Former German Army head exposes lies about Ukraine war.

This. It isn't unreasonable for Russia to consider NATO a threat. I think most countries in Russia's position would.
However, the decision to go to war, to mitigate that threat, was ill conceived - which could be debated, but not sure what Russia has really gained from all this.

This is part of what is so frustrating to me.
"The poor Russians forced by the evil NATO Imperial Machine" is just as naive and idiotic a thought process as "The Saintly West attacked by the Evil Orc Hordes of Moscow(Mordor)".
There are years of actual choices by actual people in various evolving international contexts that got people here.
 
One problem at a time. Iceland is an island, Finland is a problem but if you will notice all the most dangerous attacks on Russia in its history come from the West. Logistics dictate that. If an attack is coming through Finland or Norway Russia will be easily able to spot it and blockade the buildup. But if Finland decides to host US nukes, things could get very rocky for them. Notice Stubb actually called Putin a week ago. With the US being defeated by Iran, the European Chihuahuas are realizing Article 5 IS just a piece of paper and in a real war with Russia they will be on their own.

Wait til the Dems take full control in 2028 and see if NATO is a Chihuahua. The smartest thing Putin has ever done and probably the only smart thing, is to install his puppet in the WH.
 
Those morons deserve to be cut out. Every discussion is they want Russia to surrender. Russia did not surrender with the Nazis were just outside Moscow. And if the EU somehow got them to a point to consider surrender, they would wipe out Germany and Poland first and NATO would back down and do fuck all. That the reality, and reality is all that matters in war. Fantasies only get more people killed.

What do you consider "surrender" by Russia?
What surrender is Europe demanding?
 
No need to demand Russia to surrender. Strategically
it is actually better for Putin not to surrender at this
time but to let him fight on.

Europe can win the proxy war without having to
defeat Russia militarily.
 
What do you consider "surrender" by Russia?
What surrender is Europe demanding?
They are demanding that Russia leave all occupied Ukraine and pay reparations. Ukraine wants Putin to stand trial. The loony EUs even charged him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
No need to demand Russia to surrender. Strategically
it is actually better for Putin not to surrender at this
time but to let him fight on.

Europe can win the proxy war without having to
defeat Russia militarily.

Depends on what you consider a win. They are broke and getting more broke. Russia has been revitalized by this war and the sanctions. EU is in deep decay. Even the UK has backed off its nato GDP spend goals because they are BROKE. All of the EU is bleeding out and every EU leader is mostly hated by their people. Mean while Putin is still very popular. Russia has pivoted away from Europe permanently. I don't think there will be a cordial relationship with Russia and the EU in our lifetimes TBH.
 
They are demanding that Russia leave all occupied Ukraine and pay reparations. Ukraine wants Putin to stand trial. The loony EUs even charged him.

So for you, Russia leaving the places they invaded is "surrender"?

Or is it only surrender if they turn Putin in for trial?
 
Depends on what you consider a win. They are broke and getting more broke. Russia has been revitalized by this war and the sanctions. EU is in deep decay. Even the UK has backed off its nato GDP spend goals because they are BROKE. All of the EU is bleeding out and every EU leader is mostly hated by their people. Mean while Putin is still very popular. Russia has pivoted away from Europe permanently. I don't think there will be a cordial relationship with Russia and the EU in our lifetimes TBH.

You really need to get your facts straight!

AI Overview


Russia's wartime economy is slowing down and facing a growing budget deficit as massive military spending on the war in Ukraine strains public finances and household budgets. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Key Economic Indicators & Trends
    • GDP Growth: Growth is expected to slow sharply to around 0.8% to 1.1% in 2026 due to tight monetary policy, high borrowing costs, and capacity constraints. [1, 2]
    • Budget & Fines: The federal budget deficit is widening significantly, leading authorities to hike taxes and propose a fivefold increase in fines for economic crimes to raise an anticipated 1.7 trillion rubles ($20.5 billion) in total fines through 2026–2029. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Energy & Trade Revenue: Net oil and gas federal tax revenues fell 14% year-on-year in the first ten months of 2026 to 6.44 trillion rubles, hurt by Western sanctions and Ukrainian strikes on refineries. Meanwhile, gold shipments to Asian markets like Hong Kong have surged. [1, 2, 3]
    • Inflation & Labor: Businesses and consumers face high interest rates, severe labor shortages, rising food and household costs, and structural pressures from a shifting domestic market. [1, 2, 3]
    • Pensions & Savings: Financial strain has prompted moves to restructure pension funds, transferring trillions of rubles into voluntary long-term programs to help absorb fiscal pressures. [1]
 
Depends on what you consider a win. They are broke and getting more broke. Russia has been revitalized by this war and the sanctions. EU is in deep decay. Even the UK has backed off its nato GDP spend goals because they are BROKE. All of the EU is bleeding out and every EU leader is mostly hated by their people. Mean while Putin is still very popular. Russia has pivoted away from Europe permanently. I don't think there will be a cordial relationship with Russia and the EU in our lifetimes TBH.
Europe will pay the price of the rising of the far-right.
 
Europe will pay the price of the rising of the far-right.

Can you elaborate?
Is the rise of the far right an example of "EU in deep decay"?
Is it a consequence of the Russian war?
Is it a price paid because "Russia has pivoted away from Europe permanently" or perhaps it is what will cause Russia to pivot like that?
 
Does AI know Ukraine as it was before the war no longer exist?

You really need to get your facts straight!

AI Overview


Russia's wartime economy is slowing down and facing a growing budget deficit as massive military spending on the war in Ukraine strains public finances and household budgets. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Key Economic Indicators & Trends
    • GDP Growth: Growth is expected to slow sharply to around 0.8% to 1.1% in 2026 due to tight monetary policy, high borrowing costs, and capacity constraints. [1, 2]
    • Budget & Fines: The federal budget deficit is widening significantly, leading authorities to hike taxes and propose a fivefold increase in fines for economic crimes to raise an anticipated 1.7 trillion rubles ($20.5 billion) in total fines through 2026–2029. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Energy & Trade Revenue: Net oil and gas federal tax revenues fell 14% year-on-year in the first ten months of 2026 to 6.44 trillion rubles, hurt by Western sanctions and Ukrainian strikes on refineries. Meanwhile, gold shipments to Asian markets like Hong Kong have surged. [1, 2, 3]
    • Inflation & Labor: Businesses and consumers face high interest rates, severe labor shortages, rising food and household costs, and structural pressures from a shifting domestic market. [1, 2, 3]
    • Pensions & Savings: Financial strain has prompted moves to restructure pension funds, transferring trillions of rubles into voluntary long-term programs to help absorb fiscal pressures. [1]
 
Can you elaborate?
Is the rise of the far right an example of "EU in deep decay"?
Is it a consequence of the Russian war?
Is it a price paid because "Russia has pivoted away from Europe permanently" or perhaps it is what will cause Russia to pivot like that?

Rising cost of living is and will remain one key factor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Rising cost of living is and will remain one key factor.

So let me see if I follow the logic.

The war in Ukraine is a key driver of rising cost of living in Europe, this is driving the rise of the right wing.
IOW, the right wing issue is a knock on consequence of the war in general, and not tied to Russia directly.

Am I getting that right?
 
So let me see if I follow the logic.

The war in Ukraine is a key driver of rising cost of living in Europe, this is driving the rise of the right wing.

Ukraine doesn't have to be the key driver. The war can be a minor driver and
people may still want their leaders to stop wasting money on it. Far right
doesn't even have to be able to resolve the crisis faced by the people to win.


IOW, the right wing issue is a knock on consequence of the war in general, and not tied to Russia directly.

Am I getting that right?

 
Last edited:
Ukraine doesn't have to be the key driver. The war can be a minor driver and
people may still want their leaders to stop wasting money on it. Far right
doesn't even have to be able to resolve the crisis faced by the people to win.





I didn't say it did.

You said that "Europe will pay the price of the rising of the far-right" in the context of your conversation with nottyboi about what would constitute "winning" and whether the EU even has to.

So that is you drawing an explicit link.
Now you are decoupling the two a bit.

I am trying to get you to clarify what you are trying to say here about Europe and the far right and how it is a price of Ukraine.

Or are you saying that a price of letting the far right rise will be Europe "losing" in Ukraine?

You clearly have a theory of the issue here, but it isn't clear to me what it is.
 
IOW, the right wing issue is a knock on consequence of the war in general, and not tied to Russia directly.

Am I getting that right?

Putin might have secretly funded the anti-fracking campaign
in the U.S. Don't know how much the far-right owes to him for
their surge so far.
 
So for you, Russia leaving the places they invaded is "surrender"?

Or is it only surrender if they turn Putin in for trial?

Yes if they leave the places they have annexed by referendum then they are surrendering land that by the Russian constitution is now part of Russia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
You really need to get your facts straight!

AI Overview


Russia's wartime economy is slowing down and facing a growing budget deficit as massive military spending on the war in Ukraine strains public finances and household budgets. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Key Economic Indicators & Trends
    • GDP Growth: Growth is expected to slow sharply to around 0.8% to 1.1% in 2026 due to tight monetary policy, high borrowing costs, and capacity constraints. [1, 2]
    • Budget & Fines: The federal budget deficit is widening significantly, leading authorities to hike taxes and propose a fivefold increase in fines for economic crimes to raise an anticipated 1.7 trillion rubles ($20.5 billion) in total fines through 2026–2029. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Energy & Trade Revenue: Net oil and gas federal tax revenues fell 14% year-on-year in the first ten months of 2026 to 6.44 trillion rubles, hurt by Western sanctions and Ukrainian strikes on refineries. Meanwhile, gold shipments to Asian markets like Hong Kong have surged. [1, 2, 3]
    • Inflation & Labor: Businesses and consumers face high interest rates, severe labor shortages, rising food and household costs, and structural pressures from a shifting domestic market. [1, 2, 3]
    • Pensions & Savings: Financial strain has prompted moves to restructure pension funds, transferring trillions of rubles into voluntary long-term programs to help absorb fiscal pressures. [1]
After many years GDP is being constrained to about that of Canada with VERY HIGH RATES to contain inflation. 20B deficit in a huge war? That is LESS then a fart in the wind. Add up the EU, US And Canada deficit in 2025 and you get 2 450 000 BILLION 122x Russias deficit lol.

Multibillion dollar war on Russias oil and its down 14% boo hoo. As it says, MASSIVE gold shipments at huge prices

Labor shortages inflation economy is overheated. in the first 10 months the Russian Fed revenues are up 11% from 2025. Sure there are problems, but more growth pressures.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer
So let me see if I follow the logic.

The war in Ukraine is a key driver of rising cost of living in Europe, this is driving the rise of the right wing.
IOW, the right wing issue is a knock on consequence of the war in general, and not tied to Russia directly.

Am I getting that right?

Any time populations experience declining standards of living the demagogues come out. Same with Canada and PP, Smith etc.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer