Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

I am not a Carney fan but you need to also be realistic or else no one will take you seriously. His investment in Brookfield was estimated to be $6.2m when he became PM. It is now $6.8m. He has a long way to go to accomplish being a billionaire. If that is what he wants to do then doing it through Brookfield is a poor move 🤣

you need to do your homework properly or else no one will take you seriously

AI Overview


Yes, Mark Carney holds numerous investments outside of Brookfield. [1, 2]
According to financial disclosures published by Canada's Ethics Commissioner, his asset portfolio includes: [1]
    • Stripe Inc.: Shares in the global financial technology and payment processing company (where he formerly served on the board). [1, 2]
    • Third-Party Managed Investment Account: A broad portfolio of 567 individual stocks managed through a blind trust, which heavily skews toward international technology, consumer, and finance companies (such as Alphabet, Amazon, and Airbnb), with very few direct Canadian holdings
    • Deferred Share Units & Compensation: In addition to the unexercised options, Carney accumulated deferred share units and performance-linked compensation tie-ins (such as those connected to the Brookfield Global Transition Fund) from his tenure as chair and senior executive at the firm
in addition
his holdings in Brookfield Asset Management are 409,300 unexercised stock options with a strike price of $37.54, which expire between 2033 and 2034

BAM closed @ 51.53 USD on friday making those stock options worth $21 MM USD
they will be worth a whole lot more by the time he leaves office

come on man, he is an investment banker and knows what is held in his "blind Trust"
 
What percentage of those Canadian tradespeople that were unemployed refused jobs resulting in vacancies filled by the TFW across Canada ? Why did these “ skilled” trades people refuse those jobs and who supported them during this unemployment phase ? I am sure that the percentage is quite significant.
Based on what exactly? Provide your facts that shows it's quite significant.
 
you need to do your homework properly or else no one will take you seriously

AI Overview


Yes, Mark Carney holds numerous investments outside of Brookfield. [1, 2]
According to financial disclosures published by Canada's Ethics Commissioner, his asset portfolio includes: [1]
    • Stripe Inc.: Shares in the global financial technology and payment processing company (where he formerly served on the board). [1, 2]
    • Third-Party Managed Investment Account: A broad portfolio of 567 individual stocks managed through a blind trust, which heavily skews toward international technology, consumer, and finance companies (such as Alphabet, Amazon, and Airbnb), with very few direct Canadian holdings
    • Deferred Share Units & Compensation: In addition to the unexercised options, Carney accumulated deferred share units and performance-linked compensation tie-ins (such as those connected to the Brookfield Global Transition Fund) from his tenure as chair and senior executive at the firm
in addition
his holdings in Brookfield Asset Management are 409,300 unexercised stock options with a strike price of $37.54, which expire between 2033 and 2034

BAM closed @ 51.53 USD on friday making those stock options worth $21 MM USD
they will be worth a whole lot more by the time he leaves office

come on man, he is an investment banker and knows what is held in his "blind Trust"

Blind trust means he doesn't know where his money is.
So how does he aid the businesses he invested in if he doesn't know who they are?
 
I commend you on your nuanced post. You considered both the pros and cons of immigration. The rest of the posters here do not. Either they want to expel all immigrants, or they want the doors flung wide open.

For the record, I share your views. I had no problem with a slow and steady rate of immigration, which is what we had before Trudeau. Unfortunately he blew up the targets, and now we need a pause.
Trudeau was doing something that needed to be done....just poorly. Canada has/had a great immigration program which rated applicants on a points system that brought in the most qualified. But, bringing in the number of people his government did was a huge mistake. But, the challenge is we still need to bring people in. Ideally, we move them to less populated areas to help build them up. Imagine more large cities across Canada. Now, that won't fix all the issues that come with more folks, but it is something that could somehow be accomplished.

I think I look at it from this perspective - immigration has helped make Canada the dynamic place that it is. I remember my dad telling me how boring Toronto was in the late 50s/early 60s. Restaurants basically served meat and potatoes and we had crappy laws around booze and clubs. A diverse mix of post-war immigration helped change that. Then we got the influx of Asians and what not, and now we have so many food options and colourful festivals like Caribanna or what not. But, I recognize the razor wire line the government needs to walk across to do it right....and I don't know if there is really a way of doing it without pissing someone off...
 
Trudeau was doing something that needed to be done....just poorly. Canada has/had a great immigration program which rated applicants on a points system that brought in the most qualified. But, bringing in the number of people his government did was a huge mistake. But, the challenge is we still need to bring people in. Ideally, we move them to less populated areas to help build them up. Imagine more large cities across Canada. Now, that won't fix all the issues that come with more folks, but it is something that could somehow be accomplished.

I think I look at it from this perspective - immigration has helped make Canada the dynamic place that it is. I remember my dad telling me how boring Toronto was in the late 50s/early 60s. Restaurants basically served meat and potatoes and we had crappy laws around booze and clubs. A diverse mix of post-war immigration helped change that. Then we got the influx of Asians and what not, and now we have so many food options and colourful festivals like Caribanna or what not. But, I recognize the razor wire line the government needs to walk across to do it right....and I don't know if there is really a way of doing it without pissing someone off...
Absolutely, the booze laws and movie censorship was ridiculous, especially in Ontario. And food options have improved. But the 50s to the 70s was a time of rising real wages for working people and we had a much smaller population. And real estate was cheaper. Of course, North America had a head start with countries like Germany and Japan bombed out and China was not even in the game.
 
you need to do your homework properly or else no one will take you seriously

AI Overview


Yes, Mark Carney holds numerous investments outside of Brookfield. [1, 2]
According to financial disclosures published by Canada's Ethics Commissioner, his asset portfolio includes: [1]
    • Stripe Inc.: Shares in the global financial technology and payment processing company (where he formerly served on the board). [1, 2]
    • Third-Party Managed Investment Account: A broad portfolio of 567 individual stocks managed through a blind trust, which heavily skews toward international technology, consumer, and finance companies (such as Alphabet, Amazon, and Airbnb), with very few direct Canadian holdings
    • Deferred Share Units & Compensation: In addition to the unexercised options, Carney accumulated deferred share units and performance-linked compensation tie-ins (such as those connected to the Brookfield Global Transition Fund) from his tenure as chair and senior executive at the firm
in addition
his holdings in Brookfield Asset Management are 409,300 unexercised stock options with a strike price of $37.54, which expire between 2033 and 2034

BAM closed @ 51.53 USD on friday making those stock options worth $21 MM USD
they will be worth a whole lot more by the time he leaves office

come on man, he is an investment banker and knows what is held in his "blind Trust"
So quickly copy pasting AI regurgitated content without fact checking is you doing your "homework"? No wonder we need immigrants. lmfao.
 
Based on what exactly? Provide your facts that shows it's quite significant.
The fact that the Canadian government had to source those TFWs shows that Canadians either could not or would not take those jobs which is very significant which means that for whatever reasons, sufficient numbers of Canadians are unable to satisfy industries labour market demands and requirements . As the population ages and service needs increase in many sectors , even more workers will have to be brought in to take up the slack.
Ironically those complaining the most about immigration are those that complain when services are cut and or wait times increase or projects cannot be completed on time .
 
The fact that the Canadian government had to source those TFWs shows that Canadians either could not or would not take those jobs which is very significant which means that for whatever reasons, sufficient numbers of Canadians are unable to satisfy industries labour market demands and requirements . As the population ages and service needs increase in many sectors , even more workers will have to be brought in to take up the slack.
Ironically those complaining the most about immigration are those that complain when services are cut and or wait times increase or projects cannot be completed on time .
I’m asking you to show me that fact.
 
Blind trust means he doesn't know where his money is.
So how does he aid the businesses he invested in if he doesn't know who they are?

Trump also has a blind trust. Which is his defence when asked why his net worth has jumped about 3 fold in two years.

Carney and Trump are good at making money, they just go about it in different ways.

Honestly, I’m not nearly as worried about Carney’s personal financial activity as long as the well being of the population is getting better. unfortunately the affordability crisis in Canada isn’t improving much. Also, often when asked for status update on projects that started long ago there are very vague answers at best and press conferences cut short at worst.

I respect that he’s held positions of power in the financial sectors of governments and large corporations…..where people in his position don’t require accountability. But that is not what he signed up for as prime minister.
 
I’m asking you to show me that fact.
Is this fact not self evident by the Government of Canada’s action, listening to and supporting industry and not worrying about bipartisanship from the Official Opposition which is not likely to form a government anytime soon.and their aggrieved supporters. Any job performed by a TFW, whether skilled or unskilled is one most likely where a Canadian equivalent never showed up.
 
It is.
Job availability to employment isn't 1:1.
What evidence do you have that shows these 150K unemployed tradesmen are looking for a job, are located in regions where these jobs are available, are even interested in these jobs, or are even skilled in the specific trade in which these jobs are available?
 
  • Like
Reactions: lomotil
I think I look at it from this perspective - immigration has helped make Canada the dynamic place that it is. I remember my dad telling me how boring Toronto was in the late 50s/early 60s. Restaurants basically served meat and potatoes and we had crappy laws around booze and clubs. A diverse mix of post-war immigration helped change that. Then we got the influx of Asians and what not, and now we have so many food options and colourful festivals like Caribanna or what not. But, I recognize the razor wire line the government needs to walk across to do it right....and I don't know if there is really a way of doing it without pissing someone off...

It sounds like your parents weren't very adventurous. Toronto had its Chinatown, Little Italy and Little Portugal neighborhoods back then. Add to that pockets of French and Slavic influences.

Clearly, there has been more immigration from Asia and Africa. I am just challenging the idea that Toronto restaurants only had meat and potatoes in the late 50s/early 60s.
 
Trudeau was doing something that needed to be done....just poorly. Canada has/had a great immigration program which rated applicants on a points system that brought in the most qualified. But, bringing in the number of people his government did was a huge mistake. But, the challenge is we still need to bring people in. Ideally, we move them to less populated areas to help build them up. Imagine more large cities across Canada. Now, that won't fix all the issues that come with more folks, but it is something that could somehow be accomplished.

I don't think moving immigrants to less populated areas to help build them has any historical precedence.

Due to immigrant networks and economic gravity most immigrants will still wind up in Toronto, Montreal and Vancouver. If Alberta experiences an energy boom, Calgary could take on a large amount of immigrants.

As far as immigrants populating dying small cities, towns and rural areas, it's not going to happen.
 
Primarily, many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada which is a good part of what the angst is about and is the elephant in the room.
That is the elephant in the room. By not allowing an honest and open debate about it, the government has empowered the xenophobes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lomotil
That is the elephant in the room. By not allowing an honest and open debate about it, the government has empowered the xenophobes.
Not wanting to see people from the Indian subcontinent is automatically xenophobia which you've already pointed to earlier. So what could one possibly debate there?
Nazis do what Nazis do.
 
Absolutely, the booze laws and movie censorship was ridiculous, especially in Ontario. And food options have improved. But the 50s to the 70s was a time of rising real wages for working people and we had a much smaller population. And real estate was cheaper. Of course, North America had a head start with countries like Germany and Japan bombed out and China was not even in the game.

Real estate inflation is global, though.
Wage losses are as well, but that's neoliberalism for you.

If you travel, you have to understand Toronto as pretty special, diverse, open and safe. Even with our homeless and housing issues.
And remember, immigration was largely at the behest of Timmies and businesses looking for cheaper labour and schools and the people making cash of immigration and student loans.