40 pin vs 80 pin IDE cables

bsi

New member
May 19, 2006
959
0
0
I have an older computer to repair where the hard drive died. When I opened it up, it had the old 40 pin IDE cables inside.

I went to replace it with 80 pin cable (along with an HD) but the MB won't accept that cable. The female part of the 80 pin cable has one pin blocked out but there is no corresponding missing pin on the MB.

So, I need to know the difference. Is it "only" performance if I leave the 40 pin cable in place but put a new 250G hard drive in there? The old drive was 40G. I know there might be BIOS issues as well but my first concern is figuring out whether I must change to 80 pin to use newer hard drives.

I suppose I could drill out the blocked part of the 80 pin cable but I am sure it is blocked out for a reason.

There must be a straightforward answer for this. If it is only performance then I will use the 40 pin cable with the 250M drive but if corruption is an issue then I will have to hunt around for an older small drive like the original one. Or unless you guys generally recommend drilling out the blocked hole.

Thanks folks.

PS, I have about 6 of these machines in service doing low level tasks. I am not going to spend a mountain of time or resources on them but I am not rushing out to replace them if there is a simple solution. That is why I am looking for a workaround rather than just scrapping it.
 
bsi said:
I have an older computer to repair where the hard drive died. When I opened it up, it had the old 40 pin IDE cables inside.

I went to replace it with 80 pin cable (along with an HD) but the MB won't accept that cable. The female part of the 80 pin cable has one pin blocked out but there is no corresponding missing pin on the MB.

So, I need to know the difference. Is it "only" performance if I leave the 40 pin cable in place but put a new 250G hard drive in there? The old drive was 40G. I know there might be BIOS issues as well but my first concern is figuring out whether I must change to 80 pin to use newer hard drives.

I suppose I could drill out the blocked part of the 80 pin cable but I am sure it is blocked out for a reason.

There must be a straightforward answer for this. If it is only performance then I will use the 40 pin cable with the 250M drive but if corruption is an issue then I will have to hunt around for an older small drive like the original one. Or unless you guys generally recommend drilling out the blocked hole.

Thanks folks.

PS, I have about 6 of these machines in service doing low level tasks. I am not going to spend a mountain of time or resources on them but I am not rushing out to replace them if there is a simple solution. That is why I am looking for a workaround rather than just scrapping it.

As I recall, the 80 pin cables have an extra ground wire for each signal pin that reduces noise (crosstalk) and so allows data transfer to occur at about twice the rate of the 40 pin cables IF THE DRIVE SUPPORTS IT which all modern drives do. Most 80 pin cables have blue coloured connectors vs grey for the 40 pin cables. Both cables fit their respective connectors.

A 40 pin cable will work with modern drives but the drives will just downgrade their performance to the slower transfer rate to suit the inferior cable.

Note that the motherboard is also restricted by hardware and BIOS to the slower speeds so nothing would be gained by trying to force an 80 pin cable into a 40 pin slot.

A good procedure is to get ahold of a disk diagnostic program (Maxtor had a downloadable one at one point for their hard drives - I think they're part of Seagate now) and run that with your new setup to verify all's well. Check the drive manufacturer's web site.
 
I assume you've googled? Looks like some useful info out in the wild (e.g. select the links on that page for "Standard" and "Ultra DMA" IDE/ATA Cables).
 
Anynym said:
I assume you've googled? Looks like some useful info out in the wild (e.g. select the links on that page for "Standard" and "Ultra DMA" IDE/ATA Cables).

Those are good links. I googled "ide 40 vs 80 pin" and got some of the same articles but they talked mostly about CD and DVD drives.

I can now see that the only issue appears to be potential performance which is not a concern for me.

Thanks for the feedback. This is a great group.
 
asn said:
dont be surprised if your MB doesnt recognize the new HD as being 250GB is size.
This is a good point.
How old is your PC?
I upgraded my 11 yr old Gateway Pent2 a couple years ago when I put XP in.
It had a 8GB HDD and putting XP and all the updates filled that little drive up. I phoned Gateway and was told it's OK to put in up to a 120-160GB HDD with no problems. They said if you want more room use an Ext HDD that is plugged in with USB 2.0 cables. So I got a 120GB drive and it came with the newer IDE ribbon cable which performed better than the original ribbon cable. It still runs great and like new and faster because the old drive was 5400rpm while the new drive runs at 7200rpm.
This old PC now runs XP PRO and Ubuntu 8.04 great.