Former German Army head exposes lies about Ukraine war.

This is the "academic publication" that piece of shit writes for:


1794229200716.png

It's closely aligned with Putin, but occasionally throws in an article which is slightly more independent.

Nice try, Komrad!!
 
This is the "academic publication" that piece of shit writes for:


View attachment 673196

It's closely aligned with Putin, but occasionally throws in an article which is slightly more independent.

Nice try, Komrad!!

why don't you actually read the substance of the article you dumb dumb rather than toss it aside because it doesn't suit the delusional world you want to live in? Harald Kujat, a retired German four-star general, former Chief of Staff of the Bundeswehr and former Chairman of NATO’s Military Committee is what this opinion piece is based upon and he argues "that the Ukraine war has been prolonged by a series of false Western narratives: that Russia’s invasion was unprovoked, that Moscow intended to conquer all of Ukraine, that Ukraine could achieve military victory, that Russia was unwilling to negotiate, and that continued Western military assistance would eventually change the strategic balance. These assumptions have obstructed diplomatic solutions, contributed to Ukraine’s destruction and brought Europe dangerously close to direct confrontation with Russia." This perspective is gaining steam and Driesen and others have been saying this for years. but nahhhh, let's just ignore other perspectives because it makes my hero Zelensky look bad and makes my Boogie man Putin seem rational. we can't have that.
 
why don't you actually read the substance of the article you dumb dumb rather than toss it aside because it doesn't suit the delusional world you want to live in? Harald Kujat, a retired German four-star general, former Chief of Staff of the Bundeswehr and former Chairman of NATO’s Military Committee is what this opinion piece is based upon and he argues "that the Ukraine war has been prolonged by a series of false Western narratives: that Russia’s invasion was unprovoked, that Moscow intended to conquer all of Ukraine, that Ukraine could achieve military victory, that Russia was unwilling to negotiate, and that continued Western military assistance would eventually change the strategic balance. These assumptions have obstructed diplomatic solutions, contributed to Ukraine’s destruction and brought Europe dangerously close to direct confrontation with Russia." This perspective is gaining steam and Driesen and others have been saying this for years. but nahhhh, let's just ignore other perspectives because it makes my hero Zelensky look bad and makes my Boogie man Putin seem rational. we can't have that.

Well you cannot expect much of a simian 🙈🙉🙊🐒 actually no 🙊
 
It really is just a travesty on both sides, all that loss for no reason whatsoever, nothing has been accomplished
 
He retired in 2005, though, according to his biography.
So none of this is based on actual inside knowledge of what happened from 2008-2026.
He probably still has security clearance, at the very least he's still connected at the highest levels. I guy like him is always kept in the loop for his expertise and experience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
He probably still has security clearance, at the very least he's still connected at the highest levels. I guy like him is always kept in the loop for his expertise and experience.
Entirely possible, and he has his personal expertise to draw on.
But the phrasing of the pitch is very much to imply he was involved in all this when he clearly wasn't.
He's just another outside person making their own analysis.
Which is fine, he has every right to do that.
Just clarifying when he held the position in relation to the things he is commenting on.
 
Entirely possible, and he has his personal expertise to draw on.
But the phrasing of the pitch is very much to imply he was involved in all this when he clearly wasn't.
He's just another outside person making their own analysis.
Which is fine, he has every right to do that.
Just clarifying when he held the position in relation to the things he is commenting on.
Fair enough.
I'm not familiar with the article but as far as Russia's motivation for attacking and the West's involvement precipitating the attack, there were serious Western political scholars, critical of the West but pro West nonetheless, that supported this claim.
The deal that Putin and Zelensky agreed to in principle that would have ended the war after two weeks, and nixxed by the Americans was also confirmed by former high ranking diplomats and national security offiials at the time.
 
Last edited:
He retired in 2005, though, according to his biography.
So none of this is based on actual inside knowledge of what happened from 2008-2026.

You think he has no connections
It really is just a travesty on both sides, all that loss for no reason whatsoever, nothing has been accomplished

I can't say its without a reason for Russia, Having NATO on its border does present a real risk. Jeff Sachs has recounted a phone call with then NAt Sec Advisor. Jake Sullivan where Sullivan said Ukraine would never join NATO. To which Sachs asked him to say it publicly. But Sullivan said he could not do that. Sachs said there will be a war. Jake said noooo no war. And here we are.
 
why don't you actually read the substance of the article you dumb dumb rather than toss it aside because it doesn't suit the delusional world you want to live in? Harald Kujat, a retired German four-star general, former Chief of Staff of the Bundeswehr and former Chairman of NATO’s Military Committee is what this opinion piece is based upon and he argues "that the Ukraine war has been prolonged by a series of false Western narratives: that Russia’s invasion was unprovoked, that Moscow intended to conquer all of Ukraine, that Ukraine could achieve military victory, that Russia was unwilling to negotiate, and that continued Western military assistance would eventually change the strategic balance. These assumptions have obstructed diplomatic solutions, contributed to Ukraine’s destruction and brought Europe dangerously close to direct confrontation with Russia." This perspective is gaining steam and Driesen and others have been saying this for years. but nahhhh, let's just ignore other perspectives because it makes my hero Zelensky look bad and makes my Boogie man Putin seem rational. we can't have that.
Because Ukraine has held off a far larger power for 5 years and now appears to be winning. So the article is bullshit.
 
and probably 1.5-2m Ukrainian soldiers and Ukraine devastated. Just to expand NATO, which cannot even keep the straits of H open
8:1 casualty ratio of Russian: Ukrainian casualties in 2026.

Means Ukraine is winning BIG , Komradskyvich!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
You think he has no connections

On the contrary.
He may well have.
He may also be speaking bullshit.
What we have is someone who left his position in 2005 talking about things over the last 20 years.
He should be treated with the same amount of respect and caution most of these kinds of pundits deserve.

I can't say its without a reason for Russia, Having NATO on its border does present a real risk. Jeff Sachs has recounted a phone call with then NAt Sec Advisor. Jake Sullivan where Sullivan said Ukraine would never join NATO. To which Sachs asked him to say it publicly. But Sullivan said he could not do that. Sachs said there will be a war. Jake said noooo no war. And here we are.

Russia decided to go to war.
Russia decided its political goals would be better advanced militarily.
It had its reasons.
People will disagree on how good those reasons were.
 
You think he has no connections


I can't say its without a reason for Russia, Having NATO on its border does present a real risk. Jeff Sachs has recounted a phone call with then NAt Sec Advisor. Jake Sullivan where Sullivan said Ukraine would never join NATO. To which Sachs asked him to say it publicly. But Sullivan said he could not do that. Sachs said there will be a war. Jake said noooo no war. And here we are.
As well, Putin had drawn his line in the sand very openly, on a number of occasions. After the fall of the Soviet Union, the U.S. had committed to not pushing further east with NATO, instead they increased membership from 12 to 32, all further east.
Putin drew the line at Ukraine and the coup in 2014 to install a pro American government just capped it off.
Regardless of whose side anyone is on, the facts are the facts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shaquille Oatmeal
Fair enough.
I'm not familiar with the article but as far as Russia's motivation for attacking and the West's involvement precipitating the attack, there were serious Western political scholars, critical of the West but pro West nonetheless, that supported this claim.

And others who widely disagree.
That Putin and Russia consider any distancing of states near them into closer alignment with NATO and the EU a threat is a very real thing.
That therefore, they have the right to settle political changes they dislike via military force is not the obvious conclusion that comes from that.
It is clear Trump considers North America not doing what he wants inappropriate. He has threatened and used economic and military force to keep these countries within his sphere of influence in line.
Most people don't consider that acceptable either.

The deal that Putin and Zelensky agreed to in principle that would have ended the war after two weeks, and nixxed by the Americans was also confirmed by former high ranking diplomats and national security offiials at the time.

Evidence please?