5th November Bonfire Night

That's rights- they saw it as a way to demonize catholics and to gain more power
No, the plotters saw themselves as "the people who are right," and victims (as if the actions [gratuitous insults] of Pope Pius V, hadn't sealed the idea in the English mind of Recacitrantism and disloyalty as being linked).

For twelve years prior to the publication of the Bull Regnans in Excelsis in 1570 English Roman Catholics had been subject to fines but no one had been executed or even imprisoned for long periods. It was Regnans in Excelisis with its statements that it was the duty of Roman Catholics to overthrow the Queen later modified to it was their duty to support an invasion, which changed Recacitrants into traitors.
 
Come back May 29 and we can celebrate Oak Apple Day (Restoration Day).

I'll pass, I have no love for either the British Royals nor The Papacy.

Guy Fawkes and Giordano Bruno were executed within six years of each other. Both perished for what they believed in. The Pope resisted Italian Unification for over 300 years during which the nations went from Renaissance leader to an irrelevant doormat. When Unification finally came the Pope went into self-imposed exile. There were those within the movement who wanted the Pope moved to Jerusalem, but eventually the Royalists won out. In 1889 the Freemasons of Rome flipped the Papacy the bird by erecting a statue at the Campo di Fiori, where Giordano Bruno was immolated. In 2008, Berlin erected their own monument to Bruno at Potsdamer Platz.

http://www.romanhomes.com/your_roman_vacation/quarters/navona-campo-fiori-quarter.htm
 
The Pope resisted Italian Unification for over 300 years during which the nations went from Renaissance leader to an irrelevant doormat. When Unification finally came the Pope went into self-imposed exile.
"A Free Church in a Free State" to quote Count Cavour.


Lord Macaulay (the British Politician and Historian) had written of the Papal States three decades before, that a system where the government and legal establishment were run by celibate clerics had lead to a state where: "Corruption infects all the public offices. . . . The States of the Pope are, I suppose, the worst governed in the civilized world; and. . . . the venality of public servants. . . force themselves on the observation of the most heedless traveler."
 
There was strong support for expelling the Pope from Italy. Among those in favour were Joe Green (Verdi), Joe Pyle (Mazzini) and Commendatore Garibaldi. Unfortunately Cavour argued successfully that expulsion would destabilize the new nation. It's not surprising that the Pope ended his exile during the dictatorship of Il Pucurone (Mussolini).

...a pucurone is what you get when a moron fucks a donkey.

A beautiful woman discussing such a horrid topic:

 
Burning crosses...not sure that's a festival I would want to attend.

Too much sectarianism, it trivializes why Guy Fawkes and his conspirators were driven to do what they nearly did.

The one event that Italy has never recovered from:

 
Burning crosses...not sure that's a festival I would want to attend.

Too much sectarianism, it trivializes why Guy Fawkes and his conspirators were driven to do what they nearly did.

The one event that Italy has never recovered from:


Didn't they say, 'oops we're sorry, you're no longer a heretic' in 2008
 
Were driven? Talk of sectarianism.

Exactly Aardie, the 17th Century was a clawback of the gains made during during The Renaissance. Catholic persecution in Britain, Cardinal Richelieu repealing The Edict of Nantes in France culminating with The Thirty Years War, the bloodiest European war prior to WW I. And all for the sake of voodoo.

The delicious irony of all this is that Great Britian's greatest composer was a devout Catholic: Edwar Elgar.

 
Henry 8th created the Church of England, with himself as spiritual head, because the Pope would not grant him a divorce against his wife of 20yrs, Catherine of Aragon.
This conveniently ignores the fact that Henry wanted to divorce Catharine because she could not provide him with a male heir that would secure the Tudor dynasty. Henry and Catherine had been ineligible to marry because Catherine was Henry's elder brother's widow (that's a no-no... look it up), but the pope granted a special dispensation because England and Spain wanted to maintain their political marriage. From the perspective of many religious people of the time including Henry, Catherine's small army of miscarried and stillborn children were pretty conclusive evidence that God disapproved of the pope's decision to allow the couple to marry in the first place. The bottom line is, the pope waived the rules originally for political reasons, and he declined to dissolve the marriage for equally political reasons. Getting rid of the influence of foreign powers was an eminently sensible decision, and dissolving the marriage was perfectly in line with the religious sensibilities of the day. Henry VIII was right, Clement VII was wrong, end of story.

It's also worth remembering that for most of Henry's reign, the Church of England remained largely Catholic in religious character. It wasn't a Protestant church in the continental sense until the reign of Edward VI.

M1 died 1558 without a direct heir. Now, again, the first nine in succession were women. The strongest claimant by birth etc was Mary, Queen of Scots. However, she was also catholic, and the various powers in the land (not just parliament) saw to it that Elizabeth was crowned.
As has already been pointed out, this is factually completely incorrect. Mary Stuart's claim was the strongest only if you believed the nonsense that Elizabeth was illegitimate.

At the end of the day, Giordano Bruno died for his beliefs but Guy Fawkes was executed because he was a terrorist who conspired to blow up Parliament and murder the king. Fawkes' motives and religious beliefs are entirely secondary to that simple fact. The two men are not the same at all.

EDIT: Lest anyone think I'm arguing this for religious reasons, I'm about as religious as Richard Dawkins (albeit I'm much less shrill about it). My perspective is strictly a historical and political one.
 
Exactly Aardie, the 17th Century was a clawback of the gains made during during The Renaissance. Catholic persecution in Britain, Cardinal Richelieu repealing The Edict of Nantes in France culminating with The Thirty Years War, the bloodiest European war prior to WW I. And all for the sake of voodoo.

The delicious irony of all this is that Great Britian's greatest composer was a devout Catholic: Edwar Elgar.

There is a certain irony a century later to the lyrics of "Land of Hope and Glory" which were written at close to the apex of the second British Empire.
 
There is a mini-series from 2004 called Gunpowder, Plot ,Treason available for viewing on YouTube. I won't bother posting it since it's historically inaccurate. It's been getting attention since Michael Fassbender plays Guy Fawkes - his part in the show is accurate. In The Tower documentary it was suggested that Guy Fawkes was a pawn in the conspiracy and a mystery man, complete nonsense! He may not have been the leader of the conspiracy but he was crucial to the execution of the plot. Also, he was a religious mercenary fighting for Spain in Holland. His specialty was siege ballistics, you can be certain that English spies were keeping track of his whereabouts. They knew that when he eventually returned home he was going to be trouble. This is pure speculation but somehow he gave them the slip, possibly by faking his death. He did return to England as John Johnson.