11 11 11 ... Lest We Forget

Clearly you have enhanced your personal popularity and credibility with this approach.

You seem quite ungrateful for the things you have, and those who gave them to you.

Haha I am sure you are an authority on personal popularity. I don't think what I have was given to me. My family has lost a great deal in war, including wealth and people. If being anti-war and not wanting young people to die or sacrifice their lives so I can be richer is unpopular, I don't care. I would rather have less wealth if it meant fewer people would get maimed and killed. As for the song, I think it is very poignant, honest and probably much more real then the nonsense we are fed.
 
The lyrics reflect the personal experience of one person at that battle. . .
By the way presumably you know that Australians during World War I had to volunteer for overseas service. In fact Australia twice during the war rejected compulsory overseas service. Which rather gives the coup de grâce to the seeming point of the song.

Then in nineteen fifteen my country said Son
It's time to stop rambling 'cause there's work to be done
So they gave me a tin hat and they gave me a gun
And they sent me away to the war.
 
Gee and here all this time public reaction to the Zimmermann Telegram and German Submarine Warfare have unfairly been taking the rap?

Only to the ignorant. It's been well known for over 50 years that the primary motivation of the 1917 US decision-makers for entering the conflict was to secure the debts. The public outrage was necessary for political cover.
 
Only to the ignorant. It's been well known for over 50 years that the primary motivation of the 1917 US decision-makers for entering the conflict was to secure the debts. The public outrage was necessary for political cover.
Yes the "Daddy Warbucks" conspiracy theory. It was popular for a while in the 1920's and played a role in bringing about World War II.
 
A serious question to nottyboi.

On September 1, 1939 the German army under the orders of Mr. Hitler invaded Poland. This was the act the started the Second World War.

Given your views of not wanting young people to die, I sincerely and genuinely ask you, "What would you do if you were in power, how would you have responded?"

Rather then call each other names perhaps you can educate me as to a different way that the world could have handled the situation.

At that point it is too late. The die had been set. But if the Germans were equally unwilling to die for money, the invasion would not have happened. By continuing to glorify war we are casting the die for the next great conflict.
 
Only to the ignorant. It's been well known for over 50 years that the primary motivation of the 1917 US decision-makers for entering the conflict was to secure the debts. The public outrage was necessary for political cover.

Funny I have not read any serious historians who support this theory.

I guess we all mean something different by "well known."
 
Ok, then let's back it up in time a bit further.

November 8, 1923 - Mr. Hitler attempts to overthrow the German government with the Beer Hall Putsch.
He arrested, thrown in jail and while there writes his book Mein Kampf which clearly states his views of the world order that he advocates.

January 30, 1933 - Mr. Hitler is appointed as Chancellor of Germany by President von Hindenburg and from this point he starts his true political power.

November 9, 1938 - Kristallnacht takes place (the night of broken glass), it is the overt manifestation of the pogrom against Jews. They are killed in the street, beaten, thrown into concentration camps. Their homes, businesses, and synagogues are burned and ransacked. All of this is done on the order of Mr. Hitler.

So now let us say that it is November 13, 1938, you have full knowledge of the events that just took place, a world war is still a year away. I re-submit my previous question, "What would you do if you were in power, how would you have responded?"

He won't answer the question because beyond being ungrateful, he is a coward.

The good news is that he is not in power, nor will he ever be.
 
You are confusing actual historical events with a comic strip character.
Which seemingly confirms that you don't know as much as you think about the time period or the development of Harold Gray's "Little Orphan Annie" comic strip, when you can't see a connection between your conspiracy theory and "Daddy Warbucks."
 
Which seemingly confirms that you don't know as much as you think about the time period or the development of Harold Gray's "Little Orphan Annie" comic strip, when you can't see a connection between your conspiracy theory and "Daddy Warbucks."

It appears that the art of enjoying the subtle is dead.
 
Ok, then let's back it up in time a bit further.

November 8, 1923 - Mr. Hitler attempts to overthrow the German government with the Beer Hall Putsch.
He arrested, thrown in jail and while there writes his book Mein Kampf which clearly states his views of the world order that he advocates.

January 30, 1933 - Mr. Hitler is appointed as Chancellor of Germany by President von Hindenburg and from this point he starts his true political power.

November 9, 1938 - Kristallnacht takes place (the night of broken glass), it is the overt manifestation of the pogrom against Jews. They are killed in the street, beaten, thrown into concentration camps. Their homes, businesses, and synagogues are burned and ransacked. All of this is done on the order of Mr. Hitler.

So now let us say that it is November 13, 1938, you have full knowledge of the events that just took place, a world war is still a year away. I re-submit my previous question, "What would you do if you were in power, how would you have responded?"

I would have not imposed the treaty of versaille on Germany with it's onerus terms. In 1923 Hitler was nobody. The most reasonable time to stop Hitler was when starteed re-armament. The British should have sailed their still considerable fleet to Germany on a state visit, and then demanded the surrender of the Graf Spee, Scharnhorst and Tirpiz, barring which they would be destroyed. But the fact is, greed and the desire to punish Germany punitively resulted in Hitlers rise, combined with the great depression. At the heart of it WWII was all about greed as all wars are. The allies wanted to fuck Germany after WWi, the Germans were tired of getting fucked, so they decided to take back what they felt was theirs, and once they achieved that , they just kept on going. The Allies, were willing to let Germany have what they KNEW was rightly hers, but only decided to fight when the Germans got greedy, and of course the Germans paid a massive price in the end, but so did so many others. Nationalism, us vs them all contribute to this. War is too easy to sell. The number of people that want a war with Iran is pretty staggering....especially considering what a debacle the war with a much smaller and weaker Iraq was. A war with iran would be 20 to 30x more difficult. Yet so many people are willing to support it.
 
I would have not imposed the treaty of versaille on Germany with it's onerus terms.
That's a nice way of backing out of the question.

I will give you that a great many people besides you and I see that the Treaties of Versailles and Saint- Germain-en-Laye, where horrible mistakes.

"This war (World War II) would never have come unless, under American and modernising pressure, we had driven the Habsburgs out of Austria and the Hohenzollerns out of Germany. By making these vacuums we gave the opening for the Hitlerite monster to crawl out of its sewer on to the vacant thrones. No doubt these views are very unfashionable...."

Sir Winston Spencer-Churchill, 8th April 1945.

p.s.: Versailles