Former German Army head exposes lies about Ukraine war.

As well, Putin had drawn his line in the sand very openly, on a number of occasions. After the fall of the Soviet Union, the U.S. had committed to not pushing further east with NATO,

You know this is a subject of serious debate concerning what informal promises were given.
The only thing we know for sure is that no formal promises, treaties, or agreements were given.
Unless you have new evidence you would like to present.

instead they increased membership from 12 to 32, all further east.
Putin drew the line at Ukraine and the coup in 2014 to install a pro American government just capped it off.
Regardless of whose side anyone is on, the facts are the facts.

Yes, the number of NATO countries increased after 1991.
From 16 to 32. All of these through sovereign countries making the choice to try and join NATO.
And yes, Russia and Putin have said more than once that sovereign countries taking actions they dislike politically are a justification for war. (An explanation we usually don't accept when the US does it.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
And others who widely disagree.
That Putin and Russia consider any distancing of states near them into closer alignment with NATO and the EU a threat is a very real thing.
That therefore, they have the right to settle political changes they dislike via military force is not the obvious conclusion that comes from that.
It is clear Trump considers North America not doing what he wants inappropriate. He has threatened and used economic and military force to keep these countries within his sphere of influence in line.
Most people don't consider that acceptable either.



Evidence please?
I remember following this very closely at the time, I'm giving you my perspective, I'm not going to waste time so people can then split hairs over who's credible or not i.e. Harald Kujat, a four star general for Germany who's always had skin in the game against Russia, who is in the right circles, has nothing to gain, and more to lose in standing.
The Americans blew up Nord Stream 2, it's common knowledge. They're the only ones capable of pulling it off, Biden telegraphed his intentions, but I guess it didn't happen that way because there is nothing directly linking them to it.
 
Last edited:
I remember following this very closely at the time, I'm giving you my perspective, I'm not going to waste time so people can then split hairs over who's credible or not i.e. Harald Kujat, a four star general who is in the right circles, has nothing to gain, and more to lose in reputation.

Why on Earth would you think he has nothing to gain?
His job is political pundit now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
LoL... incredible... I knew my instincts were right.

Your instincts that I would point out his occupation?
He is paid to make appearances and offer commentary.
He therefore has commentary to offer.
This doesn't mean he is lying.
It just means the statement "he has nothing to gain" is silly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
Your instincts that I would point out his occupation?
He is paid to make appearances and offer commentary.
He therefore has commentary to offer.
This doesn't mean he is lying.
It just means the statement "he has nothing to gain" is silly.
Lol....Whatever
 
1794269037010.png
 
Because Ukraine has held off a far larger power for 5 years and now appears to be winning. So the article is bullshit.

The west has enabled Ukraine to keep fighting on not by making
Ukraine stronger than Russia on the battlefield. Winning the proxy
war against Putin eventually will be the biggest misfortune for the
people of Ukraine.
 
Russia decided to go to war.
Russia decided its political goals would be better advanced militarily.
It had its reasons.
People will disagree on how good those reasons were.
This. It isn't unreasonable for Russia to consider NATO a threat. I think most countries in Russia's position would.
However, the decision to go to war, to mitigate that threat, was ill conceived - which could be debated, but not sure what Russia has really gained from all this.
 
Because Ukraine has held off a far larger power for 5 years and now appears to be winning. So the article is bullshit.

Appears to be winning? Do you realize there is a meeting with the USA and Russia and Ukraine this week in Abu Dhabi? Europeans are explicitly NOT INVITED. TOLD DO NOT COME. Yeah Ukraine is winning. lol
 
Come on, they gained NATO closer to their border via Finland and Iceland. ;)

One problem at a time. Iceland is an island, Finland is a problem but if you will notice all the most dangerous attacks on Russia in its history come from the West. Logistics dictate that. If an attack is coming through Finland or Norway Russia will be easily able to spot it and blockade the buildup. But if Finland decides to host US nukes, things could get very rocky for them. Notice Stubb actually called Putin a week ago. With the US being defeated by Iran, the European Chihuahuas are realizing Article 5 IS just a piece of paper and in a real war with Russia they will be on their own.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: squeezer
Appears to be winning? Do you realize there is a meeting with the USA and Russia and Ukraine this week in Abu Dhabi? Europeans are explicitly NOT INVITED. TOLD DO NOT COME. Yeah Ukraine is winning. lol
That's because Trump is trying to cut the Europeans out, so he can suck Putin's dick more and Ukraine simply shrugs and shows up not to be impolite.

Nothing's going to happen at the meeting. Kushner and Witkoff will demand huge personal payoffs and that Ukraine relinquish Donbass in return for nothing whatsoever from Puttin. And Ukraine will politely refuse and continue to inflict 8:1 casualties on the Vatniks
 
One problem at a time. Iceland is an island, Finland is a problem but if you will notice all the most dangerous attacks on Russia in its history come from the West. Logistics dictate that. If an attack is coming through Finland or Norway Russia will be easily able to spot it and blockade the buildup. But if Finland decides to host US nukes, things could get very rocky for them. Notice Stubb actually called Putin a week ago. With the US being defeated by Iran, the European Chihuahuas are realizing Article 5 IS just a piece of paper and in a real war with Russia they will be on their own.
Ghengis Khan?

The Tartars?
 
One problem at a time. Iceland is an island, Finland is a problem but if you will notice all the most dangerous attacks on Russia in its history come from the West. Logistics dictate that. If an attack is coming through Finland or Norway Russia will be easily able to spot it and blockade the buildup. But if Finland decides to host US nukes, things could get very rocky for them. Notice Stubb actually called Putin a week ago. With the US being defeated by Iran, the European Chihuahuas are realizing Article 5 IS just a piece of paper and in a real war with Russia they will be on their own.
Putin will pay Trump to break Article 5, but it doesn't matter. Poland alone could beat Russia at this point. Let France, Germany and the UK pile on.
 
Putin will pay Trump to break Article 5, but it doesn't matter. Poland alone could beat Russia at this point. Let France, Germany and the UK pile on.
Lol yeah that is utterly delusional. UK has like 20K fighting men, most of them gave their weapons to Ukraine and with 2 wars ongoing the USA cannot replace them and the European industry is in shambles. Russia is outproducing NATO by about 4:1 and they can rely on NK and China and Iran for even more weapons. NK for many many soldiers if Russian territory is attacked. Ukraine is losing, its bleeding out. Most of the women have left most of the men are dead, left, disabled or in the army.
 
That's because Trump is trying to cut the Europeans out, so he can suck Putin's dick more and Ukraine simply shrugs and shows up not to be impolite.

Nothing's going to happen at the meeting. Kushner and Witkoff will demand huge personal payoffs and that Ukraine relinquish Donbass in return for nothing whatsoever from Puttin. And Ukraine will politely refuse and continue to inflict 8:1 casualties on the Vatniks

Those morons deserve to be cut out. Every discussion is they want Russia to surrender. Russia did not surrender with the Nazis were just outside Moscow. And if the EU somehow got them to a point to consider surrender, they would wipe out Germany and Poland first and NATO would back down and do fuck all. That the reality, and reality is all that matters in war. Fantasies only get more people killed.