5 drinks in a sitting is binge drinking?

Malibook

New member
Nov 16, 2001
4,611
2
0
Paradise
www.yourtraveltickets.com
Maybe 5 drinks in an hour but a sitting could be several hours and 5 drinks in not much for most drinkers.


Canada must curb binge drinking, doctors urge

Canada needs to develop a national strategy to deal with its out-of-control binge drinking, argues the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

Binge drinking — especially among youth — is on the rise in Canada and is increasing adverse health risks for the nation, doctors Ken Flegel, Noni MacDonald and Paul Hebert say in an editorial published in the CMAJ, a leading medical journal.

Binge drinking is consuming five or more drinks in one sitting.


No one wants to live in a nanny state, the authors say, but it's time for Canada to wake up. The guest editorial argues Canada's drinking habits are placing a heavy burden on the health system.

About 9% of Canadians have reported binge drinking regularly over the past five years, according to CMAJ statistics. Most of the binge drinkers were young men aged 15 to 24.

On a global level, up to 90% of men and 65% of women report binge drinking at least once a year.

Alcohol use is the third greatest contributor to global disease, the authors say, and is the cause of about 3.8% of all deaths.

Binge drinking increases the risk of unsafe sex, rape, violence, injuries and even death, the doctors argue.

"Given the many stakeholders involved in the sale and consumption of alcohol, we need a national strategy for controlling overall alcohol use," the authors say.

The strategy must include public health agencies, the hospitality industry, liquor manufacturers and control boards and municipalities, the editorial argues.

The authors suggest increasing the minimum price of an alcoholic drink and eliminating happy hours to help curb binges.

"It seems obvious that happy hour promotes heavy alcohol use in price-sensitive people such as college students and the socially disadvantaged," the editorial says. "It also propagates the message that binge drinking is socially acceptable."

Advertising should likely also be restricted, the authors say.

Better information must also be presented to children and young people about the serious loss of self-control and the other risks involved with binge drinking, the authors add.

Health-care professionals also need to more actively ask their patients about their drinking habits — especially young people — the editorial says.

http://www.torontosun.com/life/healthandfitness/2011/01/18/16931476.html
 
I agree. But it's not really a problem unless you're doing it on a regular basis.

e.g., having 5+ drinks at New Years is one thing, but having 5+ drinks every weekend is quite another...
 
I dont know, but my generation goes hard on weekends. 5+ drinks doesn't even constitute as a pre drink for us before we go out to a bar. And no, none of us get involved in violence, rape, or anything illegal. Times have changed, this is life, and this is normal.
 
I can go out and drink 12 to 15 beers like nothing on a night out, I never drive, or cause trouble, but have been told that I am more lively and funny. never been a problem for me.
 
The gruesome details just keep getting worse. They have also found that binge drinking causes permanent brain damage in teens. Reduced memory, reduced attention span. I found this info rather disturbing.

"The magnitude of the difference is 10 percent. I like to think of it as the difference between an A and a B."

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=122765890

Unfortunately, this is serious stuff. You can laugh it off, but it will catch up with you eventually.
 
man I went pretty hard when I was in my late teens and early 20s. Lots of mornings I had a reduced memory.

seriously though, what does it matter if someone wants to drink a bunch on the weekend at home, who else is being harmed?
 
I dont know, but my generation goes hard on weekends. 5+ drinks doesn't even constitute as a pre drink for us before we go out to a bar. And no, none of us get involved in violence, rape, or anything illegal. Times have changed, this is life, and this is normal.

Lol! "My generation". Ya drinking never existed until 1987!
 
It says 5 and up, I think that's a pretty good number to define a lot of drinks in one evening. It's silly to drink to unconsciousness, that indicates a serious problem but I'm into drinking until I sound good at karaoke once in awhile.

Cheers!
 
Is 12 bottles (330ml) in 8 hours binge drinking?

By the above metric, yes.

Hmph, turns out I 'binge drink' pretty much every time I go out for more than 'just supper'. Who knew? :) I never lose time, pass out, need to be carried, don't drive, or get aggressive / violent. I can get a little annoying (well, more than usual), but that's not even until about 'bottled beer #10'. Hell, I'm not even hung over from that. Over a 12ish hour period I can drink a heck of a lot of beer. If I start layering in shots or shooters, or mixing in wine, things can get away from me, but I've always been good at self regulating, and maintaining a 'good drunk' without passing out or praying for death the next day. Amateurs.
 
I don't know if this should piss me off or alarm me.

FYI a bottle of wine or a 60 oz pitcher of beer or 3 20 oz pints count as 5 drinks. While that's a little more than I would normally drink in an evening (half bottle of wine is more usual) I wouldn't have called it excessive. At the end of a 5 drink evening my mind would be sharp, my mood benign, my speech clear and un-slurred, and I'd be able to walk a straight line, touch my nose with my eyes closed, etc etc. I wouldn't drive but if I did I would expect to be fully conscious, cautious and basically ok for a short drive - though not legal. (BTW the calculator I checked suggests that much alcohol would put my close to .08 blood alcohol - the high end of the 'warn' range so not driving is a good policy.)

After such an evening I would expect to feel fine the next day.

This is a binge???? Come on!
 
I declare bullshit.
Binge drinking on a regular basis (daily) equal alcoholism.
Periodically (monthly) tying one on certainly relieves stress.
Personally I could be classified as an alcoholic because I drink on a daily basis (1 or 2 drinks a day)

(I am waiting on a report on the dangers of laughing and enjoying yourself. Soon we will be farking quakers)
 
OK I will get flamed for being an old fart, but, research clearly shows the effects of alcohol on our bodies, especially liver, kidneys and brain. Hard to get past the facts, that's the end point. "You can't have opinions about truth"

Treat your bodies with respect, you can't get another one.

OK time for some healthy exercise - who shall I go see?

Dougie
a healthy old fart who enjoys a good drink
 
You guys seem to think this is a moral judgment....it's a medical opinion or review.

So if you can find better science that says it's not "binge drinking"...more power to you.
 
You guys seem to think this is a moral judgment....it's a medical opinion or review.

So if you can find better science that says it's not "binge drinking"...more power to you.

Not to speak for others, but I think it's the rather arbitrary (seeming) nature of the definition. It's kind of like a woman saying she has 'lots of shoes' when she has 5 pairs. I think most people associate 'a binge drinker' with somebody who consumed so much in one sitting that the lose time, are falling down, end up sick, or pass out, as opposed to drinking 3 bar pints.
 
You guys seem to think this is a moral judgment....it's a medical opinion or review.

So if you can find better science that says it's not "binge drinking"...more power to you.

I didn't view this as a moral issue, but as a question of misusing language.

With respect, 'science' doesn't say it's binge drinking. Some individuals have chosen to use the term. In my view, incorrectly. Certainly having 5 drinks in an evening is not considered binge-drinking in my circle, which includes more than a few doctors, university professors, and other professionals.

As to what medical science has to say about drinking - the message is mixed. For the most part drinking is good for cholesterol, bad for the liver & often bad for blood pressure (though I have one acquaintance whose blood pressure went down when he drank). When it comes to an individual's health then individual characteristics have to be taken into account. To this point I'm in above average health, and my above average drinking doesn't seem to have had ill consequences. Might even have contributed to it. Certainly my doctor's advice has been 'just keep on doing whatever it is you're doing'. Always nice to hear that.