The Israel Lobby

Is the Pope Catholic?

I see Frank liked this, so you are both agreed that no one can become President without approval from Israel?
Thus the moment Israel said it wanted Trump to win, it was a forgone conclusion that Biden (and eventually Harris) would lose?
 
Not particularly.
I wouldn't be asking whether or not you are actually willing to commit to this as what you believe if it were.

I think its worthy of debate, at present it seems there is endless money for Israel and its wars but not for americans.
There are more bills defending Israel and criticism of Israel now, as well.



President Carter, the one who campaigned on and delivered the Israel Anti-Arab Boycott Act of 1977, which prohibited American companies from cooperating with the Arab boycott by refusing to do business with Israel?
I think you repeatedly told me that Reagan ordered Israel around and that's why it was obvious that any President of the United States can stop all Isreali action with a phone call.
But of course, no-one took AIPAC money until 2021 since AIPAC didn't have a PAC before then.

Carter who called Israel aparthied.
Are you claiming there was no Israeli lobbying money before 2021?


Sure.
"Heavily influenced."
Israel has had an extremely powerful lobby in the US for years and enjoyed broad bi-partisan support which has been crumbling over the course of the new millennium and in freefall for almost a decade now.

Freefall in popularity but not in government control. Which leads to the occupation discussion.

Clarify it.
For instance, that image, which I presume if from Track AIPAC -- have you made the equivalent for any other lobbying group?
Also, given you went with this, I presume you are doubling down on "occupied" as being the correct word?

Do your own homework, provide the names and stats of other larger lobbying influences.
I'm sure the AI gang is up there, but who else?
 
I see Frank liked this, so you are both agreed that no one can become President without approval from Israel?
Thus the moment Israel said it wanted Trump to win, it was a forgone conclusion that Biden (and eventually Harris) would lose?

Its not that they can't, its that they face way more money running against them along with other systemic issues.
You don't think the primaries show this?
 
Thus the moment Israel said it wanted Trump to win, it was a forgone conclusion that Biden (and eventually Harris) would lose?
Why do you think Biden gave them 20 billion in his last year, and Kamala sucked up to them, even though Bibi had made it clear that Trump was his preferred candidate? The Israel lobby owns both parties.
 
I think its worthy of debate, at present it seems there is endless money for Israel and its wars but not for americans.
There are more bills defending Israel and criticism of Israel now, as well.

There has always been more money for the war machine.
The "more bills defending Israel and criticism of Israel" is an interesting thread though.
They have been consistent since at least the early 2010s.

Carter who called Israel aparthied.

Yes, but let us not pretend he was some kind of anti-Israel crusader.

Are you claiming there was no Israeli lobbying money before 2021?

Of course not.
There was no "AIPAC" money.
If you want to short hand all "Pro-Israel" money as "AIPAC" money, I'm not sure that's really valid.

Freefall in popularity but not in government control. Which leads to the occupation discussion.

OK.
So what would be required to prove to you the US isn't occupied?

Do your own homework, provide the names and stats of other larger lobbying influences.
I'm sure the AI gang is up there, but who else?


Here's the top SuperPACs in the 2024 cycle.

The United Democracy Project is 14th on that list, behind two separate cryptocurrency SuperPACs.
 
There has always been more money for the war machine.
The "more bills defending Israel and criticism of Israel" is an interesting thread though.
They have been consistent since at least the early 2010s.

Sure, but they are getting more and more extreme now.
Like the bill saying university funding will be cut if they criticize Israel.

Yes, but let us not pretend he was some kind of anti-Israel crusader.
Fair.


Of course not.
There was no "AIPAC" money.
If you want to short hand all "Pro-Israel" money as "AIPAC" money, I'm not sure that's really valid.

How would you characterize it then?


OK.
So what would be required to prove to you the US isn't occupied?

Great, I get to decide.
Tell me the options.

Here's the top SuperPACs in the 2024 cycle.

The United Democracy Project is 14th on that list, behind two separate cryptocurrency SuperPACs.

Much of that list is like the SLF, a way to move money around without making it quite so obvious where its coming from.
 
Sure, but they are getting more and more extreme now.
Like the bill saying university funding will be cut if they criticize Israel.

If you are talking about the recent one that passed
then you can see it strips funds for boycotting Israel, not for criticizing it.

How would you characterize it then?

Unless you are saying any money ever spent to promote Israel as a concept is exactly the same, I'm not sure if you can bundle it all with AIPAC, which seems to have a specific rightest agenda (and there may well be debate about when that happened).

But that's part of the general problem of using "money=speech" since it isn't always obvious what is being said with the money.

Great, I get to decide.
Tell me the options.

I'm trying to point out that without some measure of what "occupied" means or what proves it isn't happening, it becomes an impossible debate.
It's just rhetoric at that point.
Which, fine, rhetoric and hyperbole is part of politics, but then don't get mad when people just dismiss it as hyperbolic rhetoric.

Much of that list is like the SLF, a way to move money around without making it quite so obvious where its coming from.

I don't know what you mean by the SLF here.
But yes, dark money is difficult to track.
That said, if the data from open secrets is useless because any of it could be secret israeli money, then it is hard to use the data from open secrets to criticize anyone.
 
If you are talking about the recent one that passed
then you can see it strips funds for boycotting Israel, not for criticizing it.

You think that makes it ok?
That bill means universities will have to invest in Israeli actions or be accused of boycotting.
Its only Florida that I know of that's made it illegal to criticize Israel.

Unless you are saying any money ever spent to promote Israel as a concept is exactly the same, I'm not sure if you can bundle it all with AIPAC, which seems to have a specific rightest agenda (and there may well be debate about when that happened).

But that's part of the general problem of using "money=speech" since it isn't always obvious what is being said with the money.

Explain how money to support 'Israel as a concept' is different from AIPAC money.

I'm trying to point out that without some measure of what "occupied" means or what proves it isn't happening, it becomes an impossible debate.
It's just rhetoric at that point.
Which, fine, rhetoric and hyperbole is part of politics, but then don't get mad when people just dismiss it as hyperbolic rhetoric.

You could define metrics, for instance when all foreign money is banned from elections.
Or when declaring allegiance to Israel is no longer necessary for politicians.
There are lots of options.

I don't know what you mean by the SLF here.
But yes, dark money is difficult to track.
That said, if the data from open secrets is useless because any of it could be secret israeli money, then it is hard to use the data from open secrets to criticize anyone.

Senate Liberation Fund.
Open Secrets notes that a lot of that money can't be tracked.
 
You think that makes it ok?
That bill means universities will have to invest in Israeli actions or be accused of boycotting.

Of course not.
It's a shitty bill on its own merits and in the hands of this administration it's an even worse loaded gun for abuse.
I was correcting your mis-characterization of the bill is all.


Its only Florida that I know of that's made it illegal to criticize Israel.

Can I be arrested in Florida if I say Israel's actions in Gaza violate international law?

Explain how money to support 'Israel as a concept' is different from AIPAC money.

AIPAC has become an explicitly pro-Likud organization.
Do you think the only view of Israel that exists is the Likud one?

You could define metrics, for instance when all foreign money is banned from elections.
Or when declaring allegiance to Israel is no longer necessary for politicians.
There are lots of options.

That's why I asked you.
OK - "Declaring allegiance to Israel is no longer necessary" will count as not being occupied?
Also the removal of all foreign money from elections? Or are you arguing for a threshold under which it will no longer be an occupation?

Senate Liberation Fund.
Open Secrets notes that a lot of that money can't be tracked.

Yes.
Everyone knows lots of money can't be tracked.
That's been the complaint about dark money from the beginning.
By that argument, it is impossible to claim that Israel is spending the most since no one can tell who is funding what.
 
Of course not.
It's a shitty bill on its own merits and in the hands of this administration it's an even worse loaded gun for abuse.
I was correcting your mis-characterization of the bill is all.

fair


Can I be arrested in Florida if I say Israel's actions in Gaza violate international law?

Yes, there is a student facing 15 years for making a joke about Netanyahu right now.
I hear the co-author of the IHRA Florida bill was also arrested for pissing in the mouth of his own grandson. That charge carries the death sentence there.


AIPAC has become an explicitly pro-Likud organization.
Do you think the only view of Israel that exists is the Likud one?

Why do you say that?
Why not discuss the views of anti zionist Jews instead?


That's why I asked you.
OK - "Declaring allegiance to Israel is no longer necessary" will count as not being occupied?
Also the removal of all foreign money from elections? Or are you arguing for a threshold under which it will no longer be an occupation?

I'm not interested in following this discussion, its clear you are looking for gotcha lines.
The idea of an occupied government is in discussion, your line of argument is designed to try to shut down discussion.
I'm interested in discussion.


Yes.
Everyone knows lots of money can't be tracked.
That's been the complaint about dark money from the beginning.
By that argument, it is impossible to claim that Israel is spending the most since no one can tell who is funding what.

Except the numbers you already posted show that even without all dark money listed its still the largest source of money.
You are just attempting to muddy the waters to dispute that argument.
 
Yes, there is a student facing 15 years for making a joke about Netanyahu right now.

That seems a misrepresentation of the case.

While this seems very fucked up, it is being positioned as a bomb threat, not an arrest for criticizing Israel.

I hear the co-author of the IHRA Florida bill was also arrested for pissing in the mouth of his own grandson. That charge carries the death sentence there.

Seems he wasn't the co-author (but was involved in sponsoring it) but the whole disgusting abuse all seems true. He may have been co-author of the bill that makes it a death sentence, though.

Why do you say that?
Why not discuss the views of anti zionist Jews instead?

I'm pointing out that if you make all "pro-Israel" money AIPAC then you are including everything from anti-zionist jews to people lobbying for things like desalination plants.

I'm not interested in following this discussion, its clear you are looking for gotcha lines.
The idea of an occupied government is in discussion, your line of argument is designed to try to shut down discussion.
I'm interested in discussion.

You said two sentences ago you aren't interested in discussion.
Just own that, Frank.

Fine.
"Occupied" is just hyperbolic rhetoric and should be dismissed as such.
Shame.
I thought you were going to actually try for once.

Frank.
You made a claim and now, when asked to defend it, you chicken out.
It's a pattern.

All you have to do is define what makes it an "occupied" government and within that is what would show it isn't.

Except the numbers you already posted show that even without all dark money listed its still the largest source of money.
You are just attempting to muddy the waters to dispute that argument.

No, it isn't the largest source of money.
There are 13 things above it.
You've just decided that those are also secretly Israeli money if you want them to be.[/QUOTE]
 
That seems a misrepresentation of the case.

While this seems very fucked up, it is being positioned as a bomb threat, not an arrest for criticizing Israel.

This is what she said, hardly a bomb threat against Israel:
“Netanyahu if you can hear me drop some bonbons for us capstone students in Ocean Bank Convention Center.”

Seems he wasn't the co-author (but was involved in sponsoring it) but the whole disgusting abuse all seems true. He may have been co-author of the bill that makes it a death sentence, though.

That's so much better.

I'm pointing out that if you make all "pro-Israel" money AIPAC then you are including everything from anti-zionist jews to people lobbying for things like desalination plants.

BDS, val, BDS.
Cut all funding.

You said two sentences ago you aren't interested in discussion.
Just own that, Frank.

Fine.
"Occupied" is just hyperbolic rhetoric and should be dismissed as such.
Shame.
I thought you were going to actually try for once.

See, still aiming for the gotcha line from instead of discussing the actual issue.

Frank.
You made a claim and now, when asked to defend it, you chicken out.
It's a pattern.

All you have to do is define what makes it an "occupied" government and within that is what would show it isn't.

Same thing here.

No, it isn't the largest source of money.
There are 13 things above it.
You've just decided that those are also secretly Israeli money if you want them to be.
[/QUOTE]

Your own sources listed AIPAC/Israeli funding as way more.

 
This is what she said, hardly a bomb threat against Israel:
“Netanyahu if you can hear me drop some bonbons for us capstone students in Ocean Bank Convention Center.”

She was arrested for making a bomb threat against Israel.
She was charged with making a bomb threat against a school.

That's so much better.

It's more specifically ironic.

BDS, val, BDS.
Cut all funding.

In that case, then yes you should group all "Pro-Israel" funding as one thing.

See, still aiming for the gotcha line from instead of discussing the actual issue.

You really are unable to debate or discuss something, aren't you?
It's kind of amazing.

Your own sources listed AIPAC/Israeli funding as way more.

Huh.
It's just gonna be straight denial then?
Didn't expect that.[/QUOTE]
 
She was arrested for making a bomb threat against Israel.
She was charged with making a bomb threat against a school.

Florida will have to work hard to keep up with the UK, they've arrested over 3,000 this year being against the genocide.


It's more specifically ironic.
Or more specifically Epstein state ironic.


In that case, then yes you should group all "Pro-Israel" funding as one thing.
Do you have a reason why that shouldn't happen?


You really are unable to debate or discuss something, aren't you?
It's kind of amazing.

I'd love to debate the subject, but you only want to debate the language of my posts.

Huh.
It's just gonna be straight denial then?
Didn't expect that.

?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Florida will have to work hard to keep up with the UK, they've arrested over 3,000 this year being against the genocide.

So what is the Florida law that makes it a crime to criticize Israel?
It wasn't used here, and I'm curious how it could be leveraged to rack up UK numbers.

Do you have a reason why that shouldn't happen?

I'm more concerned with the stuff that is specifically supporting Likud and the expansionist war machine shit.
Mind you, it is hard enough to track money anyway, so you have to make compromises on the level of detail.

I'd love to debate the subject, but you only want to debate the language of my posts.

Because you need to use language when communicating.
When you say "the US is under Israeli occupation" you either mean something by that or you don't.


77 > 70
 
So what is the Florida law that makes it a crime to criticize Israel?
It wasn't used here, and I'm curious how it could be leveraged to rack up UK numbers.

That law passed in 2019, don't know if its been used.

Rubio tried to pass a law saying he could strip away passports for criticism.
Looks like they are more likely to get people fired or sick ICE on them rather than put them on trial.


I'm more concerned with the stuff that is specifically supporting Likud and the expansionist war machine shit.
Mind you, it is hard enough to track money anyway, so you have to make compromises on the level of detail.

I think you need to stop thinking its just Likud, its all of Israeli society now.
And yeah, its pretty impossible to track or stop.

Because you need to use language when communicating.
When you say "the US is under Israeli occupation" you either mean something by that or you don't.

Again, you want quantitative methodology on a political ideology.
How about when america decides to stop funding Israeli war crimes and funds americans instead?
Or how about when dual allegiances or foreign allegiances aren't allowed in office?
I'm sure you have better metrics in mind, share them.
 

That can't be it, that's a law about conduct policies in schools and other administrative things.
It doesn't criminalize anything.

Rubio tried to pass a law saying he could strip away passports for criticism.
Looks like they are more likely to get people fired or sick ICE on them rather than put them on trial.

That was a law for Rubio, not by him.
And it was for "material support for terrorists" although I have no doubt they would have tried to argue that "saying bad things about someone" despite the definition in the bill:

(A) including currency or monetary instruments or financial securities, financial services, lodging, training, expert advice or assistance, safehouses, false documentation or identification, communications equipment, facilities, weapons, lethal substances, explosives, personnel (one or more individuals who may be or include oneself), and transportation;

Again, you want quantitative methodology on a political ideology.

Definitions are not quantitative methodology.

How about when america decides to stop funding Israeli war crimes and funds americans instead?

OK - that's a definition.
Occupied means they fund Israeli "war crimes".
So is every country the US funds which commits a war crime also "occupying" the US government?

Or how about when dual allegiances or foreign allegiances aren't allowed in office?
I'm sure you have better metrics in mind, share them.

So any dual Canadian citizen in government means that Canada is occupying the USA?[/QUOTE]
 
That can't be it, that's a law about conduct policies in schools and other administrative things.
It doesn't criminalize anything.

Could be this, which just uses the IHRA definition to declare criticism of Israel to be antisemitism.
or this boycott one


Definitions are not quantitative methodology.

sure, but....

OK - that's a definition.
Occupied means they fund Israeli "war crimes".
So is every country the US funds which commits a war crime also "occupying" the US government?

You need to factor in how much of that funding then becomes funding for lobbying on behalf of that country.
Not just whether america funds them, but also how much they fund american politicians.
Again, this sounds like you trying to find gotcha terms for later debate.

So any dual Canadian citizen in government means that Canada is occupying the USA?

How would you phrase that definition to cover those issues?
Banning dual citizens from office doesn't seem that outrageous, does it?
Even if your term isn't 'occupation', but just divided loyalty, its reasonable.
 
Could be this, which just uses the IHRA definition to declare criticism of Israel to be antisemitism.
or this boycott one

Neither of those criminalize criticizing Israel.
The closest is adopting the IHRA definition, especially along with the examples.

Oh wait - its probably this: https://www.flsenate.gov/Session/Bill/2023/269/?StartTab=BillText#BillText
Take that, combine it with the IHRA definition and a state government that wants to abuse it and you can get to criminalizing criticism of Israel without too much trouble.

sure, but....

You need to factor in how much of that funding then becomes funding for lobbying on behalf of that country.
Not just whether america funds them, but also how much they fund american politicians.
Again, this sounds like you trying to find gotcha terms for later debate.

Of course you view it that way.
You realize just saying "occupied" might require you to back it up and you don't think that's fair.
Of course, if "occupied" is just rhetorical hyperbole and not meant to mean anything literal, then you don't have this problem.

How would you phrase that definition to cover those issues?
Banning dual citizens from office doesn't seem that outrageous, does it?
Even if your term isn't 'occupation', but just divided loyalty, its reasonable.

There are lots of countries that ban dual citizenship people from office.
Neither the US nor Canada is among them.
Hell, in Canada, you don't even need to be a Canadian citizen to be prime minister, if I remember correctly.