Do You Remember Giving PM Carney A Mandate To Seek Associate EU Status?

On that note, we have the example of the U.K. politicians ceding certain authority to the EU without their citizens' approval.
Then there was all the wrenching consternation when the U.K. citizenry voted to leave the EU.

So repeated referendums and elections about the nature of the UK relationship to the EU were held.
Is this considered anti-democratic now?
 
So repeated referendums and elections about the nature of the UK relationship to the EU were held.
Is this considered anti-democratic now?
You can be more specific, can't you?

Several countries had specific votes whether to join or not join the EU.
I don't recall anything like that when the U.K. joined the EU.
In 1975, the U.K. voted to stay in the European Economic Community which was very different its reach.

My point is a direct referendum is a far more democratic way to make decisions that impact national sovereignty.
 
Nothing has been agree on yet. The mere fact that Canada and the EU has agreed to talk is a threat to Trump. It is a negotiating chip that Canada can use. Canada can not agree to any conditions where it would hinder trade with the USA or Asian countries. In the end there may be few or little agreement on loosening existing trade with the EU, maybe no change will result. Trump's time in office is limited. This talk about a Canada/EU trade agreement is a disadvantage to the current American administration.
 
So respectful of democracy they have unelected bureaucrates in brussels determining policy

i guess it is beyond your capabilities to ask why Britain wanted out
Right or wrong, Brexit is a red flag
Britain was mislead and regrets it. Carney warned them but Boris was a dolt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Britain was mislead and regrets it. Carney warned them but Boris was a dolt.


your comprehension is just as bad as your ideological impaired judgement
Right or wrong
, Brexit is a red flag


Carney’s dire record at the Bank of England is a warning to Canada

But there is one catch: Carney was a terrible Governor – and will prove to be a terrible prime minister as well.

There were four big problems with the way Carney ran the Bank. To start with, he printed way too much money, first in response to the financial crisis, and then to our departure from the EU. The result? The UK suffered from a spike in inflation that was way above the rest of our competitors.

Next, he lost control of regulation, allowing pension funds to invest far too much money into high-risk assets, paving the way for the LDI blow-up that helped end the premiership of the unfortunate Liz Truss.

Thirdly, he presided over a steep decline in the City, with the number of companies listing their shares in London in freefall, and while it would be unfair to blame that entirely on the Governor, it was certainly his job to figure out how to maintain London's status as one of the great financial centres of the world.

Finally, and perhaps most seriously, he politicized the Bank. He was a hardcore Remainer when it would have been better for the Bank to remain neutral, and then, even more disgracefully, after leaving office he very publicly endorsed the Labour Party at the last general election, even though a former Governor should remain above the fray.


And he committed the Bank to combatting climate change, when it was hard to see that it was ever part of its mandate – the Bank is meant to control inflation and maintain the stability of the financial system.

Meanwhile, growth stagnated and real wages stopped rising. On any measure you care to look at, Carney was the worst Governor of recent times. In the years since he left, Carney's successors at the Bank of England have been struggling to clear up the mess he left behind. His successors as Canadian PM will have to do the same – because Carney will prove just as deeply disappointing in that job as well.

you say 'Carney warned them'

consider yourself warned about Carney
And do not forget this is not the Liberal party of Jean Crietien / Paul Martin
This is the Liberal Party that let a complete moron / disaster Justin Trudeau lead them for a decade . the worst PM in Canadian history
 
On that note, we have the example of the U.K. politicians ceding certain authority to the EU without their citizens' approval.
Then there was all the wrenching consternation when the U.K. citizenry voted to leave the EU.

There is nothing being spoken of about our immigration policy, which was the primary reason for Brexit. Its about market access, ease for travelers(although its easy now). They are looking at work visas but they would likely only apply to people who have jobs lined up, and there would be limitations.

Thats it. We gain increased access to Euro markets. Thats 450 million. Right now they represent about 8.7% of our trade, and we have a deficit with them. We could likely double our side in ten years, evening that out.

Don't be so nervous dude, the US will still have access to us, you will just have to pay a bit more as other nations compete.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Britain was mislead and regrets it. Carney warned them but Boris was a dolt.

This is true, and not true. It was not really about economics, but about border policy. The EU wanted total control over it. Considering how even the EU wanted to go there, and even now continue to try, especially refugees, I wasn't surprised.

The EU should remain a trade bloc. Diving into national policy about foreign immigration is an overstep imo.
 
It worse than that.

On another site I explained, Carney was sent to secure Canada as an asset. Now the EU dictates our economy for their own gain.

The EU doesn't take orders, they give orders. There is no upside for Canada.

You think the EU is that united? Cripes then Why did France and Germany not want the title associate used? They run the damn thing.

That is some pretty crazy shit you wrote there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
Thats it. We gain increased access to Euro markets. Thats 450 million. Right now they represent about 8.7% of our trade, and we have a deficit with them. We could likely double our side in ten years, evening that out.

Don't be so nervous dude, the US will still have access to us, you will just have to pay a bit more as other nations compete.
Butler, all Canada can really do is sell energy to the EU.
That's a great thing. They're just not interested in importing other goods.
Frankly, the EU is getting attacked by Chinese exports.

Now the big question is how do you get it from the West to the Eastern ports.
I guess it's possible that the fossil fuel can make the long journey around Asia and the Mideast.
It just seems impractical that it would take that long, long trip going past so many oil producing countries.

You say you were very discerning of Trudeau's policies.
Now you have to decide what's substantive and what's show from Carney.
There is always show with politics. There should be no argument there.

This is what's going to happen. When Canada gets it butt in higher gear.
Alberta will amp up its energy production. It will be transported to B.C. ports.
That fossil fuel will hit the fungible commodity markets where it will compete on CIF price (cost, insurance and freight) including any extra refining costs.
I don't see a lot of that Alberta oil making its way to Europe for a very long time. Lots of infrastructure needed.
Then you have the Ontario and Quebec greens kicking and screaming as the West-East infrastructure is built.

The actual worst thing for Canada would be a peaceful (likely Putin-less) Russia and a peaceful Mideast.
Given the history of the Mideast, the latter seems less likely. Perhaps we can hope for a somewhat peaceful Mideast.
Europe kissing and making-up with Russia ain't that far-fetched.
 
Maybe seeking inferior membership of the EU isn't a
bad idea after all. Canada will be fighting climate change
alongside European climate lunatics. And the good
thing is we can finance the fight by exporting more oil,
gas and coal to Europe.
I heard the EU was developing oil tankers that run on solar and wind.
That would be a clean, efficient way to get Canadian oil to Europe.
 
Butler, all Canada can really do is sell energy to the EU.
That's a great thing. They're just not interested in importing other goods.
Frankly, the EU is getting attacked by Chinese exports.

Now the big question is how do you get it from the West to the Eastern ports.
I guess it's possible that the fossil fuel can make the long journey around Asia and the Mideast.
It just seems impractical that it would take that long, long trip going past so many oil producing countries.

You say you were very discerning of Trudeau's policies.
Now you have to decide what's substantive and what's show from Carney.
There is always show with politics. There should be no argument there.

This is what's going to happen. When Canada gets it butt in higher gear.
Alberta will amp up its energy production. It will be transported to B.C. ports.
That fossil fuel will hit the fungible commodity markets where it will compete on CIF price (cost, insurance and freight) including any extra refining costs.
I don't see a lot of that Alberta oil making its way to Europe for a very long time. Lots of infrastructure needed.
Then you have the Ontario and Quebec greens kicking and screaming as the West-East infrastructure is built.

The actual worst thing for Canada would be a peaceful (likely Putin-less) Russia and a peaceful Mideast.
Given the history of the Mideast, the latter seems less likely. Perhaps we can hope for a somewhat peaceful Mideast.
Europe kissing and making-up with Russia ain't that far-fetched.

Guess you didn't see the recent spy plane deal....

We have a lot of raw materials. But considering the pull back of the US and them increasing local military production suddenly aluminum, various petrol chemicals, and other materials are needed. And they can't trust Russian suppliers can they? Or American suppliers either at this point.

But yes this is going to be a process that starts with LNG out of Manitoba, the northern route. Look it up. And some other things. But why you can't see us doubling trade in ten years, considering the actual volumes involved and a larger market, we'll I don't get it.

The USA has created uncertainty. And chaos is a ladder. Whether you like it or not we are shifting our defense spending, and seeking and finding new markets. This is what you Yanks don't get. The almighty Dollar is not the primary priority now. Its our new understanding of how you REALLY think of us. We will take our business elsewhere where we can(and we can) just to say Fuck You. We will sell elsewhere to say Fuck You. We will travel elsewhere, or not at all, just to say Fuck You.

Air Canada just canceled all routes to South Carolina. US ski resorts chose not to a atrend a big convention in Ottawa knowing Canadians won't be coming. Ask you border towns how things are. Ask Vegas. Ask California. Ask Florida.

Trump and crew made it personal. And that matters. Anyone who knows about business knows once you really piss off a customer, this is the result.

You really need to step back and realize just how bad it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
Guess you didn't see the recent spy plane deal....

We have a lot of raw materials. But considering the pull back of the US and them increasing local military production suddenly aluminum, various petrol chemicals, and other materials are needed. And they can't trust Russian suppliers can they? Or American suppliers either at this point.

But yes this is going to be a process that starts with LNG out of Manitoba, the northern route. Look it up. And some other things. But why you can't see us doubling trade in ten years, considering the actual volumes involved and a larger market, we'll I don't get it.

The USA has created uncertainty. And chaos is a ladder. Whether you like it or not we are shifting our defense spending, and seeking and finding new markets. This is what you Yanks don't get. The almighty Dollar is not the primary priority now. Its our new understanding of how you REALLY think of us. We will take our business elsewhere where we can(and we can) just to say Fuck You. We will sell elsewhere to say Fuck You. We will travel elsewhere, or not at all, just to say Fuck You.

Air Canada just canceled all routes to South Carolina. US ski resorts chose not to a atrend a big convention in Ottawa knowing Canadians won't be coming. Ask you border towns how things are. Ask Vegas. Ask California. Ask Florida.

Trump and crew made it personal. And that matters. Anyone who knows about business knows once you really piss off a customer, this is the result.

You really need to step back and realize just how bad it is.
What your missing is that the U.S. is reconfiguring how it supports trade around the entire globe?
It can no longer stay committed to being the global buyer of excess supply for unlimited amounts .
This is impacting every trading nation in the world.

My prediction is (and its one many economists with an eye on global trade imbalances make) global trade will recede to large, regional trade blocs.
It doesn't get a lot of press, but Europe is getting more protectionist.
Canada's best bet is trying to trade as much non-energy as they can within North America.
I suspect that after Trump things will cool off quickly, but I don't think Canada will be able to go back to choosing what goods and services trade freely with the U.S. and what are restricted. That seems like a fairly innocuous statement to me.

By the way, energy is a global commodity that is in great demand. It can go anywhere at any time without many trade restrictions.
Canada should have no problem expanding energy exports over time.
Interestingly, the Canadian dollar has been trading in the low 70s versus the U.S. dollar.
Given Canada is a big energy producer, that's a terrible indicator when oil has been over $100 a barrel.
When oil was over $100 a barrel for much of 2011-2014, the Canadian dollar was trading around parody with the U.S. dollar.

As I tell others here, you don't want to just read and watch what makes you feel good. You want to be more discerning of the media you consume.
I doubt the media you follow is pointing out this contrast of the 2011-2014 period vs. today.
 
What your missing is that the U.S. is reconfiguring how it supports trade around the entire globe?
It can no longer stay committed to being the global buyer of excess supply for unlimited amounts .
This is impacting every trading nation in the world.

My prediction is (and its one many economists with an eye on global trade imbalances make) global trade will recede to large, regional trade blocs.
It doesn't get a lot of press, but Europe is getting more protectionist.
Canada's best bet is trying to trade as much non-energy as they can within North America.
I suspect that after Trump things will cool off quickly, but I don't think Canada will be able to go back to choosing what goods and services trade freely with the U.S. and what are restricted. That seems like a fairly innocuous statement to me.

By the way, energy is a global commodity that is in great demand. It can go anywhere at any time without many trade restrictions.
Canada should have no problem expanding energy exports over time.
Interestingly, the Canadian dollar has been trading in the low 70s versus the U.S. dollar.
Given Canada is a big energy producer, that's a terrible indicator when oil has been over $100 a barrel.
When oil was over $100 a barrel for much of 2011-2014, the Canadian dollar was trading around parody with the U.S. dollar.

As I tell others here, you don't want to just read and watch what makes you feel good. You want to be more discerning of the media you consume.
I doubt the media you follow is pointing out this contrast of the 2011-2014 period vs. today.

You think I haven't noticed this? Oil isn't the only reason for dollar strength. Your economy was in the tank. Your banking system suspect. 2 wars in. We were fine after the crash. Banks good, real estate good, little impact really. Thats why.

Trudeau fucked it up. Covid added to it. And our limited supply chain didn't help. As well Your ramping up your production. Then add on tariffs and they are a real drag.

But I'm still now sure why some Americans thing we are so bad off. We aren't. Still a top economy. Educated workforce. And now we are ramping up as well. I think once the trade situation settles, and that is two years away unless something drastically changes, it will climb. And btw if you do believe things will settle into trade blocs you are fucked. You have offshored so much now it would take decades to get yourself back.

Meanwhile if it is trade blocs then we would have NA, Europe with a deal, and we have added deals to the Asia bloc now. We are going our own way.

As for your economy, well, we shall see.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shakenbake
You think I haven't noticed this? Oil isn't the only reason for dollar strength. Your economy was in the tank. Your banking system suspect. 2 wars in. We were fine after the crash. Banks good, real estate good, little impact really. Thats why.

The commodity crash of 2014 directly caused the Canadian recession of 2015-2016.
High energy prices supported the high Canadian dollar up until 2015.
The U.S. did not experience this recession.
 
You think the EU is that united? Cripes then Why did France and Germany not want the title associate used? They run the damn thing.

That is some pretty crazy shit you wrote there.
I feel sorry for any women that has ever been in a relationship with you. You are very manipulative and underhanded.

Go ask people from colonized countries if what I wrote is really that crazy.

Oh yeah, and for you fools thinking this is some mastermind trade deal about to happen, there is almost nothing that the Canada makes that the EU can't. So don't think they will sacrifice their measly 1% GDP growth for Canada.
 
I feel sorry for any women that has ever been in a relationship with you. You are very manipulative and underhanded.

Go ask people from colonized countries if what I wrote is really that crazy.

Oh yeah, and for you fools thinking this is some mastermind trade deal about to happen, there is almost nothing that the Canada makes that the EU can't. So don't think they will sacrifice their measly 1% GDP growth for Canada.

Dude, 30+ years now with the same. I just play a bit on the side. And we are fantastic thanks.

And we are already a decent sized trade partner, doing billions every month. They are just as excited about creating deals. And we have lots to offer.

But seriously, make it make sense. You said you thought the "sent" Carney here as a Trojan horse to bring in Canada, but now say we have nothing to offer them, and would be a detriment.

So which is it?
 
The commodity crash of 2014 directly caused the Canadian recession of 2015-2016.
High energy prices supported the high Canadian dollar up until 2015.
The U.S. did not experience this recession.

Sure, it was your banks that created yours in 2008 which we didn't get hurt much by. And next up will be the AI bubble, coupled with a US treasuries sell off, war debt, and overall reduction in world engagement, some not your choice that will do it again.

Once we get pipelines up, and new deals, I see a decent rise in our Dollar against yours.