100,000 Illegals

I own a construction company in Calgary and I will hire 10 experienced trades tomorrow that can do foundation and/or framing.
I turned away bids this year because we couldn't find experienced trades.
 
I own a construction company in Calgary and I will hire 10 experienced trades tomorrow that can do foundation and/or framing.
I turned away bids this year because we couldn't find experienced trades.

Pay them more than what your competitors are paying.
 
Where did the Sun get those numbers from ? Immigration have been giving temp work visa to construction workers
in recent years. I know quite a few South American workers who got their visas just this year . As well, Boarder Services have been very active in recent years.....it's simply not easy for an illegal to hide any more. Places that are suspected of hiring illegals are routinely raided these days[/QUOTE]



Not true. I speak Spanish, polish Russian and some Portuguese and Ukrainian. I work in construction and meet lots of workers. They don't k ow I cn understand them. Half of them are illegals working for peanuts. Many of them are exploited by the owners. In more than 20 years in the business never saw a raid by immigration or labour board.
 
Wouldn't it be better to crack down on illegal immigrants and punish those companies who hire them? What you're saying is, welcome to the illegals!

Unfortunately there is a shortage of good labours and tradesmen. Most younge Canadians don't want to work hard anymore. They rather work in an office. Legalize there status and make them pay taxes like the rest of us do. Make it easier for people to come here to work but government should ensure they don't abuse the system. You want to come to Canada work for it. Don't expect freebies and pay taxes
 
The Toronto Sun got their number from an immigration lawyer hired to get the illegals permanent residence status in Canada.

http://www.torontosun.com/2011/12/04/contractors-fear-deportation

Of course, he does say that if you let these criminals (illegals are automatically criminals in my eyes) stay in the country that they will pay more taxes, etc. Well, they are here illegally and they are taking jobs away from Canadian citizens.

Hmmm...

Isn't this a bit wrong?

First of all, being in Canada without proper papers is not a crime or else it would be in the Criminal Code. If I'm in error, find the relevant provision and provide me with the cite for it.

Second of all, I'm not entirely sure they are taking away jobs from Canucks. Look what happened in the U.S. when the States started tightening up their anti foreigner laws. Crops rotted in the fields and farmers complained to government. If those jobs were wanted, why weren't Americans picking up the slack? It's not like unemployment is at rock bottom in the U.S. I'm reasonably sure that the same situation basically exists in Canada.

I'll agree that immigrants push down wages and add competition to Canuck workers. However, in certain parts of the country, (e.g. Alberta's oil patch), there are huge shortages of skilled labour. They seem to rail on and on and on about this fact over and over and over again. It should therefore be really easy for Canucks to get jobs (as shown by Alta.'s unemployment rate of 5% with a 74% labour force participation rate). I'm not entirely sure that Canucks have anything to complain about as it's a lot easier for them with the proper papers to get into the training programs and funding to do the skilled labour jobs that are out there. Pretty sure the feds aren't going to backstop a student loan for an apprentice or student who's not a Canuck. I don't know for sure. And no, heavy duty mechanics (and other skilled tradespeople) are not paid minium wages. They make six figures.

Anyways...
 
Sorry, but I think that it's unfair to simply allow people who come to this country and ignore our immigration policies. If they decide to ignore our immigration laws what makes you think that they will not simply ignore our tax policies too?

I agree that Canada needs more immigrants and welcome more immigration but I do not agree that people can simply come in here and jump the queue.

Unfortunately there is a shortage of good labours and tradesmen. Most younge Canadians don't want to work hard anymore. They rather work in an office. Legalize there status and make them pay taxes like the rest of us do. Make it easier for people to come here to work but government should ensure they don't abuse the system. You want to come to Canada work for it. Don't expect freebies and pay taxes
 
Hmmm...

Isn't this a bit wrong?

First of all, being in Canada without proper papers is not a crime or else it would be in the Criminal Code. If I'm in error, find the relevant provision and provide me with the cite for it.

Second of all, I'm not entirely sure they are taking away jobs from Canucks. Look what happened in the U.S. when the States started tightening up their anti foreigner laws. Crops rotted in the fields and farmers complained to government. If those jobs were wanted, why weren't Americans picking up the slack? It's not like unemployment is at rock bottom in the U.S. I'm reasonably sure that the same situation basically exists in Canada.

I'll agree that immigrants push down wages and add competition to Canuck workers. However, in certain parts of the country, (e.g. Alberta's oil patch), there are huge shortages of skilled labour. They seem to rail on and on and on about this fact over and over and over again. It should therefore be really easy for Canucks to get jobs (as shown by Alta.'s unemployment rate of 5% with a 74% labour force participation rate). I'm not entirely sure that Canucks have anything to complain about as it's a lot easier for them with the proper papers to get into the training programs and funding to do the skilled labour jobs that are out there. Pretty sure the feds aren't going to backstop a student loan for an apprentice or student who's not a Canuck. I don't know for sure. And no, heavy duty mechanics (and other skilled tradespeople) are not paid minium wages. They make six figures.

Anyways...

Pretty hard for a heavy duty mechanic to make six figures unless they are in Fort Mac perhaps. But other trades may hit that. I have heard that the highest paid union trade in the Calgary market is around $43/hr...that wouldn't quite hit six figures. But close.

But I agree with your points...if kids are willing to relocate I don't think there is any shortage of jobs. Just hard if you are stuck in an area of higher unemployment.
 
If welfare and EI wasn't so easy to obtain there would be no problem finding workers in Canada.
 
Hmmm...

Isn't this a bit wrong?

First of all, being in Canada without proper papers is not a crime or else it would be in the Criminal Code. If I'm in error, find the relevant provision and provide me with the cite for it.

Good point, I would have thought that "illegal" = "criminal". In any case, an illegal immigrant can be arrested, detained and then deported.

Second of all, I'm not entirely sure they are taking away jobs from Canucks. Look what happened in the U.S. when the States started tightening up their anti foreigner laws. Crops rotted in the fields and farmers complained to government. If those jobs were wanted, why weren't Americans picking up the slack? It's not like unemployment is at rock bottom in the U.S. I'm reasonably sure that the same situation basically exists in Canada.

I'll agree that immigrants push down wages and add competition to Canuck workers. However, in certain parts of the country, (e.g. Alberta's oil patch), there are huge shortages of skilled labour. They seem to rail on and on and on about this fact over and over and over again. It should therefore be really easy for Canucks to get jobs (as shown by Alta.'s unemployment rate of 5% with a 74% labour force participation rate). I'm not entirely sure that Canucks have anything to complain about as it's a lot easier for them with the proper papers to get into the training programs and funding to do the skilled labour jobs that are out there. Pretty sure the feds aren't going to backstop a student loan for an apprentice or student who's not a Canuck. I don't know for sure. And no, heavy duty mechanics (and other skilled tradespeople) are not paid minium wages. They make six figures.

I think that it's pretty simple that an illegal immigrant can take work away from a Canadian. If I as an illegal am willing to work for $12 an hr under the table for an employer would that employer be willing to hire someone at $14? Duh!

I think that skilled trades overall needs an image makeover and that easier access and better funding for training programs would help. I certainly would have considered trades if I had known more about them when I was in high school.
 
If welfare and EI wasn't so easy to obtain there would be no problem finding workers in Canada.
Very true, there are immigrants who are lazy fucks and live off pogey all their lives.

It's not that easy to get EI. Why do you think the program has such a huge surplus?
They should give coupons instead of cash like in the U.S. but the only problem the coupons can be exchange into the underworld for drugs, weapons, stolen property..etc.





Most Illegals start families and are supposedly hard working people and since businesses are short of workers for most trades, therefore paying underneath the table should be overlooked because illegals in return spend their money back into the Canada. Economic and population growth exists.
 
The Toronto Sun got their number from an immigration lawyer hired to get the illegals permanent residence status in Canada.

http://www.torontosun.com/2011/12/04/contractors-fear-deportation

Of course, he does say that if you let these criminals (illegals are automatically criminals in my eyes) stay in the country that they will pay more taxes, etc. Well, they are here illegally and they are taking jobs away from Canadian citizens.

taking jobs away from canadians hahah good one.
heres your average young canadian, sitting on welfare doing nothing.

baggy-pants.jpg


im 28 and have seen a funny pattern in toronto ever since highschool. people who come here from other countries work hard and make something for themselves. yet people who are born and raised here and lazy and try to find every loop hole.
and ive been raised here
 
Hmmm...

Isn't this a bit wrong?

First of all, being in Canada without proper papers is not a crime or else it would be in the Criminal Code. If I'm in error, find the relevant provision and provide me with the cite for it....
You are in error. Criminal code is not the only statute that creates what's being referred to as criminal offenses in Canada. In fact violation of any federal statute ( such as controlled drugs and substances act or immigration and refugee protection act) resulting in conviction will go on CPIC database.
Working in Canada illegally is an offense under IRPA, you can go to jail for it and be deported and not able to come back.
 
taking jobs away from canadians hahah good one.
heres your average young canadian, sitting on welfare doing nothing.

baggy-pants.jpg

yet people who are born and raised here and lazy and try to find every loop hole.
and ive been raised here
yeah, they don't realize how lucky they are to be living in this country, good schools, free health care, decent housing etc etc
 
people who come here from other countries work hard and make something for themselves. yet people who are born and raised here and lazy and try to find every loop hole.

Ain't that the hard truth. I see people in my and other neighbourhoods, who don't even speak English, go around collecting empties that they redeem at the Beer Store for 10 cents a can.

On the other hand, I don't understand how some (not all) people who have roots going back generations in Canada with the advantage of white skin and speaking the language of one or both of the founding nations living on government handouts.
 
Really? Aren't there thousands of people under deportation orders still residing in Canada?
By and large they are being caught and sent back home, I suspect CBS are availing themselves of new technologies to track illegals. However, they are doing a much better job in recent years than in the past

Deportations from Canada surge 50 per cent
http://www.canadaka.net/link.php?id=50279
 
100k..... Try 15 million.....