There were four big problems with the way Carney ran the Bank. To start with,
he printed way too much money, first in response to the financial crisis, and then to our departure from the EU. The result? The UK suffered from a spike in inflation that was way above the rest of our competitors.
Next,
he lost control of regulation, allowing pension funds to invest far too much money into high-risk assets, paving the way for the LDI blow-up that helped end the premiership of the unfortunate Liz Truss.
Thirdly, he presided over a steep decline in the City, with the number of companies listing their shares in London in freefall, and while it would be unfair to blame that entirely on the Governor, it was certainly his job to figure out how to maintain London's status as one of the great financial centres of the world.
Finally, and perhaps most seriously,
he politicized the Bank. He was a hardcore Remainer when it would have been better for the Bank to remain neutral, and then, even more disgracefully, after leaving office he very publicly
endorsed the Labour Party at the last general election, even though a former Governor should remain above the fray.
And he committed the Bank to
combatting climate change, when it was hard to see that it was ever part of its mandate –
the Bank is meant to control inflation and maintain the stability of the financial system.
Meanwhile, growth stagnated and real wages stopped rising. On any measure you care to look at, Carney was the worst Governor of recent times.
In the years since he left, Carney's successors at the Bank of England have been struggling to clear up the mess he left behind. His successors as Canadian PM will have to do the same – because Carney will prove just as deeply disappointing in that job as well.