How does one reconcile religion with SW?

I lean towards this theory: Mary Magdalene was one of Jesus' Disciples, and perhaps his muse/ confidant. There was some jealousy involved on the part of the other 11 or 12 because of her preferential status.

After His death, there was a power struggle, and Mary was voted out. The others sought to discredit her by tarnishing her reputation. She may well have shared a different 'gospel' to a different and smaller group of followers somewhere else, and that message has not survived in written form, or remains undiscovered or untranslated.

This same group dynamic scenario has played out in mankind for centuries, both before and after 'year one ', wherever and whenever those who think their beliefs are truths.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing
You are misunderstanding me. I'm suggesting that Magdala may have been Mary Magdalene's hometown.
Ah, so you were adding context and information. My apologies for misunderstanding.

There are biblical scholars who are disputing the idea that Mary Magdalene was from Magdala.

Here are two articles about that position:



A few lines from the latter:

"(T)he archaeological site known today as Magdala (…) was actually called Taricheae in the time of Jesus and Mary Magdalene. (… M)any scholars argue that it is not at all clear that Mary’s biblical nickname (“the Magdalene”) means that she was from a place named Magdala."

Since (as John’s Gospel indicates) Mary Magdalene’s brother and sister were living in Bethany at the time of the crucifixion, it seems likely that the family was from there, not Magdala or Taricheae.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing
Ah, so you were adding context and information. My apologies for misunderstanding.

There are biblical scholars who are disputing the idea that Mary Magdalene was from Magdala.

Magdalene may also be a code word, where the town's name is unimportant, but it's primary industry in ancient times is.

... for centuries. Everyone assumed that Mary Magdalene was a prostitute who had anointed Jesus.

Everyone assumed that because the Catholic Church told them that was true.

Keep in mind that none of Jesus' disciples are the authors of the New Testament Gospels. They all existed as oral traditions decades before they were written down. It's very likely that the actual authors picked and chose what they would commit to quill and papyrus, and what they had heard as reference was unlikely to have been identical to what was originally said. Most stories told have at least some embellishment, and that increases whenever the story is retold.

Who knows the actual original sources for John's Gospel? John may have just 're-tweeted' something some guy told him, and that guy heard it from someone else.

Biblical scholarly debates mean nothing, as is always true when conclusions use assumptions for the basis of conclusions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing
I'm so glad a concept of a "god" created earth and already knew as our sun (a star) will get big enough to kill off all humanity and eventually destroys this planet then that star will blow up too.

You didn't exist before 2 people decided to have intercourse. You won't exist once you're dead. Enjoy life, it's a short ride.
I believe in a body spirit and soul
 
I suggest you look into philosophy courses as you come to understanding lifes journey for yourself.
I suggest you watch the chosen show and the movie Mary with Joaquin phoenix and his now wife.
i suggests you do internet searches on historical prostitutes and concubines in different regions of the world.
I suggest you read about different religions And keep in mind the barrier of language and context and who transcribed and translated.
I suggest you consider we were and are a patriarchal Society.
I suggest you consider who leads the religious places and their gender identity and why them.
look into the I am movement or theory To compare.
I’m suggest you watch the show fleabag.
Watch the movie inner worlds outer worlds.
there are two providers at former Cupids who were very religious and often shared the same struggles as you.
if you want to dm me I could give you their working names. I don’t think they have social media that I could connect you through though.
 
Everyone assumed that (Mary Magdalene was a prostitute who had anointed Jesus) because the Catholic Church told them that was true.
You’re saying that the Catholic Church wanted people to believe that Jesus was anointed by a prostitute?

The church adopted the Pauline anti-prostitution stance. The heads of the church had no motive to want people to believe the story. People did not believe that the Magdalene was a prostitute who had anointed Jesus because the church wanted them to believe it. They believed it because it was in the Bible, and they believed it despite the church’s teachings on prostitution.

Keep in mind that none of Jesus' disciples are the authors of the New Testament Gospels. They all existed as oral traditions decades before they were written down. It's very likely that the actual authors picked and chose what they would commit to quill and papyrus, and what they had heard as reference was unlikely to have been identical to what was originally said.
I think that the story really happened, but whether it did or not, it speaks to an attitude that the earliest followers of Jesus must have had about prostitution. Even if they invented the story, it gives a prostitute an exalted role. She made Jesus a christ.

And if the earliest followers had that attitude (which ran counter to their culture’s attitude), they probably got it from Jesus.

That attitude was unfortunately replaced by Paul’s negative one about prostitution.
 
The church adopted the Pauline anti-prostitution stance.

I see Paul as the Vince McMahon of Christianity.

I am not Christian. I don't believe that Jesus was God. I don't think Jesus saw himself as God, and I don't think that anyone who heard words directly from his mouth believed that He was God. I understand the positive and negative contributions of Religion to society and civilization, and the positive and negative effects that it has on individuals. I've read some scripture but from an objective point of view, as a sociologist or anthropologist might observe group dynamics, but my motive is just curiosity.

I attended Catholic Church for a few years before 1970, and one other Church service in the early 1990's, after accepting a personal invitation to attend a Christmas eve service at a Protestant Church; I don't recall the particular denomination. I understand that some people need Religion as an 'anchor' in their life. I just don't happen to be one of them. I'm also not interested in further discussion of my own personal spiritual beliefs and my cynicism towards the Institution of Religion with strangers on a message board.

Don't expect me to reply further on this topic in this thread. Additional discussion about this doesn't interest me. I have other things that I would rather do with my time.
 
I see Paul as the Vince McMahon of Christianity.

I am not Christian. I don't believe that Jesus was God. I don't think Jesus saw himself as God, and I don't think that anyone who heard words directly from his mouth believed that He was God. I understand the positive and negative contributions of Religion to society and civilization, and the positive and negative effects that it has on individuals. I've read some scripture but from an objective point of view, as a sociologist or anthropologist might observe group dynamics, but my motive is just curiosity.

I attended Catholic Church for a few years before 1970, and one other Church service in the early 1990's, after accepting a personal invitation to attend a Christmas eve service at a Protestant Church; I don't recall the particular denomination. I understand that some people need Religion as an 'anchor' in their life. I just don't happen to be one of them. I'm also not interested in further discussion of my own personal spiritual beliefs and my cynicism towards the Institution of Religion with strangers on a message board.

Don't expect me to reply further on this topic in this thread. Additional discussion about this doesn't interest me. I have other things that I would rather do with my time.
Thank you for your well-informed and interesting perspective, Onomatopoeia. The Paul-as-Vince-McMahon comparison is an amusing one. Do I agree or disagree? I don’t know — I’m thinking about it! I might need some time to contemplate the matter.
 
I'm not sure there is a God

One thing I'm sure of is that he is not as big an Asshole as the people that claim to know him best say he is
The great quote attributed* to Gandhi: "I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians."

* no real evidence he said it but it's become a useful meme.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Endurance2024
Mary Magdalene was a huge character in Jesus life...one of the oldest profession....I would say without the SWs there would be a lot more wars
That was Lee Kwan Yu's philosophy when he legalized brothels in Singapore. The country had lots of male guest workers and thus Lee felt that men who have safe, clean, and legal outlets will behave better and not assault women etc. Although heaps of other factors involved, Singapore has one of the lowest crime rates.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing
@RealMilanaMiro I add something small.

How did you reconcile with previous boyfriends. For example when you bumped into them later in life? How did you behave?.
Or I am sure you got into fights or arguments with your parents, did you reconcile later and continue on with them?

Don't tell anyone or the religious leader that you did this job SP for a living. Just say you are or were a stock person at Walmart. And you will be okay
Remember the religious leader has also sinned.

I asked AI and I like this idea...


To reconcile means to restore friendly relations, make two conflicting ideas compatible, or accept an unpleasant situation.

Common Meanings

Relationships
: Becoming friends again after a major argument or period of separation. Don't have to become friends but let it go, and move on.

Ideas: Proving that two opposing or contradictory facts can actually both be true or work together.

Acceptance: Resigning yourself to a hard or painful reality that cannot be changed.
 
Last edited:
Most people who believe in whatever god tend to do so because of some pain or guilt or they follow in their parent(s) footsteps I suppose. The concept of a god helps ease that pain. Then they search for a religion that helps fit into their narrative. I find many tend to pick and choose things even from the one main religion they decide to go with. Personally, at the end of the day if it helps you sleep better at night and slowly makes you into a better person then great. Thinking about blowing up some tower at a major city? Ah....how about no.
Ah you’re still in the towers were blown for religious purposes camp
 
  • Like
Reactions: shadeau
I am religious (Catholic) and I do practice catholicism as much as I can e. g. going to church every other Sunday.

At the same time, I’ve been working as an independent escort since 2024 (on and off).

I don’t exactly lose my sleep over it, but I do have a cognitive dissonance of sorts. At the same time, there’s nobody whom I would trust enough to share this information with.

Maybe there are other SPs or maybe even clients who feel the same way -- if yes, I would love to hear your perspective.

Side note: I don’t feel guilty or embarrassed, I am just sharing my personal experience.

View attachment 640582


Let’s sin together
 
McVeigh...
I had no memory of Timothy McVeigh being motivated by religion. So I asked AI this:

“Did Timothy McVeigh blow up the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building for a religious reason?”

The AI says no, that "McVeigh was motivated by extreme anti-government views and anger toward federal law enforcement.”

It elaborates that "He targeted the federal building to avenge the deaths of members of the Branch Davidian religious sect during the 1993 Waco siege and the 1992 Ruby Ridge standoff.”

While the Branch Davidians were a religious group, checking Wikipedia, it doesn’t seem that McVeigh shared their religious views or held particularly strong opinions about religion. And the Ruby Ridge incident doesn’t seem to have had anything to do with religion.

I asked AI and looked up the matter on Wikipedia — that's hardly in-depth research on my part. I suspect that there’s a lot of misinformation on Wikipedia about McVeigh and Ruby Ridge. So maybe, Greensquare, you have a better source of information that conclusively establishes that McVeigh was motivated by religion. But at this point in time, despite my sceptical opinion that Wikipedia’s entry about McVeigh is probably wrong in all sorts of ways, I’m not inclined to see McVeigh as being motivated by religion.
 
The beauty of the Catholic Church, all sins are forgiven in the confessional! Sin all week and go to confession have all your sins forgiven just rinse and repeat
every time you go to confess you put some money into the collection box

Church is like big pharma

they do not want to cure you

church wants sinners to sin and big pharma wants you sick

repeat customers are good for business :)