Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

Innovation doesn't need growth, you can do change without adding more people.
No that's not possible.
When an industry or venture is established it needs new headcount.
People get old and retire, so you need headcount to replace.
People die, so you need headcount to replace.
Businesses grow and expand operations. That needs headcount.
Without growth there is no innovation as there is no incentive to invest in it.
In all cases you need human capital, aka people.
 

Lots of money​

Free health care to refugee claimants now costing $2M a day​


Just one day after publishing the 2026 federal budget, Ottawa tabled figures revealing that the cost of free health care for refugee claimants is running up a tab of at least $2 million per day.
On Nov. 6, the Treasury Board Secretariat tabled new "supplementary estimates" requesting an additional $349.5 million for the Interim Federal Health Program, a provider of free health care to the country's more than 500,000 asylum seekers.

This is in addition to $462.1 million already earmarked for the program earlier this year, coming to an accumulated total of $811 million — about $2.2 million per day.

And with one more "supplementary estimate" scheduled for February, it's entirely possible that the Interim Federal Health Program could crack $1 billion by the end of the fiscal year.
That's in line with a Parliamentary Budget Officer analysis from earlier this year, which forecast that the IFHP would probably hit $1.1 billion by the end of the fiscal year, and continue rising for the rest of the decade.

By 2030, the Parliamentary Budget Officer surmised that Canada would be spending $1.5 billion per year on free health care for refugee claimants.
It's a mammoth surge in cost for a program that was a relatively niche corner of the federal budget only a few years ago.
As recently as 2020, the annual cost of the IFHP was $211 million, about one-quarter of what has already been spent in the current fiscal year.

The skyrocketing cost of the IFHP is only one of the most conspicuous consequences of the fact that Canada is currently dealing with an unprecedented surge in foreign refugee claimants.

In 2015, the population of asylum claimants in Canada stood at just 16,058.
As of the most recent count by Statistics Canada, the number of asylum claimants and related groups in the country now stands at 530,090 — a more than 3,000 per cent increase over the 2015 totals.

And of those, more than half have arrived in just the last three years. There were 257,000 asylum claimants in Canada at the midpoint of 2023, and in the interim three years this has increased by another 270,000 — an average of 7,500 new refugee claimants every month.

All told, 1.3 per cent of the Canadian population is now a refugee claimant or someone who has had their refugee claim approved.

Nevertheless, any effect this is having on the costs of the Interim Federal Health Program has not been reflected in official Carney government communiques.

The 2025 federal budget did not itemize the cost of the IFHP at all. And in the most recently tabled federal budget, the program was allocated just $404 million — an outlay it will likely exceed in only a few months.

Similarly, the Carney government has claimed success in reducing the raw number of asylum seekers entering the country each month. The 2026 budget, for instance, boasted that "new asylum claims between January and August 2026 were 68% lower than during the same period in 2024."

But overall, Carney's tenure has seen the number of asylum claimants in the country become higher, and not lower.

There were about 480,000 refugees and refugee claimants in the country at the time of Carney's swearing-in in early 2025. This has now grown by 50,000 to the current total of 530,000.

The number of refugee claimants in Canada has skyrocketed for the simple reason that, unlike other immigration streams, Ottawa has limited ability to rein it in.

With few exceptions, any foreign national who claims to be a refugee is immediately granted status as an asylum claimant, which allows them to remain in Canada until their refugee claim is heard. Given current backlogs, this could be as long as three years.

And according to recent figures from the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada, up to 80 per cent of asylum seekers end up having their claim approved — sometimes without so much as an in-person interview.

The IFHP offers free health care to approved refugees and asylum claimants —and, in some cases, foreigners who have had their claims rejected.


In an order paper response in April, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada revealed that, over the last 10 years, $275 million had been spent on health care for foreign nationals who had filed ineligible refugee claims.

Controversially, the Interim Federal Health Program offers a level of care beyond that given to Canadian citizens, something that the Conservative party has repeatedly criticized in the House of Commons as evidence of an unfair or "two-tier" system.

Prescriptions are free save for a $4 co-payment, and the program covers 70 per cent of the cost of everything from eyeglasses to mental health counselling to speech-language therapy.

In a June submission to the House of Commons requested by Conservative MP Dan Mazier, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada revealed that the IFHP spent nearly $20 million just on supplemental health benefits for "asylum claimants whose claims were ultimately rejected by the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada."


This included $11 million on prescriptions, $6 million on dental care and $1.3 million on mental health counselling.


 
The numbers are smaller, but the population still increases, which was my original point.
And my original point was that the numbers were smaller before Trudeau, and should have stayed that way.
 
No that's not possible.
When an industry or venture is established it needs new headcount.
People get old and retire, so you need headcount to replace.
People die, so you need headcount to replace.
Businesses grow and expand operations. That needs headcount.
Without growth there is no innovation as there is no incentive to invest in it.
In all cases you need human capital, aka people.

So people move from shitty jobs to better jobs.
 
Absolutely, the booze laws and movie censorship was ridiculous, especially in Ontario. And food options have improved. But the 50s to the 70s was a time of rising real wages for working people and we had a much smaller population. And real estate was cheaper. Of course, North America had a head start with countries like Germany and Japan bombed out and China was not even in the game.
I think if you bring up wages you need to understand that we've seen wages depressed by companies that are more interested in paying out dividends or doing share buyback programs then they are in sharing the wealth with the workers. That changed in the 1980s, and while more immigrants can be a contributing factor to a lack of wage growth (more people for fewer jobs = less pay, it's the law of supply and demand), when companies started minimize pay increases and fight unions...
 
It sounds like your parents weren't very adventurous. Toronto had its Chinatown, Little Italy and Little Portugal neighborhoods back then. Add to that pockets of French and Slavic influences.

Clearly, there has been more immigration from Asia and Africa. I am just challenging the idea that Toronto restaurants only had meat and potatoes in the late 50s/early 60s.
You're not wrong, I'm pretty sure my dad wasn't an adventurous eater back in his youth (though he did later in life), but what I'm talking about is that like 98% of restaurants back then were very meat and potatoes. There wasn't a lot of fine dining (there was some, but probably a small handful of places), and the Chinese and other European/Asia style restaurants didn't really blow up until the late 1960s. There was a great story in the Star a bunch of years ago (and unfortunately couldn't find online) that talked about this evolution. Part of it happened after the great migration of Anglos from Quebec after the first separatist referendum (and its also one of the reasons the Bank of Montreal is now headquartered in Toronto...).
 
I don't think moving immigrants to less populated areas to help build them has any historical precedence.

Due to immigrant networks and economic gravity most immigrants will still wind up in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver. If Alberta experiences an energy boom, Calgary could take on a large amount of immigrants.

As far as immigrants populating dying small cities, towns and rural areas, it's not going to happen.
You're right, for the most part. We cannot tell immigrants they can't live in the GTA, Montreal or Vancouver. But, we can entice them to other places, like we did when we were settling the prairies. Offer them free land if they move to a remote area. Don't know how many would be willing to do that, to be honest, but it could help. And, the reality is there are immigrants who move to remote areas. I had a coworker who's family came from India who settled in Brandon, MB. They were the only Indians (from Asia, not indigenous) there.

I think there could be ways of greasing the wheels to get people to move to smaller places in remote areas, but it would be expensive. You would need to ensure there ways to get there, have infrastructure for things like internet, water, power, heat and food. Transportation links to the rest of Canada (rail, airports, ports, all-year paved roads and not ice bridges that are only accessible in the winter). It would be expensive and challenging. But, if climate change continues unabated, there will be livable land farther north. We just need to make the connections...And have some sort of industry up there...farming, mining, lumber...maybe other stuff...

To be honest, that is very much pie in the sky thinking, and likely will never happen by government decree. It could happen by natural expansion. Keep in mind that places like Dawson City because population centres due to the gold rush. Now, most of those people left, but a surprising number have stayed since then.
 
You're right, for the most part. We cannot tell immigrants they can't live in the GTA, Montreal or Vancouver. But, we can entice them to other places, like we did when we were settling the prairies. Offer them free land if they move to a remote area. Don't know how many would be willing to do that, to be honest, but it could help. And, the reality is there are immigrants who move to remote areas. I had a coworker who's family came from India who settled in Brandon, MB. They were the only Indians (from Asia, not indigenous) there.

I think there could be ways of greasing the wheels to get people to move to smaller places in remote areas, but it would be expensive. You would need to ensure there ways to get there, have infrastructure for things like internet, water, power, heat and food. Transportation links to the rest of Canada (rail, airports, ports, all-year paved roads and not ice bridges that are only accessible in the winter). It would be expensive and challenging. But, if climate change continues unabated, there will be livable land farther north. We just need to make the connections...And have some sort of industry up there...farming, mining, lumber...maybe other stuff...

To be honest, that is very much pie in the sky thinking, and likely will never happen by government decree. It could happen by natural expansion. Keep in mind that places like Dawson City because population centres due to the gold rush. Now, most of those people left, but a surprising number have stayed since then.

Urbanization is global now, there are less jobs in farming, mining and resource extraction. The jobs are in the cities and you can't expect to send immigrants to places where they won't thrive and have them stay there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
You're right, for the most part. We cannot tell immigrants they can't live in the GTA, Montreal or Vancouver. But, we can entice them to other places, like we did when we were settling the prairies. Offer them free land if they move to a remote area. Don't know how many would be willing to do that, to be honest, but it could help. And, the reality is there are immigrants who move to remote areas. I had a coworker who's family came from India who settled in Brandon, MB. They were the only Indians (from Asia, not indigenous) there.

I think there could be ways of greasing the wheels to get people to move to smaller places in remote areas, but it would be expensive. You would need to ensure there ways to get there, have infrastructure for things like internet, water, power, heat and food. Transportation links to the rest of Canada (rail, airports, ports, all-year paved roads and not ice bridges that are only accessible in the winter). It would be expensive and challenging. But, if climate change continues unabated, there will be livable land farther north. We just need to make the connections...And have some sort of industry up there...farming, mining, lumber...maybe other stuff...

To be honest, that is very much pie in the sky thinking, and likely will never happen by government decree. It could happen by natural expansion. Keep in mind that places like Dawson City because population centres due to the gold rush. Now, most of those people left, but a surprising number have stayed since then.

This idea of people moving to different places got me thinking about the U.S.' internal migration.
It is still very dynamic. Many small and mid-tier cities have grown dramatically in the last twenty-five years.

Outside expanding suburbs, I don't think there is exactly a Canadian equivalent. Calgary and Vancouver might qualify to some extent, but they have been among the largest Canadian cities for several decades.

This is not a criticism. It's easy to see U.S. internal migration has focused on southerly migration. Climate is a contributing factor as well as taxation, demographics, etc.
Since most of Canada's population is already near its Southern border, it's not feasible to have a southerly population shift.
 
This idea of people moving to different places got me thinking about the U.S.' internal migration.
It is still very dynamic. Many small and mid-tier cities have grown dramatically in the last twenty-five years.

Outside expanding suburbs, I don't think there is exactly a Canadian equivalent. Calgary and Vancouver might qualify to some extent, but they have been among the largest Canadian cities for several decades.

This is not a criticism. It's easy to see U.S. internal migration has focused on southerly migration. Climate is a contributing factor as well as taxation, demographics, etc.
Since most of Canada's population is already near its Southern border, it's not feasible to have a southerly population shift.
It's a good point, there are many people who are moving to Texas and Florida for the weather and other potential benefits. You're right, Canada doesn't really have a bunch of smaller cities that are growing (outside of the GTA at least, I mean places like Milton have seen a huge surge of growth in the past 25 years). Opportunity will be the key. I think, for example, you get a place in a remote area and are able to have a thriving industry, you would see people move. Like, for the sake of the argument, I was at a conference where a guy was talking about data centres and the opposition to them. But, what if a big AI company built their operation right by a remote data centre? They suddenly had 4-5,000 high paying jobs, which would lead to infrastructure for better roads, schools, entertainment and leisure activities. That could be a major catalyst for growth in the near north (like say, Northern Ontario, not as far north as like Moose Factory, but north of Sudbury).
 
But, what if a big AI company built their operation right by a remote data centre? They suddenly had 4-5,000 high paying jobs, which would lead to infrastructure for better roads, schools, entertainment and leisure activities. That could be a major catalyst for growth in the near north (like say, Northern Ontario, not as far north as like Moose Factory, but north of Sudbury).

Data centre's don't provide much in the way of jobs other than maintenance and security.
What do you think the 4-5,000 jobs would be doing?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Data centre's don't provide much in the way of jobs other than maintenance and security.
What do you think the 4-5,000 jobs would be doing?
I'm not saying it, some dude on a panel said it. And, his reasoning would be that an organization would want to be as close as possible to one of its data centres (since it minimizes lag) or something like that. The idea would be the data centre is built, then Meta or Amazon (for example) put one of their AI units right there so they get maximum advantage of the centre. Now, do I believe this would happen? No, I agree with your skeptic view on this. But, stranger things have happened...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
I think if you bring up wages you need to understand that we've seen wages depressed by companies that are more interested in paying out dividends or doing share buyback programs then they are in sharing the wealth with the workers. That changed in the 1980s, and while more immigrants can be a contributing factor to a lack of wage growth (more people for fewer jobs = less pay, it's the law of supply and demand), when companies started minimize pay increases and fight unions...
Absolutely, male wage inequality started to increase in the early 80s. It has been a problem especially for men as they are more likely to be in the private sector. Declining unionization and the increasing importance of university degrees played a role. Keep in mind that outsourcing and automation and collapsing commodity prices also played a role. Not to mention that the 80s started with a massive recession and the highest unemployment since the depression and the labour market was saturated with boomers and women all streaming in at the same time. Also, the media often equates the baby boom as the same as the U.S. baby boom. In fact, our boom was much more back ended with tons of European immigrants coming in the 50s and 60s and having kids. Also, if you include kids born elsewhere(unlike Statscan), the boom was even bigger still. A lot of these kids with parents from places like Poland, Italy, Croatia, Germany, etc could be found at the Catholic schools in Toronto.
 
Last edited:
I'm not saying it, some dude on a panel said it. And, his reasoning would be that an organization would want to be as close as possible to one of its data centres (since it minimizes lag) or something like that. The idea would be the data centre is built, then Meta or Amazon (for example) put one of their AI units right there so they get maximum advantage of the centre. Now, do I believe this would happen? No, I agree with your skeptic view on this. But, stranger things have happened...

Its never happened so far, no data centre has also resulted in local programmers.
Instead its fibre to a handful of programmers in the valley or somewhere.
 
Absolutely, male wage inequality started to increase in the early 80s. It was especially a problem for men as they are more likely to be in the private sector. Declining unionization and the increasing importance of university degrees played a role. Keep in mind that outsourcing and automation and collapsing commodity prices also played a role. Not to mention that the 80s started with a massive recession and the highest unemployment since the depression and the labour market was saturated with boomers and women all streaming in at the same time. Also, the media often equates the baby boom as the same as the U.S. baby boom. In fact, our boom was much more back ended with tons of European immigrants coming in the 50s and 60s and having kids. Also, if you include kids born elsewhere(unlike Statscan), the boom was even bigger still. A lot of these kids with parents from places like Poland, Italy, Croatia, Germany, etc could be found at the Catholic schools in Toronto.

Yup, it all started with Reaganomics, austerity or the trickle down effect.
Whatever you want to call that disaster.
 
I'm not saying it, some dude on a panel said it. And, his reasoning would be that an organization would want to be as close as possible to one of its data centres (since it minimizes lag) or something like that.
Massive AI hyperscale data centers are usually quite far away from organizations as they are just massive server farms.
They are usually located in remote areas where utilities are likely to cost less.
They also tend to be mostly automated and don't need hands on development support on an everyday basis.
Any upgrades can and are usually made online unless equipment is being replaced.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
They were elected to a minority though and they ran on the perception of low immigration.

They ran on a lot of lies.
The argument of being elected into a minority doesn't matter. People don't vote for minority governments. Who honestly votes for their local mp thinking “oh boy I hope this guy ends up in a minority”
 
The argument of being elected into a minority doesn't matter. People don't vote for minority governments. Who honestly votes for their local mp thinking “oh boy I hope this guy ends up in a minority”
This is the election process in Canada and it's the will of the people that gives the results.

I don't think you thought out what you said.