I think I was the first critic of Marner on the Board in September 2019. (Yes, the noisy trio went apeshit, because they are lousy judges of hockey talent.)
"There's another player who's far worse but he's Canadian, it's time for...
...Ode to Mitch Marner." (Quote: Insidious von)
The following are comments from an intelligent and knowledgeable hockey player, observer and fan.
"Part 1 Although I wasn't gifted, I've played a fair bit of hockey. I found it was dramatically easier to pass to a goal scorer than score myself. More hockey players fall into my category than ones that can score. The degree of difficulty in scoring is considerably higher than assisting on a goal. There were also 1.88 assists awarded for every Leaf goal. Soccer and basketball both recognize scoring as being more valuable. Rantanen and Kane had one less point than Marner. Both were more effective in high traffic areas. Rantanen had 10 more goals. Without going further, Kane, Kucherov and Rantanen are better than Marner as right wingers. Marner should not have been on the first team all star. The F3 forward on the back check become the F1 forward on the forecheck. The F3 forward on the forecheck becomes the F1 forward on the back check. The F1 position is the closet to the net and F3 forward closest to the blue line. Marner is the F3 forward at both ends. The least physical area. He covers the least amount of ice. Which his centers have to compensate for. Yet many view him as a great 2 way player. How is that possible when he lives in the perimeter? Linemates for a goal scorer create space and quality scoring lanes. Marner did neither for Matthews in the playoffs. In addition he couldn't generate offense with limited defensive coverage on himself. Marners production is more dependent on his linemates than their production on him."
"Marners contract should have been in line with his RFA peers Aho, Point, Connor, Tkachuck and Rantanen. The $7M range. $6M if he was nice enough to give the Leafs a home discount. At that amount he would have been a keeper. At $10.9M he's over paid and a drain the the cap. Most logical to trade in fixing the salary cap and icing a more balanced and quality roster. He'll never have more value than now. The time is right to trade him."