blueline said:
Anyone else just waiting for the day when a player gets hit by one of the numerous broken bats that fly all over the infield several times a night?
Just about every game I watch now, I see 2-3 of these maple bats break and head out towards a player. They are breaking in a way that one end is very sharp and is going to do some damage one day. I just saw Overbay break his bat and it went flying out towards Felix Hernandez, who leaped over top of it as it went past.
I know MLB is looking into this, but I sure hope nobody gets seriously injured by one if these bats.
I agree it's a scary situation. Here's an interesting article from the NYTimes on just this subject.
jwm
June 13, 2008
Maple Man Has Ideas to Solve Baseball’s Bat Problem
By JACK CURRY
More than 100,000 pieces of wood hang on a Wall of Shame in the Original Maple Bat Corporation’s factory in Quebec. Sam Holman, the company’s founder and the father of maple bats, said the remnants were put there because they were rejected for making bats.
As the debate about the safety of maple bats in Major League Baseball has intensified, Holman mentioned his Wall of Shame to help illustrate why he thought more bats are shattering. He said some bat companies could be using inferior wood, the kind he discarded, while trying to capitalize on a growing market.
“I think it’s a standards issue,” Holman said in a telephone interview Thursday. “I wonder if the quality of the wood just isn’t there.”
Every time Holman sees a maple bat break into three or more pieces, he said, it could be a sign that the maple was not dry enough before the bat was made. Holman’s company uses a vacuum kiln designed to thoroughly dry maple and help the bats remain durable and not splinter into dangerous pieces.
“If you leave any moisture content in maple, you leave stress in the maple,” Holman said. “If you have stress in the bat, it will break.”
Pat Courtney, a spokesman for Major League Baseball, said the organization would not respond to Holman’s theory until after a meeting on the topic scheduled for June 24 involving representatives from M.L.B., the players union and the clubs. Any change regarding bats would have to be collectively bargained. About 60 percent of major leaguers use maple bats.
Courtney said more than 30 companies were licensed to make bats for the majors, with each carrying $1 million in insurance. Baseball has asked teams to keep track of broken bats, but Courtney would not divulge any information gathered about them or the companies.
When Holman speaks about maple bats, he does so as a pioneer. Joe Carter of the Toronto Blue Jays used one of his bats in a game in 1997, the first time a maple bat was used in the majors. In addition, Holman has two patents on maple bats.
Holman said 74 major leaguers were using his bats, called Sam Bats, and none had complained about having a bat shatter this year. Ryan Howard of the Philadelphia Phillies and Alfonso Soriano of the Chicago Cubs are two of his marquee clients.
“I see the way bats are shattering and flying all over the place,” Howard said recently. “It’s never affected me.”
While Soriano has had about five bats break this season, none have shattered dangerously.
“I broke a few, but it’s because I hit it off the end of the bat,” Soriano said. “I still like them.”
Holman said M.L.B. could address the safety concerns for fans by extending the netting from behind the plate to the ends of the dugout. That possibility is expected to be discussed.
“We’ve been saying that for 10 years,” Yankees pitcher Mike Mussina said. “We’d like the fans to be able to go home with their teeth.”
But increased netting would not solve the safety concerns on the field. Don Long, a coach with the Pittsburgh Pirates, was hit in the face with a chunk of a maple bat while sitting in the dugout this season. Long needed 10 stitches and sustained nerve damage. Carlos Delgado of the Mets was hit in the left arm by a flying bat while leading off third base in spring training and needed four stitches. Chipper Jones of the Atlanta Braves said he had dodged bats at third.
With baseball’s meeting on the issue less than two weeks away, the batmaker who might know more about maple than anyone is still waiting for a call.
“So far, I haven’t been invited,” Holman said. “If I’m not invited, I’d be disappointed.”