#4

Canada and the United States have different ways of counting what makes up a city and the surrounding areas.

Whatever is said about Toronto in this thread, the FACT IS, under the current form of census the city of Toronto has passed the city of Chicago.
 
So there's no incentive for them to put a winning team on the ice. That costs more... and is therefore counterproductive for the shareholders.

Oh goodie The stupid statement makes an appearence in the Lounge.

If it were true then Liles and Komisarek would be playing, Tim Connolly would not be in the minors and a bunch of players who are pulling their weight, keeping the Leafs in a playoff spot, would be doing so for the AHL Toronto Marlies.
 
Oh goodie The stupid statement makes an appearence in the Lounge.

If it were true then Liles and Komisarek would be playing, Tim Connolly would not be in the minors and a bunch of players who are pulling their weight, keeping the Leafs in a playoff spot, would be doing so for the AHL Toronto Marlies.

Please stay on the topic of the thread.
 
In terms of livability Toronto is way up there, comparable to Chicago in almost every category, winning some and losing others
I very much like Toronto the ROM and the zoo among other things are both world class. However, Toronto has nothing to hold a candle to the Art Institute of Chicago.
 
You can't talk "metropolitan areas" when looking at the population of cities. Suburban areas are suburbs. Who knows where you start counting and where you stop.

You have to compare proper populations of city proper.

In that number, Toronto has moved ahead of Chicago and will never look back. Chicago is a fine city, but Toronto out-classes it in every respect.

Look out NYC - here we come.

As if there was some huge electric fence around Highway 427, Steeles Ave, and Port Union Road??
The truth is that large cities are now metropolitan areas....I find it ridiculous that we stop counting at the Pickering border as if everything changes once we get there. Toronto's population should really be much more than it is...and should easily encompass places like Oakville, and Ajax. Is Burlington a Toronto suburb or Hamilton suburb? Doesn't matter anymore. Chicago's metro area population is still much more than Toronto's. For those to doubt that should try getting from one end to the other by driving in Chicago..could be 3 hours in rush hour.
 
To be honest...Toronto is a better place to live...and Chicago is a much better place to visit and enjoy.
 
Only a city with an inferiority complex like Toronto would get caught up in a debate to be the 4th largest city in North America. Toronto...always trying to be New York...you cares, big cities bring smog, crime, and bad traffic
 
Only a city with an inferiority complex like Toronto would get caught up in a debate to be the 4th largest city in North America. Toronto...always trying to be New York...you cares, big cities bring smog, crime, and bad traffic

Now that's funny.....

OTB
 
Only a city with an inferiority complex like Toronto would get caught up in a debate to be the 4th largest city in North America. Toronto...always trying to be New York...you cares, big cities bring smog, crime, and bad traffic

Quickest way out of town ...
by car any of the 400 series highways.
by air go to Pearson.
by train go to Union Station.
by bus the station at Bay and Dundas is one of several places you can catch the bus.
 
Only a city with an inferiority complex like Toronto would get caught up in a debate to be the 4th largest city in North America. Toronto...always trying to be New York...you cares, big cities bring smog, crime, and bad traffic

Toronto will never be New York. New York is the premiere city in a nation of 310+ million people. Toronto is the premiere city in a nation of 34 million people. There's a well known equation that relates the size of a city to the population base it's drawn on--Canada simply is not big enough to produce a New York. To some extent, what a city is capable of in terms of "world class" cultural and financial achievements is a product of a size--New York has three times as many people to leverage for taxation and for workforce, and simply outproduces Toronto.

We are however apparently big enough to outpace Chicago, though in part that will be because the influence of New York is so large that even as far from it as Chicago is, New York sucks cultural/financial interests out of Chicago and every other major American city within a day's drive of New York. Who would want to be the leading fashion designer in Chicago, if instead you could be the leading fashion designer in New York? That is the influence of New York, and why cities scale up the way they do. The "top" cultural/culinary/artistic people in Chicago stick around there because they like being a big fish in a small pond, versus competing in New York.

In Toronto that is true to some extent, but there's a national pride element -- not every Canadian is willing to abandon their citizenship for another country, though some are. That gives Toronto an edge over Chicago that the windy city simply will never match.

But we will never have such an edge over New York. Certainly on things like livability, we can win--but when it comes to producing world class cultural icons we are simply 1/3rd the size.
 
Toronto will never be New York. New York is the premiere city in a nation of 310+ million people. Toronto is the premiere city in a nation of 34 million people. There's a well known equation that relates the size of a city to the population base it's drawn on--Canada simply is not big enough to produce a New York. To some extent, what a city is capable of in terms of "world class" cultural and financial achievements is a product of a size--New York has three times as many people to leverage for taxation and for workforce, and simply outproduces Toronto.

We are however apparently big enough to outpace Chicago, though in part that will be because the influence of New York is so large that even as far from it as Chicago is, New York sucks cultural/financial interests out of Chicago and every other major American city within a day's drive of New York. Who would want to be the leading fashion designer in Chicago, if instead you could be the leading fashion designer in New York? That is the influence of New York, and why cities scale up the way they do.

It's not even Chicago really... look at the metro area 9.4m (2011) while Toronto is 5.6m (2011) - that's about 60% of Chicago... all your explanations above about NYC explain why Toronto is no where near Chicago on the "world class" scale.

OTB
 
It's not even Chicago really... look at the metro area 9.4m (2011) while Toronto is 5.6m (2011) - that's about 60% of Chicago... all your explanations above about NYC explain why Toronto is no where near Chicago on the "world class" scale.

OTB

As James pointed out, that really just depends on where you draw the line. You could amalgamate a few more cities into "GTA" and produce a larger population. There are about 12 million people in Southern Ontario most of whom are essentially within the sphere of Toronto. If you wanted to look at how broad the city is rather than how tall it is, you would want to compare the total populations served by the commuter rails and highway systems into each city.

However the breadth of a city is reasonably associated with its height, so looking at the number of skyscrapers or the size of the core urban population is a reasonable estimate of the total size of the city.
 
As James pointed out, that really just depends on where you draw the line. You could amalgamate a few more cities into "GTA" and produce a larger population. There are about 12 million people in Southern Ontario most of whom are essentially within the sphere of Toronto. If you wanted to look at how broad the city is rather than how tall it is, you would want to compare the total populations served by the commuter rails and highway systems into each city.

However the breadth of a city is reasonably associated with its height, so looking at the number of skyscrapers or the size of the core urban population is a reasonable estimate of the total size of the city.

A census metro area is a pretty standard measure... I spend quite a bit of time in both cities, business in Toronto, family in Chicago - they are simply not comparable. The GDP ranking I posed earlier should point that out. In any case, as bobbyhullfan points out, both great cities, the only "real" mid-west cities.

Where I disagree with bobby is on NYC - that city ROCKS, the only other city as impressive is London. LA - meh, I prefer San Fran over LA any day.

OTB
 
Toronto can only hope to aspire to what Chicago has achieved. Amazing public spaces, world class museums, incredible architecture, the best jazz north of New Orleans, the best urban shopping outside of Rome, and a city pride that says "can do"! I love my adopted TO but it could do with more than a dash of Chicago spirit.

Chicago is a much "World Class"-ier city in Toronto in many respects. The waterfront is amazing unlike Toronto's that's nothing but a broken down highway and a bunch of condos. Of course we need to have a Great Fire to achieve the same waterfront as most of the waterfront parks in Chicago are built on rubble from the fire that was plowed into the lake.

When I worked there briefly, murders didn't even make the news since (to quote a local) "It's just gang-bangers killing each other. The more, the better..". There are entire areas if Chicago that no sane person would consider entering at night, or even the daytime...

IMHO Chicago is a fantastic city... as long as you have money. It's very representative of the US...
 
Quickest way out of town ...
by car any of the 400 series highways.
by air go to Pearson.
by train go to Union Station.
by bus the station at Bay and Dundas is one of several places you can catch the bus.

This is likely the finest feature of toronto....different ways to get the fuck out as quickly as possible...except any weekday after 2:30 in the afternoon and particularly any friday of a long weekend when everyone bails
 
Toronto is completely different and far nicer than Chicago. Outside of the Mile and the Gold Coast, Chicago does not have a viable downtown core. The 2 above mentioned affluent areas are surrounded by a large moat of Inner City. there is little or no viable night life in chi's downtown. You have to travel out to the burbs to find bars, restaurants and clubs.

A lot of chi is rust belt with crumbling buildings and infrastructure and abandoned cars. Not to mention the large areas that are genuine ghetto with mega crime rate and a virtually segregated population.

Chicago is probably still demographically larger than TO. The issue is where do suburbs stop being suburbs and become different urban areas as all major North American cities now spread for dozens of miles outside their political borders. OTOH, Toronto is expanding at a vastly faster rate and will eventually overtake Chi at about the time where the DVP becomes COMPLETELY undriveable 18 hours a day, instead of just 4 - and who wants that anyway.
 
Toronto is completely different and far nicer than Chicago. Outside of the Mile and the Gold Coast, Chicago does not have a viable downtown core. The 2 above mentioned affluent areas are surrounded by a large moat of Inner City. there is little or no viable night life in chi's downtown. You have to travel out to the burbs to find bars, restaurants and clubs.

A lot of chi is rust belt with crumbling buildings and infrastructure and abandoned cars. Not to mention the large areas that are genuine ghetto with mega crime rate and a virtually segregated population.

Chicago is probably still demographically larger than TO. The issue is where do suburbs stop being suburbs and become different urban areas as all major North American cities now spread for dozens of miles outside their political borders. OTOH, Toronto is expanding at a vastly faster rate and will eventually overtake Chi at about the time where the DVP becomes COMPLETELY undriveable 18 hours a day, instead of just 4 - and who wants that anyway.

This is funny, the nightlife in Chicago - downtown nightlife far outpaces Toronto... you guys breath too much of your own frozen air....

OTB