How does one reconcile religion with SW?

Just do like most Jewish guys do, Eat kosher at home and when outside eat bacon and ham like pigs are going extinct. I saw this Jewish guy at a wedding eating shrimp like the ocean was drying up.

If it was a an orthodox Jewish wedding, it was fake shrimp, made out of fish. Just like we have kosher sushi.

It helps the attendees to feel a little naughty...
 
if you believe that god exists

then you have to assume that he created the "Assholes" as well as the saints

the sun shines equally on roses and poison ivy
Although I am a devout atheist, I am far more likely to take the evidence of what happens, and has happened, both historically, and daily, on Earth, and to believe in the existence of a malevolent deity...
 
I am religious (Catholic) and I do practice catholicism as much as I can e. g. going to church every other Sunday.

At the same time, I’ve been working as an independent escort since 2024 (on and off).

I don’t exactly lose my sleep over it, but I do have a cognitive dissonance of sorts. At the same time, there’s nobody whom I would trust enough to share this information with.

Maybe there are other SPs or maybe even clients who feel the same way -- if yes, I would love to hear your perspective.

Side note: I don’t feel guilty or embarrassed, I am just sharing my personal experience.

View attachment 640582
What answers did you expect to get from an escort review forum? 😂
 
Although I am a devout atheist, I am far more likely to take the evidence of what happens, and has happened, both historically, and daily, on Earth, and to believe in the existence of a malevolent deity...
I am afraid that I will regret getting into a conversation about God with a Jewish guy :)

I remember this joke:

"Two old men are discussing if there is or isn't a God

third old man hears the conversation and says:

if there is no God then this conversation is for nothing

but if there is a God, then this conversation could have serious consequences"
 
believe in the existence of a malevolent deity...

some believe that Earth is a jail created by higher beings who harvest our negative emotions and feed on them

fear, hate, anger, guilt, jealousy, shame to name a few are just low level energy that feeds our owners

and reincarnation is just a way they keep us here so they can keep feeding on our misery

that's why there is so much suffering on earth
 
I'm agnostic but have gone through the going to church stuff when I was very young. IMO, the only conflict you have is more personal in your belief in God vs your work as an escort. There are times we all doubt ourselves regarding certain things in our lives but work them out and move on. And I perceive this may be the OP's concern, how to make peace with her religious beliefs vs having worked as an escort. If you're proud of both the work you did as an escort and your belief in God then I don't see any problems. Just enjoy the happiness and pride you have in both.

LTO_3
 
I am religious (Catholic) and I do practice catholicism as much as I can e. g. going to church every other Sunday.

At the same time, I’ve been working as an independent escort since 2024 (on and off).

I don’t exactly lose my sleep over it, but I do have a cognitive dissonance of sorts. At the same time, there’s nobody whom I would trust enough to share this information with.

Maybe there are other SPs or maybe even clients who feel the same way -- if yes, I would love to hear your perspective.

Side note: I don’t feel guilty or embarrassed, I am just sharing my personal experience.

View attachment 640582
Thanks for sharing this. I’m not at all religious, however we all will experience different types of cognitive dissonance in participating in the world of the sex trade.

I’ll just say this. Many “devout” religious people in our world will profess their love and devotion to their god, while at the same time bomb the shit out of other people who don’t agree with them, when killing is probably the most major sin in any religion. I think your “transgressions” are relatively mild.😊

Remember, Jesus did not judge or shun prostitutes, he forgave them, and offered them mercy, while criticizing the hypocrites like I illustrated above. Like I said, I’m not at all religious, but I think he would forgive you. I would also imagine that the real “sin” one commits when doing sex work is having extramarital sex/ adultery. You are in good company with the vast majority of society.
 
If it was a an orthodox Jewish wedding, it was fake shrimp, made out of fish. Just like we have kosher sushi.

It helps the attendees to feel a little naughty...
Not an Orthodox Jewish wedding, real shrimps and lobsters. This family knows all the best Chinese restaurants where they give you the large shrimps. They told me about a Chinese restaurant ( not kosher ) that had a large Jewish clientele where they would often see Jews they know dining there. ( isn't that like seeing someone leaving a rub and tug as you are going in )
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Not an Orthodox Jewish wedding, real shrimps and lobsters. This family knows all the best Chinese restaurants where they give you the large shrimps. They told me about a Chinese restaurant ( not kosher ) that had a large Jewish clientele where they would often see Jews they know dining there. ( isn't that like seeing someone leaving a rub and tug as you are going in )

Lots of Conservative Jews keep kosher at home, but anything goes in restaurants.

My parents were like that.

from Wikipedia:

Jewish-American patronage of Chinese restaurants

Jewish-American patronage of Chinese restaurants is a cultural phenomenon, particularly associated with Christmas, that emerged in American Jewish culture in early 20th century New York City.
The tradition developed as large Jewish and Chinese immigrant communities lived in close proximity on Manhattan's Lower East Side. They were, as observers noted, "bound by proximity and otherness" as the two largest non-Christian immigrant groups. Chinese restaurants welcomed Jewish customers compared to the antisemitism Jews experienced in the eateries of other immigrant groups, lacked Christian iconography, and appeared compatible with Jewish dietary laws because the food did not mix milk and meat. Despite the presence of pork and shellfish, the chopping and concealment of ingredients allowed many Jews to view the cuisine as acceptable.

By the 1930s, Chinese restaurants were firmly established in Jewish neighborhoods, and eating Chinese food on Christmas became a ritualized alternative to a holiday not usually celebrated by Jews. Over time, the practice evolved into a marker of American Jewish culture, celebrated for reinforcing community bonds, symbolizing assimilation, and reflecting the ongoing construction of Jewish identity in the United States.

Jewish-Canadian too... :geek:
 
I am religious (Catholic) and I do practice catholicism as much as I can e. g. going to church every other Sunday.

If you have gone to church you will know that are not much different than your visit. You teach men about one of God's most amazing gifts and pass the collection plate after the sermon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SlitherBeth
I am religious (Catholic) and I do practice catholicism as much as I can e. g. going to church every other Sunday.

At the same time, I’ve been working as an independent escort since 2024 (on and off).

I don’t exactly lose my sleep over it, but I do have a cognitive dissonance of sorts. At the same time, there’s nobody whom I would trust enough to share this information with.

Maybe there are other SPs or maybe even clients who feel the same way -- if yes, I would love to hear your perspective.

Side note: I don’t feel guilty or embarrassed, I am just sharing my personal experience.

View attachment 640582

KING DAVID:
    • The Lust: David saw Bathsheba bathing from his palace roof. He desired her and brought her to the palace.
    • The Pregnancy: Bathsheba became pregnant with David's child.
    • The Failed Cover-Up: David called Uriah back from the war. He wanted Uriah to sleep with his wife to hide the pregnancy. Uriah refused because his fellow soldiers were still sleeping in tents during the battle.
    • The Murder Plot: David sent a secret order to his army commander, Joab. He told Joab to put Uriah at the front of the fiercest battle and pull the other troops back so Uriah would be killed.
    • The Confrontation: Uriah died in battle. David then married Bathsheba. God sent the prophet Nathan to expose David's sin. David confessed and repented of what he had done.
So the answer to whatever consternation you may have is in the Bible itself.

If God forgave David for having the husband of a woman he desired killed in battle so he could marry the woman Bathsheba, I am sure he can forgive you for making you insanely hot so you can bring happiness to so many of his deprived children.
All you have to do is write a book in repentance just like David wrote the bulk of the Book of Psalms after committing murder.
 
I do have a cognitive dissonance of sorts. (…) Maybe there are other SPs or maybe even clients who feel the same way -- if yes, I would love to hear your perspective.
Milana, I am a client who has been paying for sex for decades. I am also a non-denominational Christian. (I was raised as a protestant, not a Catholic). I believe there is a God and I pray every day. (Well, maybe I accidentally miss the occasional day.) Your church attendance is better than mine — I show up once in a while (always because a friend or family member is going and I’m tagging along).

I’ve read enough of the Bible to know that one can find harsh condemnations of prostitution in it, particularly in the Christian New Testament.

I resolve the seeming contradiction this way: I take the Bible seriously, but I don’t believe that it is the “word of God”. Reading the Bible, I’ve spotted too many contradictions to think that that makes sense. The Bible was written by men, flawed men who, even if they were frequently inspired by God, nevertheless were able to make mistakes.

I find the words in the New Testament of writers like Paul and John of Patmos to be interesting, but I also take them with a grain of salt. (I mention those two because they’re probably the most harsh in relation to “harlots”.) I consider them to be mistaken on this point.

I pay much more attention to the words of Jesus. I’m a Christian, not a Paulian or a Johnian. And the words of Jesus, as recorded in the Bible, never condemn prostitution.

Indeed, a detail that complicates the discussion of Jesus and prostitution is rarely discussed.

“Messiah” and “christ” are the Hebrew and Greek words for the same concept: the anointed one. Jesus was “The Anointed One”. That meant that someone had to anoint Him. In “Old Testament” anointings, the anointer was always a man. A man who was either a prophet or a priest — in other words, a man with religious authority.

That’s not the case for Jesus. The four biblical gospels give four very similar accounts of the anointing of Jesus (in Matthew chapter 26, Mark chapter 14, Luke chapter 7, and John chapter 12). They are accounts of the same event, an event in which Jesus was anointed, not by a man, but by a woman.

In Luke’s gospel, she's described as “a woman who was a sinner”. In John’s gospel, she's named — her name was Mary. And because this Mary was walking around with her hair publicly exposed, we know that she was a prostitute. (In the ancient world, it was seen as sexually provocative for a woman to expose her hair publicly — only prostitutes did so.) I note that Mary’s hair was publicly displayed during the anointing, indicating that she was still a prostitute at the time of the anointing. (This wasn’t something that she had repented of and left in the past.)

The only other significant person with the name Mary in John’s gospel is Mary Magdalene. (The name of the mother of Jesus is not given in that gospel.) So it’s sensible to conclude that the anointer of Jesus was Mary Magdalene.

This is the reason why Mary Magdalene was traditionally considered to be a prostitute. Only recently have various Christian denominations and biblical scholars been attempting to “rehabilitate” the image of Mary Magdalene by vehemently denying that she was a prostitute. I suspect that these MM image-rehabilitators are motivated by whorephobia, but they’re ignoring the solid scriptural reasons for the traditional view.

So why did Jesus arrange for a prostitute to anoint him? I have no idea, but it’s not what one would do if one had a negative impression of prostitution. It was a provocative and bold thing to do, even if we’re not exactly sure of the message that Jesus intended to convey.

Milana, there’s my reply to your request for the perspective of people like me.

/////////////////

I imagine that the atheists who’ve already responded to Milana will have a field day with my answer.

“If you admit that there are contradictions in the Bible, why pay any attention to it?”

“You’re just cherry-picking the stuff from the Bible that serves your bias and your lifestyle!”

Atheism makes no sense to me. I can not relate at all to a materialistic world-view that posits that life has no spiritual meaning and that we and our world were created through random chance. It is obvious to me that intelligent design is on display all around us. Those of you who are atheists will disagree, and that’s fine. I’m not trying to convince you or argue with you. I’m not writing this post for you. I’m writing it because a fellow Christian asked for my opinion (or, at least, for the opinions of Christians who sell sexual services or pay for them).
 
@shadeau: Every other woman mentioned in the New Testament had Mary as their given name. Ancient surnames were often derived from someone's occupation or their hometown. Magdala was a town on the shores of the sea of Galilee.

Various theories have been advanced that Jesus and Mary Magdalene were married, that Mary was pregnant when Jesus was crucified, and that Mary left Judea and gave birth in France.

A stylized image of a fish was often used as an early symbol for Jesus. It may or not be a coincidence that the primary industry of Magdala was the preservation, (using salt) of fish, and primarily for export to Europe.
 
@shadeau: Every other woman mentioned in the New Testament had Mary as their given name. Ancient surnames were often derived from someone's occupation or their hometown. Magdala was a town on the shores of the sea of Galilee.

Various theories have been advanced that Jesus and Mary Magdalene were married, that Mary was pregnant when Jesus was crucified, and that Mary left Judea and gave birth in France.

A stylized image of a fish was often used as an early symbol for Jesus. It may or not be a coincidence that the primary industry of Magdala was the preservation, (using salt) of fish, and primarily for export to Europe.

The Old Testament is pretty funny also regarding the names of women.

This isn’t as good as the musical Book Of Mormon, but it is still damn good.


Lot’s wife is not given a name in the Old Testament, so in the movie Lot just yells Lot’s Wife when he is trying to find her in the decadent town of Sodom.

A fun fact is that Sodom and Gomorrah are the only Biblical places mentioned in multiple sources in ancient writings. Even then, such harbor cities with prostitution were widely mentioned with love by people who looked forward to visiting them. Nobody gave a shit even back then if there were gays, as long as the straight sailors and travelers got what they wanted.

It likely blew up from a chemical explosion and then burned. The moralists said God did it. Not much has changed in the subsequent thousands of years.

Lot’s daughter is smoking hot in the movie. She has sex in the movie with a good-looking suitor. Unlike in the Holy Bible, where she and her sister have sex with their father, Lot. The censors and editors do have more sense now than thousands of years ago when they put that incest bit in the Holy Bible.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing
@shadeau: Every other woman mentioned in the New Testament had Mary as their given name. Ancient surnames were often derived from someone's occupation or their hometown. Magdala was a town on the shores of the sea of Galilee.

Various theories have been advanced that Jesus and Mary Magdalene were married, that Mary was pregnant when Jesus was crucified, and that Mary left Judea and gave birth in France.

A stylized image of a fish was often used as an early symbol for Jesus. It may or not be a coincidence that the primary industry of Magdala was the preservation, (using salt) of fish, and primarily for export to Europe.
Onomatopoeia, if I’m misunderstanding you, please feel free to correct me, but you seem to be saying that, because Magdala was in Galilee, Mary Magdalene therefore could not possibly have been in Bethany (which is where Jesus was anointed) because the two locations were many miles apart from each other. You’re forgetting the passage from Luke’s Gospel — 8:1 & 2 — that states that the Magdalene was travelling with Jesus and his disciples.

You also note that Mary was a popular name at the time. Very true, but if the author of John’s Gospel (who, for convenience, I’ll call John) had wanted to make it clear that the Mary who had anointed Jesus was a different person from the Mary who attended the crucifixion and talked to Jesus shortly after his resurrection, it would have been easy for John to do so. All he would have had to do is write, when he introduced the Magdalene at the crucifixion, something like this:

“This was a different woman from the one who anointed Jesus.”

Or maybe:

“This was a different woman from the one who was the sister of Lazarus.”

Without a clarification like that, the natural way to read the gospel is to assume that the two Mary’s were one. We know that that is the natural way to read the passages because that IS how the text was read and understood by readers for centuries. Everyone assumed that Mary Magdalene was a prostitute who had anointed Jesus.

It also just makes sense that the woman who anointed Jesus had some sort of special connection with him and would have attended the crucifixion and, later, the tomb.

But, Onomatopoeia, you might say that John could have carelessly forgotten to indicate that the two Marys were separate women. And you might be correct — the gospel writers (probably) didn’t have editors. So, for the sake of argument, let’s say that you are right, and there were two Marys: Mary Magdalene and anointer-Mary, whose last name is never given. That doesn’t change my main point, that the Mary who anointed Jesus was a prostitute.

Yes, of course I’m aware of the myths or legends that Jesus was married to MM and she gave birth to His child in France. This was popularized, as I’m sure you know, in the famous novel and film The Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown. That sort of speculation is fun, but I don’t have a strong opinion on the matter one way or the other.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Muchadoaboutnothing