
Depends on whether you're talking about Canada or the US.

So far, in Canada, all that has happened is that the government has assumed a number of low risk loans (mortgages, etc), thereby freeing up capital in the banks so that there isn't a shortage of money to lend. In effect, the government has become engaged in a low risk investment. It isn't (not yet, anyway) "throwing good money after bad", like it would be to provide funding to the auto industry.

It's yet to be seen what the design of the US financial package will be.
Why should my taxpayer's money assume any mortgages in Canada or the US? If Joe Forklift can't afford his house that is not my problem. Where is my bailout? Let the friggin family move to a run down apartment in Brampton or Detroit and start over again. It's their bloody fault for assuming too much debt, car loans, credit cards..... And, why should I pay for the financial weasels at the top of the financial industry who got us into this mess in the first place.

While the above is not entirely my opinion I am pointing out that you can't selectively apply capitalism. There are a lot of financial guys on this board and they always advocate let free market take its course with GM. But protecting the financial industry is somehow supposed to be essential for America.
Bunch of hypocrites.
 
Meister said:
Why should my taxpayer's money assume any mortgages in Canada or the US? If Joe Forklift can't afford his house that is not my problem. Where is my bailout? Let the friggin family move to a run down apartment in Brampton or Detroit and start over again. It's their bloody fault for assuming too much debt, car loans, credit cards..... And, why should I pay for the financial weasels at the top of the financial industry who got us into this mess in the first place.

While the above is not entirely my opinion I am pointing out that you can't selectively apply capitalism. There are a lot of financial guys on this board and they always advocate let free market take its course with GM. But protecting the financial industry is somehow supposed to be essential for America.
Bunch of hypocrites.

I think you misunderstood. The mortgages in Canada are good. The government investment will be repaid, with interest. It is an investment. Usually, the Canadian government is spending your money on crap that produces nothing of value for you. In this case, the interest revenue actually offsets your tax liability.

No one can say what the Feds have in mind in the U.S. The Fanny Mae, Freddy Mac mortgages were bad mortgages. The banks were not going to be repaid, and neither will the US government if it takes them over. I'm not sure what they intend to do with other elements of the financial sector.
 
Bud Plug said:
I think you misunderstood. The mortgages in Canada are good. The government investment will be repaid, with interest. It is an investment. Usually, the Canadian government is spending your money on crap that produces nothing of value for you. In this case, the interest revenue actually offsets your tax liability.

No one can say what the Feds have in mind in the U.S. The Fanny Mae, Freddy Mac mortgages were bad mortgages. The banks were not going to be repaid, and neither will the US government if it takes them over. I'm not sure what they intend to do with other elements of the financial sector.
btw, I'm mostly talking about the US.
So, pumping 400000 dollars into a house that is now worth 250000 is a good investment. Well, carry on then.
 
I actually own a Triumph TR6.

It's worth more than I paid for it and it's not depreciating (other than due to market forces.)

It's a great fucking car. More fun than a barrel of monkies. Easy to fix, cheap to fix, and I love driving it on a nice summer's evening. I always get people coming up to me commenting on it (Usually, "I used to own a Triumph, but then I made the mistake of my life and I sold it when I got married...")

If I had my way, I'd own a TR250 as well, and an E type Jag (Series I).

I love the old British stuff.

Looking at BL and the North American industries, there are similarities, however, the Brits really got caught with their pants down because for too long they weren't keeping up with changes in technology. For example, the 76 TR6 was largely based on early 50's technology (as were most British cars - other than the Mini, which was quite a revolutionary car really - First production car featuring front wheel drive with a transverse engine.) Most British cars were brutally primative - even for the day. I really can't say that North American cars are on the same scale of lagging behind the Japanese as the British were in the 70's.

The North Americans have largely been keeping up with the technology, both in production and in the cars themselves, however, they are producing terrible quality cars and they are definitely poorly managed.

BL made some great classic cars, unfortunately, the great cars that they made - MG, Triumph, Healy, Jags, were generally not good for day to day drivers and they sucked in the winter. As far as I am aware, the Rovers, and Austin Marinas which were supposed to be day to day drivers were huge pieces of shit. So in the end, BL didn't have a car that they could market as a solid day to day driver. (Like the Honda Civic for example with to me personifies the perfect day to day driver. BL didn't have their own Honda Civic (though, ironically, the original civics were clones of the Austin Mini. Honda Engineers were often trained at BL even.)

To me, success in the Automotive Industry comes down to who has the best Engineering and Design. If you have crappy engineering, you're done.

BTW, the Triumph name is currently owned by BMW. They bought the rights to Mini and to Triumph. I see a LOT of minis running around town. Someday, I hope to see a TR9.
 
Meister said:
btw, I'm mostly talking about the US.
So, pumping 400000 dollars into a house that is now worth 250000 is a good investment. Well, carry on then.

You're definitely right about the US proposal. It is a true "bailout" as far as the mortgage issue is concerned.
 
The other problem with the North American industry is simply too much capacity.

Realistically, GM and Ford could easily make a profit if they reduced their size. I don't think that they will be able to ever get back on top.

Simply put, there's too many people making too many cars for too few buyers and something has to give.

The thing that we arm chair Automotive Engineers sometimes forget that all this is a boon for the consumer. If the auto industry ever consolidated and rationalized, we'd be paying a LOT more for our vehicles.

Scary thoughts.
 
JohnLarue said:
I hope you are being sarcastic
If car makers go under there is always someone else to replace their sales
GM, Ford & Chrysler could all go down & Exxon would not lose a beat
There would be temporary economic fall out from the big three collapse that would probably lower oil prices, however in the long term the price would stabilize

I think you missed the joke but I will admit the delivery could have been better.

In all honesty I was throwing out a line for LancsLad but he wasn't biting.