26-Year Secret Kept

Thus the reason some lawyers don't want to know and they never ask their client if in fact they did the crime.

A lawyer does not HAVE to take the case. He can decline the case if it hasn't gone to trail yet-even during the trail he could have a private meeting with the judge and say he choses not be on the case anymore for private reasons. It be up to the judge if the lawyer can quit but then a new trial would be needed-that cost $$$ so its best for the lawyer to get off the case before the trail starts.

This is why it raises people interest when a lawyer quits a case, people wounder if the lawyer knows the client is guilty. Theres many other reasons lawyers decline a case even if the person has lots of money. Some defense lawyers don't handle cases of rape because they don't like being hard on a lady whos claims a rape even if it my not have really been a rape--maybe she did agree and afterwards had second thoughts. The guy tells her about Terb :p
 
Quest4Less said:
This is "justice" - and the ONLY thing that should matter. To hell with privilidge - JUSTICE should trump all else.

A lawyer could still argue extenuating circumstances - but no way should they help a guilty person get off.

If this were true, the defense lawyers would be in effect judging the defendant! You would then have taken away the democritising element of the jury.

In this case it wasn't these lawyers who screwed up.

It was the police and prosecution who didn't investigate enough and the other defense lawyers who didn't put up a good enough defense. You are blaming the wrong people...
 
red said:
they can't go to the judge and say we have information that this guy is innocent? if this is the law then the law is wrong.

They cannot go to a judge and say that the innocent guy didn't do it cause the judge would need to know what evidence they have. They would then have to say that their client confessed and they would be violating solicitor-client privilege. They would have been dis-barred by the Law Society and never be allowed to practice law again.

Solicitor-client privilege exists so a client can confide in his or her lawyer so the lawyer has all the facts when preparing a defense. Anything communicated between a lawyer and a client for the purposes of seeking/giving legal advise and/or preparing for trial falls under the privilege and cannot be divluged by the lawyer for any reason at any point in time. The lawyer must literally take this information to his grave with him.

The privilege is an intergral part in maintaining a person's fundamental right to a fair trial and fair representation. To remove the privilege is to create a flaw in a fair and democratic justice system.

Is it messed up? Oh yeah... I know a couple of people who are or have been defense lawyers. One of my former professors was a defense lawyer and he walked away from it one day after he had a really messed up client who told him about how he committed sick crimes and how he enjoyed it. Some of them don't want to know if their clients are guilty or innocent, but if the client tells them then they have to keep the secret.

Being a defense lawyer is really tough. Its a double edged sword. Your gonna represent the innocent and the guilty and you have to always try to get your client off even if you know they are guilty.
 
radius said:
If this were true, the defense lawyers would be in effect judging the defendant! You would then have taken away the democritising element of the jury.

In this case it wasn't these lawyers who screwed up.

It was the police and prosecution who didn't investigate enough and the other defense lawyers who didn't put up a good enough defense. You are blaming the wrong people...

Thats exactly right.

The police and the crown attorney's didn't get the right guy the first time, i.e. their evidence was lacking. As such they went back to the evidence and it pointed them to a new suspect, the innocent fellow that was wrongly convicted. Since he was innocent, in theory, there should be some thing in the evidence that would indicate that he was not the guilty party. His lawyer needed to find that contradiction in the evidence to clear his client and he did not.
 
There could have been another way to avoid this.

All that was needed was an anonymous tip. The lawyers did not think of other ways to help an innocent man and frankly did not care. I am sure Mr. Logan will file a suit against the lawyers and the state. The charges will be dropped and they will not re-try an innocent man. This will not ever hit the courtroom and there will be a out-of-court settlement. In most cases, that's the way these cases work.
 
tboy said:
So in other words: you're ok with illegal search and seizure by the police? So the next time they have a suspect they are looking for they can break down your door, remove all your belongings, put you in jail, seize all your assets and it is up to YOU to prove your innocence? Remember: you said it so yourself: the defence attorney has to insure justice is done, nothing else. So if the police commit an illegal search, and find evidence, so what right?

Man, thank god I don't live in YOUR world.

If a defence attorney's job is to protect his client's rights guilty or not, then what do we need them for? Because what criminal in their right mind would ever admit anything to their defence attorney if their defence attorney would just turn them in? If we don't need defense attorneys then we don't need prosecutors. Heck, we don't even need judges. Just let the police determine who is innocent or guilty. Think of all the money we'd save!!!!

Man, you really have to take a step back and think before you post.

Apparently you enjoy creative writing. I never said anything about illegal search / seizure. That would not be justice now would it?

The reason we still need defense attorneys is to defend the INNOCENT. People who have been accused but did NO wrong. The cops do not always get it right and innocent people are charged sometimes.

Apparently you don't have a problem with the guilty getting off?? With a lawyer who goes out of his way to "prove" his client is innocent even though he (or she) is scum and they know they are guilty??

I'll say it again - if the lawyer KNOWS their client is guilty then they should be pleading guilty. They could still argue extenuating circumstances (such as your illegal search situation). In that case the judge would throw the case out for "cause".

In "my world" as you put it, there would be less guilty people on the street, trials would be less lengthy and costly, and there would be less scumbag lawyers. So again I ask - how is that bad exactly??
 
Quest4Less said:
Apparently you enjoy creative writing. I never said anything about illegal search / seizure. That would not be justice now would it?
Tboy's jumps in logic are legendary to say the least

Quest4Less said:
The reason we still need defense attorneys is to defend the INNOCENT. People who have been accused but did NO wrong. The cops do not always get it right and innocent people are charged sometimes.
Like it or not our system is setup to protect everyone including the guilty. It is the job of prosecution to prove guilt or innocence. It isn't up to the defense lawyers to throw their clients under the bus. In order for defense lawyers to properly defend their clients they need full disclosure. (Sometimes that means admission to other crimes.) It sucks but that is the way it works.

Quest4Less said:
Apparently you don't have a problem with the guilty getting off?? With a lawyer who goes out of his way to "prove" his client is innocent even though he (or she) is scum and they know they are guilty??
That is the lawyers job and everyone is entitled to a defense. If you start to pick and choose who get a defense and who doesn't you have already convicted a person before the trial begins. If the person is truly guilty he will be convicted. In the case of this thread you have to wonder how the prosecution has 3 eye witnesses to a crime that the guy didn't commit. Either the guy is really guilty or the real problem is the prosecution with fake witnesses not the lawyers not coming forward.

Quest4Less said:
I'll say it again - if the lawyer KNOWS their client is guilty then they should be pleading guilty. They could still argue extenuating circumstances (such as your illegal search situation). In that case the judge would throw the case out for "cause".
The lawyer can resign a case if he has ethical problems but again everyone is entitled to a defense or the system is worthless.

Quest4Less said:
In "my world" as you put it, there would be less guilty people on the street, trials would be less lengthy and costly, and there would be less scumbag lawyers. So again I ask - how is that bad exactly??
There are guilty people everywhere and innocent people in jail. The system isn't perfect and I hope some day not to be on the wrong end of a crime I didn't commit.
 
Brownie69 said:
They cannot go to a judge and say that the innocent guy didn't do it cause the judge would need to know what evidence they have. They would then have to say that their client confessed and they would be violating solicitor-client privilege. They would have been dis-barred by the Law Society and never be allowed to practice law again.

Solicitor-client privilege exists so a client can confide in his or her lawyer so the lawyer has all the facts when preparing a defense. Anything communicated between a lawyer and a client for the purposes of seeking/giving legal advise and/or preparing for trial falls under the privilege and cannot be divluged by the lawyer for any reason at any point in time. The lawyer must literally take this information to his grave with him.

The privilege is an intergral part in maintaining a person's fundamental right to a fair trial and fair representation. To remove the privilege is to create a flaw in a fair and democratic justice system.

Is it messed up? Oh yeah... I know a couple of people who are or have been defense lawyers. One of my former professors was a defense lawyer and he walked away from it one day after he had a really messed up client who told him about how he committed sick crimes and how he enjoyed it. Some of them don't want to know if their clients are guilty or innocent, but if the client tells them then they have to keep the secret.

Being a defense lawyer is really tough. Its a double edged sword. Your gonna represent the innocent and the guilty and you have to always try to get your client off even if you know they are guilty.

they only have one client? could they not say one of our clients has confessed to this crime but because of solicitor client privilege i can't say who?
 
Quest4Less said:
Apparently you enjoy creative writing. I never said anything about illegal search / seizure. That would not be justice now would it?

The reason we still need defense attorneys is to defend the INNOCENT. People who have been accused but did NO wrong. The cops do not always get it right and innocent people are charged sometimes.

Apparently you don't have a problem with the guilty getting off?? With a lawyer who goes out of his way to "prove" his client is innocent even though he (or she) is scum and they know they are guilty??

I'll say it again - if the lawyer KNOWS their client is guilty then they should be pleading guilty. They could still argue extenuating circumstances (such as your illegal search situation). In that case the judge would throw the case out for "cause".

In "my world" as you put it, there would be less guilty people on the street, trials would be less lengthy and costly, and there would be less scumbag lawyers. So again I ask - how is that bad exactly??

1) Sure, there would be less guilty people on the street, but there'd be less innocent people as well. When you remove someone's right to a fair trial, you remove all rights in regards to anything to do with the law.
2) The leap of logic from the defence attorney/client priviledge to illegal seach and seizure isn't that far. You're saying that if the accused is guilty, the defence attorny should inform the courts of this even if the evidence was obtained illegally (aka illegal search and seizure). Why is that so far fetched? So if someone who has committed a crime cannot challenge evidence obtained illegally, then EVERYONE is subject to illegal seach and seizure because why would the cops have to do it legally if they don't have to?

The point that you and hunter so failingly don't grasp is that once you through out a defendant's rights, you throw out everyone's rights.

Man, and some here accuse ME of wanting a police state? This guy is not only for it, he embraces it!

As for the anonymous tip scenario: if the person who was actually guilty only told one person, then it wouldn't be a far stretch to connect the tip to the lawyers would they themselves be committing a criminal act. I guess you could say that in this case, two wrongs DO make a right eh?

Let's put it simply so even quest can understand it: would YOU go to jail to free an innocent man?
 
The other part...

Is that the guy out 26 years of his life is a low income person vs. someone rich or socially/politically prominent. What kind of defence attorneys and jury did this innocent man have in the first place??
 
y2kmark said:
Is that the guy out 26 years of his life is a low income person vs. someone rich or socially/politically prominent. What kind of defence attorneys and jury did this innocent man have in the first place??

It was probably a public defender and we all know what that means.

If there ever was a rule of law that needed to be changed I would say that a limit should be set on how much a lawyer can charge. For eg: a fund set up so that when wealthy defendants get charged, they pay x into the fund and get the best defence. Then if a poor defendant gets charged, and the case requires a strong defence, the additional funds required can be pulled from this fund.

Either that or they use the proceeds from the crime to bolster this fund.

while we're on the subject, 60 minutes also did a story on another long time convict who was actually guilty. But he stole something like a chocolate bar or something back in the early 60's and was in prison for 30 yrs because of it. Something about because he used a knife to threaten the shopkeeper he was charged with armed robbery (he was 17 when he did it).
 
tboy said:
1) Sure, there would be less guilty people on the street, but there'd be less innocent people as well. When you remove someone's right to a fair trial, you remove all rights in regards to anything to do with the law.
2) The leap of logic from the defence attorney/client priviledge to illegal seach and seizure isn't that far. You're saying that if the accused is guilty, the defence attorny should inform the courts of this even if the evidence was obtained illegally (aka illegal search and seizure). Why is that so far fetched? So if someone who has committed a crime cannot challenge evidence obtained illegally, then EVERYONE is subject to illegal seach and seizure because why would the cops have to do it legally if they don't have to?

The point that you and hunter so failingly don't grasp is that once you through out a defendant's rights, you throw out everyone's rights.

Man, and some here accuse ME of wanting a police state? This guy is not only for it, he embraces it!

As for the anonymous tip scenario: if the person who was actually guilty only told one person, then it wouldn't be a far stretch to connect the tip to the lawyers would they themselves be committing a criminal act. I guess you could say that in this case, two wrongs DO make a right eh?

Let's put it simply so even quest can understand it: would YOU go to jail to free an innocent man?

you have lots of good points about the rights of the defendant. but what about the convicted innocent guy- there has got to be a way for this to be done- the law society could have acted as a go between without revealing the lawyers or their client. maybe it would have had no impact but christ to not even try is really fucked up.
 
red said:
you have lots of good points about the rights of the defendant. but what about the convicted innocent guy- there has got to be a way for this to be done- the law society could have acted as a go between without revealing the lawyers or their client. maybe it would have had no impact but christ to not even try is really fucked up.

It is my understanding that they did contact the law society numerous times to try and find a way to right this wrong but the rules are VERY explicit: a lawyer cannot divulge information obtained from their client without their consent (and what person would give consent to the use of information that would send them to prison for a longer term, well, what criminal would, some honest people would confess and face the music....)
 
tboy said:
It is my understanding that they did contact the law society numerous times to try and find a way to right this wrong but the rules are VERY explicit: a lawyer cannot divulge information obtained from their client without their consent (and what person would give consent to the use of information that would send them to prison for a longer term, well, what criminal would, some honest people would confess and face the music....)

yeah- change the rule. thats what I am saying.
 
red said:
yeah- change the rule. thats what I am saying.

That's just it: you can't. Once you remove the attorney/client priviledge rule the whole house comes tumbling down. As stated previously in this thread: a defendant must be able to confide in his defence attorney knowing that anything he says will be kept in confidence because if he can't, how can he be assured of a fair trial?

I mean, look at it from the guy who was wrongly convicted, he was protected under this right and STILL went to jail. Imagine how many innocent people would be convicted if they couldn't confide in their defence attorney? There are abuses of the system now, can you imagine how easy it would be for a defence attorney to send someone to jail?

The reason the court trials are called "trials" is because it is one of the defence attorney's jobs to TRY to poke holes in the prosecution's case. To TRY and get evidence thrown out that was obtained illegally. (in this case the evidence to prove his innocence would have been obtained illegally via the 2 other attorneys).
 
This is a very complex situation and there are many good points being made.
Brownie69 said:
They cannot go to a judge and say that the innocent guy didn't do it cause the judge would need to know what evidence they have. They would then have to say that their client confessed and they would be violating solicitor-client privilege. They would have been dis-barred by the Law Society and never be allowed to practice law again.
This is very true Brownie. In addition, I think the point was made in the video that EVEN IF they had brought the information forward, the judge would have ruled it inadmissable. So they would have been disbarred AND it wouldn't have made a difference.
lawyerman said:
There could have been another way to avoid this.

All that was needed was an anonymous tip.
I am wondering about this as well. But my impression is that these 2 lawyers, who afterall know and understand the law, considered all their options and could find no way to bring the information forward. Yes indeed, it is a flaw in the system and justice did not prevail in this case.

My initial response was that the lawyers are a couple of douche bags. However, when I consider the case with a more detached perspective, I think they explored all their options and did what they could. I still wonder about the anonymous tip option though.

One of the most striking things about this case for me is the demeanour of the convicted man who is still behind bars. He seems to have learned an almost zen-like detachment to the injustice of his own situation. Given the social cliimate in jail, especially US jails, I would think it would be easy to come out 26 years later so consumed with hate as to be unfit to live in society. I wish the man all the luck in what I am sure will be an extremely difficult adjustment. He seems to have a very supportive family and that will help.
 
red said:
they only have one client? could they not say one of our clients has confessed to this crime but because of solicitor client privilege i can't say who?

Well, odds are that they only have one client who would be connected to any other particular case. For example, party X is charged with a crime but gets off. The Police go after party Y now. The lawyer for party X knows that party X was guilty, not party Y. If the lawyer for party X goes to the judge and says party Y didn't do it, the judge, the prosecution and the police can easily make the connection that the lawyer believes party X did it. There is a direct connection to parties X and Y in this scenario.

Solicitor-client privilege also extends to information that could reveal the contents of privileged information.
 
I agree questor, but in the video didn't he say he was angry for the first 5 yrs, then accepted it from then on? Or something like that. I guess at some point one either has to accept their situation or go crazy fighting it with anger.

If any technology needs to be developed they should be working on one that can determine unequivocally whether someone is telling the truth or lying. Either that or the ability to record and play back memories like that movie Dreamscape.

Just consider this concept for a second: do you think that we'd even need a justice system if people were incapable of lying?

I mean, if you want a travesty of justice, just look at OJ simpson....that is a direct polar opposite of what happened to this guy but IMO it is even WORSE because he got off because the cops didn't follow the rules (the same rules that protect the innocent I might add).
 
lawyerman said:
There could have been another way to avoid this.

All that was needed was an anonymous tip. The lawyers did not think of other ways to help an innocent man and frankly did not care. I am sure Mr. Logan will file a suit against the lawyers and the state. The charges will be dropped and they will not re-try an innocent man. This will not ever hit the courtroom and there will be a out-of-court settlement. In most cases, that's the way these cases work.

Here is the thing, your trying to find a way to circumvent solicitor-client privilege in a way that will be meaningful to the wrongly accused. An anonymous tip doesn't help at all. I can imagine it now... The defense lawyer stands before the judge "Your Honour, my client is innocent, the Police received an anonymous tip which indicates my client didn't do it."

No police officer, crown attorney or judge will ignore solid evidence in favour of an anonymous tip. For the tip to be substantial it needs to provide something which can prove that the wrongly accused is indeed innocent. A defense lawyer would most likely have to give damning evidence about his client, in addition to the anonymous tip, for anything to happen and that is threading a dangerous line.

These are the rules established in our society. In this system, your asking a lawyer to give up a lot for morality. They could lose their livelihood, primary source of income, all their goals and dreams, etc. Its like asking someone to forfeit their life. I know the system sucks in this way, but a lawyer has very little choice in the matter unless s/he is willing to make a very big sacrifice.
 
One thing about crimes where the death penalty is concerned is they are even MORE careful to make sure that they don't off an innocent person. THere are thousands of appeals, requests for clemency etc. There was a documentary on TV about a black woman who shot and killed her boyfriend and his girlfriend and they showed all the steps taken. Plus once someone is sentenced to death it is years and years before the sentence is carried out which gives plenty of time to discover new evidence etc.

As for not paying taxes etc. They don't disclose what the settlements are but rest assured that anyone exonerated after spending any amount of time in prison IS compensated. David Milgaard ended up with a couple of million dollars but blew it all on drugs etc and ended up destitute in the end (I believe). I think more importantly than a monetary compensation is years of psychotherapy as well.